Does life begin at conception or 14 day stage?

  • Thread starter Thread starter St_Gregory
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

St_Gregory

Guest
Recent (i.e. the last 100 years or so) Catholic theology has firmly help that we become true humans from conception.
The strengths of this position are that it makes sense to give the dignity of humanity right from the start of the human’s journey through life: if you have a picture of dots/lines firstly in random squiggles in chaos followed but a wiggly, but definite line, then the dignity of that line (whatever that is) begins surly from its start. With Abortion, to pick a point between conception and death where “life” begins is nonsensical.

But has any Catholics seriously considered the plausibility of ensoulment occurring at 14 days? While I do not accept this position, a few recent Catholic Philosophers have including Peter Singer have (though you may need to know that many of his views seem quite unorthodox). I will briefly outline what seems to me to be the two main strengths of this position:
  1. The pre-embryo can split into two organisms and return to one up to 14 days. If this is so it seems ludicrous to say that this organism has a soul since it seems to have no definitive identity. Our soul is the one thing that ABSOLUTELY makes us who we personally are. But if the pre-embryo cannot be said to have a definite identify/person then how can it have a soul? Or how can it be said to be “a person”?
    — I cannot honestly give a strong counter argument to this except offer a weaker counter argument that goes roughly like this: whatever it will be is observed by the Timeless God and so it (or they) may have it’s/their soul/s
  2. The other reason, why some would reject that the pre-embryo is a true human before 14 days, is that many pre-embryos naturally are lost (miscarriages). It seems hard to believe that God would lovingly create a human being, only to flush it down the toilet the next day or the next week. (sorry for the strong language but I felt it was appropriate).
    — This is another strong argument. It seems to me that because of this argument we either admit that pre-embryos are not humans OR we accept that God/nature kills many many innocent people in just a few days of existence which clearly adds a whole new dimension to the problem of evil and suffering. It’s not an easy question.
I will concede that the 14 day stage does seem a strong position; in fact I’d go as far as to say that it is MORE likely that ensoulment occurs then rather than conception but because we do not know, and ensoulment may occur at conception despite the above problems, we should not abort, or experiment on, pre-embryos.

My conclusion is in no way conclusive (hence the reason I made this thread for the discussion to begin) but I think it is rational.
 
The soul is what makes a living thing live; the spirit is a living immaterial being with capacity for emotion, perception, reason and moral judgment (including undeveloped capacity); the human soul and spirit are one and are never separable; therefore, the human organism is ensouled from the moment s/he comes into existence, which is at conception.
People die at every age. God wants us all to live. But the fallen world makes us subject to nature, including death. Our role is to protect one another, and we get better at it all the time, but there are those too frail to be protected from harm still. It would be comforting, surely, to imagine that the tiniest humans are still awaiting souls, but it isn’t so. They have souls. One day we will be able to protect them better.
 
Peter Singer is not a Catholic philosopher. He’s the guy who thinks parents should be able to kill off their born children, that handicapped people have no right to live, and some really revolting things about animals.

“Ensoulment” is not a new concept. It was a brief speculative theological response to the science of a past day, in which it was difficult to tell that the baby was alive and kicking until the baby actually started kicking. The notion went away again as biology progressed, and as the importance of conception to Christology, the scriptures, and Mary became clear.

It also may have reflected some the beliefs of some non-Christian groups, such as the beliefs of Roma and other groups from India that babies weren’t babies but rather demon-infested until they were a certain number of days old, and hence that they should not be named or treated as persons until the parents were sure that the kid wouldn’t die and hence decided that the kid had a soul instead of a demon now. (Or something like that. I’m not good at remembering the details.)

The only reason “ensoulment” has come back into play is that people want to abort kids without feeling guilty about killing another human being like themselves.

As for miscarriages… Is there really a difference between having your natural death at 14 days, or 14 years, or 140 years? Are some people more important than others because they live longer? Are kindergarten kids only an eighth the person I am, and am I only 40% as human as Aunt Ruth in the nursing home?

(I’ve heard of respect for elders, but that’s ridiculous!) 😉
 
The question is a scientific question, not one of theology or philosophy. It is a scientific fact that from conception, the developing embryo is alive.

– Mark L. Chance.
 
The question is a scientific question, not one of theology or philosophy. It is a scientific fact that from conception, the developing embryo is alive.

