Donating Organs and Blood

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarianCatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MarianCatholic

Guest
Is there anything that prevents a practicing Catholic from donating Blood and organs?

I do believe that I already know the answer to my question before I ask, but I’m just wondering if there is anything I should bear in mind regarding this.

Yours in Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
 
As long as you’re not killing yourself to do it, no, there are no issues.
 
I believe there is another consideration too: for profit. You cannot just sell a kidney, your ovaries, your sperm, an eye, your blood, etc. That too is a consideration. I once lived at a parish where the Pastor himself had a niece, (it may have been a cousin, I don’t clearly remember) who needed a kidney and he was a perfect match although a large man. He spoke about his donation before and all through the process and he was out for about a week and the Sunday he made it back they gave him a standing ovation!

Here is what the CCC says: “2296 Organ transplants are in conformity with the moral law if the physical and psychological dangers and risks to the donor are proportionate to the good that is sought for the recipient. Organ donation after death is a noble and meritorous act and is to be encouraged as an expression of generous solidarity. It is not morally acceptable if the donor or his proxy has not given explicit consent. Moreover, it is not morally admissible directly to bring about the disabling mutilation or death of a human being, even in order to delay the death of other persons. (2301)”

usccb.org/beliefs-and-teachings/what-we-believe/catechism/catechism-of-the-catholic-church/epub/index.cfm?p=37-chapter17.xhtml%23para2296

Then there is always the prohibition against the harvesting of organs and tissues for research from the deceased bodies of children lost to abortion. That is always wrong, no matter what. The babies body parts are always off limits.

Glenda
 
Thanks for responses to my thread I really appreciate it:)
I am thinking of signing up for Organ Donation.
That means that Im willing to donate certain organs (or all) if I die suddenly and the Hospital needs some of my organs to treat others.

I wasnt thinking of donating sperma or anything like that just organs if I die.
I hope that clarifies things a bit:)

Yours in the Hearts of Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
 
I am willing to donate my organs after death but will not put it on my drivers license because if anything happens to me, I don’t want them to be thinking more about the organs than about me! There have been cases where this has happened–I am not saying anything bad but doctors are people and so sometimes make mistakes.
 
No organ donors here.

I would never accept an organ either, though blood is a different matter (replaceable in a matter of days).

Does this make me a sinful person?
 
Is there anything that prevents a practicing Catholic from donating Blood and organs?

I do believe that I already know the answer to my question before I ask, but I’m just wondering if there is anything I should bear in mind regarding this.

Yours in Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
No issues. In fact, I think it’s a very kind and generous thing to do. They have ads here at the hospital saying, “Don’t take your organs to heaven! Leave them here on earth!” They’ll have a picture of a church organ! lol

I think it’s even acceptable to donate one’s cadaver, as well, since in most cases, probably like 98% of the cases, due to the way we die, only a fraction of cases will have all the criteria necessary for organ donation.

If you die at the house, and they find you later, hours later, I think you would not qualify to donate organs. It’s hard to qualify. If you have cancer, I think that disqualifies you, contagious diseases, etc., etc.

As to organ donation, some people donate kidneys and other things even while alive. I find that tremendously heroic.

My mother, (who is now I guess 89?) has donated a GALLON of blood during her life! I found that really impressive, because this was a woman, who like me, had a needle phobia!

My ex-husband’s father also donated a gallon of blood during a lifetime, and the Red Cross honors these people and will give them a certificate. I envy that. I wish I could! It’s SO beautiful! What a tremendous act of love!

I greatly admire those who donate blood, especially. One of my sisters tried to give blood. Many in my family are squeamish. She started to pass out, and they told her not to come back. She wanted so badly to try to do this. She is a very giving person that she tried once more, despite that warning. Again, she began to faint. Again, they told her NOT to come back!

I wanted to donate despite my phobia, but in my case, my mother saw that I’ve had all kinds of medical problems. They will have done about a dozen operations on me. They take blood on me all the time.

Years ago, before the cancer, I think, my mother advised me NOT to give blood or do anything else that could potentially weaken me, due to my special circumstances.

I can’t donate blood, anyway, now, since I have had cancer, not been free of it for 10 years. I also don’t think I’d qualify for organ donation either, same reason, not sure, though.

I’d really like to give my corneas, especially, because I work with the blind. I’ve seen what they go through.

I have one brother who is a doctor. He used to work on cadavers as a required part of a doctor’s study in medical school. They seemed to have had not enough people donating cadavers.

