Dualistic and non-dualistic thinking

  • Thread starter Thread starter AlanFromWichita
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AlanFromWichita

Guest
Thank you for visiting this thread.

I’m reluctant to offer a formal definition at this point in the thread, so I’ll tell you a bit about what I mean by dualistic and non-dualistic thinking. I’m combining my own ideas and experience with those of a couple different spiritual directors I’ve heard on the topic.

Here are some observations…

Dualistic thinking divides and separates us by giving us different labels.
Non-dualistic thinking unites.

Dualistic thinking typically sees a question as yes/no, true/false, good/bad, or otherwise with limited options.
Non-dualistic thinking cannot be forced into choosing between options given to it by dualistic thinkers.

Now, I believe that when I child is born, it doesn’t know dualistic thinking, but is trained in such by modeling others’ dualistic thinking, and through experience with behavior modification using reward/punishments, bribes/threats, and the like. So by the time a kid is 7 or so, he really isn’t any longer capable to looking at things non-dualistically.

Without dualistic thinking, we would not have communications. For example, if I say “elephant” that divides the world of thoughts into those that pertain to “elephant” and those that pertain to “not an elephant.” It is this distinction that tells you what I mean by the word.

So I’m not claiming one type of thinking is better than the other, just that our toolbox of thought is missing a valuable tool if dualistic thinking is the only tool we have now.

Now for a few examples that show what I take to be the two kinds of thinking:

dualistic: the law says to stone her. what do you say, stone her, or not?
non-dualistic: let he who is without sin cast the first stone.

dualistic: if a man marries two different women in his lifetime, when he gets to heaven who will be his wife?
non-dualistic thinking: in heaven it isn’t about having a wife.

Jesus was a master at saying things to break people out of strictly dualistic mindset.

Anyone have thoughts on dualistic and non-dualistic thinking?

Alan
 
I would like a definition of dualism, dualistic, etc. that is somewhat agreed upon, not the base for a personal philosophy or for refinement of established philosophy or Catholic doctrine ( I’m not complaining about the OP’s question or views). When Fr. Richard Rohr uses dualistic I think he is using an eastern religion definition and trying to conform Catholic truth to this, but I would put Catholic truths first as the beginning principle and judge dualism on this basis.

When dualism is used to say that good and bad are dualistic and thus denies the existence of evil, it is just wrong. Jesus was constantly showing the higher truths of both God’s Mercy and His Justice that cannot be reduced to a simple explanation with the removal and denial of hierarchical truths that “dualism” seems to be used for. God is One and utterly simple as a matter of Catholic doctrine but, in this world separated from God by sin and in our abstraction of universal concepts in our sense knowledge, His Nature must be analogously conceptualized separately. It is the limitation of our nature but one God made and His revelation to us conforms to this.

In the end though, there are so many bastardizations of good philosophy, so many just plain bad philosophies, and then there is Thomism, which is not an official Catholic philosophy but is Magisterially put forth as “one more in conformity with the teaching of the Church” by Pope Leo XIII and a myriad of other official Magisterial documents. What is a Catholic, Thomistic, or standard definition of dualism and where is it used in error in opposition to these? This is what I hope to have answered.
 
To get a vantage point different than my own, I found this article on wiki answers: What is dualistic thinking?
The first answer took me by surprise, for its simplicity: “The belief in good and evil. Sin.”

I see where it’s coming from, but I think it would be easier to start the discussion with the second answer.
Answer #2: It is a mind that is caught between polarities. It exists only in relativity - meaning it can only exist in relation to something else. A dualistic mind is not one mind, but two of them. These minds must be in opposition to each other in order for them to exist. They cannot exist on their own. Neither of them can see their own unreality, because if they could they would no longer be separate. Both sides of the dualistic mind are blind, and when they see - they become self aware and merge together forming a unified mind, or One mind - transcending all forms of relativity and becoming self sustaining. Thus, the true key to life is to transcend the duality consciousness. And the true key to not being blinded by it is the same.
This is a bit like what I thought before I read it, but not quite. So for now I’m not claiming I agree or not. I find some merit in parts of it.

