Does 2 Tim 3:16-17 support Sola Scriptura?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RussAuburn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.

2 Timothy was just another book when it was written - it had no more authority as Scripture then, than anything by any “uninspired” writer. The doctrine of Sola Scriptura is based on an optical illusion: as though the NT writings had, during the Apostolic period, the same status they were later recognised as having, & as though the writers were regarded as inspired authors of books of the Bible in their own life-times.​

I think this is not right. If it is inspired now, then it was inspired when it was written. I do agree that it may have been regarded as nothing but a normal pastoral letter, but it carried the authority of the Apostle to the persons who read it. We also have no evidence which of Paul’s writings Peter was talking about when he referred to them as scripture.
He is “the Apostle”, & a writer of inspired Scripture, only in retrospect - in no way is this to depreciate him; the point here is not his value, but the need of time the Churches had in order to appreciate his value: which is, that of an inspired author; not of one important but unispired teacher among others.
I think the recipients considered it as though the Apostle was speaking, and therefore, authoritative. It is true that the formal canonization was many hundreds of years later. What gets me when Tim. is used to support Sola Scriptura is that he was referring to the OT at the time. I don’t know a single fundamentalist that could base their Christian faith on the OT.
 
Where do the Scriptures claim transformation only occurs when blessed thru apostolic succession?
I reject your incorrect standard of proof. The Church says so, and the God speaks through the Church.
Then you admit your claim about me is only speculation.
Only if your profile, which lists you as “protestant”, is incorrect and thus misleading. Stop being coy - if you attend a Church with valid apostolic succession, just come out and say so. That will make for an interesting bit of news.
 
… if you attend a Church with valid apostolic succession, just come out and say so. That will make for an interesting bit of news.
How many disciples were at Pentecost? 120? 500?

All who were there were waiting on the Holy Spirit which was promised by Jesus.

Since the Bible does not record what happened to all of them
(that would make for a very long canon) how do you know where all the apostolic successors are? The RC only claims Peter’s successors, correct?
 
How many disciples were at Pentecost? 120? 500?
The Eucharist was not instituted at Pentecost, but in the upper room.
All who were there were waiting on the Holy Spirit which was promised by Jesus.
Since the Bible does not record what happened to all of them
(that would make for a very long canon) how do you know where all the apostolic successors are? The RC only claims Peter’s successors, correct?
Incorrect.

So, what line of apostolic succession does your church claim?
 
No. I believe everything has to be confirmed thru Scripture.
I agee with you that scripture is sufficient, but it can’t be at the expense of oral apostolic tradition. When you say “I believe everything has to be confirmed thru Scripture," you say it becuase you believe Scripture is the inspired word of God. With that said, you are necessarily basing your beliefs on a tradition outside of Scripture. That is because Scripture is not self-authenticating. We would not know the Scriptures were inspired unless the Church first told us that they were. Relying on a source outside of Scripture to demonstrate the truth of Scripture undermines sola Scriptura.

Those Fathers who wrote about the sufficiency of Scripture wrote elsewhere about the equally binding apostolic tradition and the authentic interpreter of all Tradition (both written and unwritten), the Catholic Magisterium.

Peace,

Ryan 🙂
 
We are not talking about when the Eucharist was instituted, but who has authority/power by the HS to make it the literal body and blood of Christ.

You said
It is the Holy Spirit who effects the transformation. And any priest with valid orders (apostolic succession, etc) can call forth that transformation, not just Catholic priests."
Apostolic succession is from Apostles. The Holy Spirit was given at Pentecost.

Aside from Peter whom the Roman Catholic Church claims exclusive succession, what happened to the other apostles who received the Holy Spirit at Pentecost?
 
We are not talking about when the Eucharist was instituted, but who has authority/power by the HS to make it the literal body and blood of Christ.

You said

Apostolic succession is from Apostles. The Holy Spirit was given at Pentecost.

Aside from Peter whom the Roman Catholic Church claims exclusive succession, what happened to the other apostles who received the Holy Spirit at Pentecost?
This is not the Church’s claim. The only exclusivity is respect to the papacy. All of the apostles had the authority to appoint successors.
 
Scripture is not self-authenticating. We would not know the Scriptures were inspired unless the Church first told us that they were. Relying on a source outside of Scripture to demonstrate the truth of Scripture undermines sola Scriptura.
That is incorrect. The Bible is a group of books. Each tells a part of the story. Stories are over-lapping and confirm one another.

