Do we know for a fact we are saved

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bill_Pick
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Carlan
As far as Purgatory, if you could point me to a patristic argument or something from the Deuterocanonical books that indicates that those who have rejected Christ or never became a Christian can go to Purgatory…🤷 I was always told Purgatory is NOT a second chance for those who are not Christians but correct me if I was told wrong.
But I am not talking about those individuals who have rejected Christ after knowing him, but about those who believe in the God of Abraham and though no fault of their own do not know Christ. Purgatory isn’t a second chance for any one, perhaps it would help you understand if you were to search out reading on the subject from a catholic source.
As I said previously Purgatory is a place of purification and surely God in his mercy would not send any one to hell before giving them a means of purification.These people I spoke of in my previous post, believers in the God of Abraham, who through no fault of their own have not been exposed to the Truth of the Gospel.

Yes, perhaps some pondering and resting on it all for a while is called for, God bless you Brian.:)Carlan
 
I assume you mean non-Christians. The word Muslim is not in the Bible so you would need to clarify.
Methodists do not deny the Real Presence…you DO know that…right?
But sure, I have the Catechism and Blue Letter right here, I can type out everything about hell and the judgment.
So the Bible doesn’t say that Muslims are damned? And it doesn’t say that starting a new Christian denomination, changing doctrine, and attacking the CC is the way to Heaven. Hmm, it seems that you’ve stumbled on to something there.

UMS don’t believe in the real presence (transubstantation), and they aren’t in full communion with the CC, the church that Christ founded. Even if an individual UM chooses to believe that the bread and grape juice at a UM church is the real body and blood of Jesus and accepts transubstantation, it can’t be so, since the clergy in the UMC don’t have valid orders. Also, the bread at Communion must be unleavened and the wine must be wine. At the UMC I’ve visited, they serve leavened bread and grape juice. If the UMC does, as you say, believe in it, they aren’t acting on what they believe.

**“Outside the Church there is no salvation” **
[846](javascript:openWindow(‘cr/846.htm’)😉 How are we to understand this affirmation, often repeated by the Church Fathers?335 Re-formulated positively, it means that all salvation comes from Christ the Head through the Church which is his Body:
Basing itself on Scripture and Tradition, the Council teaches that the Church, a pilgrim now on earth, is necessary for salvation: the one Christ is the mediator and the way of salvation; he is present to us in his body which is the Church. He himself explicitly asserted the necessity of faith and Baptism, and thereby affirmed at the same time the necessity of the Church which men enter through Baptism as through a door. Hence they could not be saved who, knowing that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, would refuse either to enter it or to remain in it.336

847 This affirmation is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ and his Church:
Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience - those too may achieve eternal salvation.337
[848](javascript:openWindow(‘cr/848.htm’)😉 "Although in ways known to himself God can lead those who, through no fault of their own, are ignorant of the Gospel, to that faith without which it is impossible to please him, the Church still has the obligation and also the sacred right to evangelize all men."338

You ask for statements by the Church Fathers, Here you have, repeated in the CCC, the statement that it is only through Christ and his Church, the CC, that there is salvation.

And you say that your refusal to join the CC is not on topic? What church did you think they were talking about?! :eek:

Maybe you should spend more time thinking about the CC and less time damning non-Christians to Hell.
 
Judaism still teaches that. Well the Reform do.
Okay back to my verses.
 
I am not attacking the Catholic Church. At one time, until this forum, I had given it serious thought as I have said hundreds of times on here.
I understand that you do not accept our orders as valid. But we certainly do.
Valid orders are not too hard to come by its gotten so convuluted (sp?)
 
