Does God permit evil to draw a greater good from it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter sacramentdivine
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

sacramentdivine

Guest
Thomistic philosophy says so, however if God permits/allows evil it implies he could stop evil from happening and doing evil is a part of our free will. Therefore, he would be preventing an aspect of our free will which is our capacity for evil and thus, is erroneous. This is my best friend’s (a self described “liberal Christian”) argument. What is a solid philisophical answer to this that is in accord with the Church? 🤷
 
I believe with all my heart and soul that he lets us suffer.
All that matters is that after our death, we return home to him.
The pain here on this Earth is not a matter of questioning,
suffering doesn’t last forever, but being in the presence of God is eternal.
 
God could never be a part of evil since it is against His nature. Evil is part of human nature not God’s.
 
It is up to us…His children to stop it. If He does decide to end it…so goes His creation.
 
God could never be a part of evil since it is against His nature. Evil is part of human nature not God’s.
Aren’t there evils that are not part of human nature? Natural evils such a drought, tsunamis and hurricanes. Isn’t it a bit reductionist to say that evil only comes from man. Evil also comes from the natural world that God created.
 
God is love. He wants only goodness to enter our lives. The devil is alive and well and placing the temptations of this life in our path…just like the devil tempted Jesus, he is always in our path. So we must always be on guard.
 
If God really knows the future, then He must somehow have a way to prevent the bad things that had happened. does that mean God really doesn’t know the outcome of His works?

God is all knowing right? so does that also means before we are born, God had already knew who is going to be in Hell and who is going to be in Heaven?
 
What can you say to someone who flatly states there is no God or the terrible things that happen in this world would not happen?
 
Historical evidence makes it clear that God chose to reveal himself to the people of ancient Israel. Miracles in our modern age confirm God is with us. It is that simple.

God also loves us so much he granted us real freedom. He wants us to choose Him. Sometimes, in our fallen nature and in this fallen world we live in, we make the wrong choices. He even gave us the Sacrament of Penance to reconcile ourselves to Him. He gave us his life to provide the Eucharist that sustains our growth in holiness.

If these points do not work, try to start with a modified form of Pascal’s Wager. It can go something like this. There are two lottery tickets left costing $1/each. The winning prize is $200-million. Would you buy both tickets? Would you buy even one?

What God is offering is eternal life (infinity). All we have to do is follow him. Pick up your cross and follow him for a short 90 years on earth and you have eternal life. Compare this offer with eternal hell. It is persuasive if you think about it a while.

Rick
 
What can you say to someone who flatly states there is no God or the terrible things that happen in this world would not happen?
The existence of evil does not prove the nonexistence of God. I would imagine that those who argue otherwise are swayed by emotion.
Historical evidence makes it clear that God chose to reveal himself to the people of ancient Israel. Miracles in our modern age confirm God is with us. It is that simple.

God also loves us so much he granted us real freedom. He wants us to choose Him. Sometimes, in our fallen nature and in this fallen world we live in, we make the wrong choices. He even gave us the Sacrament of Penance to reconcile ourselves to Him. He gave us his life to provide the Eucharist that sustains our growth in holiness.

If these points do not work, try to start with a modified form of Pascal’s Wager. It can go something like this. There are two lottery tickets left costing $1/each. The winning prize is $200-million. Would you buy both tickets? Would you buy even one?

What God is offering is eternal life (infinity). All we have to do is follow him. Pick up your cross and follow him for a short 90 years on earth and you have eternal life. Compare this offer with eternal hell. It is persuasive if you think about it a while.

Rick
I really don’t think that the historical evidence is as sound as it’s made out to be, nor that the miracles really are miracles.
 
This Fall a new documentary will be available on the miracles of Fatima. In this series of appearances of our Blessed Virgin Mary, an estimated 20,000 people witnessed the “dancing of the sun.” It was reported in newspapers. It is a documented miracle.

Studies have been launched into the image on Saint Juan Diego’s tilma. It also is a miracle.

Yes, miracles do exist to provide hope to all of us. They are also a good tool to use in evangelization.

If the facts are presented, it is clear there is a God and He is calling us. He provides enough evidence to allow our free choice to choose Him, or not. He loves us so much that he allows us the freedom to make either choice. But like the Hound of Heaven, He is persisten in searching us out.
 
This Fall a new documentary will be available on the miracles of Fatima. In this series of appearances of our Blessed Virgin Mary, an estimated 20,000 people witnessed the “dancing of the sun.” It was reported in newspapers. It is a documented miracle.

