E
Eilish_Maura
Guest
"If Our Lady makes a promise of any kind, we know it is God’s will, and is therefore, infallibly true. "
No."If Our Lady makes a promise of any kind, we know it is God’s will, and is therefore, infallibly true. "
That’s correct – there is no infallible doctrine derived from any apparation.Is there some context for this quote? Perhaps a link? Because Our Lady is only going to promise things that are in full accord with Church teaching and thus, it could be infallible in that sense because Church teaching is infallible. The Church as far as I know, has made no formal teaching on any promise from Mary in an appartion. Rather, the Church declares an apparition and the message worthy of belief.
True that. The reason I want to see the context and who said it is because it sounds a little like Ligouri from *Glories of Mary, *which many of our naysayers love to cherry pick from.That’s correct – there is no infallible doctrine derived from any apparation.
I am not sure context makes any difference as most of what it is claim that Mary ‘says’ comes from private revelation (as we can count on one hand what she says in Public Revelation).True that. The reason I want to see the context and who said it is because it sounds a little like Ligouri from *Glories of Mary, *which many of our naysayers love to cherry pick from.
Would you cite or link where this quote came from so we can discuss if it is relevant? I entered the quote in a search engine and only this thread here comes up. Briefly, although private revelation is not binding on anyone other than the recipient (and I’m not even sure about that), that doesn’t make it wrong per se. The Church afaik, does not explicitly teach the above quote. BUT the quote is not necessarily prima facia objectionable.I am not sure context makes any difference as most of what it is claim that Mary ‘says’ comes from private revelation (as we can count on one hand what she says in Public Revelation).
OK. you guys, enough is enough.Would you cite or link where this quote came from so we can discuss if it is relevant? I entered the quote in a search engine and only this thread here comes up. Briefly, although private revelation is not binding on anyone other than the recipient (and I’m not even sure about that), that doesn’t make it wrong per se. The Church afaik, does not explicitly teach the above quote. BUT the quote is not necessarily prima facia objectionable.
Only her words in Scripture are infallibly true. All else is private revelation,"If Our Lady makes a promise of any kind, we know it is God’s will, and is therefore, infallibly true. "
It was the opening line and is copied as it appeared.If that is a quote from another thread, does it ‘stand alone?’ Did somebody just come out of thin air, post those ‘exact’ words down out of the blue, and vanish?
So yes, context is important. If this was actually stated just as the OP puts it, that’s one thing. On the face of just those words, and nothing to explain the reasoning or the context, brought out of nowhere, one would certainly think, 'say what?"
But if this is what the OP ‘thought’ was being said, or if it’s an inference the OP drew, then it would be ‘interesting’ to see what was actually said, and why.
"If Our Lady makes a promise of any kind, we know it is God’s will, and is therefore, infallibly true. "
Then you should have no problem linking us to the thread & post that you quote from.It was the opening line and is copied as it appeared.
It’s been 2 full days since I requested this link. Have you skedaddled again?Then you should have no problem linking us to the thread & post that you quote from.