Dualistic thinking believes that there is no winner if there is no loser. It thinks a question is yes or no, and that any other answer dodges the question. For example, when we demand of someone, “just answer the question!” like Larry King or something, then we are saying that whatever the question means to you, you must give us the answer in terms a dualistic mind can understand.

God can turn bad into good, so to say something is bad, is only a temporary label I apply for various reasons that I need because I am a human being living in an imperfect human population. For example, I can lock up the bad guy so he doesn’t hurt anyone, but I don’t presume to know his heart and make a spiritual judgment of him, just judge that we fear him based on his pattern of past behavior. God can rename Saul into Paul, so if I judge the soul of another man as evil, then I suppose – how can I make this a positive thing – that could be a prayer to God. Maybe I’ll just say in advance, “Lord, help me become wiser in my thoughts and words. If you ever hear me say I’ve judged a man’s intent, I ask you to amend my thinking in whatever way You will, and on your own schedule.” Meanwhile, I tell my brain that it is allowed to pretend, whenever it hears, “this is a bad man,” to think, “Lord, I am concerned about my brother. We have him safely in a lockup, and I ask that You bring your healing touch upon him, and to bring to us the guidance by Your Holy Spirit about how to handle all of this from this point on.”

There. Now I’ve programmed my mind in advance so that any time I have a judgmental thought, it automatically renews this prayer to the Lord. 😃

Anyway, back to the topic … let’s get back to the first wiki answer:

dualistic thinking = “The belief in good and evil. Sin.”

Hmmm… dualistic thinking must be something we learned around the time of the fall… :hmmm:

I have so much to say about that, that I think i’ll start by ending this post here. :cool:

Thank you everyone for reading my ideas,
Alan
 
Denial of good and evil and sin. If one believes this then one must replace Catholic with Dualism when asked what religion they are.

Dualistic being no winner without a loser or it must have a yes or no answer the “mind” can understand is esoteric hogwash. It is in itself a judgment that reality cannot be known or understood and this is called Relativism.

The mind as made by God participates in reality through sense knowledge, abstracting “treeness” from the essence of a tree and can compare and contrast all trees with the distinctness from other essences such as cats, man, etc. in the intellect which is the image of God in man.
36 “Our holy mother, the Church, holds and teaches that God, the first principle and last end of all things, can be known with certainty from the created world by the natural light of human reason.” Without this capacity, man would not be able to welcome God’s revelation. Man has this capacity because he is created “in the image of God”.
37 In the historical conditions in which he finds himself, however, man experiences many difficulties in coming to know God by the light of reason alone:
Code:
Though human reason is, strictly speaking, truly capable by its own natural power and light of attaining to a true and certain knowledge of the one personal God, who watches over and controls the world by his providence, and of the natural law written in our hearts by the Creator; yet there are many obstacles which prevent reason from the effective and fruitful use of this inborn faculty. For the truths that concern the relations between God and man wholly transcend the visible order of things, and, if they are translated into human action and influence it, they call for self-surrender and abnegation. The human mind, in its turn, is hampered in the attaining of such truths, not only by the impact of the senses and the imagination, but also by disordered appetites which are the consequences of original sin. So it happens that men in such matters easily persuade themselves that what they would not like to be true is false or at least doubtful.
As for judging someone evil… JP II in Veritatis Splendor confirms the constant teaching of the Church on the object or matter of an act being where the evil or good of that act resides. A person makes oneself into an evil or good doer by freely willing to do the act, but culpability is mitigated (or increased) in relation to various factors like knowledge, habit, circumstances, etc…

This dualism is an easy out, instead of the study of difficult truths, one fashions out a single dimension the equivocation of the hierarchy of truth that renders Jesus and Mary’s yes to God devoid of content or meaning.
 
I would like a definition of dualism, dualistic, etc. that is somewhat agreed upon, not the base for a personal philosophy or for refinement of established philosophy or Catholic doctrine ( I’m not complaining about the OP’s question or views). When Fr. Richard Rohr uses dualistic I think he is using an eastern religion definition and trying to conform Catholic truth to this, but I would put Catholic truths first as the beginning principle and judge dualism on this basis.
Thank you for your post. I didn’t specifically mention Richard Rohr for several reasons; he says things I’d guess would be offensive to some here, and besides he’s a Franciscan and around here the label “Franciscan” seems to telegraph disobedience in the minds of some posters. 😛 I was trying to get beyond who said what, and down to what it is.

