Donating money to "luxurious" causes?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaveEucharist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DaveEucharist

Guest
I am interested in making a contribution that will make me a Patron of the Metropolitan Opera in New York city. It is the highest possible level of donating to the MetOpera. I am a 26 year old medical science professional and amateur musician/classical-opera music fan.This contribution will result in certain benefits (discounts, backstage passes, etc).

I have no family to support and have the means to do this, so am not committing the sin of failure o support others, etc.

Is making a contribution to “luxury”/entertaining less of a “good work” than donating to other causes?

I mean not to boast of my good works. This is an anonymous forum.
 
I think this is one of those cases, where it is evaluated case by case. I think a helpful question you can ask yourself is Is this donation helping me get closer to God? Is this for the glory of God?, Is this donation going to hinder me getting closer to God?
 
I think there are gradations of corporal works. If I open the door for someone with their arms full, that’s all well and good. I wouldn’t compare that to someone donating a kidney.
 
I think this is one of those cases, where it is evaluated case by case. I think a helpful question you can ask yourself is Is this donation helping me get closer to God? Is this for the glory of God?, Is this donation going to hinder me getting closer to God?
👍
 
I agree, that’s why it is hard to know if it is a sin. It depends on so many variables. For example, I am an economist, and do a lot of research into abstract topics to earn money. Does my work glorify God? It’s hard to know, but I do need the money to pay for my expenses, donate, and help others. Does going to the gym glorify God? Hard to tell, but keeping your body in shape gives you more energy and stamina to do more activities which could be Godly activities, and so on.

Does donating to MetOpera glorify God? Hard to tell, does it allow you to reach others and to bring them closer to God?, and so on…
 
It’s stuff like this I have trouble with. I am able to support my parish beyond 10% and support certain charities I carefully chose. How much is enough? I mean, should I give up the luxury apartment (doorman, gym, pool, housekeeping,etc) I live in? Should I give up the car I drive? Should I shop to clothing elsewhere? If so, the business I support (direct or indirectly) will not thrive, and people depend on those to their livelihood.

Why shouldn’t I give up the pleasures of opera to help the poor even more than I do?
I see music and enjoying life (to some extent) as a means of glorifying God. But, this is all luxurious.

So confused.
 
Beauty in culture is not a luxury. The arts are an essential component of life. Many of the famous composers were supported by wealthy patrons. Use it wisely to support a company that honors God.


Pope Benedict praised for appreciation of classical music
m.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=23125
Castel Gandolfo, Italy, Aug 10, 2011 / 04:53 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- The Catholic Church is blessed to have a Pope who shows such a deep appreciation of classical music, says composer James MacMillan.
“We are lucky that we have a pontiff who values the true pinnacles of human civilization and creative achievement,” MacMillan remarked to CNA, Aug. 10.
His comments followed a gala concert in honor of Pope Benedict’s 60th anniversary of being ordained a priest. It was held on the evening of Aug. 9 at his summer residence of Castel Gandolfo.

Performing before the pope and his brother Georg - who is also marking his 60th year as a priest – were the German oboist, Albrecht Mayer, and Arabella Steinbacher, a young German-Japanese violinist. They were joined by an ensemble composed of six musicians from different international orchestras.
The evening’s repertoire was drawn exclusively from the 18th century, with works by Johann Sebastian Bach and Antonio Vivaldi being performed. In his words of thanks, the Pope highlighted the Christian faith permeating both composers’ work.

He said the works of Vivaldi, an Italian priest, were “an example of brightness and beauty that conveys serenity and joy,” revealing “his deeply religious spirit.”
The Pope also recalled how the Bach would always sign his compositions “SDG,” meaning “Soli Deo Gloria” in Latin, or “the Glory to God Alone” in English. This, said the Pope, reflected the composer’s “religious conception of art” and “strong faith” which “sustained and illuminated his entire life” and produced sacred music that “almost groped to reproduce the perfect harmony that God has imprinted in creation.”
“It is marvelous that Benedict can delight in the secular outpouring of the western canon of ‘classical’ music as well as the sacred,” said MacMillan, reflecting upon last night’s concert.
“The great composers were like angels who fell to earth to give the rest of us a glimpse of heaven. The fact that many of them were faithful servants of the Church, too, creating the finest music for our sacred liturgies is a double bonus which should excite and exult all Catholics.”
MacMillan’s own work hasn’t escaped the cultured ear of Pope Benedict in recent years. The Scottish composer created much of the music that accompanied the Pope’s visit to the United Kingdom last year. This included the “The Mass of Blessed John Henry Newman” which was sung at the papal liturgies in Glasgow and Birmingham as well as the grand processional “Tu es Petrus” which heralded the Pope’s entrance into Westminster Cathedral in London.
More recently, MacMillan was one of only 60 artists from around the world asked to create works to mark the Pope’s 60th priestly anniversary. He feels Pope Benedict’s promotion of a classical Western culture has a much deeper significance beyond mere artistic appreciation.

