Does God Answer Prayer?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Faith1960
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

Faith1960

Guest
At Mass tonight, our Deacon gave a homily about the importance of prayer. My question is – does God answer prayers? There was a huge study done a few years ago where some cardiac patients were prayed for and some weren’t. The results indicated that there was no difference between those being prayed for and those who weren’t. The patients in the group who knew they were being prayed for actually did worse.
There have been times I’ve thought my prayers were answered but this study makes me wonder.
Thoughts?
 
In fact, my dad was just a cardiac patient in the hospital … who died after I prayed for him.
That said, he died soon after receiving Holy Communion and the Sacrament of the Sick.
I thank God for His Divine Mercy and providing us with the Sacraments of the Church.
God answered my prayer for my dad, and I am at peace with the answer.
The funeral will be held on Monday.
 
First of all: Study Schmudy. Who conducted the study and how did he insure that the patients in the “no prayers” group did not have prayers said on their behalf? Plus who ever said that dying is a bad thing? Just a bad experiment, if you ask me.

Second of all: You better know that he answers prayers! He will sometimes answer prayers exactly the way that we expect. Other times, it seems that He is so much more complex and intelligent that we, that He answers them in a different way and even on a different level than what we anticipated.
 
At Mass tonight, our Deacon gave a homily about the importance of prayer. My question is – does God answer prayers? There was a huge study done a few years ago where some cardiac patients were prayed for and some weren’t. The results indicated that there was no difference between those being prayed for and those who weren’t. The patients in the group who knew they were being prayed for actually did worse.
There have been times I’ve thought my prayers were answered but this study makes me wonder.
Thoughts?
My prayers have not been answered (in the “miraculous sense”), so I would be lying if I say I can give an answer from first-hand experience.

That said, I did hear about this study. Studies only show so many things. What the study can not reveal to you is whether the cardiac patients and their family members received emotional comfort from praying. You sometimes hear some Christians talk about how they inevitably ended up accepting “God’s will”, and such feeling is beyond the scope of the study done.

Don’t forget also that we live in a secular world. Were the patients to be healed from their plight, scientists wouldn’t conclude that God was behind it. In fact, they would still rule out the possibility of God regardless, and look for material explanation.

That’s all I can give, and I’m putting my trust into the reliability of some of the weird stories I’ve heard here on CAF and beyond…

Thank you,
Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk
 
In fact, my dad was just a cardiac patient in the hospital … who died after I prayed for him.
That said, he died soon after receiving Holy Communion and the Sacrament of the Sick.
I thank God for His Divine Mercy and providing us with the Sacraments of the Church.
God answered my prayer for my dad, and I am at peace with the answer.
The funeral will be held on Monday.
I’m sorry for the loss of your dad. May he rest in peace.
 
First of all: Study Schmudy. Who conducted the study and how did he insure that the patients in the “no prayers” group did not have prayers said on their behalf? Plus who ever said that dying is a bad thing? Just a bad experiment, if you ask me.

Second of all: You better know that he answers prayers! He will sometimes answer prayers exactly the way that we expect. Other times, it seems that He is so much more complex and intelligent that we, that He answers them in a different way and even on a different level than what we anticipated.
web.med.harvard.edu/sites/RELEASES/html/3_31STEP.html
 
The report on the study pointed out what I said. It is impossible to tell study prayer from background prayer. Also, it assumes that complications after the surgery are a bad thing.

From the three study groups, the one that stands out is the one where the patients had additional intercessory prayer and also knew about the prayers. Any conclusion from the study is that prayer is neutral, but knowledge of prayer is detrimental. The result makes me suspicious of how the groups were divided and data collected. Also, are their results repeatable? It really isn’t science unless someone else can repeat the experiment with similar results.

-AND- I have a suspicion. My suspicion is that God does not want us to use science to test matters of faith. A great example is the miracle of Our Lady of Guadalupe. Our Lady’s image was imprinted on a man’s jacket about 500 years ago. We still have the jacket. Since the 1940’s it has been examined or tested eight or so times. Each time the result is different. There are brush marks. There are no brush marks. The material used for the image is not of this world. The materials are common from that area during that time. The image has been remade three times. The image is original. Etc. Etc. Etc. Each time the jacket was examined/tested the results contradicted the previous effort. The conclusion is always that the previous test employed poor science or technique. My conclusion is different. I conclude that the miracle continues. The examinations provide inclusive results because we are supposed have faith.
 
