Eastern Rite Saints & Latin Rite Adherents

  • Thread starter Thread starter mistfall
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mistfall

Guest
I don’t understand why there are people acknowledged as saints by Eastern Rite churches (e.g. Pilate’s wife, the archangel Uriel) but whom Latin Rite Catholics are not permitted (or would it be better to say “discouraged”?) from venerating or turning to for intercession.

Can anyone help me out with this? If someone is in heaven, why may we not all turn to him or her? If we are uncertain whether he or she is in beatitude, why are we not all discouraged from venerating him or her?
 
Hi Mis,

When you say Eastern Rite, are you talking about Catholic Eastern Rite or Orthodox? I would be surprised that Eastern Catholics venerate saints Latin Rite Catholics are “discouraged” from honoring.

On the other hand it is perfectly all right for Catholics to pray to the dead, no matter who they are. They all can intercede for us with God.

Verbum
 
I don’t understand why there are people acknowledged as saints by Eastern Rite churches (e.g. Pilate’s wife, the archangel Uriel) but whom Latin Rite Catholics are not permitted (or would it be better to say “discouraged”?) from venerating or turning to for intercession.

Can anyone help me out with this? If someone is in heaven, why may we not all turn to him or her? If we are uncertain whether he or she is in beatitude, why are we not all discouraged from venerating him or her?
Any Catholic can venerate any Saint canonized by the Catholic Church or develop a devotion to them. Any Catholic can venerate any deceased person by private devotion and prayer for intercession, canonized or not.
 
I don’t understand why there are people acknowledged as saints by Eastern Rite churches (e.g. Pilate’s wife, the archangel Uriel) but whom Latin Rite Catholics are not permitted (or would it be better to say “discouraged”?) from venerating or turning to for intercession.

Can anyone help me out with this? If someone is in heaven, why may we not all turn to him or her? If we are uncertain whether he or she is in beatitude, why are we not all discouraged from venerating him or her?
If I have a personal moral conviction that someone is in heaven, then I can honor them as such and ask for their intercession. The Church does not discourage this, quite the contrary. So if I’m honestly convinced that my saintly grandmother is in heaven, or Pilate’s wife, or the nice old lady that I used to serve at the restaurant, then I’m perfectly free to act as if they’re there.

But what’s not allowed is their public veneration as an official act of the Church. Before that can happen, the Church must go through a process of investigation. It’s during that process than one is officially given the title of Servant of God, Blessed, or Saint. The title is an indication of the certainty that the Church has as to whether they’re in heaven; it has nothing to do with whether they’re actually there or not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top