Engagement Length

  • Thread starter Thread starter o0Raille0o
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

o0Raille0o

Guest
Hello all!

You all have given me some great help in the past, and I thought that I would come to you all to ask for some non-biased opinions. My mother are currently arguing about how long I should be engaged before getting married.

I’m almost 22 years old, a senior in college, and with one week left in this semester, I have one semester left (spring semester) before I am completely done with my bachelor degree in exercise science. While I am capable of being a personal trainer once I graduate, how steady a job it would be is unknown to me yet. How well it would pay would depend on who I would work for and where. However, I am in the midst of finishing PT school applications for graduate school. I would really love to be a physical therapist and I feel it is my calling. God has helped me on a number of occasions toward getting to PT school although I am not officially accepted to any one place yet. If I were to go to graduate school I would start this upcoming summer/fall semester and graduate school would last 3 years.

My fiancee is 21, and is currently going to a very well-to-do engineering school. He is a junior in college, and right now his expected date of graduation is at the end of the next fall semester. If he gets an internship, however, he will finish at the end of the next spring semester. His internship would be paid (well for a student) and that would be a little money saved. He would not be going on to graduate school. The average expected time it takes a graduate from this institution to get a job (who does not already have a job by the date of graduation) is within 6 months.

My wonderful boyfriend of two and a half years asked me to marry him about 3 months ago, and as of tomorrow we will finally be going to a priest to talk about preparing for marriage. My mother firmly opposes the idea of either of us getting married before at least one of has a job. I do not think this is unreasonable, however if we wait until one of us has a job, I may not have an opportunity to marry for the three years I’m in PT school. I feel that 3 years is too long a time to wait around while engaged. My fiancee and I have spent most of our relationship long distance from school and I can’t say it hasn’t been a strain. It would be nice to be together and have the support/reassurance of having him there when I come home from a long day of school and studying.

That said, we haven’t set a date for a wedding, because grad school isn’t a sure thing in my future yet. I believe that if I do not get into grad school this year, I would not mind waiting until my fiancee has a job before getting married. At the latest it would be by the spring/summer of the year after I graduate. However, if I get into graduate school, the program would most likely start next fall. If we were to get married just before next fall’s semester began, that would leave my fiancee with one semester (and potentially a paid internship/potential job offer) left.
I may seem a little eager about not wanting to wait, but the thought of 3 long and difficult years of engagement makes me anxious. I feel that any struggle (financial struggles, having children unexpectedly, etc.) would be worth it in comparison to waiting 3 years. I feel that it would bring us closer, and I would feel like I’m struggling towards a greater goal if we were together rather than apart. As an added bonus, we have already been struggling with the issue of chastity before marriage. (Successful so far, but starting to dip.)
I’m not expecting getting married before either of us has a job to be easy, but I love my fiancee, I love children, and if there’s one thing I’m committed to, it’s making my marriage last and be the best marriage anyone could ever hope for. My fiancee has a kind heart and his main worry is being able to provide for a family.
In order to prepare for the future, we have been praying (together and separately), I have been looking into forms of NFP and have begun practicing one of them to get used to my body’s quirks. I have been stockpiling a hope chest, looking at how finances would work if we lived together, and trying to save any extra money that I get into my hands for the future. It’s true, neither he nor I has a job, but I do have a hefty sum of money (in savings bonds and in cash) saved up over the years for college. My fiancee only has what little he has saved up from college loans.
I know that we wouldn’t want to have to touch that money if we could help it, and it wouldn’t be enough to cover the cost of having a baby if we had no insurance (which I actually factored into cost of living together, so don’t be fooled, we would definitely be buying health insurance), but it’s more than what most college students have upon arriving at graduate school. We would be living off of student loans while we were in school, and my fiancee would have to lean on me while he is job hunting, but I feel that it is still doable. My fiancee agrees that we could make it work.
 
(Afraid my post was too long, sorry about that!)

