S
St_Gregory
Guest
Recent (i.e. the last 100 years or so) Catholic theology has firmly help that we become true humans from conception.
The strengths of this position are that it makes sense to give the dignity of humanity right from the start of the human’s journey through life: if you have a picture of dots/lines firstly in random squiggles in chaos followed but a wiggly, but definite line, then the dignity of that line (whatever that is) begins surly from its start. With Abortion, to pick a point between conception and death where “life” begins is nonsensical.
But has any Catholics seriously considered the plausibility of ensoulment occurring at 14 days? While I do not accept this position, a few recent Catholic Philosophers have including Peter Singer have (though you may need to know that many of his views seem quite unorthodox). I will briefly outline what seems to me to be the two main strengths of this position:
My conclusion is in no way conclusive (hence the reason I made this thread for the discussion to begin) but I think it is rational.
The strengths of this position are that it makes sense to give the dignity of humanity right from the start of the human’s journey through life: if you have a picture of dots/lines firstly in random squiggles in chaos followed but a wiggly, but definite line, then the dignity of that line (whatever that is) begins surly from its start. With Abortion, to pick a point between conception and death where “life” begins is nonsensical.
But has any Catholics seriously considered the plausibility of ensoulment occurring at 14 days? While I do not accept this position, a few recent Catholic Philosophers have including Peter Singer have (though you may need to know that many of his views seem quite unorthodox). I will briefly outline what seems to me to be the two main strengths of this position:
- The pre-embryo can split into two organisms and return to one up to 14 days. If this is so it seems ludicrous to say that this organism has a soul since it seems to have no definitive identity. Our soul is the one thing that ABSOLUTELY makes us who we personally are. But if the pre-embryo cannot be said to have a definite identify/person then how can it have a soul? Or how can it be said to be “a person”?
— I cannot honestly give a strong counter argument to this except offer a weaker counter argument that goes roughly like this: whatever it will be is observed by the Timeless God and so it (or they) may have it’s/their soul/s - The other reason, why some would reject that the pre-embryo is a true human before 14 days, is that many pre-embryos naturally are lost (miscarriages). It seems hard to believe that God would lovingly create a human being, only to flush it down the toilet the next day or the next week. (sorry for the strong language but I felt it was appropriate).
— This is another strong argument. It seems to me that because of this argument we either admit that pre-embryos are not humans OR we accept that God/nature kills many many innocent people in just a few days of existence which clearly adds a whole new dimension to the problem of evil and suffering. It’s not an easy question.
My conclusion is in no way conclusive (hence the reason I made this thread for the discussion to begin) but I think it is rational.