Nor is there salvation in any other, for there is no other name under heaven given among men by which we must be saved." (Acts 4:12)

Jesus said to him, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.” (John 14:6)

“He who believes in the Son has everlasting life; and he who does not believe the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God abides on him.” (John 3:36)

And we have seen and testify that the Father has sent the Son as Savior of the world. Whoever confesses that Jesus is the Son of God, God abides in him, and he in God." (1 John 4:14)

Let me be very clear. I confess that Jesus is the Son of God and I believe he rose from the dead and I have been baptized in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

No, I do not believe your church can save me. Only Christ
Having said that, love the Catholic Church and the Catholics I have met in real life:D; not so much the ones on here:o
 
But I am not talking about those individuals who have rejected Christ after knowing him, but about those who believe in the God of Abraham and though no fault of their own do not know Christ. Purgatory isn’t a second chance for any one, perhaps it would help you understand if you were to search out reading on the subject from a catholic source.
As I said previously Purgatory is a place of purification and surely God in his mercy would not send any one to hell before giving them a means of purification.These people I spoke of in my previous post, believers in the God of Abraham, who through no fault of their own have not been exposed to the Truth of the Gospel.

Yes, perhaps some pondering and resting on it all for a while is called for, God bless you Brian.:)Carlan
Islam rejects Christ as the Bible teaches. The God of Abraham revealed Himself in scripture. You cannot teach and believe things contrary to the God of Abraham, Issac, and Jacob and believe in him. You might believe things about him but not in Him.
People of the Book! Commit no excesses in your religion: Nor say of God aught but the truth. Christ Jesus the son of Mary was (no more than) an apostle of God, and His Word, which He bestowed on Mary, and a spirit proceeding from Him: so believe in God and His apostles. Say not “Trinity” : desist: it will be better for you: for God is one God: Glory be to Him: (far exalted is He) above having a son. To Him belong all things in the heavens and on earth. And enough is God as a Disposer of affairs." (Koran 4:171)
 
Nor is there salvation in any other, for there is no other name under heaven given among men by which we must be saved." (Acts 4:12)

Jesus said to him, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.” (John 14:6)

“He who believes in the Son has everlasting life; and he who does not believe the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God abides on him.” (John 3:36)

And we have seen and testify that the Father has sent the Son as Savior of the world. Whoever confesses that Jesus is the Son of God, God abides in him, and he in God." (1 John 4:14)

Let me be very clear. I confess that Jesus is the Son of God and I believe he rose from the dead and I have been baptized in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

No, I do not believe your church can save me. Only Christ
Having said that, love the Catholic Church and the Catholics I have met in real life:D; not so much the ones on here:o
I’ll ask again. What church did you think the Fathers were talking about?
 
Islam rejects Christ as the Bible teaches. The God of Abraham revealed Himself in scripture. You cannot teach and believe things contrary to the God of Abraham, Issac, and Jacob and believe in him. You might believe things about him but not in Him.
And so why are you refusing to be a member of the Church that Christ founded. You say that the Muslims are damned to Hell because they don’t believe in Christ, and yet you know of the CC, the church founded by Christ, and you refuse to join it. And you think that you should be saved and the Muslim damned. You believe some things about God, but not the Jesus (God) founded the CC. Does this mean that you don’t believe in God? You also don’t believe in the Sacraments. Is this further proof that you believe things about God but not** in** god?

You asked for words of the Church Fathers on salvation. The Fathers said that outside the Church there is no salvation. What Church were they talking about?

You believe some things about God, too, but you also follow false doctrines that the UMC has taught you.

As I said in an earlier post, many people are prejudiced against the CC because of what they’ve been taught. Once they are taught by authority figures that the CC is the Whore of Babylon and other such lies (like that the CC is corrupt and the Reformation restored Christianity to its roots), it is very difficult for the person to see the truth. Should God hold this against them?

And what of the people who’ve never heard of Jesus?

You have been prejudiced against the CC, which you say you love (Yeah, OK :rolleyes:), so I supposed your refusal is through no fault of your own.
 
And so why are you refusing to be a member of the Church that Christ founded. You say that the Muslims are damned to Hell because they don’t believe in Christ, and yet you know of the CC, the church founded by Christ, and you refuse to join it. And you think that you should be saved and the Muslim damned. You believe some things about God, but not the Jesus (God) founded the CC. Does this mean that you don’t believe in God? You also don’t believe in the Sacraments. Is this further proof that you believe things about God but not** in** god?