“There is much talk within certain quarters of the Church about ‘inculturation.’ Some use this as a pretext for attacking the Western, Hellenistic, European, classical and Gregorian roots of Catholic culture. This subterfuge is wrong-headed,” he warned.

“What the Church should fear most is the de-culturization of society. Results of this are playing themselves out on the streets of the U.K. as I write.”
 
It’s stuff like this I have trouble with. I am able to support my parish beyond 10% and support certain charities I carefully chose. How much is enough? I mean, should I give up the luxury apartment (doorman, gym, pool, housekeeping,etc) I live in? Should I give up the car I drive? Should I shop to clothing elsewhere? If so, the business I support (direct or indirectly) will not thrive, and people depend on those to their livelihood.

Why shouldn’t I give up the pleasures of opera to help the poor even more than I do?
I see music and enjoying life (to some extent) as a means of glorifying God. But, this is all luxurious.

So confused.
No, no, no, no and, no.

God gives abundantly. Be happy for so many blessings of God!!. God continue to bless HIM ABUNDANTLY!.

Enjoy your opera, enjoy your hobbies, but ALWAYS put God first. That is all!. Be sure that any of those activities does not interfere with your time with God. That time is SACRED, and should be more important to you above opera and everything else.

Go ahead and enjoy your apartment, your gym, your opera, and please do keep donating and helping out those in need. In terms of donations, I recommend that once in a while You be present doing the social service. It is such an enriching experience, especially when God has provided you, so you can give to others.
 
The Church recognizes the value of The Arts. True, you get certain benefits for being a big donor, but you also keep the place afloat with your donation. It would be a huge loss if they closed up.

JPII said something once about how the west suffers from spiritual poverty, rather than material poverty, and that’s why we need beautiful Cathedrals and such. That’s why they don’t just sell all the artwork at the Vatican to feed the poor.

If you’re supporting your parish and kicking in to the Diocesan Appeal, don’t feel guilty about spending your disposable income on this. If you’re shortchanging the church, then you have a good reason to feel guilty. Don’t be like the people who toss a buck in the basket at Mass and stop at Starbucks on the way home for a five dollar foo-foo coffee!
 
"JPII said something once about how the west suffers from spiritual poverty, rather than material poverty, and that’s why we need beautiful Cathedrals and such. That’s why they don’t just sell all the artwork at the Vatican to feed the poor."

Man thats a cop out thing to say, we can’t sell the artwork to feed the poor as people need beautiful Catherals becasue we have spiritual poverty,

that is blaming us because the vatican doesn’t want to sell their artwork and give to the poor.

thats like saying I need a beautiful house because my company wants a nice place to visit, but I would downsize and give some to the poor, but my company would be upset.
 
"JPII said something once about how the west suffers from spiritual poverty, rather than material poverty, and that’s why we need beautiful Cathedrals and such. That’s why they don’t just sell all the artwork at the Vatican to feed the poor."

Man thats a cop out thing to say, we can’t sell the artwork to feed the poor as people need beautiful Catherals becasue we have spiritual poverty,

that is blaming us because the vatican doesn’t want to sell their artwork and give to the poor.

thats like saying I need a beautiful house because my company wants a nice place to visit, but I would downsize and give some to the poor, but my company would be upset.
Well, maybe that interpretation is a little extreme. I don’t doubt the Pope has certain luxuries (nice shoes, etc).

But, selling important artwork to some rich donor and using the money for helping the poor will lead to the loss of important works of art/literature, etc to the public. Should the Ruins of Athens (or part of) be sold and become private? Just an example.