My mom still wants me to wait. She has told me she would be very unhappy with our marriage unless I wait until at least one of has a job, and she would still rather I wait until PT school is over. She believes I will get pregnant and drop out of school as she’s seen happen to many others, and never go back to school/have a chance to go back to school. She has also refused to help us get married unless we comply with her demands. I believe that at that point, she is going a bit far. The choice should be ours, and she shouldn’t be making marriage (a typically joyful situation) into a downright depressing thing. I do not want to fight or argue with her. I don’t even want her to love the idea. I just want her to accept my decision and not make a fuss. She’s threatened to pray that I don’t get into the school of my choice (the one that would leave me closest to my fiancee) and not to help us financially with the wedding (which would be a big help, honestly). The thing that has made me most upset is that she has started making jabs where she can. Today when I told her my fiancee was coming (tomorrow) so that we could meet with the priest, she reiterated she would rather we wait. I bluntly told her I could not wait through 3 years of engagement, and she retorted that if I could not wait through 3 years of engagement, I probably couldn’t be married for 3 years. I feel the devil is at work in here somewhere… I do recall this quote, perhaps I should tell it to my mom? “Indeed, I wish everyone to be as I am, but each has a particular gift from God, one of one kind and one of another. Now to the unmarried and to widows, I say: it is a good thing for them to remain as they are, as I do, but if they cannot exercise self-control they should marry, for it is better to marry than to be on fire.” 1 Cor. 9:7-9

I know my mom worries because I’m the only child to be finishing a bachelor’s degree, much less a doctorate with PT, and she doesn’t want to see me mess that up. But even family friends see how she’s been slightly irrational about the whole thing, and they know that I am more driven an individual than either of my two older sisters. She is afraid of the uncertainty of it all and would rather err on the side of caution. I, being the youth that I am, feel that all matters are in God’s hand, and when called to a path, it’s not always at the most convenient of times, but it becomes a great test of faith in God to get you through the rough spots. I romanticize it in my head a bit, but doesn’t the Bible say: “Are not five sparrows sold for two small coins? Yet not one of them has escaped the notice of God. Even the hairs of your head have all been counted. Do not be afraid. You are worth more than many sparrows.” I believe that God always has his eye on us, and life is always an uncertain mystery, even at the times we believe we know things for certain.

Sooo… the big question(s) (if you’ve read this far): What do YOU personally think on this situation? Am I being too romantic? Am I spot on? Somewhere in the middle? Should I take more consideration of my mom’s worries? Is this God’s way of testing her at the same time on her life journey? Is there something I’ve missed? Is there a way I could improve this or my way of thinking? Any advice or encouragement?

Thanks you all. Even your prayers in this matter would be a big help.
 
There are many that work through grad school even while pregnant - it depends on what is job ends being and how badly you want it. Honestly this sounds like something you should discern in marriage prep and keep an open mind to discussing with your mother as well - the priest/deacon will be able to be a bit more objective.
 
One year is a good engagement length time, go full a full set of holidays and life events. That gives you time to do your pre cana and at a relaxed pace as well.
 
I was engaged for 8 months, after having been in the relationship for quite a few years.
 
It’s an exciting time in your life, and it’s understandable that you’re eager to move ahead. But I think your anxiety about a three-year wait sounds misplaced. From your description, that doesn’t seem likely at all. My guess is that, even to satisfy your mother, the longest would be about a year and a half, don’t you think?

Overall I think your fiance’s job prospects are probably good, even in this economy. My only concern is the geography. I take it that you’re apart now–is that right? Can he easily get a job in the field he wants to work in the same area you’re planning to go to school? If you’re apart now, it seems to me that it probably doesn’t make a lot of sense to get married until you can geographically be together–wouldn’t that be right after he graduates? About a year from now? I think at least six months is required for pre-cana most places, anyway.
 
It’s not your mom’s life and it’s not your mom’s marriage.

Time to cut the apron strings.

Make the plan that suits you and your fiance best, and your mom wil accept it or not. You will need to set the boundaries with her, and that includes the cessation of snarky comments. She can choose to be a part of things and be on good behavior, or can choose bad behavior which will result in her exclusion. Her choice.
 
