Does the arguing help us reach mystical union?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JReducation
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JReducation

Guest
I have been on CAF for almost two years. This question really causes me to think. During the two years that I have been on CAF I have see more arguing about everything from the form of the mass to the election of a president. I understand that these issues are important to people. However, there is more to the faith than arguing and debating. There is the search for interior peace, the search for God’s voice in our lives. Where is that search? Isn’t it sad that there are most posts on the Traditional Catholicism and Liturgy threads than on the Spirituality Threads? One would think that the spiritual life of contemplation, penance, austerity, detachment from material things, Christ in the liturgy, and the Gospel life are more important topics of discussion.

Shouldn’t we be thinking about our life in the Church, rather than everyone else’s? Rather than becoming self-appointed canonists, liturgists, theologians and pastors, should we be struggling to become saints? Should we be talking about that? Shouldn’t we be talking about the saints more and learning from them?

This has been a very rich time of year and many posters on CAF have not noticed or have not commented on it. During the summer months we remember great men and women such as: Maximilian Kolbe, Bl. Mother Teresa, St. Clare, St. Bonaventure, St. Augustine, St. Dominic, St. Monica and coming up are the Stigmata of St. Francis, the Exultation of the Holy Cross, St. Padre Pio, St. Teresa of Avila, St. Therese of Liseaux and St. Francis of Assisi. There is so much that we can learn from these holy men and women, so much about our faith, the love of the Blessed Sacrament, their love of the liturgy of the Eucharist and the Liturgy of the Hours and their love for the Church.

I wonder if we don’t have to soften up a little and move away from the conflicts once in a while and enter into the silence. I was recently reading some writings by the Carthusians and I was stunned by what they find in the silence and separation from the noise and tumult of the Church and yet remain within the Church. This is an incredible achievement, to stay clear of the conflicts in the Church and to remain in the Church in love with her and at her service. I for one would like to learn their method.

As my community begins its month long preparation to celebrate the Solemnity of St. Francis on October 4 and we just celebrated the feast day of Bl. Mother Teresa on September 5, I am struck by both of these holy people. They were not robots. They were not ignorant of the issues in the Church around them. Yet, they lived in their present moment. They dealt with what was at hand, their call to respond to the Father’s love with a perfect human love. They dealt with their own sinfulness, rather than struggle with everyone else’s sins. They dealt with their own call to serve, rather than with the lack of service on the part of others. They worshiped God in the liturgy without running it through a litmus test every time. Finally, they gave of themselves to those who came before them, because they saw Christ in every person, not because the person needed to convert to Catholicism. Yet, they knew of all this. But it did not take away from their focus on the one thing that really counted for their salvation, to do God’s will in their lives first and as they went along, they brought others to God.

Shouldn’t we take lessons from these holy men and women? Does our soul really benefit from the conflicts and debates on these threads or do these conflicts take away from our inner silence and peace, where God whispers words of eternal love as a bridegroom to the bride on their wedding night?

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
You have a point but there should never be a question of ‘either/or’ as if it’s “either argue or remain silent.”

Some argument is unkind and unhelpful. But other argument, even if it looks (to some) to be unkind and unhelpful, isn’t.

If a person has, say, a gangrenous foot, and loses blood supply, one first tries non-invasive treatments, and then sometimes surgery must be done. It’s painful. And sometimes that surgery still does not work, and further surgery must be done, even to amputation of that gangrenous foot, in order for the rest of that person to be healed.

It could be that any given argument exchange is just an unwanted or hurtful wound. . .but it could also be a necessary treatment.
 
You have a point but there should never be a question of ‘either/or’ as if it’s “either argue or remain silent.”

Some argument is unkind and unhelpful. But other argument, even if it looks (to some) to be unkind and unhelpful, isn’t.

If a person has, say, a gangrenous foot, and loses blood supply, one first tries non-invasive treatments, and then sometimes surgery must be done. It’s painful. And sometimes that surgery still does not work, and further surgery must be done, even to amputation of that gangrenous foot, in order for the rest of that person to be healed.