The report on the study pointed out what I said. It is impossible to tell study prayer from background prayer. Also, it assumes that complications after the surgery are a bad thing.

From the three study groups, the one that stands out is the one where the patients had additional intercessory prayer and also knew about the prayers. Any conclusion from the study is that prayer is neutral, but knowledge of prayer is detrimental. The result makes me suspicious of how the groups were divided and data collected. Also, are their results repeatable? It really isn’t science unless someone else can repeat the experiment with similar results.
What if their results were repetable and further studies garnered the same results – then what?
 
At Mass tonight, our Deacon gave a homily about the importance of prayer. My question is – does God answer prayers? There was a huge study done a few years ago where some cardiac patients were prayed for and some weren’t. The results indicated that there was no difference between those being prayed for and those who weren’t. The patients in the group who knew they were being prayed for actually did worse.
There have been times I’ve thought my prayers were answered but this study makes me wonder.
Thoughts?
Answered prayer generally, IMO, revolves around the extension of the kingdom of God. IOW, sincere prayer that in some way builds faith and/or contributes to accomplishing His will in some manner when answered, will be heard.
 
In fact, my dad was just a cardiac patient in the hospital … who died after I prayed for him.
That said, he died soon after receiving Holy Communion and the Sacrament of the Sick.
I thank God for His Divine Mercy and providing us with the Sacraments of the Church.
God answered my prayer for my dad, and I am at peace with the answer.
The funeral will be held on Monday.
I’m so sorry to hear about your dad. May he rest in peace. :gopray:
 
I think God answers prayers.

The problem is that it’s not always answered in the exact way we were thinking it should nor is it always with the timing we think we need.

God may also not answer a prayer because it may not be in your or someone else’s best interest or that it simply doesn’t work with in His grand plan.

God knows all of the moving parts in the world where as we only know what’s happening around us.

So I’d say God always hears our prayers but does not alway answer them due to reasons far too complex for any of us to really know.
 
The problem with studies is that you can find studies that show that prayer does work as well.

I would think that studies either way would be faulty just for the simple fact that I think that not all prayers are answered. It’s a matter of faith, hard to prove or deny through science.

What I would do is survey Christians who pray regularly and ask how it affects them. Do they get the outcome they were looking for? Do they get a sign from God? How do they feel when they pray?

The most obvious way to find out if there is a connection between your prayer and God is how you feel afterward. Most Christians I know say they feel uplifted, secure, or more positive following a good prayer session and to me that’s God’s doing.
 
When you say their prayers were not answered. To what degree? In the sense that there illness wasn’t healed? Thats not an answer to a Prayer, thats a Miracle. And thats not common.

But whose to say what was answered in those prayers? Whos’ to say these Souls don’t reside in Heaven?

St Augustines mother prayed 16 years for his conversion as a sinner. What we consider time and a 24hr period. Whats that to God?

If indeed these were people of Faith, Baptised and placed their lifes in the hands of Jesus Christ as their savior. They are fine. The only thing lacking is the Faith in believeing that.

God calls those home whom he desires. Man has no control over that. Who’s to question the will of God?
 
A dear friend of mine contracted a very rare eye disease, in which parasites were eating away at his cornea. A bit at time, the vision in that eye became obscured. He said it was like trying to look through a black cloth.

He went to a university hospital and attracted the attention of all of the most senior professors. They gathered around and made a case study of him. All were in agreement that there was no way to reverse the loss of the cornea that had already occurred, and they also agreed that his cornea would continue degenerating until it had all been eaten away, and thus, he would go blind. It was a matter of time; they guessed 3-4 months until the eye was lost forever. They said there was no surgical intervention or medicine that would make any difference.

I began praying for his eye. I visualized it reforming, so that the missing cornea would grow back. I pictured it in my mind as clearly as I could. I also kept “talking to” his other, healthy eye, and asking the two eyes to work together so that the sick eye could “emulate” the pure health of the good eye. I would say to the bad eye, “look at the neighbor next to you, and emulate his pure health! You once looked like that too, and you will again.”

I asked God to intercede on his behalf, and I also asked St. Lucy who had been martyred and whose eyes had been removed.