You asked for words of the Church Fathers on salvation. The Fathers said that outside the Church there is no salvation. What Church were they talking about?

You believe some things about God, too, but you also follow false doctrines that the UMC has taught you.

As I said in an earlier post, many people are prejudiced against the CC because of what they’ve been taught. Once they are taught by authority figures that the CC is the Whore of Babylon and other such lies (like that the CC is corrupt and the Reformation restored Christianity to its roots), it is very difficult for the person to see the truth. Should God hold this against them?

And what of the people who’ve never heard of Jesus?

You have been prejudiced against the CC, which you say you love (Yeah, OK :rolleyes:), so I supposed your refusal is through no fault of your own.
I am not at all prejudiced against the Catholic Church. I do not agree that non-Christians go to heaven. How did that make me prejudiced exactly…I dunno. As far as the Whore of Babylon, I am not sure why you brought that one up…🤷

I think I should just talk to Carlan about this. The topic of whether or not non-Christians can go to heaven is a good one.
 
I am not at all prejudiced against the Catholic Church. I do not agree that non-Christians go to heaven. How did that make me prejudiced exactly…I dunno. As far as the Whore of Babylon, I am not sure why you brought that one up…🤷

I think I should just talk to Carlan about this. The topic of whether or not non-Christians can go to heaven is a good one.
Chicken. 😉

And you still haven’t addressed the question of those who’ve never heard of Christ. And what of the Muslims who’ve heard of Christ, but have been taught false things about Him?
 
Islam rejects Christ as the Bible teaches. The God of Abraham revealed Himself in scripture. You cannot teach and believe things contrary to the God of Abraham, Issac, and Jacob and believe in him. You might believe things about him but not in Him.
You are not listening to me, Bri . I am not talking about the whole of non Christian religions, Islam, Judism… I speak of individuals, the Catholic Church in the CCC also refers to the individuals of these various religions who believe in the same God you and I believe in but through not fault of their own do not know Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, Please go back and read what the Church says as previously posted in this thread.We have no right to do God’s judging for him , only He knows all things and only he does the judging after we are no longer living in this life,Peace, G’night.Carlan
 
Chicken. 😉

And you still haven’t addressed the question of those who’ve never heard of Christ. And what of the Muslims who’ve heard of Christ, but have been taught false things about Him?
False teachings would mean hell. Never heard of Him…Him being God or Christ… I never heard a verse that applies. The Bible is full of false religions and those false religions reject God.
As far as being chicken, I do not care for your personality or style of posting. Because I am considering Othodoxy slightly and Catholicism a tiny bit…I think it would be best for me to stick with people who are a little nicer about things…even when they disagree. I have spent the last 30 minutes thinking about how I cannot stand you and I have never even met you…that aint good :o
 
You are not listening to me, Bri . I am not talking about the whole of non Christian religions, Islam, Judism… I speak of individuals, the Catholic Church in the CCC also refers to the individuals of these various religions who believe in the same God you and I believe in but through not fault of their own do not know Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, Please go back and read what the Church says as previously posted in this thread.We have no right to do God’s judging for him , only He knows all things and only he does the judging after we are no longer living in this life,Peace, G’night.Carlan
But I do not think Islam believes in the same God. Carlan, I read the Koran for my world religions class 25 years ago and I STILL remember it and…wow. I mean wow!!😦
I agree we should not do God’s judging. I FEEL LIKE I am trying to defend God’s word againt fellow Christians and its a very very odd thing for me. I am used to it with some people but I usually see eye to eye with you guys 99 percent of the time so this is very odd for me.
Have a good evening. Thanks for your attitude.
 
