Does this make me a horrible person?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jazzy0710
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

jazzy0710

Guest
Quite a while ago I had posted a thread talking about how I found my father in law and his wife very overwhelming to be around and deal with.

They have done and said various things to us that really hurt. Planning our wedding was the most stressful thing I have ever done because my father in law made it so difficult.

They have lied to my husband and I about various things, like their engagement and their trip to elpoe in Las Vegas.

My father in law’s wife made a huge scene at my birthday party back in April as well as my husband’s birthday party in August.

Most people that replied to my previous thread felt it would be a good idea if I kept a distance which I have.

I have both my Father in law and his wife on my facebook. I put both of them on limited profile so all they can really do is send me private messages however if I post to a mutual friend, well they can see that.

So here’s the issue. I love my sister in law to death. She lives alone because my Father in law’s wife sold her house and bought another one 40 minutes away because she didn’t want to move into my Father in law’s house and said that the new house wan’t big enough for all 3 of them so my sister in law stays at my Father in law’s house.

Tonight is Halloween. I don’t have to work tonight and my sister in law doesn’t work at all. She is on disability because she has a pain disorder that causes her foot to swell :rsds.org/pdf/recognizing_understanding_treatingCRPS_RSD.pdf here’s the link to info on it for any medical gurus!

Anyway the area that my father in law’s house is in isn’t exactly the safest and it’s even worse on Halloween so I offered to go up and help her give out candy and keep her company. She agreed. However my Father in law’s wife posted after I did saying that she and my father in law are very excited to come up and help her give out candy and watch movies with her.

I was willing to go up because I thought she was going to be alone and I sort of looked forward to hanging out with her because I haven’t been able to do that much. I can’t be around my Father in law and his wife because they make my blood boil so bad that I know I’ll snap and say things that I’ll regret so I called my sister in law and left her a message and told her I couldn’t make it up there tonight, that it’s a long story and that I’ll call her the next day that I’m off that I’m very sorry.

Am I a horrible person?:confused:
 
No, I don’t think you are a horrible person. You are avoiding a scene, your sister in law doesn’t need 3 people to help her hand out candy. Does she know of the tension between you and her father and step-mother? If she does, then she will understand, and if not, you have told her that you simply cannot make it after all. She may guess since you presumably had your plans first.

Perhaps you and she can get together another time though. Be sure not to gossip about your in laws with her.
 
No, I don’t think you are a horrible person. You are avoiding a scene, your sister in law doesn’t need 3 people to help her hand out candy. Does she know of the tension between you and her father and step-mother? If she does, then she will understand, and if not, you have told her that you simply cannot make it after all. She may guess since you presumably had your plans first.

Perhaps you and she can get together another time though. Be sure not to gossip about your in laws with her.
Yes she knows about some of the tension. The thing is that I never had any prior plans so now I’ll just be hanging out at my place by myself(my husband is away with the Navy). She may understand but at the same time all she’s ever really wanted was for everyone to get along so she may get mad at me I don’t know for sure.
 
Quite a while ago I had posted a thread talking about how I found my father in law and his wife very overwhelming to be around and deal with.

They have done and said various things to us that really hurt. Planning our wedding was the most stressful thing I have ever done because my father in law made it so difficult.

They have lied to my husband and I about various things, like their engagement and their trip to elpoe in Las Vegas.

My father in law’s wife made a huge scene at my birthday party back in April as well as my husband’s birthday party in August.

Most people that replied to my previous thread felt it would be a good idea if I kept a distance which I have.

I have both my Father in law and his wife on my facebook. I put both of them on limited profile so all they can really do is send me private messages however if I post to a mutual friend, well they can see that.

So here’s the issue. I love my sister in law to death. She lives alone because my Father in law’s wife sold her house and bought another one 40 minutes away because she didn’t want to move into my Father in law’s house and said that the new house wan’t big enough for all 3 of them so my sister in law stays at my Father in law’s house.

Tonight is Halloween. I don’t have to work tonight and my sister in law doesn’t work at all. She is on disability because she has a pain disorder that causes her foot to swell :rsds.org/pdf/recognizing_understanding_treatingCRPS_RSD.pdf here’s the link to info on it for any medical gurus!

