Does this make Sense?

  • Thread starter Thread starter humilis_viator
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

humilis_viator

Guest
Well, I guess I’m just trying to find someone to listen to this before I actually talk to someone face-to-face about it. Hopefully this will be at least partially comprehensible.

So much has happened over the past year and what I perceive to be my calling seems to be so entwined with my conversion and spiritual growth in general that it is hard to pick out all of the events (or parts of events) that have to deal with what I see as this calling. That being said, this obviously does not include everything that surrounds this realization.

About one year ago, I was a group leader on my High School’s Kairos retreat (for those that don’t know, it’s a religious retreat usually reserved for High School Juniors and Seniors). We had just finished listening to and talking about one of the talks that was part of the retreat so all of the retreatants were relaxing and such.

I decided to hang out with two of my fellow retreat leaders and we were joined by our school’s chaplain. While we were talking, I was surprised to find out that the two other retreat leaders had been seriously contemplating joining the priesthood.

We had been talking for a while when the priest asked if I had ever considered joining the priesthood. As an afterthought, he added that I would have to convert first. I guess he saw my reaction to his afterthought because he then asked me again if I had ever considered converting.

The thing is, I’m not sure in what light I should take his question. At the time, I brushed his question aside because what I was really surprised about was that I had coincidentally made the decision to talk to him about my decision to convert the night before.

This idea somewhat quieted down for a while until about half a year ago. One of my mother’s friends had been trying to convince me to see a priest who she was very good friends with to talk about converting. A few days after we met, my mom told me that he had asked her friend if I had ever considered joining the priesthood.

When I first heard this, my reaction was to initially be dumbfounded and later to think that no, that could never happen.

I hadn’t even converted yet for goodness sake. But then I thought about it, prayed about it, and read about it. And the more I did this, the more it seemed to fit.

But being slow and thick-headed, I still thought, “Well, it’s a nice idea but I don’t really know if God is actually calling me to do this.” So I accepted that it might be an option but didn’t give it too much thought.

*** For clarity’s sake, I thought it’d be a good idea to add that I was in college by this point of this narrative ***

Last Wednesday, I was at a small group that was organized by the Newman Center at my University that meets weekly. One of my group leaders asked me why I had decided to convert. I had talked to him before about my conversion but hadn’t really given any details as to the “why?” Somehow, he managed to think that when I said “convert to Catholicism,” I was actually saying “Convert and become a Catholic priest” or something along those lines.

Now I know that I’m not the most vocal person ever, but it seems to me that there is a slight discrepancy between those two phrases. He later attributed it to him sometimes hearing what he “wants to hear.”

So including all suggestions, both serious or not, that brings the total number of people who have told me that I should become a priest to two priests, one theology teacher, two other adults, as well as the group leader I described above. And I have a sneaking suspicion that I could probably add my university’s Newman campus minister at the school that I attend if I was to ask him about it.

On top of this, it seems like a lot of the anxieties that I had about this have gradually been removed through different events over the past couple of weeks and through interactions that I’ve had with other people that almost seem tailor-fitted to answer those anxieties I had even when none of these people knew that I was considering this.

I honestly don’t know what question would be a good one to ask or what I’m trying to ask for that matter. I’ll leave the topic of the comments open to whoever has been able to read through all of this.

God bless,
Humilis Viator
A.M.D.G.
 
First of all, Welcome!

Interesting post… You know, you will often see on those vocations websites that people are asking the question “should I be considering priesthood or religious life?” There are many reasons why one should consider that they may have a vocation to religious life: the Gospel message makes you want to love & serve God as best you can, you may feel “drawn” to ordained ministry, administering the sacraments and serving God’s people would be fulfilling…there are many reasons. But many will say that the fact that someone - a priest, friend or family member - has asked you if you’ve ever thought about the priesthood is an indication that perhaps you should at least consider it!