– Mark L. Chance.
Science is more often wrong than right. The best thing to do is accept the Church’s teaching over science.
 
Your title and your question don’t match.

Life begins at conception, this is a simple biological fact.

As for ensoulment, the Church has never definatively taught as to what the timing is for the soul to enter the body. It does teach and has always taught that human life is to be protected and not destroyed. Ensoulment is a purely philosophical question, not a moral one.

Peter Singer is not a Catholic nor a philosopher. I believe he is an atheist and is a bioethicist by trade.
  1. a lot of weird and interesting things happen during pregnancy. By this reasoning, Siamese twins should be condered as one person and to have only one soul even in adulthood.
  2. It depends on how you define many. Many babies die in the first trimester. Many babies died during childbirth in centuries past. Many babies die in infancy. That people die in large numbers every day is part of being human and God does not kill them. (I can’t even type your crude metaphore :mad: ) in utero or at any other point in their life. This is all part of God’s permissive will.
 
“the developing embryo is alive and is human.”

Well, only if the parents are human.

👍

– Mark L. Chance.
 
The difficulty of accepting ensoulment anytime after conception is that it’s arbitrary,
The pre-embryo can split into two organisms and return to one up to 14 days. If this is so it seems ludicrous to say that this organism has a soul since it seems to have no definitive identity.
I wonder who’s claiming this can happen and on what evidence? And at what particular stage (pre-embryo isn’t exactly a scientific term…blastocyst? morula? etc.
Our soul is the one thing that ABSOLUTELY makes us who we personally are. But if the pre-embryo cannot be said to have a definite identify/person then how can it have a soul? Or how can it be said to be “a person”?
Well, yes, that’s the thing. No soul-No person-No Human.

That’s why we say an embryo has is ensouled at conception, otherwise the time of ensoulment would be stage-dependant, giving abortionists their “moral window of opportunity”, so to speak. Not that we arbitrarily decide that conception is the time of ensoulment to head off any pro-abortion arguments, rather vice-versa, we can counter such arguments precisely since the embryo is humanly ensouled at the moment of conception.
 
hm. Could have thought that this discussion was about human life:rolleyes:
 
  1. The pre-embryo can split into two organisms and return to one up to 14 days. If this is so it seems ludicrous to say that this organism has a soul since it seems to have no definitive identity. Our soul is the one thing that ABSOLUTELY makes us who we personally are. But if the pre-embryo cannot be said to have a definite identify/person then how can it have a soul? Or how can it be said to be “a person”?
    — I cannot honestly give a strong counter argument to this except offer a weaker counter argument that goes roughly like this: whatever it will be is observed by the Timeless God and so it (or they) may have it’s/their soul/s
Why is that a weak counter argument? God most certainly does know if the pre-embryo will split. Why is it weak to suggest that he acts accordingly?
  1. The other reason, why some would reject that the pre-embryo is a true human before 14 days, is that many pre-embryos naturally are lost (miscarriages). It seems hard to believe that God would lovingly create a human being, only to flush it down the toilet the next day or the next week. (sorry for the strong language but I felt it was appropriate).
    — This is another strong argument. It seems to me that because of this argument we either admit that pre-embryos are not humans OR we accept that God/nature kills many many innocent people in just a few days of existence which clearly adds a whole new dimension to the problem of evil and suffering. It’s not an easy question.
Why is a few days more problematic than “three score and ten”? And why is it more problematic than 9 months - many embryos and fetuses die in the womb, not to mention all the ones aborted.

The problem I see with both of your arguments is that they try to draw a demarcation line where there is really only a continuum. There is no sharp break at 14 days. If anything, your arguments reinforce the idea that there is no demarcation line anywhere in the life of a fertilized human ovum, other than the very moment of conception.
 
I have actually thought about this question when I took embryology in college. It is amazing how twins are developed. Either the zygote (fertilized egg) splits but the two newly form cells do not attached and you have two babies now, or during the blastocyte stage, the cell mass splits into two and develop on opposite sides and again you have two babies. My personal conclusion was life must begin at conception because the zygote begins to divide showing a sign of life, since we know the soul animates the body and the single cell is animate by dividing. If the zygote splits and does not attach, the two cells still continue to divide, again showing life. With the blastocyst, both cell mass continues to grow again showing sign of life.