You are not listening to me, Bri . I am not talking about the whole of non Christian religions, Islam, Judism… I speak of individuals, the Catholic Church in the CCC also refers to the individuals of these various religions who believe in the same God you and I believe in but through not fault of their own do not know Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, Please go back and read what the Church says as previously posted in this thread.We have no right to do God’s judging for him , only He knows all things and only he does the judging after we are no longer living in this life,Peace, G’night.Carlan
I think Brian would rather speak in grander terms - all of Islam. Islam is wrong, so every Muslim is damned. The problem with that theory is that truth it truth wherever it’s found. The Muslims believe in God, and they believe truth about God. They don’t have the fullness of truth that’s found only in the CC, but neither do the Methodists.
 
False teachings would mean hell. Never heard of Him…Him being God or Christ… I never heard a verse that applies. The Bible is full of false religions and those false religions reject God.
As far as being chicken, I do not care for your personality or style of posting. Because I am considering Othodoxy slightly and Catholicism a tiny bit…I think it would be best for me to stick with people who are a little nicer about things…even when they disagree. I have spent the last 30 minutes thinking about how I cannot stand you and I have never even met you…that aint good :o
I never imagined that I had such influence over you. Really? 30 minutes devoted to little old me? 😃

If false teaching means Hell, you better get yourself in the right Church. According to the Church Fathers that you wanted quotes from, that is the Catholic Church. If you’re thinking of joining the Church that Christ founded, you need to get used to Tradition and the Magisterium. You seem to be appealing to the Bible as the soul source. That will bug you to no end when you finally come home.

BTW, if you met me, you would love me. I love you. I really do, Honeybunch. 😉
 
You are not listening to me, Bri . I am not talking about the whole of non Christian religions, Islam, Judism… I speak of individuals, the Catholic Church in the CCC also refers to the individuals of these various religions who believe in the same God you and I believe in but through not fault of their own do not know Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, Please go back and read what the Church says as previously posted in this thread.We have no right to do God’s judging for him , only He knows all things and only he does the judging after we are no longer living in this life,Peace, G’night.Carlan
What about Muslims who hate Christians and Jews? If they never get a chance to repent then how can they be saved?

In order to receive salvation, a Muslim must have faith AND works… If the works are bad then how can they be saved?

The only way a Muslim can be saved is by accepting the true faith of the Church before actual death… Unless they have never heard of Jesus… Then they have a chance… But they must have received “miraculous” knowledge, gifts, etc, from God… (miracles)

We are all judged by our works!
 
But I do not think Islam believes in the same God. Carlan, I read the Koran for my world religions class 25 years ago and I STILL remember it and…wow. I mean wow!!😦
I agree we should not do God’s judging. I FEEL LIKE I am trying to defend God’s word againt fellow Christians and its a very very odd thing for me. I am used to it with some people but I usually see eye to eye with you guys 99 percent of the time so this is very odd for me.
Have a good evening. Thanks for your attitude.
The Catholic Church affirms that Islam worships the same God, the God of Abraham. It’s not my personal opinion you have a problem with, it’s the CC’s teaching.
 
But I do not think Islam believes in the same God. Carlan, I read the Koran for my world religions class 25 years ago and I STILL remember it and…wow. I mean wow!!😦
I agree we should not do God’s judging. I FEEL LIKE I am trying to defend God’s word againt fellow Christians and its a very very odd thing for me. I am used to it with some people but I usually see eye to eye with you guys 99 percent of the time so this is very odd for me.
Have a good evening. Thanks for your attitude.
I have never read the Koran and I do not know much about Islam.
I do know tho’ that the CCC says that they (Muslims) believe in the God of Abraham the God we and the Jews believe in.Peace Carlan
 
I have never read the Koran and I do not know much about Islam.
I do know tho’ that the CCC says that they (Muslims) believe in the God of Abraham the God we and the Jews believe in.Peace Carlan
Yet even demons believe (and know whom God is) and tremble in fear…yet the Muslim does not know God in the same as a christain does.So the question is how can one reject that which they do not know?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top