Do you ever feel like you are too Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AlruwhAlquds
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I know burnout exists in all fields and perhaps that’s it. But sometimes I get the feeling like we need a break from church.
I’ve been a practicing Catholic for my 58 years. I wouldn’t say ‘burnout’ but there are definitely swings in my devotional life during that time which looking back now, I regard as fairly natural. I didn’t feel like I ever needed a ‘break from church’. Perhaps you just mean you need a break from amount of involvement you currently have? Never forget the Our Father and its request to protect you from temptation and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with reshaping your devotional life.
 
Not too Catholic but perhaps you need more in your life separate from church. You can do that. I am devoted to becoming more faithful but am put off when every conversation is about God and Faith…it starts to feel fake and overdone. We can have secular lives as well.
 
Last edited:
Does getting trolled by your own daughter count?(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
Being Catholic is a good thing for sure. The feeling and meaning behind my attention grabbing question is one from grief or fatigue. The exasperated feeling when a loss happens and you look at the cross or Jesus in adoration, or just being engaged so much at church and still ask Him, 'what do you want me to do now, I’ll do it?!" And then, not feeling like you can hear Him is the feeling and meaning behind it. It happens, I can recognize it.

I’m explaining this to you because your answer would make a fellow Catholic brother or sister feel isolated rather than feeling like can relate and bring them closer. My advice (take it or leave it): It really doesn’t take much to extend someone some empathy. Catholics should be more charitable towards each other.

But nonetheless, I suppose you did the job and answered the question. Thanks.
I’m not clear whether you are replying to me, or to someone else. The OP asked a question, and I answered it. It wasn’t anything that required all that much explanation. I suppose it would be helpful to add, possibly, that I can divide the question in two — put the joys, the peace, and the self-assurance that go with being a Catholic, and seeing the beauty of all the Church’s teachings on one side of the ledger, and put the ultimate futility, despair, transitory earthly pleasures, and moral degradation of the secular world on the other. There is a great feeling of mastery — the secular world, and the world of many even who profess Christ, has a lot of “givens” — “you have to be happy (as the world defines happiness)”, “you have to have nice things”, “you have to have pleasant and enjoyable sex on demand”, “you have to do the things everyone else does, or they won’t like you”, “everyone just knows XYZ, and you have to think like everyone else does”, and so on. It’s a sense of freedom that you can’t know until you experience it.

One thing I learned very early, and I bless the catechist for telling me about this, is that there is great power in praising and glorifying God for everything, even the things that our earthly lights tell us are bad things. This is one thing you don’t even have to be Catholic to learn — he had me to read the book by Merlin Carothers, Power in Praise. Talk about a life hack! This has helped me so much throughout the years. And, I must confess, there have been times when I failed to do this — I had this thing, or that thing, that I just HAD to have, and when it didn’t come, I couldn’t accept it. I made my own misery that way.
 
The way I’m reading your post is you’re describing “being Catholic” as being involved in the active aspects of the Church. Sure, that’s a good thing. But the past few months for me have been similar to the desolation you described, and I actually ended up disengaging from my parish a bit. It’s helped me to distinguish the pleasure I get from fellowship from “the peace of God that surpasses all understanding.”

I believe God came closer and helped me to see myself more clearly, and I’ve been able to re-engage as a better version of myself. It’s still a little choppy, though. God may be calling you to work on some things in the silence between you and Him that are harder to notice when moving from one activity to another.

This is just a brief impression I’m getting from the feel of your post. I don’t claim to have a concrete answer, but when I read you’re OP I felt like, "Hey, it’s not just me! 🙂 and hope this contributes to helping you through this situation.

Peace!
 
I know burnout exists in all fields and perhaps that’s it.
Perhaps looking at the Faith as a job might be a problem. It seems to me it is not being ‘too Catholic’ that is the problem but the opposite. As you said you are feeling distant from God. I would think you would want to practice the Faith more to remedy that.
 
Last edited:
Living in sometimes an anti catholic climate that views the practices and devotions that I have grown up with as overboard catholic can sometimes put some kind of weird pressure on
,especially having some immediate family who
are also anti catholic .
But i recognise it for what it is (a type of persecution )and try to live my faith more fully
because ultimately it’s between me and our God .
 
Last edited:
But sometimes I get the feeling like we need a break from church. Perhaps it’s a lack of joy due to a recent loss in our family almost a year ago.
I went through a similar period after my mother died. I know it’s hard, but my advice would be to do what you are comfortable with (regarding the other activities), but do continue to go to Liturgy. Even if when you go you don’t participate, just being there will be beneficial for you.

Losing a loved one can really do a number on you (general you). This is when we need the Lord the most, even if we don’t feel it.
 
Last edited:
That brings to mind the lovely anecdote Footprints.

It’s also a time to contemplate the Communion of Saints and be confident that others both in heaven and on earth are carrying us in our struggles.
 
No. Compared to the saints, I fall way short in my Catholic living.
 
