Enjoying the movie Da Vinci Code

  • Thread starter Thread starter scimitar60
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

scimitar60

Guest
Hi, first post here. I was wondering about a film called ‘Da vinci code’ with Tom Hanks. This is one of my favourite movies, I find it very interesting and fun to watch; until recently I looked up the movie on google and it came up with ‘Criticisms’. I opened it up and apparently it recieved heavy barrages of Criticism from the Catholic Church! I hope I havn’t commited a sin from liking this movie or anything, what are your opinions?:confused:
 
Hi, first post here. I was wondering about a film called ‘Da vinci code’ with Tom Hanks. This is one of my favourite movies, I find it very interesting and fun to watch; until recently I looked up the movie on google and it came up with ‘Criticisms’. I opened it up and apparently it recieved heavy barrages of Criticism from the Catholic Church! I hope I havn’t commited a sin from liking this movie or anything, what are your opinions?:confused:
I don’t think it’s necessarily a sin to enjoy the movie in and of itself (with some important qualifications). If the film and/or book are jeopardizing your faith and distorting your view of the Church, then there would be cause for concern. If you’re concerened about this, bring it up to your priest in your next Confession.

The Catholic Church hasn’t issued any authoritative documents condemning the film (or the book on which it is based) because they leave the commentary on specific works of popular media to those who are more directly affected by them.

I would highly recommend reading a book like The DaVinci Hoax, though. Hopefully you realize that the book and film are filled with egregious errors about Church History, Art History, Catholic doctrine, and just about every discipline Dan Brown attempts to incorporate, which leads to a portrait painted about the Church that is as inaccurate as it is unflattering. If you are not that familiar with these areas, it’s good to read up on just how far off the mark Dan Brown really is.

Yes, it is “just fiction”, but there are many people out there taking the book very seriously because they (falsely) believe that there must be at least a grain of truth to the wild claims made in the book. That is why there are so many books that point out all the inaccuracies of the novel.
 
Hi, first post here. I was wondering about a film called ‘Da vinci code’ with Tom Hanks. This is one of my favourite movies, I find it very interesting and fun to watch; until recently I looked up the movie on google and it came up with ‘Criticisms’. I opened it up and apparently it recieved heavy barrages of Criticism from the Catholic Church! I hope I havn’t commited a sin from liking this movie or anything, what are your opinions?:confused:
Technically I don’t think it’s possible to sin if you didn’t know beforehand what you were doing was bad, so no.

I’ve never quite understood the appeal of the movie or the book its based on. It seems to me if you take what he is alleging (albeit fictitiously, although not really because many people including my father think the book is based on some solid historical truths and I believe the author deceitfully encourages people to think this) at face value it’s something that all Christians should find offensive, namely that Christianity is nothing but a vast and convoluted conspiracy. But overall the lack of any historical sense (or from what I’ve heard even good writing) in the books renders them ultimately fairly harmless.

I guess what I’m saying is, if you find something of value in these books (say, escapist pleasure) tant mieux but since they are basically one long calumny against the Church (albeit an unbelievably ludicrous and feather-headed one) I would think a Catholic would find that somewhat repellant or at least disturbing? How did this manage to get past you?
 
Hi, first post here. I was wondering about a film called ‘Da vinci code’ with Tom Hanks. This is one of my favourite movies, I find it very interesting and fun to watch; until recently I looked up the movie on google and it came up with ‘Criticisms’. I opened it up and apparently it recieved heavy barrages of Criticism from the Catholic Church! I hope I havn’t commited a sin from liking this movie or anything, what are your opinions?:confused:
I enjoyed the book-thought the movie was lousy. I enjoy debunking people who took everything in the book/movie as being correct.

BTW-I also watched a Harry Potter movie yesterday so i suspect my sould is in great dager!
 
I enjoyed the book-thought the movie was lousy. I enjoy debunking people who took everything in the book/movie as being correct.

BTW-I also watched a Harry Potter movie yesterday so i suspect my sould is in great dager!
Well what did you enjoy about the book, Bob? I guess it was sort of a quasi-intellectual suspense story?
 
Well what did you enjoy about the book, Bob? I guess it was sort of a quasi-intellectual suspense story?
Yes-I had a good time going on the net and taking a look at the paintings and statues he describes. I have been reading Brown since before he was famous. I liked the Movie Angels and Demons better than the Movie The Davinci Code.

IMO his latest book, The Lost Symbol ,is terrible. I would be reluctant to buy another of his books-looks like he is just cranking out trash to try and capitalize on the sucess of the Davince Code.
 
Yes-I had a good time going on the net and taking a look at the paintings and statues he describes. I have been reading Brown since before he was famous. I liked the Movie Angels and Demons better than the Movie The Davinci Code.