I think that “dualistically” dividing mindsets into those that are dualistic and those that aren’t, provides a valuable tool for discussion. I’m not saying dualistic thinking is wrong, because without it we would have no way to express ourselves at all.

That’s why I used the wiki answers as a starting point for a definition. If you have one to propose for this discussion, whether or not it’s from Rohr, I’m eager to see it. 🙂 Few things seem as pointless as arguing about terms that haven’t been defined.
When dualism is used to say that good and bad are dualistic and thus denies the existence of evil, it is just wrong. Jesus was constantly showing the higher truths of both God’s Mercy and His Justice that cannot be reduced to a simple explanation with the removal and denial of hierarchical truths that “dualism” seems to be used for. God is One and utterly simple as a matter of Catholic doctrine but, in this world separated from God by sin and in our abstraction of universal concepts in our sense knowledge, His Nature must be analogously conceptualized separately. It is the limitation of our nature but one God made and His revelation to us conforms to this.
I don’t intend to use “dualism” as a label to indicate imply wrong thinking, only limited thinking. Without dualistic thinking, we could not even have a language because words are divisive; they divide thoughts we mean from thoughts we don’t mean.

Dualistic thinking IMO, was something that man immediately gained when he ate from the apple. Knowing good and evil, man became double-minded, with the fleshly temptations toward evil on one side, and spiritual desires for good on the other side.

So we cannot have non-dualistic thinking as a substitute for, but rather an extension of dualistic thinking, if you will.

It’s like when I first started learning piano, the focus was on right or wrong. Which note am I to play? When am I to play it? How loud does it say to play? In general, am I conforming to the music?

Then once we get beyond the basics we look to the nuances that allow for human expression, and is ceases to be about right and wrong. For example, an ever-so-slight pause at certain times – selected by various factors including the mood of the person playing – can help the audience breath properly, especially if they are singing. The pause wasn’t written into the music, and most people didn’t even realize we took an extra 1/20 of a second on that beat. But it’s there and it conveys a message that gets past the conscious mind. It isn’t whether it’s right or wrong to play the pause, aka “agagic” pause. One musician may use them differently from another, but these excursions from the “ideal” or “proper” ways to follow the music, are what makes the music human.

A robot can play the music objectively correctly with “perfect” timing and tone. But that’s not enough for humans. Few true musicians care to spend any time listening to computers playing music.

That said, here’s an example of computer playing music I think is pretty cool. Sterile, perhaps, but still pretty cool.

Truly, though, we go to concerts with experience listening to the studio version of a song, but if they delivered it exactly “perfectly” according to the way we are used to hearing it, they’d have to play the studio album, lip sync, and play air guitar with it. People sue performers over lip syncing without telling them.

Such music, though technically perfect according to the written “commands” for how to play it, is sterile and lacks humanity, and to someone who craves a truly human experience, it is not satisfying. We must move from right and wrong into an area of “artistry” which has its own ways of describing things that the terms “right and wrong” are subjective to the point of being without use in the discussion.

After I have taken lessons for a few years, my teacher might say, “what do you think of giving just a little emphasis to the tenor voice in the fourth measure? Some musicians do, but others think it’s a bit pretentious.” She doesn’t even lead me in reading the music, unless I make a blatant error and then her dualistic reminder comes in, “sweet child, you played an F there, and it really needs to be F-sharp.” Both types of advice from the teacher are of value, but every musician can tell you objectively whether you were right or wrong in your interpretation in the second example, but in the first example it is not about correctness but about personal taste.
What is a Catholic, Thomistic, or standard definition of dualism and where is it used in error in opposition to these? This is what I hope to have answered.
I am far from a scholar in these matters, which is why I started this thread without claiming any particular authority. If you can help answer this question yourself, or if others far more knowledgeable than i am in church teachings, then I’m all for it. Let’s get it on the table. 🙂

Alan
 
Thank you for again taking time to post a reply.
Denial of good and evil and sin. If one believes this then one must replace Catholic with Dualism when asked what religion they are.
Before Adam and Eve at the apple, did they live in sin for their lack of dualistic thinking?