It could be that any given argument exchange is just an unwanted or hurtful wound. . .but it could also be a necessary treatment.
But is this the example of the saints? The saints seemed to radiate truth and teach truth while at the same time preserving silence and inner peace. What we often see on CAF is that people get angry, hurt or hurt others, become obsessive over an issue and even attack the Church and her leadership, which was not part of the behavior of the saints. The saints communicated truth in a peaceful manner and always closed with the same humble admission that they were nothing and no one. The postings on CAF rarely end with this admission of nothingness. They tend to end with an air of authority that must make us wonder if the person is benefiting from what he or she is saying.

My point is that we must benefit spiritually from these diaglogues and the only way to do so is to admit that our inner peace is more important than winning the argument. In the end, we will not find Christ by winning an argument, but only as the fruit of true contemplation and silence. At some point, one must state his peace and move along rather than continue through 300 posts defending a point that another person does not want to buy into. The wisdom of the saints points out that this is not a proper use of time that is given to us for the contemplative life, which we are all called.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
Thank you Brother JR for putting up a great argument for balancing up CAF and helping us to be more aware of what we are really missing out on. I am going to try to follow your useful suggestions when on CAF, like paying more attention to the lives of the many exemplary saints… and also on, as you suggest, aspects of:

“…contemplation, penance, austerity, detachment from material things, Christ in the liturgy, and the Gospel life [which] are more important topics of discussion.”

I think that most of us really use CAF on several levels and I’m afraid that one of the main ones is entertainment… as unlikely as it might sound but Catholic faith centred entertainment… and for some that’s like playing one of those computer games where winning is the ultimate goal (hence the ‘competitions’ about winning the argument on some Canonical point, sin classification, minute detail about how a Mass is conducted or the ‘proper’ way a prayer or devotion is recited)…while kindness and the love of Christ takes one of the back seats in the CAF synagogue.

I will have to say that CAF has become important to me because I don’t have anyone local with whom I can discuss the deeper or even petty issues of the Catholic faith with. I confess that I do use CAF for entertainment sometimes but I try to balance it out a bit by helping out with the prayer intentions and paying attention to the very helpful insights people have on aspects of our Catholic faith. I have already been richly rewarded in my faith as a result.

I will have to say that you are a true Franciscan.

In Christ,
 
As a matter of fact, I’ve started a prayer thread in which I asked St. Maximilian Kolbe for intercession on his feast day, and Bl. Mother Teresa of Calcutta for intercession on her feast day. This seemed appropriate given that both of these figures had ties to both the media and the defense of the sanctity of human life. The thread is currently buried somewhere in the Prayer Intentions section of the forum and is called “For Sarah Palin.” If you take a look at my profile page and look under Statistics to see which threads I’ve started, you should be able to find it pretty easily. When it seems like more prayers are needed for this intention, I will go back to the thread and post again.

The other day I was by some coincidence talking on the phone with a friend I’ve made here at CAF and the feast of the Exultation of the Holy Cross came up.

I regret having missed several of the feast days, and will hopefully be more mindful of the upcoming ones, especially for St. Padre Pio and St. Teresa of Avila. (To St. Teresa it might well be a prayer like, “Well, you know what I’m like … help!”) :o As for the feast day of St. Francis, some years back he apparently gave me the gift of a Mockingbird coming close to sing for me special through his intercession on his day … I still gratefully remember.

All this said, there are other saints. I’ve always had a hard time trying to figure out whether I was more Benedictine, Carmelite, Dominican, or Franciscan … and none of these seemed to really fit. Meanwhile, when asked to name a favorite saint, over the years it seems that St. Michael is the one who comes the quickest to my mind. And it seems that I tend to go better with St. Joan of Arc than with St. Therese and the roses. And the saint whose feast day is closest to my birthday is St. John the Baptist, the voice crying in the wilderness to make straight the way of the Lord … until that voice was silenced when he was beheaded.

Amazingly enough, it also happens that I’m the one who’s started the Carthusian Spirituality social group here at CAF. This would help explain why I could never decide between the more well-known Orders and charisms … because it was only all-too-recently that I was introduced to the hidden treasure of this lesser-known one. I admit that there are probably many here at CAF who would be far more knowledgeable on Carthusian life than I am … I’m definitely a learner along with others who join and ask questions. What we don’t know, we research together. And I trust the Holy Spirit to send the right people to join, … as few or as many as it will be … whatever is for the best.