Anyway the area that my father in law’s house is in isn’t exactly the safest and it’s even worse on Halloween so I offered to go up and help her give out candy and keep her company. She agreed. However my Father in law’s wife posted after I did saying that she and my father in law are very excited to come up and help her give out candy and watch movies with her.

I was willing to go up because I thought she was going to be alone and I sort of looked forward to hanging out with her because I haven’t been able to do that much. I can’t be around my Father in law and his wife because they make my blood boil so bad that I know I’ll snap and say things that I’ll regret so I called my sister in law and left her a message and told her I couldn’t make it up there tonight, that it’s a long story and that I’ll call her the next day that I’m off that I’m very sorry.

Am I a horrible person?:confused:
I do not think you are a horrible person at all. You are doing all the right things in keeping a healthy distance with toxic people while still being loving by avoiding useless fights. We have a similar relationship with my father in law and his wife, and that healthy distance has kept things from boiling over. Luckily, they live several hours away. I am sorry that it has indirectly affected your relationship with your sister in law, that stinks 😦 She sounds like a bit of a bystander to all of the drama.

I feel for your sister in law, I suffered from RSD when I was much younger. I had to go through aggressive physical therapy and suffered mild nerve damage in the affected limb. Luckily, I made a full recovery and have not suffered a relapse since.
 
Yes she knows about some of the tension. The thing is that I never had any prior plans so now I’ll just be hanging out at my place by myself(my husband is away with the Navy). She may understand but at the same time all she’s ever really wanted was for everyone to get along so she may get mad at me I don’t know for sure.
I’m sorry, I did not write clearly what I meant. What I was trying to say is that since you and SHE had plans to get together BEFORE her dad and step-mom said they would come over, and since you canceled once they decided to show up, she may “get it” that you just don’t want to be there when they are. Next time you see her, if she asks about it, just say something like, “I have found that limited contact helps everyone the most.” She must know that her father and step-mother are difficult people.
 
Yes she knows about some of the tension. The thing is that I never had any prior plans so now I’ll just be hanging out at my place by myself(my husband is away with the Navy). She may understand but at the same time all she’s ever really wanted was for everyone to get along so she may get mad at me I don’t know for sure./QUOTE

If she knows about the tension and how difficult this is for you, then she should not be forcing you to do things with them. Sure, she wants everybody to get along. I want world peace and all that. The problem is, we can’t always get what we want because these things are not under our control. She has no business being angry with you. Maybe you could invite her for coffee and have an honest chat, explain that you simply can’t be around those two, and ask her not to manipulate you into situatuons like the one you described. And no, you are not a horrible person.
 
She sent me a message and said no problem and hopes everything is alright and to give her a call later this week.
 
I would avoid posting anything to her wall in the future and just private message her. Or text her. Or call her.
 
She sent me a message and said no problem and hopes everything is alright and to give her a call later this week.
I would make that call and make sure everything went well on Halloween. In the future, I would not use a social network to communicate with her, just email directly or call; I’m sure she would love a chat.
 
My experience with difficult people that I’m used to is that it is far easier on me to deal with them myself than to have to watch helplessly as they terrorize other people. The latter situation is far harder on me. I would not be surprised if your sister-in-law feels the same.

If I’m understanding you correctly, you made your plans with your sister-in-law by posting them on Facebook where anyone who is remotely acquainted with you can read them? The next time you are posting about anything these toxic people might find remotely interesting, you might want to try the phone or private e-mails?
 
The next time you are posting about anything these toxic people might find remotely interesting, you might want to try the phone or private e-mails?
Even if I hadn’t discussed coming over with my sister in law on facebook and discussed it on the phone I have no doubt that my Father in law and his wife still would have showed up anyway at some point.
 
Even if I hadn’t discussed coming over with my sister in law on facebook and discussed it on the phone I have no doubt that my Father in law and his wife still would have showed up anyway at some point.
Whether the facebook attracted them was a conjecture; just something to consider.

It sounds as if it turned out fine. You are not a horrible person. I think you spared your sister-in-law some discomfort. Find another time, and don’t worry about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top