Does 2 Tim 3:16-17 support Sola Scriptura?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RussAuburn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Anyone who is saved is saved thru Christ Jesus.
Noone ever denied this to the contrary. Being guaranteed salvation? You really haven’t read the Gospels very carefully. There is the constant warning that we might lose this pearl of great price.

We can lose salvation, and reject redemption.

Don’t you believe in free will? Don’t you believe in sin after Baptism? Dying unrepentant is a real possibilty.

The Catholic Church has always taught this.

peace
 
I have been given a guarantee. God ALWAYS keeps His promises, so I know for a fact I am saved ans will one day be in heaven with Jesus.
Well, we pray that is true. But, according to your Protestant founders, we can sin at will, that the merits of Jesus Christ covers our sins. Our justification just comes with covering these sins, which God apparently is not great enough to take away through the merits of Jesus Christ.

According to the Reformers, we don’t have to do anything, just believe and we are saved. We can even sin, after baptism, but no matter, we are still saved. Those sins are under some covering over our souls, with all the rest of them.

The power that Jesus gave to his first priests: “Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them. Whose sins you shall retain, they are retained”. What sins was he talking about, since with baptisms are sins are washed away (covered over according to you). So this Sacrament of Penance? The Church has made this all up, and so the revisionists did away with it?

Since you are so big on interpreting scripture, how do you interprete that?

Your christian community is a wondrous place. No sin, no guilt, just salvation, and hatred for the Church that Jesus founded…

peace
 
Well, we pray that is true. But, according to your Protestant founders, we can sin at will, that the merits of Jesus Christ covers our sins.
You really don’t know what you are talking about.

Being saved is not a free pass for sinning.

''Blessed are they whose transgressions are forgiven, whose sins are covered. Blessed is the man whose sin the Lord will never count against him." (Romans 4:6-8)
 
…and hatred for the Church that Jesus founded…
I don’t hate Catholics. There are many Catholics whom I love dearly.

Altho, I must admit, I’m not overly fond of you. 😦

But, not to worry…I’m sure we’ll get along fine in heaven. 🙂
 
Not true. There are those who love the Lord, and know the claims of the Catholic Church, but refuse to join.

Look to yourself.

Outside the Church there is no salvation. Any one who is saved is saved through the merits of the Roman Catholic Church.

peace
The Catholic Church is the Mystical Body of Christ. Christ is the Head, and we are the members. Salvation comes through the Church, through Jesus Christ, who is the Head.

That is why the statement is so meaningful, Outside the Church, there is no salvation.

peace
 
You have to understand. Ginger is here to spread her Protestant ‘truth’. She is not here for any Catholic information.
That is why she must be responded to.

peace
I am sorry she doesn’t feel worthy of heaven. The protestant nature in itself is not truth.
 
Salvation comes through the Church, through Jesus Christ, who is the Head.
Salvation comes thru Jesus Christ to the church.

The church is the body of believers who serve in whatever capacity God desires.
 
I don’t hate Catholics. There are many Catholics whom I love dearly.

Altho, I must admit, I’m not overly fond of you. 😦

But, not to worry…I’m sure we’ll get along fine in heaven. 🙂
Yes we detect that bitterness in you and that you are a slave to sin. We will pray for you.
 
:confused:

I’m sorry you have trouble with reading comprehension. 🙂
I comprehend fine, am full of the Holy Spirit and have over come much tendancy to protest myself.

I see that you are a fallen away Catholic. You know that once baptized Catholic you are always Catholic dispite denying the Church. Catholics can always come home. I don’t know what caused your dissillusionment but please remember that if you find yourself alone and betrayed. We are here for you.

Peace.
 
Originally Posted by ryanoneil View Post
Scripture is not self-authenticating. We would not know the Scriptures were inspired unless the Church first told us that they were. Relying on a source outside of Scripture to demonstrate the truth of Scripture undermines sola Scriptura.

That is incorrect. The Bible is a group of books. Each tells a part of the story. Stories are over-lapping and confirm one another.

Much of the Bible can be confirmed thru historic records and archeology - but most important…

The Bible is the living word of God. Thru the Scriptures God often speaks to His people. That in itself allows the Scriptures to be self-authenticating.
The Bible is the living word of God? And through the Scriptures God often speaks to His people? Who said so? The bible said so? Or the Church said so?
 
Joab Anias;2953958:
Ginger2;2953642:
my Church does not contradict Scripture.
But Ginger2, this is what I don’t quite understand from protestant thinking.

How can your church not contradict scripture, and the bible believing church down the street also not contradict scripture if you both have different interpretations of scripture.
It could be OSAS, infant baptism, baptismal regeneration, worship on Saturday or Sunday, and the list could go on.

How do you know that your church does not contradict scripture?

