Eastern Religious Ideals

  • Thread starter Thread starter BrooklynBoy200
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BrooklynBoy200

Guest
I wasn’t sure whether i should post this in other religions are not, but here it is: I’ve been studying various eastern religion, just becuase i randomly became interested in them. I was wondering which beliefs are against Catholicism. Obviously reincarnation, Buddah, etc. are, but what about meditation and “oneness” with the universe, chi, etc.? I’m just wondering because it doesn’t sound blatantly against Christianity as much as the other things.
 
I wasn’t sure whether i should post this in other religions are not, but here it is: I’ve been studying various eastern religion, just becuase i randomly became interested in them. I was wondering which beliefs are against Catholicism. Obviously reincarnation, Buddah, etc. are, but what about meditation and “oneness” with the universe, chi, etc.? I’m just wondering because it doesn’t sound blatantly against Christianity as much as the other things.
“oneness” with the universe, a thing ??

why not “oneness” with God :confused:
 
I’m not defending any of these concepts so don’t get me wrong, i’m just curious.

But why not oneness with God, and everything he made?
 
If by “oneness” you mean feeling the presence of God that permeates creation, fine. This is not the “oneness” of Eastern philosophy. Traditional Eastern Thought is that one empties himself into nothingness and that nothingness is the oneness. This is not acceptable. We can empty ourselves for God to fill us, but we cannot empty ourselves to meld into the void.

There are possible issues with meditation, but those kind of have ot be discussed case by case. Christian meditation is not the same as Eastern meditation, as one is to lead to God and the other is to lead to nothingness.
 
The Oneness with the universe that Buddhists are after, is really that you try to realize you already are one with the universe, because neither you nor it actually exist. Only Being/Existence Itself (God) exists, Buddhism says.

You do realize that Buddhism, Taoism, Confucianism, and Chinese Traditional Religion/Shinto/Korean Shamanism are all different religions, right?

The way it sort of works is like the various philosophies in Ancient Greece and Rome. One might worship the Gods (that’d be Shinto/Shamanism/CTR), but one would also, if one was not satisfied with, basically, making sacrifices for good luck, one would also belong to an ethical/philosophical group, like Epicureanism or Stoicism (sort of like Taoism and Confucianism respectively) or the Neo-Platonists, Pythagoreans, or mystery cults (sort of like Buddhism).

Buddhism is generally what buries the dead, since its teachings are concerned with salvation–namely, not getting reincarnated anymore.

Taoism teaches a different kind of salvation: by learning the rhythm and cycle of the cosmos, one can become wise enough to become Immortal, and, again, not have to die/get reincarnated anymore.

Confucianism is more pragmatic, but it teaches people to revere their ancestors, respect their elders, and study the classics.

The traditional religions (Shinto/Shamanism/Chinese traditional) are based, more than anything, on the idea of purity. One tries to avoid anything, from dog-poop to dead bodies to resentment to an obligation, that might make one unworthy to offer sacrifices to the gods. Korean shamans (whose gods talk through them) will throw people out of their rituals if, for instance, they’ve just come from a funeral, or they’re on their periods–because of ritual purity. They’re also concerned with living in harmony, but because immoderation creates an impurity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top