Do you help your parents first before helping others?

  • Thread starter Thread starter anon64704623
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

anon64704623

Guest
If your parents and girl/boy friend is drowning together, who will you save first? If you save both, everybody drown. If you save your friend, your parents will drown and vice verse.
 
I will save the members of my family first. This is the natural and right thing to do. However, if the other person was a child then I’d save the child first.
 
Last edited:
Are there any verse in the bible that we should attend to the needs of our family first before outsiders?
 
If you google that saying it is often misquoted…
something about blood on the battlefield is thicker than water of the womb .
You can read up on that 🙂
There’s probably many inturperatations.
 
Last edited:
Are there any verse in the bible that we should attend to the needs of our family first before outsiders?
1 Timothy 5:8: “If any man have not care of his own and especially of those of his house, he hath denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel.”
 
There are so many ways this could play out and I don’t think there’s a clear “always correct” way to do this when it happens in real life. You probably won’t have time to think it out, either, and may find yourself acting instinctively.

If circumstances were such that I could make decisions, I think I would probably rescue children or whoever was closest first. But I’d like to think that I’d keep going as long as possible. There wouldn’t be a deliberate choice to not save anyone. The intent would be everyone.
 
If your parents and girl/boy friend is drowning together, who will you save first? If you save both, everybody drown. If you save your friend, your parents will drown and vice verse.
Drowning is physical death, and each and every human being will experience physical death…there is no escape.

Our call is to save all (we are commanded to be Christ like) from eternal death.

And, like Christ, we don’t need to triage those facing eternal death…we can save all at the same time.

Do we pray only for the salvation of others?..do we pray first for the salvation of some, and then later? Even if we do, is God only capable of handing prayers on a “first come, first serve basis”, and is He unable to multitask and hear and act on the prayers of all His children at one time? I would think not.

Seeking a human hierarchy of physically saving people…parents first, or others…is a worldly perspective not a spiritual one…that is not to say, because of our fallen human nature we would not be moved to save those closest to us first…but then again, what good of saving their physical lives if we ignore working on saving their eternal lives?

The physical death of a human is sad and difficult to handle, especially if that death is of one close to us…but what is the sadness and lamentation at death of a loved one all about? If we have faith in the Resurrection and life after death, then is that sadness and lamentation really about us, and not the person dying?

Pax et bonum!
 
I dsave my family first.
I think it’s only natural because that is where your affection is.
 
Last edited:
This is a cultural question.

Westeners pick their spouse
Easterners pick their parents.
 
I hate these drowing scenarios as they often, but not this time, involve your children. Being so outnumbered by my children makes imagining these things too heart breaking. Just as it really stopped being fun to imagine trying surviving a zombie apocalypse because surely we are goners with all these noisy little people who tire so easily.

So this reminds me I still need to enroll them in swim lessons because that is the answer to this scenario. You prevent drowing by teaching everyone in your life to swim before it is too late. That extends metaphorically to whatever you want it to.
 
If your parents and girl/boy friend is drowning together, who will you save first? If you save both, everybody drown. If you save your friend, your parents will drown and vice verse.
Frankly, this type of thread is stupid. How many of these have we had. If your mother and daughter were drowning who would you save first. If your two sisters were drowning which one would you save? and so on…!
 
Some of these have real simple answers. I can’t swim. I gonna be first at the Pearly gates. See y’all.
 
Its okay. @Vico already answered the real question behind this question.
 
These sort of high school “ethics” exercises help to teach young people the doctrine of consequentialism.

The first logical hole is how are the 4 of you suddenly in deep water with no other people and no flotation devices? You are required by law to have flotation devices for every person on a boat (ETA and by law the children must be wearing life jackets for all of the time they are on the boat), if you were in a plane crash there would likely be floating debris.

What a person does when there is their granny, their child and a stranger all in danger is to do all you can to save everyone. We never chose one person at the expense of another.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top