So, the fact that so many people have asked you that question may be an indication that you ought to consider it. None of us here can say whether or not you have a vocation to priesthood, but there must be something about you that caused people to ask you the question even before you had converted! I don’t know - perhaps you relate very well to people, maybe you’re a great listener, a good communicator, perhaps you “preach” the Gospel by your actions…

But at the end of the day, the question is: do you feel that you are being called to priesthood? It’s worth spending time thinking about the possibility - what different feelings arise when you consider the possibility of serving as a priest (noting that fear is not always a bad thing!), do you feel comfortable with it or not, do you like the thought of living your life on a routine of prayer and service of God & His people…

If you decide that it is something you feel compelled to at least consider, I think you should contact your diocesan vocations director or a priest you feel comfortable talking to about this. Remember, by contacting him, you’re not signing your life away! They’re there to help, whether or not you do eventually go to the seminary.
 
I’m sorta confused…I had a pretty radical conversion experience in 1973 along with my coworker druggie friend…Jesus turned our lives around…Our coworker were amazed as we started talking to them about Jesus and His plan for salvation…You said you had a conversion experience, why would you convert again…You became a christian…
 
I think he is refining his conversion. Just because you believe in all that Jesus teaches–that doesn’t make you ‘Christian’ per se. "More’ is the bottom line here. You can always be more and do more, as a Christian. It’s a journey more than a turning point in life. It starts as a turning point, but it sure doesn’t end there.gzh
 
I’m sorta confused…I had a pretty radical conversion experience in 1973 along with my coworker druggie friend…Jesus turned our lives around…Our coworker were amazed as we started talking to them about Jesus and His plan for salvation…You said you had a conversion experience, why would you convert again…You became a christian…
:confused: I don’t think he’s talking about converting again, unless I’ve missed something. I think he was wondering why some people seem to have the impression that conversion and a priestly vocation go hand in hand - that when he mentioned converting, that people were under the impression that he was necessarily going to convert and become a priest.
 
Hiyas:)

In all sincerity, I ask…Have you thought about becoming a Priest?

I hope so.🙂
 
Several things to keep in mind. The first and foremost is asking God what He wants you to be, and being open to that. Secondly if you arent even Catholic yet, and if it is God`s will for you to be Catholic, it still takes three years after you enter the Church before someone is allowed to discern with a religious community or enter a seminary. The three years is a cooling off period. Third pray pray pray. Fourth find someone, a priest or religious, to talk to that isnt going to push in you in any direction except to do what God wants.

Read this very helpful article
lafayettecarmelites.org/god_calling.php
 
Several things to keep in mind. The first and foremost is asking God what He wants you to be, and being open to that. Secondly if you arent even Catholic yet, and if it is God`s will for you to be Catholic, it still takes three years after you enter the Church before someone is allowed to discern with a religious community or enter a seminary. The three years is a cooling off period. Third pray pray pray. Fourth find someone, a priest or religious, to talk to that isnt going to push in you in any direction except to do what God wants.

Read this very helpful article
lafayettecarmelites.org/god_calling.php
As far as I can tell from the O.P., he’s already a Catholic - probably for the past year or so?? Plus, the profile above his post indicates that he is a Catholic:D

I do agree with the “cooling off period” though - not that it’s necessarily the case regarding the O.P., but it is understandable that some converts who are so “on fire” for their new faith can confuse this with a vocation to religious life.

All in all, though, as I said in my original post, there must be something about you, Humilis Viator, to cause so many people to ask you about considering the priesthood, so I still think that there would be no harm whatsoever in approaching your vocations director at this stage.
 