As for whether our souls really benefit from the debates here at CAF, that depends of course on the charity of the participants in the debate. God made us all unique individuals … the answer in all cases is to seek and follow His Will.

~~ the phoenix
 
I agree with the above. Our goal should be to do the will of God. However, I remain rather uncomfortable with some threads on CAF where I see too many people dig their heels in a posiiton or a point and like someone already said, they argue as if this was some kind of Catholic game where the goal is to win, not to grow in faith.

I was recently on a liturgy thread and I had to back out of it as graciously as possible. The individuals involved were so focussed on the rubrics of the mass that no one was talking about the spiritual value of the mass for the soul and for the world. It seemed that everyone felt it was more important to argue the rules of Gregorian chant vs the rules of other kinds of music at mass and no one once mentioned the fact that singing, which ever kind you do, should be a form of prayer I’m trying to remember which saint said, “When you sing you pray twice.” I felt saddened by the fact that the focus was on what pope said what about liturgical music, rather than on the purpose of music in liturgy and even in private prayer.

From where I sit, as a religious who belongs to a contemplative community (mendicant, not monastic) I was frustrated to find that many of my Catholic brothers and sisters have missed the boat on this point. We sing to praise God, not to comply with rules. The rules are there to help us pray better. In the end, the goal is to pray and through prayer that begins with song to reach prayer that is silent where the soul and God communicate through love without words. That being said, I felt that I was not getting much learning about prayer and holiness through liturgy, but in reality I was watching a contest as to who could quote more Church documents on liturgical music in order to shut the other person’s mouth.

In speaking to a priest who subscribes to CAF we were both saddened to realize that there are so many people on these threads who are well educated on the rules of liturgy and other Church documents, but have such a weak knowledge of Christian spirituality, to the point that they do not realize that what made the saints great was not their attachment to rules and encyclicals, but their heroic lives and most of all their interior life and how they approach the Incarnate Christ in the liturgy and in others. They seem to forget that the liturgy sanctifies because it produces in us the grace of charity, not the grace of legalism. While good liturgy will certainly inspire prayer, liturgical policing will only trigger frustration and distraction during the most critical prayer in Christian spirituality. I certainly feel that it’s a shame when that time before the Lord of Lords is spent distracrted. What most saints discovered was the art, if it can be called that, the art of silencing their mind and focussing their attention and their senses on Christ, whether it’s in the liturgy or in the daily activities of human life.

Fraternally,

Br, JR, OSF 🙂
 
Dear brother

Couldn’t agree more. People bicker and argue and spend too much time on the wrong pursuit. We are supposed to become saints. If we do this all else will fall into place. People should be on the spirituality forum for the purpose of becoming saints. I’ve been here near 5 yrs and we used to have as many contributors as the apologetics forum but not now. The greatest and first form of charity we should do for others is pray for them. Knowledge does not save souls on its own. We can have all the knowledge in the world and go to hell. We go to heaven if we are saints. And saints drag many souls there with them. Knowledge is good so we can be apostles but if we are striving for sanctity that knowledge we have will have a far greater understanding and appreciation attached to it and our apostolate will bear much more fruit. We are supposed to be focused on our personal sanctification first and then worry about others. Get the log out of our eyes first. Thank you for raising this thread.

God bless you:thumbsup:🙂
John
 
That’s a great point. It seems to me that many threads end up completely off the topic and evolve into a heated debate between a few people. There are members who very obviously want to make everything into an argument and address others in very disrespectful ways. That put me off and I haven’t been to the forum in a few weeks. On the other hand, many people are very helpful and I have learned a lot so that balances things out.
 
I agree with the above. Our goal should be to do the will of God. However, I remain rather uncomfortable with some threads on CAF where I see too many people dig their heels in a posiiton or a point and like someone already said, they argue as if this was some kind of Catholic game where the goal is to win, not to grow in faith.