My friend’s cornea completely grew back within a two-month period, and not only that, there is no scarring! Even when they examined the eye microscopically, no scarring was visible. Every one of the doctors on the case said that it was not explainable by modern science. They even stated intentions to draw up a scholarly journal article about his particular case, hoping it would be published by JAMA.

He mentioned to the doctors that I had prayed for his eye to heal, and they all had a good laugh! He challenged them by saying, “Well, if that didn’t do it, what did?” They admitted that there was no acceptable scientific explanation for how this was possible.
 
A dear friend of mine contracted a very rare eye disease, in which parasites were eating away at his cornea. A bit at time, the vision in that eye became obscured. He said it was like trying to look through a black cloth.

He went to a university hospital and attracted the attention of all of the most senior professors. They gathered around and made a case study of him. All were in agreement that there was no way to reverse the loss of the cornea that had already occurred, and they also agreed that his cornea would continue degenerating until it had all been eaten away, and thus, he would go blind. It was a matter of time; they guessed 3-4 months until the eye was lost forever. They said there was no surgical intervention or medicine that would make any difference.

I began praying for his eye. I visualized it reforming, so that the missing cornea would grow back. I pictured it in my mind as clearly as I could. I also kept “talking to” his other, healthy eye, and asking the two eyes to work together so that the sick eye could “emulate” the pure health of the good eye. I would say to the bad eye, “look at the neighbor next to you, and emulate his pure health! You once looked like that too, and you will again.”

I asked God to intercede on his behalf, and I also asked St. Lucy who had been martyred and whose eyes had been removed.

My friend’s cornea completely grew back within a two-month period, and not only that, there is no scarring! Even when they examined the eye microscopically, no scarring was visible. Every one of the doctors on the case said that it was not explainable by modern science. They even stated intentions to draw up a scholarly journal article about his particular case, hoping it would be published by JAMA.

He mentioned to the doctors that I had prayed for his eye to heal, and they all had a good laugh! He challenged them by saying, “Well, if that didn’t do it, what did?” They admitted that there was no acceptable scientific explanation for how this was possible.
That’s awesome!
 
In fact, my dad was just a cardiac patient in the hospital … who died after I prayed for him.
That said, he died soon after receiving Holy Communion and the Sacrament of the Sick.
I thank God for His Divine Mercy and providing us with the Sacraments of the Church.
God answered my prayer for my dad, and I am at peace with the answer.
The funeral will be held on Monday.
I am very sorry for your loss phoenix,my sincere condolences.May he rest in eternal peace with Our Blessed Lord.

To answer the OP

We are to “pray without ceasing”.1 Thessalonians 5:17

Prayer is to praise God and to communicate with Him.Prayer is not just about asking for our intentions to be answered.

We are encouraged to start and end each day with the sign of the cross (a prayer in itself) and pray throughout the day. It could be one line prayers such as “O Sacred heart of Jesus I place all my trust in You” to the Our Father ,Hail Mary, Glory Be & so forth.October is the Rosary month.

While doing our daily chores we can be silently praying & communicating with Our Blessed Lord.He loves to hear from us.

When we pray for a particular intention yes He hears all our prayers and answers them in His way.We do not always understand the answer or agree with it but in time to come we will learn to understand the answer was for our greater good.

I have had many many prayer petitions answered and I am very grateful to Our Lord.

May God bless you
 
I am very sorry for your loss phoenix,my sincere condolences.May he rest in eternal peace with Our Blessed Lord.

To answer the OP

We are to “pray without ceasing”.1 Thessalonians 5:17

Prayer is to praise God and to communicate with Him.Prayer is not just about asking for our intentions to be answered.

We are encouraged to start and end each day with the sign of the cross (a prayer in itself) and pray throughout the day. It could be one line prayers such as “O Sacred heart of Jesus I place all my trust in You” to the Our Father ,Hail Mary, Glory Be & so forth.October is the Rosary month.

While doing our daily chores we can be silently praying & communicating with Our Blessed Lord.He loves to hear from us.

When we pray for a particular intention yes He hears all our prayers and answers them in His way.We do not always understand the answer or agree with it but in time to come we will learn to understand the answer was for our greater good.

I have had many many prayer petitions answered and I am very grateful to Our Lord.

May God bless you
If God has a plan for us, then what difference does praying actually make? Isn’t He going to follow whatever plan He’s set for us regardless of what we pray for?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top