Do you believe in the "real presence" in a Lutheran mass or?

  • Thread starter Thread starter almost2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

almost2

Guest
Do you believe in the" real presence" in a Lutheran mass service?
or other religious service?
 
No.

They do not properly ordained, and do not have the capacity to confect the Eucharist. The only other religion with this capacity are the various Orthodox churches because they were started by validly-ordained Bishops, and have not distorted the meaning of the Eucharist beyond recognition.
 
almost2 said:
Do you believe in the" real presence" in a Lutheran mass service?
or other religious service?
Click to expand...
The saving presence of Christ is there in the community, but the Eucharistic Presence of Christ is absent from the bread and wine because there is no consecration.
 
No, the Real Presence isn’t in their bread and wine. One Lutheran told me they believe in consubstantiation not transubstantiation. Then he told me they were truer Catholics than Catholics!😠
 
They are asking for a miracle in faith to God; I don’t know why God wouldn’t grant it just because a Lutheran was asking. They aren’t asking for the same miracle and I don’t have the same level faith that they receive a miracle as I do at Mass; but, it’s also not something I really worry about.
 
No. It’s just bread and grape juice. I went to my parents’ Lutheran church and partook in their " Eucharist " and I felt a huge difference between a true Eucharist and the Lutheran. Just bread and grape juice and nothing else.
 
no, i don’t. lutheran services are largely about the pastor’s ability to deliver a homily and little or nothing to do with sacramentals

not trying to be sarcastic, mean or offensive

just one person’s opinion
 
Last edited:
almost2 said:
Do you believe in the" real presence" in a Lutheran mass service?
or other religious service?
Click to expand...
While I have never been to a Lutheran mass, I do not believe they have Real Presence regardless of what they say that they have. Real Presence can only be confected by priests with apostolic succession, which their priests do not have.
 
Yes as children we are taught something is true. But as adults we can determine evaluation

Peter in acts said God is not a respector of persons.
And spiritual decernment is a gift
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top