Once, someone wrote a letter to the editor on organ donation. I followed it up with another on cadaver donation, which I later heard was liked so much by some doctors that they took my letter, posted it up in the College of Medicine at a local university!

So, yes, by all means, organ, blood, even cadaver donation seems to all be acceptable by the Church.
 
Fencersmother,
I donate blood on a regular basis. Have a sister-in-law that is a liver recipient. Have offered to be a kidney donor, but am not eligible. I also know a woman that was a living donor of one of her kidneys for her sister. In my view not donating something whether it’s blood or an organ doesn’t make one sinful. It simply means that one has an attachment to something they can’t use any longer. Blessings to you and yours-stay safe-be well.
 
Hello MarianCatholic.
Thanks for responses to my thread I really appreciate it:)
I am thinking of signing up for Organ Donation.
That means that Im willing to donate certain organs (or all) if I die suddenly and the Hospital needs some of my organs to treat others.

I wasnt thinking of donating sperma or anything like that just organs if I die.
I hope that clarifies things a bit:)

Yours in the Hearts of Jesus and Mary
  • MarianCatholic
If you desire to limit the organs donated then you need a living will. Perhaps you aren’t aware of it, but if you are female and die and they harvest your organs and you haven’t specified what they can have, they may take your ovaries and if they can use them then they check for eggs for fertilization, etc. and will use them. You need to specify what you will and will not allow. Unfortunately this is so.

Glenda
 
You can’t donate any organs while you’re alive, which if donated while you are alive, would result in your death… And much of the medical community, involved as they are in the big $$$ organ donation business doesn’t recognize this moral law and is perfectly willing to remove your organs while you are still alive and make a lot of money doing so as long as long as they can declare you ‘legally’ dead even if you’re not actually ‘dead’.

Quoting an article:
In a paper entitled “Brain Death is Not Actual Death: Philosophical Arguments,” Dr. Seifert makes a dramatic argument when he writes:
“During the first six weeks of pregnancy our body lives without a brain and hence our human life does not begin with the human brain. Certainly, the embryo is alive but his life is not bound to the functioning of his brain. Therefore, the thesis of brain death being the actual death of the person which ties human life inseparably to a functioning brain goes against this biological fact: the development of the embryonic body proves that the brain cannot be simply the seat of the human person’s life or soul. To hold the opposite view, you have to defend the position that the human soul is created or enters the body only after the human brain is formed.”
Here’s a sermon on ‘May we donate our organs.’

Sample:

Some 50 years ago, the moral theologian, Francis J. Connell, CSSR, was posed a question concerning embalming. Question:

“In view of the modern opinion that apparent death may precede real death by a considerable period of time, what admonition should be given to our people particularly to Catholic undertakers as to how soon the process of embalming can be started after a person has apparently breathed his last.”

Answer:

“This is a problem of great importance in the US, where the embalming of the dead is a general practice. The main principal is this: the process of embalming may not be commenced until it is certain that life is extinct, for undoubtedly, if the person is still alive, the embalming process will directly cause death. Furthermore, mere probability, even very great probability, that death is insured will not justify the beginning of this process, for it is not permissible to do anything which even only probably will directly cause the death of an innocent person.”

Now let’s do a thought experiment. Suppose we were about to embalm somebody and as we begin to make an incision on the body, suddenly the corpse begins twitching and grimacing. In light of the moral principle stated by Fr. Connell, first, that the process of embalming may not commence until it is certain that life is extinct; and second, that it is not permissible to do anything which even only probably will directly cause the death of an innocent person. In light of those moral principles, does anyone think we should continue the embalming as scheduled?
 
Hello MarianCatholic.

If you desire to limit the organs donated then you need a living will. Perhaps you aren’t aware of it, but if you are female and die and they harvest your organs and you haven’t specified what they can have, they may take your ovaries and if they can use them then they check for eggs for fertilization, etc. and will use them. You need to specify what you will and will not allow. Unfortunately this is so.

Glenda
Its not a issue as Im a male:pshaw:
Im sorry that my nickname is confusing.

I wasnt aware that they would take overies AND use them?! :dts:
wow, even though it doesnt concern me at a personal level as Im a man I have to say that Im somewhat shocked that this actually occures.

In Norway we dont have a register where donors may volunteer, but instead we have the posibility of carrying a donor card in our wallet that paramedics will see as soon as they pick a person up with an ambulance.
We can choose which organs we like to donate at that card.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top