T
TheHolyTrinity9
Guest
Just wondering if you need to keep repenting a specific mortal sin or do you have to only repent it once and then it’s forgiven forever?
Unless you continue or persist in a mortal sin and you have confessed and been absolved of the mortal sin, you need not confess it again. You might, however, just wish to mention it again in subsequent confessions if it’s still something that bothers you.Just wondering if you need to keep repenting a specific mortal sin or do you have to only repent it once and then it’s forgiven forever?
I assume you meant, is it necessary to keep repenting when you have not committed that sin again?Just wondering if you need to keep repenting a specific mortal sin or do you have to only repent it once and then it’s forgiven forever?
This is not true.If you keep repeating a mortal sin the priest may not offer absolution
Well actually, while it is rare in ordinary parish situations, the priest does have the authority to judge that repentance is not present, and refuse to grant absolution.This is not true.
I accept your more complete explanation.Well actually, while it is rare in ordinary parish situations, the priest does have the authority to judge that repentance is not present, and refuse to grant absolution.
e.g. if a person comes and confesses that he is living in a gravely sinful situation, like an adulterous or fornication based relationship, and does not indicate any intent to change his situation then the priest is unable to grant absolution.
Such a person is not repentant, but simply wants to be granted license to continue his lifestyle. A pre-requisite for absolution is repentance and contrition.
Repentance is difficult and I know I definitely struggle with some habitual sins… but there’s a huge difference between resolving to try to avoid a sin, and having no such resolution, but rather the explicit intention to go straight from the confessional back to the sinful situation.
So: in the situation where a person is confessing a habitual or lifestyle based mortal sin again and again (because they keep repeating it) It is totally appropriate for the priest to query whether there is an intention to repent, or whether the sin of presumption is being committed:
i.e. “I know Jesus will forgive me so it doesn’t matter if I keep on sinning… I don’t need to change my behavior I will just keep confessing”
This mindset turns the attempt at the Sacrament of Penance from a Sacrament of Grace and Salvation into an occasion of further Sin!!!
Please note: this is about a repeated sin being confessed again and again with no real desire of attempt to change… not about confessing a singe historic sin again.