Does anyone else struggle with mainstream music?

  • Thread starter Thread starter maxdouglas402
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Clearly, you fit the stereotype of a religious music fan to a T. However, please know that differences in tastes and character are one of finest features of being a human being.

No amount of happy, campy hymns can ever match my sorrow and rage, the war with my own despair, the desire to live an adventure, and the aspirations of freedom.

You can keep your hymnal if that’s what you identify with. I’ll stick to who I am and keep to music that plays true to that tune.
Well you sure are a paragon of tolerance and open-mindedness.🤷

I believe in living a virtuous life which rejects those things contrary to virtue, truth, goodness, and morality. Certainly this doesn’t dictate that I must reject all music that isn’t specifically Christian, but there certainly are plenty of examples of music in the secular realm that should be rejected without question because they do indeed violate these principles. Giving a morally repulsive artist your hard earned money or endorsement is cooperating with evil, even reinforcing of that evil, and is entirely unacceptable even if their work “sounds good.” Many artists and bands who live publicly sinful or atheistic lives produce music that isn’t necessarily filled with evil or sin, but even so you are feeding their habits by paying for or perhaps even merely enjoying the work they create. Positive reinforcement at its best.
 
Well you sure are a paragon of tolerance and open-mindedness.🤷

I believe in living a virtuous life which rejects those things contrary to virtue, truth, goodness, and morality. Certainly this doesn’t dictate that I must reject all music that isn’t specifically Christian, but there certainly are plenty of examples of music in the secular realm that should be rejected without question because they do indeed violate these principles. Giving a morally repulsive artist your hard earned money or endorsement is cooperating with evil, even reinforcing of that evil, and is entirely unacceptable even if their work “sounds good.” Many artists and bands who live publicly sinful or atheistic lives produce music that isn’t necessarily filled with evil or sin, but even so you are feeding their habits by paying for or perhaps even merely enjoying the work they create. Positive reinforcement at its best.
AMEN TO THAT

:amen:
 
Giving a morally repulsive artist your hard earned money or endorsement is cooperating with evil, even reinforcing of that evil, and is entirely unacceptable even if their work “sounds good.” Many artists and bands who live publicly sinful or atheistic lives produce music that isn’t necessarily filled with evil or sin, but even so you are feeding their habits by paying for or perhaps even merely enjoying the work they create. Positive reinforcement at its best.
Take your preaching to the Renaissance Popes. Let’s take this a step further and say why pay for meat when your butcher is an atheist?

Why pay the taxes when your government stands for everything the Church teaches?

Why even live at all when everything eat, drink, and breathe is produced by a sinner?

You preach to me about open-mindedness and tolerance yet you’re no more hypocritical than the left-leaners you so despise.
 
One can listen to whatever they want but why would you want to pump ideas antithetical to Christianity into your brain? I mean if your a devout Catholic and your listening to the Sex Pistols for example your working on serious damage to the soul.
I have a Sex Pistols song and I’m not doing any damage to my soul.
 
Giving a morally repulsive artist your hard earned money or endorsement is cooperating with evil, even reinforcing of that evil, and is entirely unacceptable even if their work “sounds good.” Many artists and bands who live publicly sinful or atheistic lives produce music that isn’t necessarily filled with evil or sin, but even so you are feeding their habits by paying for or perhaps even merely enjoying the work they create. Positive reinforcement at its best.
Oh good! So right here we have a ringing endorsement to illegally download music from anyone deemed “morally repulsive” rather than give them your hard-earned money!

😃
 
Oh good! So right here we have a ringing endorsement to illegally download music from anyone deemed “morally repulsive” rather than give them your hard-earned money!

😃
I don’t quite think that’s what he was getting at…
 
I’ve thought a lot about this subject. I listen mostly to classic rock (Beatles, Queen, The Who, and even some Monkees). While most of what I listen to doesn’t seem to be damaging my soul, or mind, I still wonder if I should be listening to it.
 