Now I think it would be silly to try to try to answer the question when are the two souls ensouled. Are both souls ensouled at the moment of conception or is one souls ensouled first and then the other soul is ensouled when the new child comes forth from the dividing zygote or cell mass. It would be like arguing over the very moment the bread becomes Jesus. Who cares? It Jesus.

Sorry for the medical term. I am not trying to dehumanize the child, just trying to verify the stages of development.
 
Educating oneself away from the Truth by The Liar.

Life begins at the moment of conception. Catecism #2270. It is doctrine of the faith.
 
Now I think it would be silly to try to try to answer the question when are the two souls ensouled. Are both souls ensouled at the moment of conception or is one souls ensouled first and then the other soul is ensouled when the new child comes forth from the dividing zygote or cell mass.
Yes, it may be a silly distinction for us, but it’s an important moral theology question that needs to be explained to counter the “it’s just a blob of tissue” or a “parasite” or “not human until it’s born” arguments.
 
Yes, it may be a silly distinction for us, but it’s an important moral theology question that needs to be explained to counter the “it’s just a blob of tissue” or a “parasite” or “not human until it’s born” arguments.
I agree that personhood or ensoulment is an important moral theological question. But to counter the points you listed, you just need basic biology (and a dictionary).

Not a human, than what? As Cardinal Egan often says, " a rabbit?". Life of any kind must fall into a scientific classification. Newly conceived life is human, it can’t be anything else.

Blob of tissue? Nope, that doesn’t work either, biologically. People can have all kinds of masses and blobs in thier bodies but they all share DNA with the person in which they are contained. With a newly conceived human, it has its own unique DNA.

Parasites (this is where the dictionary helps) are dependant organisms of other species. Again, what species, other than human, can you possibly classify the newly conceived life into?
 
Life begins at conception. End of story. The Liar would throw all these “thological possibilities” at us to confuse us, certainly he has confused them because they don’t know. They believe the Lie and thus hold the knife.
 
Life begins at conception. End of story. The Liar would throw all these “thological possibilities” at us to confuse us, certainly he has confused them because they don’t know. They believe the Lie and thus hold the knife.
I think someone who suggested and evaluated theological possibilities should be commended for being objective and honest actually. Sure he may not know the definite answers himself but it really would be immoral to deny the progress of understanding for the sake of traditions.
If you’re gonna make a harsh stab at people for being honest and wanting to seek the truth then I expect you think to re-evaluate your own virtue.
40.png
Corki:
Your title and your question don’t match.

Life begins at conception, this is a simple biological fact.
As for ensoulment, the Church has never definatively taught as to what the timing is for the soul to enter the body. It does teach and has always taught that human life is to be protected and not destroyed. Ensoulment is a purely philosophical question, not a moral one.
Well I was treating “life” and “ensoulment” synonymously in my context: IOW “human” as opposed to mere “organism” (for example; a bunch of human cancer cells are biologically homo-sapiens, that doesn’t make them humans)

I was also question your distinction between philisophical and moral questions; in American is no moral philosophy a branch of philosophy? Is not Ethics a branch of philosophy? or is that just english? – either way your point seems null.
40.png
Corki:
  1. a lot of weird and interesting things happen during pregnancy. By this reasoning, Siamese twins should be condered as one person and to have only one soul even in adulthood.
  2. It depends on how you define many. Many babies die in the first trimester. Many babies died during childbirth in centuries past. Many babies die in infancy. That people die in large numbers every day is part of being human and God does not kill them. (I can’t even type your crude metaphore :mad: ) in utero or at any other point in their life. This is all part of God’s permissive will.
  1. yes it does, but that’s irrelevant to the question: how can one have a soul without a definite identity?
    As for siamese twins; they are two people → two souls; but I see not why that changes the validity of my argument - if a pre-embryo is only one organism then it has a soul surly? but if it then splits does that mean the soul has split too? and if the two organisms become one again, does that mean the souls have fused into one?
  2. What crude metaphore? - and why get mad? I see not how that is justified
    You can’t just say “this is all God’s permissive will” for at least two reasons: firstly you have to explain why a Good God would permit this incredible evil and secondly Philosophers such as T. Aquinas held that God is Simple and Necessary (which are now Dogmas) and therefore God’s knowledge is causal: this means that God’s will is not permissive in the sense that things happen beyond His control, but rather God’s Will is always persuasive.
40.png
Tobinatorstark:
Science is more often wrong than right. The best thing to do is accept the Church’s teaching over science.
I have problems with this: as Catholics we accept Dogmas as true, but we shouldn’t put things which aren’t dogmas above ideas which are scientifically justified (though not proven since you cannot prove anything in science) since God calls us to rational thought.
Were the fundamentalist Catholics who denied the motion of the earth right to accept traditional doctrine over Galileo’s science? No.
 
