Do you think it is morally permissible to spend $5,000 or more for pet surgery?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JamalChristophr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Some foreigners feels Americans love their pets more than their fellow man based on the time and money invested in them.
Understand the same could be said for their cars, video consoles, etc. Yet your point is something we should remember. Where our money is, there are heart is. Outside of living expense, if we spend more on anything more than we do on charity, we fail the Matthew 25 judgment.
 
I would suggest that some foreigners not judge all animal owning and loving Americans. Broad brush characterizations tend to be wrong, and this is no exception. I love my pets and I take care of my pets very well. But I also care about my fellow man and the money I spend monthly on tithing and charities prove that.
 
exnihilo, Margaret and everyone else on this thread who clearly is not an “animal person”, I am going to say this as charitably as I can.

I have loved many pets, including cats, a rabbit, guinea pigs, and several others. The only reason I have not had a dog since young childhood is because my lifestyle and the needs of the other animals would make it unfair to bring a dog into our crowded home right now. If I live long enough, I will likely have a dog in my elder age when I no longer have to work and travel around all the time.

I have also been involved in animal rescue. I currently have a number of cats living with me who I adopted, mostly from kill shelters and other bad situations. These animals were in danger of death if not adopted by someone. A couple of them were “difficult cases” that had issues making them hard for the average person looking for a nice family cat to adopt (biting problems, litterbox issues, dispositions, etc.). They needed to live with an experienced cat person who can handle their idiosyncrasies. Another one of the cats was my deceased mother’s cat, who Mom dearly loved. Mom also rescued a lot of cats after she got interested in them because I was interested in them. I also have a number of friends who are involved in rescuing all sorts of animals from pit bulls to bears and/or have taken in strays.

I appreciate that not everyone is going to be that interested in an animal or “into” animals or want to have a pet. Some people have family responsibilities, allergies, limited budgets, or just would rather use their energies and spare time elsewhere. But these animals come into the world, in the case of pets partly through the irresponsibility of people who don’t spay/neuter, and they have needs. They do show affection, and any “animal person” will simply laugh at people who claim they don’t. We hear that all the time. We are made fun of and criticized all the time for caring about animals. We are told that only humans are worth caring about. Never mind that I and most of the people I know also contribute to human charities, and/or in other ways. For example, some of my rescue friends also have taken in foster children, or visit nursing homes with therapy animals.

We see working with these animals as important. The animals do not have a voice, or have legal protections that humans do, and some people see them as disposable. People abandon their pets when they move and the poor animal, who has been a pet its whole life, is not able to hunt for food and is easy prey for the first predator that comes along. One of my cats was abandoned in that way and there are many more in my hometown as there are many renters.

You get out of animals what you put into them. I have thanked God for my animals many times. They are a blessing in ways I can’t begin to describe. If you don’t feel affection for an animal, the animal senses it. They aren’t stupid. And you are doing the right thing by finding that animal another home, or taking it to a no-kill shelter (please not a kill shelter), where it will hopefully end up with someone who will value it. And please neuter and spay. That’s all.
 
I don’t want disclose my ethnicity that why I used the word foreigner. I sometimes get the sense from some people they care more about their precious pets than their fellow man. Seriously who leaves a million dollar will for a dog?
 
I wasn’t criticizing people who care for pets. Nothing wrong with that. I actually want my children to love animals. I’m only criticizing people who come across like they care more about animal life than human life.
I don’t have a sensitivity towards animals. I’m presenting a perspective poor people from my country hold. They don’t understand dogs having clothes. Like I said it could be a cultural difference on my part.
 
@MargaretofCortona Your perspective is a good one. Most Americans don’t have that experience of what it’s like to live in a country where the majority of the population is struggling to get by. It’s not a moral judgement. It’s just a fact. A person has to have some amount of disposable income in order to have a pet. But even the phrase “disposable income” is perhaps not black and white from nation to nation or person to person.
 
Last edited:
exnihilo, Margaret and everyone else on this thread who clearly is not an “animal person”, I am going to say this as charitably as I can.
Actually I think I am an animal person. I just think they are here to serve us and they aren’t anywhere close to human. I’m not a cat person. They are nice outdoors but not in a house. I do like dogs but even then they belong outside.
The animals do not have a voice, or have legal protections that humans do, and some people see them as disposable.
Nor should they. They are animals. If we protect these things we do so for the sake of man not the sake of the animal.
I have thanked God for my animals many times. They are a blessing in ways I can’t begin to describe.
As well we should. They are a blessing. They can provide much to man. But that is just it. They are here to provide for us.
 