I was recently on a liturgy thread and I had to back out of it as graciously as possible. The individuals involved were so focussed on the rubrics of the mass that no one was talking about the spiritual value of the mass for the soul and for the world. It seemed that everyone felt it was more important to argue the rules of Gregorian chant vs the rules of other kinds of music at mass and no one once mentioned the fact that singing, which ever kind you do, should be a form of prayer I’m trying to remember which saint said, “When you sing you pray twice.” I felt saddened by the fact that the focus was on what pope said what about liturgical music, rather than on the purpose of music in liturgy and even in private prayer.

JR, do you think some people become so Catholic they forget about being Christian? p.s. I wish you would post more.

That being said, I felt that I was not getting much learning about prayer and holiness through liturgy, but in reality I was watching a contest as to who could quote more Church documents on liturgical music in order to shut the other person’s mouth.

In speaking to a priest who subscribes to CAF we were both saddened to realize that there are so many people on these threads who are well educated on the rules of liturgy and other Church documents, but have such a weak knowledge of Christian spirituality, to the point that they do not realize that what made the saints great was not their attachment to rules and encyclicals, but their heroic lives and most of all their interior life and how they approach the Incarnate Christ in the liturgy and in others. They seem to forget that the liturgy sanctifies because it produces in us the grace of charity, not the grace of legalism. While good liturgy will certainly inspire prayer, liturgical policing will only trigger frustration and distraction during the most critical prayer in Christian spirituality. I certainly feel that it’s a shame when that time before the Lord of Lords is spent distracrted. What most saints discovered was the art, if it can be called that, the art of silencing their mind and focussing their attention and their senses on Christ, whether it’s in the liturgy or in the daily activities of human life.

Fraternally,

Br, JR, OSF 🙂
 
I’ve got a few simple guidelines that have helped me navigate this issue that’s served me well for the 5+ years I’ve been coming here.

First, St. John of the Cross teaches that the purification of our will of all it’s selfish clingings (opinions, opinions and more opinions) is typically one of the last things to occur in most people. So I’m not suprised at all by the “human-ness” we see around here . . . even amongst those who consider themselves knowledgeable and devout.

Second, St. John of the Cross also teaches we are to guard our interior peace very closely . . . and this is a very hard lessen to learn. Sometimes we think we can be a force of good simply through a well written turn of a phrase . . . and we assume others can be persuaded by our good thoughts and intentions. But often we are sadly mistaken . . . especially when we don’t make wise choices about what we read and respond to on these forums.

Bottom-line: if we find our peace disturbed by what we see on these forums - can’t recollect ourselves in prayer, composing posts in our mind when we should be doing other things, having mental arguements with one of the bullies - then it’s good to take our leave. Simply put, we’ve become “attached” and are “inordinately clinging.” And very little good ever comes when we’re in that state. So a good approach is to limit our viewing/posting to those discussions in which people are being raised up . . . and not torn down. Hearts can’t be changed if they’re not open in the first place. In such situations we’d do well to follow the counsel of the Saints that “God will take care of His own.”

Lastly, if we feel compelled we “must” jump in one of those contentious discussions it’s best to get in and get out quickly . . . again so that peace can be maintained. The way I see it, the post will be positively noticed by “whom it was meant to serve” – ie, typically those following along with an open mind but not necessarily commenting. And, by definition, that excludes the bullies so belaboring our point serves little useful purpose anyway.

Hope this helps,
Dave 🙂
 
Simply said…Thank you, JR.

God bless you,
stteresasgirl
 
good thread…

An Eastern Orthodox Saint once said (I’m sorry I forget which one…)
“acquire a peaceful spirit and thousands around you shall be saved.” 🙂

I think if we seek to *live out *the Gospel, others would join… but if we only talk, that would not convince anyone.

Sadly I fail a lot 😦 I tend to argue a lot, but I know I shouldn’t 😦
 
good thread…

An Eastern Orthodox Saint once said (I’m sorry I forget which one…)
"acquire a peaceful spirit and thousands around you shall be saved." 🙂

I think if we seek to *live out *the Gospel, others would join… but if we only talk, that would not convince anyone.