I sometimes think I see people who are more in love with a faith tradition than Jesus. I’m not sure if that’s what you mean? Sometimes I think we get too caught in the details and don’t treat people well, which after all is a major part of the excercise isn’t it? Could you just use a change of pace maybe? A different parish community?

In school or in some parishes I’ve struggled because I felt like someone was flaunting their authority, or just being a real prick, and using religion to do it. From those people I often take a pretty good break.
 
The way I’m reading your post is you’re describing “being Catholic” as being involved in the active aspects of the Church. Sure, that’s a good thing. But the past few months for me have been similar to the desolation you described, and I actually ended up disengaging from my parish a bit. It’s helped me to distinguish the pleasure I get from fellowship from “the peace of God that surpasses all understanding.”

I believe God came closer and helped me to see myself more clearly, and I’ve been able to re-engage as a better version of myself. It’s still a little choppy, though. God may be calling you to work on some things in the silence between you and Him that are harder to notice when moving from one activity to another.
I have had another train of thought this evening, this from my own experience. Without getting too specific, I have found that I have needed to make some changes in my prayer and devotional life recently. This isn’t the first time. Pope Pius XII said that our spirituality can be different at different times in our lives, and that this is okay. (I don’t have his exact words or a citation, I just know what I read.) Everyone is different. St Therese of Lisieux did not particularly care for the rosary. Some people, myself among them, find the scapular comforting and indispensable. Some like Eucharistic adoration. Others like the Chaplet of Divine Mercy. We’re all different in this regard, and one size definitely does not fit all.
 
I think sometimes we can become over involved with
church, job, kid’s activities. I am an introvert. I don’t like being around large crowds of people.

I have been sick for almost 10 days. I did not attend Mass last weekend and I am not going this weekend.
I am both sick and burned out. I miss my Adoration
hour and I miss the Mass and receiving the Eucharist, but I do not miss being among 200 other people. I have been trying to watch Mass online or on tv and have still continued my prayer life and spiritual reading
at home.
 
Last edited:
That sounds really difficult. I can totally understand"taking a break" in some way. Honestly it can just be tiring. You may be going through a hard time emotionally and just feel weary mentally and emotionally and physically. And going to church or praying at those times often just feels like a chore and not consoling in any way. For me takin a break really helped me to take a step back and just finally think and recover from one of the negative experience and thoughts and feelings that emerged from my faith in Catholicism. That’s only my experience though and you may need something different
 
Having been fully immersed in Catholicism and it’s tradition all my life I can say it’s not always been a positive experience. I’ve honestly felt so much more peace when I was away from the Church and much more fulfilled. I assure you not following a religion does not mean you are only seeking earthly pleasure and low unsatisfying things. There are plenty of ways to seek out meaning through service and relationships and learning etc that don’t include religion. You don’t need religion to rise above a shallow and materialistic and selfish mindset not does religion prevent that.

Religion resonates with a lot of people, makes them feel good, brings them peace and security and makes them feel loved. For others it’s not the same experience and that’s okay and not their fault.
 
Having been fully immersed in Catholicism and it’s tradition all my life I can say it’s not always been a positive experience. I’ve honestly felt so much more peace when I was away from the Church and much more fulfilled. I assure you not following a religion does not mean you are only seeking earthly pleasure and low unsatisfying things. There are plenty of ways to seek out meaning through service and relationships and learning etc that don’t include religion. You don’t need religion to rise above a shallow and materialistic and selfish mindset not does religion prevent that.

Religion resonates with a lot of people, makes them feel good, brings them peace and security and makes them feel loved. For others it’s not the same experience and that’s okay and not their fault.
It has not always been a positive experience for me either, and I can tell you that I have drifted closer to it, then farther away, then closer… it’s a lifelong thing. I can only say that when I have drifted away, there was a great emptiness and futility in my life. There is a great peace in disregarding your own wishes and what you would prefer, and replacing that with what God wishes and prefers. One person remarked to me many years ago that Catholicism is closer to Buddhism in that regard.
 
I would think that many of us may go through times when we feel more distant from God. I don’t think we are actually more distant from God, but it just feels that way. I think this can be viewed as a test and a spiritual exercise. I think what matters is not what we feel, but what is.

I also think that we can get too caught up in the need to do lots of things, activities etc. Sometimes we need to slow down and focus on what really matters.
 
Last edited:
I very much agree! I recently read The Three Ages of the Interior Life and one of main themes I drew from it was that our prayer life should change as we grow spiritually. And, like physical growth, where we hit major life changes at adolescence, mid-life and retirement, for example, the spiritual life is also demarcated by critical points of change that cause us to come out of them very different when we went in. And being limited fragile creatures, anything that changes us at this depth is going to involve some pain, fear and confusion. But from the saints I’ve read who have been through this process, the emphasis when they emerge from these transitions seems to be, “It’s worth it!”
 
I could feel everything I was trying to express just reading you’re two sentences…thank you! 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top