I think being an “animal person” occurs along a spectrum. Some people rate a '1" while other’s a ‘10’. My mom is cat krazy …maybe a 7 or so. lol

My sister is pug crazy…probably a 6.5 🙂
 
I’m not a millionaire, so I don’t know. But I wouldn’t jump to the conclusio that someone who did leave an amount like that for the care of their pet did so at the exclusion of helping mankind.
 
It is difficult for me to understand why anyone would leave such a high amount for a dog.
 
It’s a freaking dog. I could understand that much for a farm, a shelter, etc. What is that dog going to be doing with over a million dollars? A lavish lifestyle for an animal is an insult to humanity. This is when I start thinking some people value animals way too much. Some millionaire’s dogs have inherited more money than some poor countries. Oh come on. Animals can take care of themselves except humans have domesticated them.
 
Simply put, I have nothing against animal lovers but I notice some Americans value animal life too much. I just have a different point of view. I’m certain if you visited a different country you may not agree or understand their values or why they are so important.
Dogs can be spoiled too like children. People complain spoiling children is wrong, but I can’t say anything about spoiling pets.
For some people their pets become their life.
Anything is excess is wrong.
 
Well, I notice that some foreigners value animal life too little. You may not agree , but maybe you just don’t understand some pet owners values or why they are so important.
 
Some of the views expressed on this thread have just underscored the importance, to me, of being a committed helper of and advocate for animals. It’s easy to forget the lack of sensitivity of many in the world to our animal friends, but every once in a while I get a big wake-up call.

Re foreigners, there are some who truly love animals. One of my favorites is Mohammed Alaa Aljaleel, the “Cat Man of Aleppo”, who runs a big cat shelter in Aleppo for the cats abandoned or displaced in the fighting there, has also helped abandoned zoo animals to be rescued, and in addition brings cheer to the area children by giving them teddy bears and candy. He has persisted even after his original cat shelter was destroyed in the conflict and more recently after his “Cat Ambulance” vehicle was destroyed by a nearby bombing while he was distributing candy to the local children. He is an inspiration to me.
 
I actually have to say I agree with this. In some countries like where I’m from animals aren’t cared for and I think this line of thinking has more to do with poverty. cats are pets to drive out rats. Dogs are for security or protection. I’m generalizing here. I apologise for coming off too strong and if I was dismissive. I think i mentioned the extreme cases of people overvaluing pets. My neighbors aren’t that way. Most pet owners I know in person aren’t that way I either.
 
Someone must care for the well being of animals. I shouldn’t overlook that ever. Perhaps we all have different callings and I must respect. I’m sorry if I attacked anyone. Like I stated most pet owners I know in person aren’t neglectful of human welfare either. Unfortunately, I know about two people in particular who would honestly in a heartbeat help an animal over a human. They aren’t kind people in general though. People like that exist.

This is a particularly sensitive topic for me. Again, I apologise and God bless.
 
This is a particularly sensitive topic for me. Again, I apologise and God bless.
It’s okay. There are people who are drawn to helping animals because they have serious problems with other humans, or serious problems in general. We have to watch out for those people because while some of them can be very kind to the animals, others of them just have problems, and might take their frustrations out on animals, or perhaps be unable to provide good care because they have too many problems of their own.

There are quite simply too many dogs and cats and other things in the USA due to irresponsible and over-breeding, and either some of us need to try to alleviate that problem while also trying to push for responsible spay and neuter, or else we just end up killing off (I don’t use the word “euth” because to me that’s reserved for animals that are old or very sick, not healthy animals we don’t want around) thousands of them. But people have different interests and missions in life, which is fine.

As for someone leaving a million dollars to the cat, Kitty will live at most 20 years give or take, and presumably won’t burn through the whole million dollars in that time, so the money will move on to other relatives or to a charity when Kitty dies. Sometimes people do that just so relatives they do not like won’t get hold of the money, or because they are worried that unless Kitty has a lot of money, she will not be cared for. Which is a real worry. Two of my cats are with me because their owners died and whoever inherited the cat sent it to the kill shelter. They are sweet cats and were obviously cared for by their owners based on their dispositions and the fact that one was very fat when I got her and I had to put her on a diet.
 
Last edited:
No need to apologize! We’re just having a discussion. God bless you as well!
 
Anything over $500 and it’s getting put down. Thinking of all the people in need, I could never justify spending thousands of dollars to keep an unthinking creature alive for a bit longer.

I love animals, but not even close to the love I hold for a fellow human being. If it was a choice between feeding my worst enemy or feeding my dog, there is no debate: humans always come first.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top