Studies have been launched into the image on Saint Juan Diego’s tilma. It also is a miracle.

Yes, miracles do exist to provide hope to all of us. They are also a good tool to use in evangelization.

If the facts are presented, it is clear there is a God and He is calling us. He provides enough evidence to allow our free choice to choose Him, or not. He loves us so much that he allows us the freedom to make either choice. But like the Hound of Heaven, He is persisten in searching us out.
A little bit of research into the Fatima incident reveals that not all witnesses saw a dancing sun. I find that very revealing.

An image on a tilma that cannot be explained does not automatically prove divine intervention.
 
A little bit of research into the Fatima incident reveals that not all witnesses saw a dancing sun. I find that very revealing.

An image on a tilma that cannot be explained does not automatically prove divine intervention.
Shame they couldn’t set up scientific conditions to test unprejudiced reactions - mind you, I don’t notice everything that goes on, up to and including whether the sun dances or not - the question is, who would be delusional? Those that saw the dance and expected to see the dance, or those who expected *not * to see the dance and did not? Are such expectations necessarily directly causal?

Of course, you could then take it further - say those who saw the dance despite skepticism were subliminally induced to believe - or that those who did not see the dance despite belief were subliminally induced to disbelieve… if either of these is relevant…

(Furthermore, you could reverse all this - view the believers as disbelievers in exclusively mundane causation, making them able to see what was real, and the disbelievers as believers in exclusively mundane causation, deluding themselves in visions of normalistic phenomena - making the accusation of delusion, subsequently, wholly reversable also)

The possibilities are endless! Oh, to see the World with unprejudiced eyes! :rolleyes:
 
Shame they couldn’t set up scientific conditions to test unprejudiced reactions - mind you, I don’t notice everything that goes on, up to and including whether the sun dances or not - the question is, who would be delusional? Those that saw the dance and expected to see the dance, or those who expected *not * to see the dance and did not? Are such expectations necessarily directly causal?
There were a few “conformity experiments”: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asch_conformity_experiments

I don’t think that anybody was delusional. I think that this whole incident is attributable to mass hysteria.
Mystic Banana:
Of course, you could then take it further - say those who saw the dance despite skepticism were subliminally induced to believe - or that those who did not see the dance despite belief were subliminally induced to disbelieve… if either of these is relevant…
Subliminal messaging/control doesn’t really work, and I’m not proposing that any group of people actively tried to deceive others.

Mystic Banana said:
(Furthermore, you could reverse all this - view the believers as disbelievers in exclusively mundane causation, making them able to see what was real, and the disbelievers as believers in exclusively mundane causation, deluding themselves in visions of normalistic phenomena - making the accusation of delusion, subsequently, wholly reversable also)

The possibilities are endless! Oh, to see the World with unprejudiced eyes! :rolleyes:

I don’t know why you’re speculating as to what I could argue.
 
What can you say to someone who flatly states there is no God or the terrible things that happen in this world would not happen?
You tell them that God loves them so much that He even allows the greatest evil of all: the ability to reject Him…teachccd
 
If God really knows the future, then He must somehow have a way to prevent the bad things that had happened. does that mean God really doesn’t know the outcome of His works?
Actually, I’m pretty sure God has allowed “bad” things to happen all the time. One might argue that he’s taken a more direct hand in it from time to time as well. Furthermore, what may seem like a bad thing at one point may lead to a greater payoff later. I don’t like to use the example, but it might be like in chess when you see someone lose the queen early on and then they beat you later.
God is all knowing right? so does that also means before we are born, God had already knew who is going to be in Hell and who is going to be in Heaven?
This is a touchier issue and I’m still stuck with the chess thing. Say you’re playing a game against God, He is allowed to pass turns and is trying to teach you something. He knows all the strategies, all the moves, and all the consequences. Nonetheless, there are instances he says pass and suddenly thousands of options are eliminated and opened up. He isn’t interested in forcing anyone to win, but rather in getting you to realize something. At the end of the game, he has your answer, you got it or you didn’t. Yes, he knows you before you were even born, but there are times he’s saying pass and waiting for your move. Yes, it’s a convoluted example, but I hope it helps. I can’t really word it differently without sounding funny.
 
For clarity, are you specifically asking about the Christian God?

There are many religions out there, so which one are we concerned with here and why?
 
OK - this is the third thread (at least) in the last few hours which brings up the basic question of “Why does God allow evil in the world.”

The short answer is:

“God does not want to make us happy. God wants to make us holy.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top