Sadly I fail a lot 😦 I tend to argue a lot, but I know I shouldn’t 😦
This is so very true. We have a tradition in the Franciscan family of keeping silence during conflict. I know that many lay people find this disturbing, because they think that we’re not interested or worse, that we approve of that which is wrong. Nothing could be further from the truth.

One thing that St. Francis taught us about poverty is this. Poverty is detachment from everything that keeps us from seeing Christ, hearing Christ and being Christ. St. Francis always taught his brothers and sisters to imitate Jesus as literally as possible. One thing that we see in the scripures is how Jesus responds when spoken to by the Pharisees and the Saducees, but he does not go seeking them out to engage them in debates. He spends his time and energy teaching those souls who are fertile and when he’s not teaching he’s engaging with his fraternity (the apostles) or in contemplation.

The tendency on CAF reminds me of my father when he got his first hunting dog, “Go get 'em Rover.” LOL

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
This is so very true. We have a tradition in the Franciscan family of keeping silence during conflict. I know that many lay people find this disturbing, because they think that we’re not interested or worse, that we approve of that which is wrong. Nothing could be further from the truth.

One thing that St. Francis taught us about poverty is this. Poverty is detachment from everything that keeps us from seeing Christ, hearing Christ and being Christ. St. Francis always taught his brothers and sisters to imitate Jesus as literally as possible. One thing that we see in the scripures is how Jesus responds when spoken to by the Pharisees and the Saducees, but he does not go seeking them out to engage them in debates. He spends his time and energy teaching those souls who are fertile and when he’s not teaching he’s engaging with his fraternity (the apostles) or in contemplation.

The tendency on CAF reminds me of my father when he got his first hunting dog, “Go get 'em Rover.” LOL

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
Thank you Br. JR for sharring all of your thoughts on this thread.
It is what I know in my heart but I am still fighting with my own weaknesses and have a hard time being able to put these words into action all the time.
Thank you for reminding me to do this.
 
I agree. I haven’t been a member here for very long, but I have “lurked” in a lot of the threads and looked back and read old threads and I see a lot of them go into arguing and debating and sometimes it gets very heated and feelings get hurt. I think we should be praying for each other and trying to lift each other up. Not tear each other down just for having a differing opinion.
 
I just read a thread on something that Fr. McBrien wrote on the Eucharistic Adoration. I believe it’s in the Catholic News sub-forum. Anyway, the case is that Father holds the opinion that Eucharistic adoration is no longer necessary. I disagree with him and so do many other people.

However, the point is this. Almost every single post on the thread jumps and calls the man a heretic, compares him to the devil, calls him a dissenter, a Protestant and anything else. The posters go as far as referring to him by his last name, when the article itself refers to him as Father. In other words, the posters have taken the liberty of laicizing this man.

The fact is that the man has not said anything that is heretical. Adoration is not a dogma, not a commandment, not a doctrine. It is a tradition, a pious practice and a cult that is strongly recommended by the Church and by her saints. You can in fact believe that it is not necessary, since the Church does not require us to attend Eucharistic adoration. Again, I do not agree with Fr. McBrien.

My point is that when you read such an article and you post on these threads, it is legitimate to say why you disagree with him. But the question is this. Is it legitimate to call someone a heretic and other such language, when the Church would not apply such terms to that person?

The second question is how much damage does it do to me when I get so emotional that I begin to call someone a heretic, when in fact they are in good standing with the Church, even if they hold an opinion that is unpopular?

If I am calling someone a name such as heretic and the crime does not meet the Church’s criteria for heresy, am I sinning against justice?

If I am sinning against justice, does that help my journey toward union with God?

In fact, if being on CAF causes me to sin against justices, do I belong here? Do I belong on certain threads?

The mystical journey has as its fruit truth in charity, not aggression.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
I just read a thread on something that Fr. McBrien wrote on the Eucharistic Adoration. I believe it’s in the Catholic News sub-forum. Anyway, the case is that Father holds the opinion that Eucharistic adoration is no longer necessary. I disagree with him and so do many other people.

However, the point is this. Almost every single post on the thread jumps and calls the man a heretic, compares him to the devil, calls him a dissenter, a Protestant and anything else. The posters go as far as referring to him by his last name, when the article itself refers to him as Father. In other words, the posters have taken the liberty of laicizing this man.