How do you know that it is not the other church which teaches something else contrary to what your church teaches that does not contradict scripture?
Is it because your church is led by the Holy Spirit, and theirs isn’t?
Is it because there is more than one truth that the Holy Spirit leads us to?

This is why Sola Scriptura does not work.
Sola Scriptura leads to division.
Christ prayed for unity, not division

I do not pray for these alone, but also for those who will believe in Me through their word; that they all may be one, as You, Father, are in Me, and I in You; that they also may be one in Us, that the world may believe that You sent Me." (John 17:20-21).
 
The Bible is the living word of God? And through the Scriptures God often speaks to His people? Who said so? The bible said so? Or the Church said so?
Ginger says that the Scriptures are self-authenticating. Whenever did she ever hear such nonesense. Where do you get this stuff from, Ginger?

"I am superman, cause I say I am superman’

The bible is the revealed word of God because the bible says it is the revealed word of God? Pure, unadulterated nonesense. In Logic it is called ‘circular reasoning’.

There are lots of apocrypha. Who says they are not authentic? The Catholic Church says they are not, through the Deposit of faith.

You are swimming way over your head, Ginger, and you are 10 miles off shore.

There are no proofs for Sola Scriptura; there are no proofs for the Scriptures being self-authenticating.

Give the divinely instituted Church of God, the Roman Catholic Church, credit for authenticating the books of the Bible. Give the Catholic Church credit for preserving and interpreting these books for 2,000 years.

peace
 
Ginger2;2954152:
Joab Anias;2953958:
But Ginger2, this is what I don’t quite understand from protestant thinking.

How can your church not contradict scripture, and the bible believing church down the street also not contradict scripture if you both have different interpretations of scripture
.

The Catholic Church admits it does not have an infallible teaching for every verse and that which is not dogma, members are free to believe or not. If two disagree on the meaning of a verse, it does not effect their salvation.

Popes, bishops and priests thru the ages have disagreed on certain teachings and meanings of verses. They are not excommunicated for heresy when there is no declare dogma.
How can your RC not contradict scripture, and the RC down the street also not contradict scripture if you both have different interpretations of scripture?

Because they are not impeccable?

That is my answer also.

But because we depend on the Holy Spirit and agree on the basic doctrine of faith as outlined in Scripture, we become “infallible” What God says is infallible.
 
Popes, bishops and priests thru the ages have disagreed on certain teachings and meanings of verses. They are not excommunicated for heresy when there is no declare dogma.
How can your RC not contradict scripture, and the RC down the street also not contradict scripture if you both have different interpretations of scripture?
Joh 16:13 But when that One comes, the Spirit of Truth, He will guide you into all Truth, for He will not speak from Himself, but whatever He hears, He will speak; and He will announce the coming things to you.

1Jn 4:6 We are of God; the one knowing God hears us. Whoever is not of God does not hear us. From this we know the spirit of truth and the spirit of error.

1Ti 1:3 Even as I called on you to remain in Ephesus, (I going to Macedonia), that you might charge some not to teach other doctrines,

We trust that what the Church proclaims in the final analysis that it is from the Holy Spirit.

And since it holds the keys to the kingdom and the power to loose and bind on Earth and Heaven then what it declares dogma through proper deliberation in the Holy Spirit is now expected to be acsended to regardless if you disagree.

This is in Christ’s plan to achieve unity among the believers.
But because we depend on the Holy Spirit and agree on the basic doctrine of faith as outlined in Scripture, we become “infallible” What God says is infallible.
Exactly and what God says is the Church is the Pillar and Foundation of Truth 2Tim 3:15 and that you must recieve the bread of life, John 6.

Peace.
 
Ginger says that the Scriptures are self-authenticating. Whenever did she ever hear such nonesense. Where do you get this stuff from, Ginger?
The Bible is a collection of many books written by different authors at different times in history. That is one way the Bible authenticates itself. The books speak of historical events and places that can be verified thru independent sources. They can be scientifically dated to know when each was written. The language can be examined to see if it was indeed written in a specific time and area. When these things

So, since the books are authentic and contain accurate historical and geological information, they are able to testify to the truthfulness of their claims about God by cross referencing from one book to another. This also assists in accurate interpretation. In additional, all the books, written by different authors at different times and places, are in harmony with one another - giving the same account from OT to NT. The OT confirms and authenticates the NT.
"I am superman, cause I say I am superman’
The Bible is not one book with one author bearing testimony to itself.
The bible is the revealed word of God because the bible says it is the revealed word of God? …
Yes. Apocryphal books do not clain divine inspiration. In fact, at least one 2 Macc denies it. They contain historical and geographical inaccuracies.
You are swimming way over your head, Ginger, and you are 10 miles off shore.
Praise God!! He is always holding me up and will never let go!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top