None of us here can say whether or not you have a vocation to priesthood. . .
Part of why I wrote this was to try to explain what was going on to other human beings. I don’t expect anyone on this forum to tell me that I should become a priest unless by freak coincidence, they know who I am.
why would you convert again…You became a christian…
Yeah, I know I had botched something up when I was writing this. I was actually formerly protestant. I am currently going through RCIA. Sorry about that.
In all sincerity, I ask…Have you thought about becoming a Priest?
It’s been on and off my mind fairly regularly for the past two or three months and on my mind daily for the last two weeks.
it still takes three years after you enter the Church before someone is allowed to discern with a religious community or enter a seminary. The three years is a cooling off period.
Thanks. That helps a lot!
I do agree with the “cooling off period” though - not that it’s necessarily the case regarding the O.P., but it is understandable that some converts who are so “on fire” for their new faith can confuse this with a vocation to religious life.
So do I for that matter. I think that’s a part of why I wanted to post this also. Honestly, though I cannot yet be sure, I currently think that this feeling I have is going to be present a year from now, two years, and even three.

Even as a protestant, I had contemplated the possibility of going to a protestant seminary school (obviously not the same thing though) even up to my freshman and first few months of my sophomore year in high school. I don’t know how much it would have grown, however, because it was shortly after the first few month of my sophomore year that I began to have issues with the denomination I was attending. By Christmas of my Junior year of High School (two years ago this December 19/20) I had finally found something that I could not accept that my denomination supported.

It was only a year ago that I realized that God was calling me to the Catholic Church and I started the RCIA process about three months ago.

It’s also been about a year since the priest I first talked about in the original post asked me if I had ever thought about becoming a priest, and only in the last six months since I’ve actually given any thought to it again.

Thanks to everyone for the comments. This has actually been really helpful right here. It helps me to sort things out in my head when I have other people asking questions about it.

Obviously, I’m not going to pack my bags up right now and run off to a seminary. I used the same approach of a “cool down” period on my own when deciding whether to convert or not and I don’t intend on changing my approach on what would be another monumental and lifelong decision.

Thanks again to all who read. This has definitely been a very, very good start to my first day on this forum. I have great hopes that this forum and the people I meet here will be able to help me whatever decision I make and who knows, I might even be able to help someone myself some day.

God bless,
humilis viator

A.M.D.G.
 
Oops missed this one. Sorry about that.
As far as I can tell from the O.P., he’s already a Catholic - probably for the past year or so?? Plus, the profile above his post indicates that he is a Catholic:D
Coincidentally, I actually went through the Rite of Acceptance (or in my parish’s case, The Combined Rite since we have both baptized and non-baptized people in my RCIA class) today.

It’s hard to explain where that puts me in relation to being considered a Catholic. It’s somewhat of a gray area, if you will, between being a Catholic and not being a Catholic.

Officially (at least this is what they told us), I am now considered a member of the Catholic Church, although not yet in full communion with the church.

Hope that explains it. I had to try to explain it to a couple of my friends today. It wasn’t easy let me assure you.
 
I just wanted to add here that the three-year waiting period between entrance into the Catholic Church and entrance into a religious community is not set in stone. Only bishops are bound by that rule. Religious superiors are not. Every religious community has its own statutes on this point. The usual waiting period is two-years, but much depends on the person’s background. Men who come in from the Anglican, Episcopalian or Orthodox communities are rarely asked to wait that long. This is more for the benefit of those who enter from the Reformation communities. The Anglicans/Episcopalians are not Reformation communities. The Orthodox certainly are not. Other factors are also taken into account.

Most religious communities have an aspirancy period of at least six months, a postulancy of at least a year, before you enter the novitiate. By the time you become a religious, which happens upon entry into the novitiate, you have been in the Church at least 18 months sometimes longer. The aspirancy and the postulancy can be extended up to four years, combined. That decision is made by the formation team with the approval of the Provincial Superior.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
First of all, welcome home!

In response to your question, yes it does make sense. I have heard so many stories from both men and women religious and priests of how they first started thinking about a vocation because somebody asked them if they had ever thought about it. I am of the opinion that everyone should be thinking and praying about it. I can’t encourage you enough to look into it. Discerning really doesn’t mean that you are signing on the dotted line. Discerning really is just looking into it and finding out what God’s will is for you. I will keep you in my thoughts and prayers!

JMJ+
~Betsy

Totus tuus Maria!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top