The fact is that the man has not said anything that is heretical. Adoration is not a dogma, not a commandment, not a doctrine. It is a tradition, a pious practice and a cult that is strongly recommended by the Church and by her saints. You can in fact believe that it is not necessary, since the Church does not require us to attend Eucharistic adoration. Again, I do not agree with Fr. McBrien.

My point is that when you read such an article and you post on these threads, it is legitimate to say why you disagree with him. But the question is this. Is it legitimate to call someone a heretic and other such language, when the Church would not apply such terms to that person?

The second question is how much damage does it do to me when I get so emotional that I begin to call someone a heretic, when in fact they are in good standing with the Church, even if they hold an opinion that is unpopular?

If I am calling someone a name such as heretic and the crime does not meet the Church’s criteria for heresy, am I sinning against justice?

If I am sinning against justice, does that help my journey toward union with God?

In fact, if being on CAF causes me to sin against justices, do I belong here? Do I belong on certain threads?

The mystical journey has as its fruit truth in charity, not aggression.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
If you keep sharring your insight that you are sharring here.
I am asking you to please stay. but if you sense that it is pulling you away from God I will understand why you need to leave but I would like to keep conversing with you outside of the forums.

Humbly listening to you and sharring the dilemma you are facing.
 
I’m very glad I came across this thread, having just ploughed my way through a rather unedifying thread where there were a lot of quite un-Christian things being said.

I am a member of the Legion of Mary, and we are counselled to behave with great humility in our interactions with our fellow human beings, something I sometimes forget when I read through the forums and feel the urge to jump in and tell people what nonsense they’re talking! :o

A lot of the arguments on here are, I think, quite damaging to those who get involved and not a good example to set for non-Catholics.
 
****Simple Soul **** Humbly listening to you and sharring the dilemma you are facing.
Please let me clarify. I’m not facing a dilemma. I just avoid some posters and I usually stop participating when the posting goes on and one without anythign but attack and counter attack. My concern is for those who stay in there. I’m not sure what they get out of it, if anything. I often wonder if these are just lonely people who have no other form of distraction of anything to challenge their mind and occupy their time. Why else would anyone give up their inner peace and silence to be blasted on an internet thread?

But as a religious and someone who has committed his life to the dignity of human life, I find that these kinds of interactions are also a violation to the dignity of human life. Human life is not meant to be spent fighting. There are times when one has to fight to get out of an oppressive situation. But for the most part, we must avoid getting into such situations. The idea is to speak the truth and keep going. Never give the enemy a chance to engage you, because he can drain you. I am concerned that so many of our brothers and sisters are doing just that. They are allowing themselves to be drained. Where are they going to find the energy to love, to pray, to do penance, to serve?
ora pro nobis A lot of the arguments on here are, I think, quite damaging to those who get involved and not a good example to set for non-Catholics.
This is an important point. Not only are the arguments damaging to those who argue, but they are not a good example to those who are lurking. Sometimes, even when you’re speaking the truth you can set a poor example of Christianity. I’ve always beleived that perception is everything. How we say things leaves an impression on the person who is observing. More often than not, the impression speaks louder than what we have said. We can often speak the greatest truth and not be heard, because our delivery speaks even louder.

I believe that’s the reason that some of our most famous and endearing saints are usually those who are the most simple and gentle. While they may not have very deep teachings, their humility and their great sensitivity leaves a deep impression on the listener. Often that impression makes the listener want to return to hear more. I am reminded not only of my own dear father St. Francis, but also St. John Vianney, St. Vincent de Paul, St. Anthony of Padua, St. Therese of Liseux, Bl. Mother Teresa and Pope John Paul II. They were such simple souls, even though their spiritual lives were so very deep. But those who came into contact with them didn’t get overwhelmed by their depth, but by their kindness, simplicity and their joy. The preached truth wiht happiness.

When a poster or a preacher lacks the kindness, the simplicity and the joy, the greatest truth is going to fall on rocky soil. Only stones are attracted to other stones. Butterflies like flowers.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top