  1. Get married as soon as possible. To me, that would be as soon as your guy has a full-time regular job. DO NOT wait three more years to get married. Yuk! To me that would be NUTS, and it would as a practical matter make chastity impossible. Even beyond that, three years is big chunk of the best years of your life and his life. Don’t waste them. Enjoy them. Live them to the fullest. I think it is sad when young people spend so much of their time always PREPARING to live, but do so little actual LIVING. In the time of Jesus, women were generally married at age 14 or 15. That was the norm in most of history. Life is happening now. Life is passing by. Life is “in session.”
  2. Once you finish your Bachelor’s degree, ask for no more financial assistance from your mother for anything. You are a grown up. Make all your plans as if it totally up to you and your guy to pay for everything. Financially, cut the ties to parents. Give up all thoughts of dependence on parents. Don’t allow that “backup” factor to be in any of your planning. She can give you gifts if she wants. But don’t ask, and don’t accept them with strings or conditions attached. That will end the aggravation of your mom trying to control you. She will have no power to control you if you are on your own. She can be on your side emotionally, or not, that is her choice. If she won’t relent in criticisms, you will just reduce your contact and time with her. But that would be her choice. The Bible says what is meant to happen with children is that they leave their parents and cleave to their spouse. I’m sure you know the verse. You will always honor your mother and father, but your life as a child is now ending, if it is not already over. Your life as a wife and mother is beginning. This really is the beginning of a whole new phase of your life.
  3. Try to avoid going into debt. Debt is a form of slavery. Student loans are so easy to take out, so hard to pay back.
  4. Get a job with your Bachelors degree only. Do that job at least for a year, or maybe two or so. It distorts a mind to be in school all the time for so many years, for 7 years. You need to take a break from School World, and get to know full-time adult Work World. Then, if later you want to get a graduate degree in PT (or something else–working might give you some ideas), okay, do it, but even then, try to pay for it without loans, or with minimal loans. If you focus, you will be able to find some acceptable job with your Bachelor’s alone.
  5. Don’t be angry with your mother. She is vexing your for reasons that she deems to be justifiable. She is trying to control you for your own good. Just don’t let her insults get to you. Don’t argue back. Don’t try to get her to understand your feelings, needs or point of view. She is a generation older than you. She will never see or feel things like you do. Just love her and honor. But get on with YOUR life. She had her young life once upon a time, and that is over now (except that YOU are one of the fruits of that earlier life she had). When she sees you and your guy handling everything, getting on with life, not being dependent on parents, she will be happy for you, and proud of you. You see your mother as unjustly being negative towards you. But in my view, the underlying problem here is something you are responsible for, and, specifically, it is the fact that you are a full grown adult who still wants to a parent to provide for her financially to some extent. I say that no to be mean or harsh, but to nudge you to be a full-fledged grown up and take charge of your life.
  6. Your PT graduate degree is really vital only if you think you marriage with this guy might not last, and that you may end up having to support yourself and your kids. If you feel you can trust him to be faithful to you forever, then what does it matter that you earning capacity may not be as great with a Bachelors degree only? He’s going to be a high wage earner, right? All work really is same: tedious, straining. The meaningful aspect of life is what happens at home, with loved ones.
I hope none of that was too harsh. You asked for guidance, so I gave you my straight opinion. Best wishes!
 
I think you should plan the wedding for sooner rather than later. The longer you wait, especially after making a commitment of engagement, the harder it will be to prevent yourselves from doing what comes naturally to people who have been together for a long time. You’ve dated 3 years, being engaged for 3 more years will become stressful. Could you not marry after your graduation or his next fall? Then one or both of you could get part time jobs and work through grad school. It’s not impossible to do. It may take longer bt its not impossible. School isn’t going anywhere. It will still be here if it takes longer to finish. Tell your mom its your decision to choose your wedding date. Show het scriptures that Paul wrote." Better to marry than to burn with passion." Does she even see that waiting a total of 6 years to marry sounds a bit excessive?
 
I think you’re correct in your analysis, and your mother is not. Marry soon, and live while you’re young, instead of planning your life until you’re too old to live it.
 
I vote for marrying soon. You’ve been together a long time, I don’t think there is any reason to have a prolonged engagement. 3 years will be a very long engagement.

I had my first baby when DH was finishing his last year of school, and I had another year left as well. I was pregnant during the final semester of college. It wasn’t ideal, but if I had to go back and re-do things, I would still have gotten married as early as we did.

If you and your fiancee both agree that you can make things work getting married sooner rather than later, go for it. It’s okay for you to hear your mom out, say “thanks for your opinion, mom” and then make your own choice. You don’t have to take her advice just because she’s your mother. When you marry your fiancee, it will be up to the two of you to make decisions together, and this is when it needs to start.
 