40.png
mintaka:
“Ensoulment” is not a new concept. It was a brief speculative theological response to the science of a past day, in which it was difficult to tell that the baby was alive and kicking until the baby actually started kicking. The notion went away again as biology progressed, and as the importance of conception to Christology, the scriptures, and Mary became clear.

It also may have reflected some the beliefs of some non-Christian groups, such as the beliefs of Roma and other groups from India that babies weren’t babies but rather demon-infested until they were a certain number of days old, and hence that they should not be named or treated as persons until the parents were sure that the kid wouldn’t die and hence decided that the kid had a soul instead of a demon now. (Or something like that. I’m not good at remembering the details.)

The only reason “ensoulment” has come back into play is that people want to abort kids without feeling guilty about killing another human being like themselves.
Whatever you interpret ensoulment to mean, I am only asking when an pre-/embryo gains a soul
40.png
mintaka:
As for miscarriages… Is there really a difference between having your natural death at 14 days, or 14 years, or 140 years? Are some people more important than others because they live longer? Are kindergarten kids only an eighth the person I am, and am I only 40% as human as Aunt Ruth in the nursing home?
No one is denying that the sanctity of life is equal across all life I don’t think.
But I do have massive problems with this passage of your post: you are intellectually correct that natural death is just as bad whenever, but I cannot spiritually agree with it: a God who is meant to love us should not just kill people arbitrarily. O yes “God’s will be done” but we believe that God’s Will is good, rather than arbitrary and so there must be some good reason for these many pre-premature deaths; or else they’re not real deaths (of humans with souls) at all since ensoulment occurs at 14 days (I am questioning)
Look at it this way: if life on earth is a vessel of freewill so to build love for God and enter heaven (though some may freely go the other way), then what happens to pre-premature babies who die without a few days? They have had no power to exercise freewill so they could not have build love of God. Yes they will go to heaven since they are unaccountable but they are denied the ultimate joys of heaven since they did not love and suffer for God.
If you deny that they cannot experience the fullness of heaven then you need to explain what the point of life on earth was anyway? Why couldn’t God create us all as pre-embryos, kill us and take us to heaven?
Another idea is that they are re-incarnated but this would be contrary to Catholic doctrine of course.
40.png
sidekick:
I have actually thought about this question when I took embryology in college. It is amazing how twins are developed. Either the zygote (fertilized egg) splits but the two newly form cells do not attached and you have two babies now, or during the blastocyte stage, the cell mass splits into two and develop on opposite sides and again you have two babies. My personal conclusion was life must begin at conception because the zygote begins to divide showing a sign of life, since we know the soul animates the body and the single cell is animate by dividing. If the zygote splits and does not attach, the two cells still continue to divide, again showing life. With the blastocyst, both cell mass continues to grow again showing sign of life.
Wow that’s interesting. I’ll think about it.
However I would question whether it is the soul which animates the body; I would say the brain determined by nature animates the body and the soul is the person of you which makes choices of freewill, i.e. in choices in faith/morals.
 
I agree that personhood or ensoulment is an important moral theological question. But to counter the points you listed, you just need basic biology (and a dictionary).

Not a human, than what? As Cardinal Egan often says, " a rabbit?". Life of any kind must fall into a scientific classification. Newly conceived life is human, it can’t be anything else.

Blob of tissue? Nope, that doesn’t work either, biologically. People can have all kinds of masses and blobs in thier bodies but they all share DNA with the person in which they are contained. With a newly conceived human, it has its own unique DNA.

Parasites (this is where the dictionary helps) are dependant organisms of other species. Again, what species, other than human, can you possibly classify the newly conceived life into?
I’m with you. Too bad so many others aren’t out there. 😦
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top