I do like the Beatles. and yes adampeter please do message me any other song or bands that are good, both in values and in sound 😃

and lostwanderer I think faithbuilder is just trying to say that it isn’t a good idea to support music that is blatantly evil, especially when the artists openly talk about their disagreement with God and his church outside of a song.
 
I do like the Beatles. and yes adampeter please do message me any other song or bands that are good, both in values and in sound 😃

and lostwanderer I think faithbuilder is just trying to say that it isn’t a good idea to support music that is blatantly evil, especially when the artists openly talk about their disagreement with God and his church outside of a song.
Will do.

I agree to a certain extent…case in point:
Sinead O’Connor, an Irish singer & songwriter, disagrees with the Church on the issue of women priests…She is a fabulous songwriter but chooses to parade around in clerical garb and gives blessings in the name of the Holy Spirit.

I do think as well that some artists (as long as they’re not totally extreme) can be accepted as just being not catholic and we can enjoy their music.
 
Will do.

I agree to a certain extent…case in point:
Sinead O’Connor, an Irish singer & songwriter, disagrees with the Church on the issue of women priests…She is a fabulous songwriter but chooses to parade around in clerical garb and gives blessings in the name of the Holy Spirit.

I do think as well that some artists (as long as they’re not totally extreme) can be accepted as just being not catholic and we can enjoy their music.
I agree. Mature discretion should be applied when selecting any type of media or the arts to enjoy. I do have perimeters for my music tastes and those perimeters are probably wider than some people’s tastes. But I personally can not purchase any music by an artist is blatantly sinful and feels justified in being so. I don’t think anybody should be shamed or attacked to do otherwise. I don’t think we should avoid any artist that isn’t all Catholic or all Christian either. Its not an either/or situation, but discretion should be used and for many, that means not purchasing music with immoral lyrics.
 
and lostwanderer I think faithbuilder is just trying to say that it isn’t a good idea to support music that is blatantly evil, especially when the artists openly talk about their disagreement with God and his church outside of a song.
Even so, my post is the last one you’d reply to to make such a statement. No doubt there are stupid songs out there but still, their stupidity is actually a value.

Take your typical gangsta rap song. In it, I find the perfect sound that resonates with urban decay and the kind of society I’d live to strive against in my own, grim, anti-heroic way.

As a matter of fact, that doesn’t support such music at all but it still one way to listen.
 
Personally, game and anime themes are superior to mainstream music. Why? It’s because those things have depth and beauty.
 
I think that the bottom line here is that we should respect our conscience, and we should make every effort to properly form it. Everyone should have a confessor, if not a spiritual director. If you are involved in an activity that might be a sin, either your conscience or your friends will let you know. Then take it to your priest. Explain the situation clearly and honestly, and follow his advice. Don’t shop around with your morality or attempt to shun his proper authority. In matters that pertain to your soul, he speaks for the Church. Allow him to inform your conscience properly.

It should be a red flag for anyone who posts to these forums when a started thread ignites controversy. There is no clear consensus in this thread because popular music is a spectrum of moral good and evil, and perceptions vary widely about what is acceptable. You may well encounter many priests who come down on both sides of this debate. But you should be careful to observe proper authority by the pastor of your own soul.

We are not alone in this world, and those of us who are Catholic don’t have to interpret the Word of God for ourselves. The Church speaks clearly in all matters of faith and morals. The Holy Spirit is a sure guide for us through the maze of earthy life. Don’t go it alone! The Apostles were never alone, they had Jesus and their brothers for guidance. The saints were never alone, they looked to the Church. Praise God that we can too.
 
If rap music is polluting my mind then long may my mind be polluted.

through the lights, cameras and action / glammer, glitter and gold / i unfold the scroll / plant seeds to stampede the globe
 
I stopped listening to most of it. I listen to Christian music mostly-it can be theologically problematic, but it’s better than most of the stuff in the top 40.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top