The simple formula is:
If you’re not ready for children, you are not ready for marriage.

If you’re not ready for marriage, you shouldn’t be engaged.

So, let’s say you get married NeXT year and upon consummating your marriage you end up pregnant ( all NFP Methods have failure rates). Would you be able to support your Child 9 months later ( so, 21 months as of today if you were to get married next November) or would your parents end up having to raise the Child?

Be realistic when working out this formula.
All the best!
 
My husband and I were engaged for two and a half years. Looking back, we should have been engaged maybe only a year and a half at most. We waited until we were both done with graduate school, but we could have done it otherwise.
 
I think your mother is being unreasonable in the way that she is acting toward you. But I think her concerns are valid, even if she should keep most of what she is thinking to herself. Telling you she’d be “unhappy with your marriage” is not ok and must be very saddening to you.

I do think at least one of you should have a job, or at the very least have finished a degree so you can have a full time job. Living off student loans is not smart. My fiance and I have been together five years, because we waited until we could take care of a family (now we can, and are getting married in a few months). I don’t regret this, and I think our future children will benefit from our patience. But that is what worked the best for us.

However, there are posters on here who have made things work on very little, and their stories might be what you need to hear. I don’t think it’s wrong of you to get married, but I do think you need to accept that your plans may not work out the way you wanted them to. It’s one thing to have plans and stick to them when the only person you are accountable to is yourself, but entirely another thing when you have to consider not only a spouse but also potential children. Yes, people work and go to school while being pregnant and having kids- it can be done. But some people are just not cut out to do it all at once, and I am one of those people. I think you should decide whether you think you can do it all for awhile, and whether you’ll be ok with it if things don’t work out- if you don’t end up getting an advanced degree, if neither of you have jobs and you have a baby. If you can be ok with a change in plans and a shift in focus, then maybe it could work.

Don’t make it about your mother, though. This is not her life and not her future marriage. It sounds like her concern is genuine, but she needs to let you make your own decisions, even if she doesn’t like them. However, she is not obligated to pay for a wedding for you either way, so I think any consideration of that should be removed from the equation. If you decide to get married sooner, you’ll figure it out. What you need to do is figure out what God wants you to do, and not be concerned with what she wants you to do.
 
I just want to say thank you to everyone for your great advice.

It’s true, this is definitely something that needs prayer. I’m not trying to rush this decision.

It seems there’s a majority consensus that a long engagement usually hasn’t worked out the best for most people, although this is not always the case. While my mom has made it clear she would like me to wait 3 years, the choice IS ultimately mine (and my fiancee’s) and I take full responsibility for that. I realize I’ve relied a little bit too much on my parents during my first 4 years of college, and it’s time for me to start stepping up and being a big girl who’s responsible for herself financially. I know I’ve been working in that direction for some time now, but finances are really the only issue I’ve struggled with letting go on. I do not always accept their offers, but sometimes it’s just too tempting to say yes when my parents are overeager to help. That needs to stop now if I ever want my mom’s respect. Thank you Bartolome Casas for helping me realize that.

Some good news: Today when my mom came home from work, she asked me how my visit with Father went. I was a little nervous because Father had given me and my fiancee papers for our parents to fill out and sign saying that we are free to marry. I was afraid my mom would dig in and refuse, but surprisingly, she was very civil and it appears she will fill out the paperwork and not stand in the way. From there, we just started talking and all my worries just came spilling out, and I genuinely broke down and began crying. My mom really hadn’t realize how much all the things she had said had had an affect on me, and she was really surprised that I was crying about it. Although I know the battle isn’t necessarily over, I think the tone has changed between us. God is GOOD! For those of you who have been praying, it’s already working!

Thank you again for all your prayers. I have much to consider, including what you have said, 1inICXC. The truth is, we are spiritually and mentally prepared for children. We really want them. We just aren’t sure we’re financially ready for them. Everything apparently boils down to money. As my grandma says, “Money is the root of all evil and if I didn’t need it to live, you wouldn’t be able to GIVE me the stuff.” Luckily, my fiancee and I are simple people. We will figure out the area of finances, and once that (and PT school) is settled, we will be able to make a more informed and mature decision. Please keep us in your prayers!

