Downloading media a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Antonio_022
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Look, i see where you’re coming from. But in here, it works completely different.

In the US, Anti-Piracy may be a top-tier law but in the Philippines, my country, it falls right under “No Littering”.

Which is why nobody here sees the problem with copying and downloading whereas the prices here are UNFAIR. Piracy here is nothing. Which is why not me, not parents, nor teachers, and not even priests see the problem with piracy.
Look up the word piracy. You can’t pay the price? Too bad. There are many things I want to own in the US but I can’t pay the price, so I don’t have them.

Peace,
Ed
 
Just because “everybody’s doing it” does not make it morally justified.
“Everybody” is using Contraception and having abortions.
“Everybody” lies.
“Everybody” drives under the influence of alcohol
“Everybody” at college / university takes illegal drugs
“Everybody” steals, and pirates stuff of the internet…

Sin is sin
Piracy is Theft.
Thou Shalt Not Steal

Just because a law in not able to be enforced (like piracy laws) or is just Wrong (Like abortion laws) does not make it OK to carry out immoral acts.

To show a movie or other show in a public environment like a school or church requires not just a normal legal copy, but also an additional licence.
If you look at many catechetical DVD’s they have 2 prices. One for private or home use, and a totally different price for the version which includes a licence for public use at a church or school.

You will notice the copyright notice at the start of commercial DVD’s explicitly state they may not be shown at Schools, Churches, Oil-Rigs or other public or institutional locations.
Note to those who pirate stuff. We send takedown requests to pirate sites all the time.

Peace,
Ed
 
Yes, it is a sin. It is stealing. If you were a musician signed to a label, wouldn’t you be angry if people just torrented your music and no one bought it?
 
Yes, it is a sin. It is stealing. If you were a musician signed to a label, wouldn’t you be angry if people just torrented your music and no one bought it?
Why do people keep saying that ‘File sharing’ is stealing? Nothing is stolen. If you really think I support piracy, you are dead wrong. Piracy is when the person deliberately downloads and sells a product without the licence to do so thus deceiving customers into thinking it’s an original copy therefore making it a sin. But however sinful it may be, I still do not believe it to be stealing.

Refer to this statement I found: in the United States Supreme Court case Dowling v. United States (1985), bootleg phonorecords did not constitute stolen property. Instead, “interference with copyright does not easily equate with theft, conversion, or fraud. The Copyright Act even employs a separate term of art to define one who misappropriates a copyright: ‘…] an infringer of the copyright (Not a thief).’” The court said that in the case of copyright infringement, the province guaranteed to the copyright holder by copyright law—certain exclusive rights—is invaded, but no control, physical or otherwise, is taken over the copyright, nor is the copyright holder wholly deprived of using the copyrighted work or exercising the exclusive rights held

Piracy is not the same as downloading a file for personal use such as watching a movie or listening to a song as explained above. Therefore, I will accept whatever file my cousin sends me until the Church says otherwise.

EDIT: And no, I would not stoop so low as to get angry just because people wouldn’t buy my songs. Besides, if it gets pirated, I’d be happy that they’re enjoying my creation.
 
I have 3 exceptions for download:

The product is no longer available
The product is paid for and I just can’t have it yet for one reason or another.
The product is already owned by me and I don’t want to wear the disk or the disk was destroyed.
 
I have 3 exceptions for download:

The product is no longer available
The product is paid for and I just can’t have it yet for one reason or another.
The product is already owned by me and I don’t want to wear the disk or the disk was destroyed.
I dont get your 2nd and 3rd points 🤷 When a file is shared, the sharer obviously pays for the product before upload. If it were the case that the uploader STOLE and RIPPED the product, nobody would accept that. Nobody uploads something that is STOLEN (Physically).

As for the 1st exception, that’s what people call “Abandonware”. If it is no longer sold, ANYONE can use it.
 
Why do people keep saying that ‘File sharing’ is stealing? Nothing is stolen. If you really think I support piracy, you are dead wrong. Piracy is when the person deliberately downloads and sells a product without the licence to do so thus deceiving customers into thinking it’s an original copy therefore making it a sin. But however sinful it may be, I still do not believe it to be stealing.

Refer to this statement I found: in the United States Supreme Court case Dowling v. United States (1985), bootleg phonorecords did not constitute stolen property. Instead, “interference with copyright does not easily equate with theft, conversion, or fraud. The Copyright Act even employs a separate term of art to define one who misappropriates a copyright: ‘…] an infringer of the copyright (Not a thief).’” The court said that in the case of copyright infringement, the province guaranteed to the copyright holder by copyright law—certain exclusive rights—is invaded, but no control, physical or otherwise, is taken over the copyright, nor is the copyright holder wholly deprived of using the copyrighted work or exercising the exclusive rights held

Piracy is not the same as downloading a file for personal use such as watching a movie or listening to a song as explained above. Therefore, I will accept whatever file my cousin sends me until the Church says otherwise.

EDIT: And no, I would not stoop so low as to get angry just because people wouldn’t buy my songs. Besides, if it gets pirated, I’d be happy that they’re enjoying my creation.
Well, that’s your personal opinion about if some one pirated your songs. Regardless if its legal, it is not moral.
 
I dont get your 2nd and 3rd points 🤷 When a file is shared, the sharer obviously pays for the product before upload. If it were the case that the uploader STOLE and RIPPED the product, nobody would accept that. Nobody uploads something that is STOLEN (Physically).

As for the 1st exception, that’s what people call “Abandonware”. If it is no longer sold, ANYONE can use it.
Mario 3 on the Nes and Gameboy are not consider abondonware and you can’t buy it anywhere but if the right people knew you downloaded it you’d be fined.

As for the second: If I ordered something on line and it was quite late I’m just going to dl it. I paid for it I have receipts.

The Third:
I have cds some of which I won’t wear out by playing them some of which were lost while moving but I still have the case. They have been paid for I will dl them.
 
One problem I have with the whole argument over downloading, at least as it pertains to music, is that the way the law is written now, when I buy a CD I’m actually just buying a license to listen to that music while the CD is in my possession. Technically speaking, if you buy a CD, rip it to your computer then sell the CD, you’re are legally obligated to delete the file from your computer. I had a massive collection of tapes back in college, converted almost all of them to CD, collected hundreds more CDs, ripped them all to my PC, then sold them all off once space got to be an issue. I don’t feel any moral obligation to delete the files of these songs I’ve paid for, especially considering I’ve paid for them more than once in a lot of cases. At the same time, by the strict letter of the law, used CDs ought to be illegal as well since the license that goes with the CD only applies to the initial purchase.

Now, I’m not advocating illegal downloads, but the technology has advanced quite a bit since I first ripped those CDs years ago. The cost of storage has dropped tremendously, and you’re now able to rip much higher quality mp3s, as well as higher quality music files. A lot of my old collection, which I paid full price for at some point in the past, was encoded to 128 Kbps mp3s (or less) and sounds awful compared to my 256 or higher Kbps files. While there are a lot of albums that I’ve purchased yet again, I don’t have the money to do that for all of them, and a lot of them went out of print long ago, meaning I either have to pay ridiculous second-market prices for the originals, or try to find the songs on various compilations. I don’t see how downloading copies of those songs to replace my old, low-quality files could be morally objectionable.
 
If it’s not a legal download then it’s theft.

Better to give up watching TV and find peace in your life like I have done. 🙂

Pax vobiscum+
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top