Theoretically, we could also give up the internet access we have right now and use the money to help the poor…
 
No, no, no, no and, no.

God gives abundantly. Be happy for so many blessings of God!!. God continue to bless HIM ABUNDANTLY!.

Enjoy your opera, enjoy your hobbies, but ALWAYS put God first. That is all!. Be sure that any of those activities does not interfere with your time with God. That time is SACRED, and should be more important to you above opera and everything else.

Go ahead and enjoy your apartment, your gym, your opera, and please do keep donating and helping out those in need. In terms of donations, I recommend that once in a while You be present doing the social service. It is such an enriching experience, especially when God has provided you, so you can give to others.
Absolutely!!!

For goodness sake ----- YES to this post!!!

It is not a sin to enjoy and support the talents of others. Those musicians have families to feed, and this is the work they do to support them. There is no sin there.

Being scrupulous — now THAT is a sin.

~Liza
 
This is anonymous so I am not boasting.
I thought long and hard. I made a Patron Level donation to the fund that supports discounted tickets for students age 29 or younger with valid educational institution ID. I’m 26 so I’ll be helping those around my age. They may not be the best seats in the opera house but oh well, I sat in them once when I was a student without a full-time career.

Before each opera (I go to 2-4/month) I pray to somehow “offer” the music to God. Meanwhile, I know that many famine/poverty stricken people cannot enjoy such things…it’s probably the last thing on their radar…if it is at all.

I am amazed at the work of Catholic charities and will increase contributions to them proportionally.

Note: Two great Italian Bel Canto opera composers were Catholics of sorts:
Rossini and Verdi!​

Not from the MetOpera, but enjoy anyhow:
youtube.com/watch?v=FqSBdeuV6nw&feature=related

Praise God and special thanks to St. Jude, my Patron:thumbsup:
 
I don’t know if this will help you decide in the future, maybe. I often ask myself if unbelievers support this venue. Let’s say the Heart and Stroke Foundation, or Humane Society. I believe that unbelievers will donate to these charities. When I wonder if unbelievers will support the local charity that teaches engaged couples NFP, I am pretty sure they would have no interest in such a charity! Or, if the roof of our church needs replacing.
 
This is anonymous so I am not boasting.
I thought long and hard. I made a Patron Level donation to the fund that supports discounted tickets for students age 29 or younger with valid educational institution ID. I’m 26 so I’ll be helping those around my age. They may not be the best seats in the opera house but oh well, I sat in them once when I was a student without a full-time career.

Before each opera (I go to 2-4/month) I pray to somehow “offer” the music to God. Meanwhile, I know that many famine/poverty stricken people cannot enjoy such things…it’s probably the last thing on their radar…if it is at all.

I am amazed at the work of Catholic charities and will increase contributions to them proportionally.
In our society, we have a tendency to downplay the value of culture. It’s not a part of society “just for fun”- culture DOES matter. It inspires us to meditate about beauty, which (if the beauty is authentic) ought to lead us to God. The Church recognizes this and has traditionally been a great- probably the greatest- patron of the arts. It is good to support such things. Also, the donor level you want to be in provides discounted tickets to people your age, so you are helping promote interest in something that popular culture rejects to young adults.
 
"JPII said something once about how the west suffers from spiritual poverty, rather than material poverty, and that’s why we need beautiful Cathedrals and such. That’s why they don’t just sell all the artwork at the Vatican to feed the poor."

Man thats a cop out thing to say, we can’t sell the artwork to feed the poor as people need beautiful Catherals becasue we have spiritual poverty,

that is blaming us because the vatican doesn’t want to sell their artwork and give to the poor.

thats like saying I need a beautiful house because my company wants a nice place to visit, but I would downsize and give some to the poor, but my company would be upset.
It’s not that the Vatican doesn’t want to sell “their” artwork…it’s that it doesn’t want to sell our artwork. The art and cultural treasures in the Vatican are held in trust for all humanity to freely enjoy. Yes, they could be sold for a one-time sum that could buy material help for the poor…and then disappear forever into private collections. Alternatively, they could remain as a source of spiritual inspiration for all. Those artifacts are part of our cultural and spiritual heritage as Catholics and as such, the Vatican maintains that it does not have the right to sell them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top