Much of the Bible can be confirmed thru historic records and archeology - but most important…

The Bible is the living word of God. Thru the Scriptures God often speaks to His people. That in itself allows the Scriptures to be self-authenticating.
 
We are not talking about when the Eucharist was instituted, but who has authority/power by the HS to make it the literal body and blood of Christ.

You said

Apostolic succession is from Apostles. The Holy Spirit was given at Pentecost.

Aside from Peter whom the Roman Catholic Church claims exclusive succession, what happened to the other apostles who received the Holy Spirit at Pentecost?
Do me a favor. Go onto the Eastern Christianity forum and tell them your theory about apostolic succession and who can preside over the Eucharistic transformation. See if they agree with you. I simply cannot deal any further with such obstinate rejection of the Church founded by Christ, and the subsequent invention of new theologies never taught by the Church.

And BTW, this notion you have that “we” have Peter’s apostolic succession and other’s have other apostles, or whatever it is you’re claiming, is unfounded. The lines of apostolic succession have intermingled to the point where no bishop can possibly trace his lineage to a particular apostle, nor is this necessary.
 
No. I believe everything has to be confirmed thru Scripture.
While I feel that is honorable, I have to ask where in the Scriptures does it say that everything has to be confirmed through the Scriptures?

As far as I can tell, whenever something was ‘confirmed’, it was either confirmed by enabling people to either do miraculous signs and wonders-- or else it was simply confirmed in the actions of those who professed their faith in Christ as witnessed by a continuum of those whom Christ himself sent out into the world.

This isn’t to say that the Scriptures do not confirm information. Jesus himself, beginning with Moses and all the Prophets, explained to them what was said in all the Scriptures concerning himself. But this was Christ talking and this isn’t the same thing, not unless you’re claiming that the Church is Christ-- and ‘everything’ can be verified in this manner.
 
Do me a favor. Go onto the Eastern Christianity forum and tell them your theory about apostolic succession and who can preside over the Eucharistic transformation. See if they agree with you. I simply cannot deal any further with such obstinate rejection of the Church founded by Christ, and the subsequent invention of new theologies never taught by the Church.

And BTW, this notion you have that “we” have Peter’s apostolic succession and other’s have other apostles, or whatever it is you’re claiming, is unfounded. The lines of apostolic succession have intermingled to the point where no bishop can possibly trace his lineage to a particular apostle, nor is this necessary.
We no longer have Eastern Christianity Forum, its been replaced by Eastern Catholicism. Most Eastern Orthodox are scatted in Non-Catholic Religion Forum.
 
While I feel that is honorable, I have to ask where in the Scriptures does it say that everything has to be confirmed through the Scriptures? .
Scriptures demonstrate is that the truth can be confirmed thru Scripture Acts 17:11 Now these were more noble-minded than those in Thessalonica, for they received the word with great eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so.

and that anything in conflict with the Scriptures should not be trusted. Isa “If they speak not according to this word, there is no light in them.”
 
No. I believe everything has to be confirmed thru Scripture.

It is easy to find proper interpretation within the Scriptures themselves. I knew a woman who didn’t believe the Bible was literal. After praying for her for about three months she suddenly wanted to do a Bible study. I cross reference between books and used the Bible to explain itself.

I avoided any explanations on my own, but instead read Scriptures about the same event from other books in the OT & NT. She understood. God spoke to her thru the Scriptures.

The key is whether or not a person is truly seeking God with there whole heart and soul. When you read, are you seeking to find what you want God to be, or are you seeking to know God. That is what makes the difference. God gave us free will and we get what we are truly seeking.

Freewill. God can speak to us thru the Scriptures.
We can choose to interpret Scripture to please and justify ourselves. Or we can listen to God and trust Him and He will justify us.

John 10:27 My sheep hear my voice, I know them, and they follow me:
OK, here is a real life issue that almost tore the church into two.

With this line of reasoning in you post, can you please explain how the Council of Nicea came to it’s conclusion on the divinity of Christ, considering the fact that the Arian’s used scripture alone as their sole rule of faith in their denying the divinity of Christ.

If the Church used scripture, and the Arians used scripture, how was the decision confirmed by scripture alone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top