Pax Christi
 
My engagement lasted about nine months, from the summer between our junior and senior years of college, and our graduation from undergrad. We graduated on Monday, got married on Friday, and we neither of us had a job. We are doing fine. We have been married over 14 years, have six children, and we both went on to get Master’s degrees after marriage. We were both 22 when we married. 👍
 
I just want to say thank you to everyone for your great advice.

It’s true, this is definitely something that needs prayer. I’m not trying to rush this decision.

It seems there’s a majority consensus that a long engagement usually hasn’t worked out the best for most people, although this is not always the case. While my mom has made it clear she would like me to wait 3 years, the choice IS ultimately mine (and my fiancee’s) and I take full responsibility for that. I realize I’ve relied a little bit too much on my parents during my first 4 years of college, and it’s time for me to start stepping up and being a big girl who’s responsible for herself financially. I know I’ve been working in that direction for some time now, but finances are really the only issue I’ve struggled with letting go on. I do not always accept their offers, but sometimes it’s just too tempting to say yes when my parents are overeager to help. That needs to stop now if I ever want my mom’s respect. Thank you Bartolome Casas for helping me realize that.

Some good news: Today when my mom came home from work, she asked me how my visit with Father went. I was a little nervous because Father had given me and my fiancee papers for our parents to fill out and sign saying that we are free to marry. I was afraid my mom would dig in and refuse, but surprisingly, she was very civil and it appears she will fill out the paperwork and not stand in the way. From there, we just started talking and all my worries just came spilling out, and I genuinely broke down and began crying. My mom really hadn’t realize how much all the things she had said had had an affect on me, and she was really surprised that I was crying about it. Although I know the battle isn’t necessarily over, I think the tone has changed between us. God is GOOD! For those of you who have been praying, it’s already working!

Thank you again for all your prayers. I have much to consider, including what you have said, 1inICXC. The truth is, we are spiritually and mentally prepared for children. We really want them. We just aren’t sure we’re financially ready for them. Everything apparently boils down to money. As my grandma says, “Money is the root of all evil and if I didn’t need it to live, you wouldn’t be able to GIVE me the stuff.” Luckily, my fiancee and I are simple people. We will figure out the area of finances, and once that (and PT school) is settled, we will be able to make a more informed and mature decision. Please keep us in your prayers!

Pax Christi
It seems like you are very mature and have really thought this through 🙂 People love to tell you how expensive babies are… and they can be… but there are so many silly bells and whistles that are just unnecessary! We had a baby on a MAJOR budget, we were dead broke… but she did not suffer from cloth diapers, baby wearing, and not having a baby swing until she was 2 months old (which she promptly outgrew at 9 months!).
 
The simple formula is:
If you’re not ready for children, you are not ready for marriage.

If you’re not ready for marriage, you shouldn’t be engaged.
I couldn’t agree with this more.

I was engaged once before when I was in college and the length would have been one and one half year. I ended up calling it off. I felt unprepared to have children and then the more I thought about it just didn’t want to have his children (I’ve always wanted children, I just didn’t want to have them with him, which has got to be a red flag.) I also didn’t feel like he was in a position to take care of me or that I was in a position to take care of myself based on me still being in college and the type of job he had picked up. There is a level of adulthood required being a married person that many of us are not ready for as college students. I’m not saying money is a reason not to wed, just that a lot of people are still recieving a lot of help from their parents during college. It would seem off to enter the very adult commitment of marriage and still have mom and dad paying some of your bills afterward (I meant the generic you and not the original poster who may, for all I know, be paying for school herself.)

That being said, my younger sister married while still in college and I think they made the right decision because I have met few people more suited for each other than those two. Watching her and her husband exchange vows validated the decision I made not to go through with the wedding to my college suitor, not because of our stations in life, but because the kind of quality love that really is out there.

My husband and I were engaged six months before we were married. There was no doubt in my mind that God had put him in my life for that reason and we had dated for almost 2 years. The norm seems to be one year or longer but when you want to be married enough you don’t wait that long. My wedding had a lot less attention to detail than my friends who were engaged one or more years, but I wouldn’t trade any of our six months of happy marriage for wedding programs or better centerpieces.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top