Do we not tend to lament (but I don’t – that’s another topic) that Adam chose to have that knowledge, and consider everything that happened as a result of his learning to think that was as the fundamental basis for all evil in the world.

So was it “good” or “bad” that Adam ate from the tree of dualistic knowledge?

Of course, since Catholicism operates in a world that is full of sin, the Church must work with us where we are, and since Adam had already started the ball rolling on dualistic thinking, Catholicism cannot deny that this is a fundamental and necessary component of the way all humans think. That’s why we have rules and regulations. These apply to a dualistic mind by labeling things “good” or “bad.” These labels were gifts by God so that “sin” may be introduced. But once one is born of the spirit, one is free from those bounds and can operate either dualistically or non-dualistically, because the idea of whether they do something right or wrong according to the law of sin and death, isn’t part of the decision making process anymore. (Rom 6-8, for example)
Dualistic being no winner without a loser or it must have a yes or no answer the “mind” can understand is esoteric hogwash. It is in itself a judgment that reality cannot be known or understood and this is called Relativism.
OK, this helps me see where you are coming from. I take issue with the general notion that “relativism” is necessarily a bad thing. I’ll leave that for the moment, though.

If you disagree with my characterization of dualistic thinking as being limited to two or more options and failing to see outside a “choose one or the other” scenario, then what about it is “esoteric hogwash?”

Was it esoteric hogwash when Jesus was asked by one brother to tell the other he was wrong, and Jesus dodged the question? Was Jesus unable or unwilling to decide which one was right?
Luke 12:13-14:
Someone in the crowd said to him, “Teacher, tell my brother to share the inheritance with me.”

He replied to him, “Friend, who appointed me as your judge and arbitrator?”
Isn’t that interesting? Don’t we look to Jesus to answer just those sorts of things? Why didn’t Jesus say what should be done – by giving a non-answer, IMO, He has answered non-dualistically. He knew perfectly what was in the heart of each brother and could judge them with an absolutely right judgment.

But when asked, He declined. To me this is saying that there are things more important than knowing which of two brothers is right on a given issue. Therefore, in the way I understand the term “dualistic,” Jesus was rejecting a dualistic question by refusing to give a dualistic answer."
The mind as made by God participates in reality through sense knowledge, abstracting “treeness” from the essence of a tree and can compare and contrast all trees with the distinctness from other essences such as cats, man, etc. in the intellect which is the image of God in man.
I agree completely. Without dualistic thinking, we could point toward a tree, but not define its boundaries.
As for judging someone evil…
I thought the saying was, “judge the sin, not the sinner.” I have another thread on that. But no, I cannot judge you as evil. I can say you did something that involved grave matter, or that you did something that is harmful or destructive to me, but I can no more judge a person as evil than I can predict what your exact thoughts will be when you read this.
This dualism is an easy out, instead of the study of difficult truths, one fashions out a single dimension the equivocation of the hierarchy of truth that renders Jesus and Mary’s yes to God devoid of content or meaning.
I beg to differ. I see it exactly opposite.

We want to think all decisions have a finite number of choices. Otherwise we can’t thoroughly analyze each choice. But they don’t, if we are open to embrace all of reality. It is a simplified view of reality, that is helpful sometimes but sometimes is not rich enough to adequately capture the lesson at hand.

Have you ever been on a multiple choice test, and all four answers are wrong, and there is no “none of the above” option? How do you decide which of the four you should select?

Now I have some dualistic questions for you. Can you give me dualistic answers to them that is consistent with your personal beliefs of Church teachings? If you can’t answer one, is it because you don’t know everything, or is it because it was a trick question?

Are you led by the spirit, or by the flesh? One or the other, please.

Do you make decisions based on selfish motives, or desire to do God’s will? Which is it?

Which is more offensive to God – someone who does violence and then repents, or someone who harbors anger and hatred against his brother in his mind, but doesn’t repent?

Which one is more problematic for human beings? (I’ll guess it is the one who does violence.)

If Jesus were to answer the question directly, and with dualistic answers, would He have said it was proper to stone the adultress or not? He never answered the question. If it is important for us to know dualistically what is right and wrong, then why did he dodge the question?

Thanks again for your participation in my thread, :tiphat:
Alan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top