Does the Church teach that hell is a place?

  • Thread starter Thread starter catholic1seeks
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

catholic1seeks

Guest
**Yes, another hell question. What does the Church teach about hell? Is it a place of material fire or a spiritual state?

I was reading a couple of good Catholic resources—one from the Original Catholic Encyclopedia and one from Pope John Paul II—and they seem to contradict. Personally, I’d rather believe in John Paul’s description (I added color to emphasize certain points): **

>>From Catholic Culture, Pope John Paul II’s July 28, 1999:

To describe this reality Sacred Scripture uses a symbolical language which will gradually be explained…

The New Testament sheds new light on the condition of the dead, proclaiming above all that Christ by his Resurrection conquered death and extended his liberating power to the kingdom of the dead.

…By using images, the New Testament presents the place destined for evildoers as a fiery furnace, where people will “weep and gnash their teeth” (Mt 13:42; cf. 25:30, 41), or like Gehenna with its “unquenchable fire” (Mk 9:43)…

The images of hell that Sacred Scripture presents to us must be correctly interpreted. They show the complete frustration and emptiness of life without God. Rather* than a place, hell indicates the state of those who freely and definitively separate themselves from God, the source of all life and joy…

“Eternal damnation”, therefore, is not attributed to God’s initiative because in his merciful love he can only desire the salvation of the beings he created. In reality, it is the creature who closes himself to his love. Damnation consists precisely in definitive separation from God, freely chosen by the human person and confirmed with death that seals his choice for ever. God’s judgement ratifies this state.

catholicculture.org/culture/library/view.cfm?id=1183 ]

** >> Here’s some selections from the encyclopedia: **

Where is hell? …As to its locality all kinds of conjectures have been made; it has been suggested that hell is situated on some far island of the sea… some assigned it to the moon, others to Mars; others placed it beyond the confines of the universe…The Bible seems to indicate that hell is within the earth, for it describes hell as an abyss to which the wicked descend. …Is this merely a metaphor to illustrate the state of separation from God? …However, no cogent reason has been advanced for accepting a metaphorical interpretation in preference to the most natural meaning of the words of Scripture. Hence theologians generally accept the opinion that hell is really within the earth.

…The poena sensus, or pain of sense, consists in the torment of fire so frequently mentioned in the Holy Bible. According to the greater number of theologians the term fire denotes a material fire, and so a real fire. We hold to this teaching as absolutely true and correct. However, we must not forget two things: from Catharinus (d. 1553) to our times there have never been wanting theologians who interpret the Scriptural term fire metaphorically, as denoting an incorporeal fire; and secondly, thus far the Church has not censured their opinion. Some few of the Fathers also thought of a metaphorical explanation. Nevertheless, Scripture and tradition speak again and again of the fire of hell, and there is no sufficient reason for taking the term as a mere metaphor…

It is quite superfluous to add that the nature of hell-fire is different from that of our ordinary fire; for instance, it continues to burn without the need of a continually renewed supply of fuel.

newadvent.org/cathen/07207a.htm ]

**I’m not very attracted to the Original Catholic Encyclopedia’s description of hell as a place in the earth or as hell consisting of real, material fire. The enyclopedia is not the magisterium, but I usually hold the OCE with high respects. Any thoughts?

When the OCE says “Some few of the Fathers also thought of a metaphorical explanation. Nevertheless, Scripture and tradition speak again and again of the fire of hell, and there is no sufficient reason for taking the term as a mere metaphor,” it confuses me, because I thought it was OK to hold to a metaphoric fire. But then, again, they say this view has only been around since the 1500s.

Any thoughts would be nice.**
 
Hi catholic1seeks! I’ll attempt a shot at your question, if no one else will be so kind 🙂

A couple thoughts here. I see the question with regards to hell as being a place or a state of being as analogous to the whole science/religion debate–why can’t both be right? In my opinion, it is absolutely certain that hell is complete and utter separation from God, which in and of itself would be horrendous: no faith, hope, or love. But why would such a state of being necessarily be separate from an actual physical place? Just as we believe that heaven is an actual place where our state of being will be eternal bliss in the presence of God, so too hell for those unfortunate enough to go there.

I do not see metaphorical speaking in Jesus’ numerous statements regarding hell (Gehenna). I for one believe there really is a “fire”, but it is a supernatural fire that torments the soul as opposed to a material one that afflicts the body.

Haven’t there been saints that have been shown visions or experiences of hell, and hasn’t it been a place in every circumstance? I think some of the Medjugorje visionaries experienced this as well.

As far as what the Church actually says about the matter, unfortunately, it is rather vague about the matter, though I think it affirms that both are the case:

From the Catechism (paragraph 1035):
The teaching of the Church affirms the existence of hell and its eternity. Immediately after death the souls of those who die in a state of mortal sin descend into hell, where they suffer the punishments of hell, “eternal fire.” The chief punishment of hell is eternal separation from God, in whom alone man can possess the life and happiness for which he was created and for which he longs.

Doesn’t the fact that souls “descend” into hell, suggest that it is a place? Otherwise, why not just say that souls go into the “state of” hell. Similarly, it specifies that the “chief punishment of hell is eternal separation from God”, implying that there are other punishments associated with it (i.e. torture via fire).

Hope that helps 👍
 
Hi catholic1seeks! I’ll attempt a shot at your question, if no one else will be so kind 🙂

A couple thoughts here. I see the question with regards to hell as being a place or a state of being as analogous to the whole science/religion debate–why can’t both be right? In my opinion, it is absolutely certain that hell is complete and utter separation from God, which in and of itself would be horrendous: no faith, hope, or love. But why would such a state of being necessarily be separate from an actual physical place? Just as we believe that heaven is an actual place where our state of being will be eternal bliss in the presence of God, so too hell for those unfortunate enough to go there.

I do not see metaphorical speaking in Jesus’ numerous statements regarding hell (Gehenna). I for one believe there really is a “fire”, but it is a supernatural fire that torments the soul as opposed to a material one that afflicts the body.

Haven’t there been saints that have been shown visions or experiences of hell, and hasn’t it been a place in every circumstance? I think some of the Medjugorje visionaries experienced this as well.

As far as what the Church actually says about the matter, unfortunately, it is rather vague about the matter, though I think it affirms that both are the case:

From the Catechism (paragraph 1035):
The teaching of the Church affirms the existence of hell and its eternity. Immediately after death the souls of those who die in a state of mortal sin descend into hell, where they suffer the punishments of hell, “eternal fire.” The chief punishment of hell is eternal separation from God, in whom alone man can possess the life and happiness for which he was created and for which he longs.

Doesn’t the fact that souls “descend” into hell, suggest that it is a place? Otherwise, why not just say that souls go into the “state of” hell. Similarly, it specifies that the “chief punishment of hell is eternal separation from God”, implying that there are other punishments associated with it (i.e. torture via fire).

Hope that helps 👍
Thank you for your help!
I know I can always count on you, geo!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top