IMO his latest book, The Lost Symbol ,is terrible. I would be reluctant to buy another of his books-looks like he is just cranking out trash to try and capitalize on the sucess of the Davince Code.
It’s really hard for lightning to strike twice when it comes to these sort of genre-altering publishing events.
 
highly recommend reading a book like The DaVinci Hoax, though. Hopefully you realize that the book and film are filled with egregious errors about Church History, Art History, Catholic doctrine, and just about every discipline Dan Brown attempts to incorporate, which leads to a portrait painted about the Church that is as inaccurate as it is unflattering. If you are not that familiar with these areas, it’s good to read up on just how far off the mark Dan Brown really is.
Yes, it is “just fiction”, but there are many people out there taking the book very seriously because they (falsely) believe that there must be at least a grain of truth to the wild claims made in the book. That is why there are so many books that point out all the inaccuracies of the novel.

Post from ORD NASILA:

The movie based on Dan Brown book contain a fatal error. Looking at Da Vinci’s painting of The Last Supper you see the slightly feminine form of the disciple to the right of Jesus.Brown wrongly identified that disciple as " the disciple whom He (Jesus) loved", and named that disciple as Mary Magdalene. But the Gospel of John makes it clear that it is not a woman, viz., " When Jesus therefore saw His mother, and the disciple standing by, whom He loved, He saith unto His mother, Woman, behold thy son! " Then saith He to the disciple, Behold thy mother! And from that hour that disciple took her unto **his **owm home."
Therefore, ’ the disciple standing by, whom He loved…", was not a woman. It may have been Simon Peter, or another disciple (not identified other than by fact he known to High Priest) - see John 18:15 & 16. I amazed nobody seem to have mentioned that before, am I correct? Regard, O.N.
 
The movie based on Dan Brown book contain a fatal error. Looking at Da Vinci’s painting of The Last Supper you see the slightly feminine form of the disciple to the right of Jesus.Brown wrongly identified that disciple as " the disciple whom He (Jesus) loved", and named that disciple as Mary Magdalene. But the Gospel of John makes it clear that it is not a woman, viz., " When Jesus therefore saw His mother, and the disciple standing by, whom He loved, He saith unto His mother, Woman, behold thy son! " Then saith He to the disciple, Behold thy mother! And from that hour that disciple took her unto **his **owm home."
Therefore, ’ the disciple standing by, whom He loved…", was not a woman. It may have been Simon Peter, or another disciple (not identified other than by fact he known to High Priest) - see John 18:15 & 16. I amazed nobody seem to have mentioned that before, am I correct? Regard, O.N.
It hasn’t been mentioned yet in this thread, but, believe me, it has been mentioned!

The saddest thing is how many people believe it. I was reading some article by Amy Welborn where she was visiting some exhibit which displayed a copy of “The Last Supper”. As she stood there, two people came up to it and one said to the other, “You know that’s really Mary Magdalene…” :eek:
 
It hasn’t been mentioned yet in this thread, but, believe me, it has been mentioned!

The saddest thing is how many people believe it. I was reading some article by Amy Welborn where she was visiting some exhibit which displayed a copy of “The Last Supper”. As she stood there, two people came up to it and one said to the other, “You know that’s really Mary Magdalene…” :eek:
Could it be meaning of 2 Thess. 2:11, " And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie." Regard, O.N.
 
I didn’t watch it because the premise was plain silly.

If Jesus were married to Mary Magdalene and they had a child named Bridget I would have known about it.
 
disciple standing by, whom He loved, He saith unto His mother, Woman, behold thy son! " Then saith He to the disciple, Behold thy mother! And from that hour that disciple took her unto **his **owm home."
Therefore, ’ the disciple standing by, whom He loved…", was not a woman. It may have been Simon Peter, or another disciple (not identified other than by fact he known to High Priest) - see John 18:15 & 16. I amazed nobody seem to have mentioned that before, am I correct? Regard, O.N.
Better yet Davinci had penciled in the names of the apostles before he painted them-notations that are visible when x-rayed. Under the picture of John he had written, suprisingly enough, JOHN!
 
Better yet Davinci had penciled in the names of the apostles before he painted them-notations that are visible when x-rayed. Under the picture of John he had written, suprisingly enough, JOHN!
I can never tell when you’re joking or when you’re being serious, Bob. :o
 
Better yet Davinci had penciled in the names of the apostles before he painted them-notations that are visible when x-rayed. Under the picture of John he had written, suprisingly enough, JOHN!
That is a revelation to me, thank you! Something else comes to mind, how would Da Vinci have known what all people in picture looked like more than 1400 years after event? Along the same idea, why would all disciples & our Lord have had long hair if St Paul writes, " It is a shame for a man to have long hair." ( 1 Cor. 11:14 & 15 ) ? Were they all under a Nazarite vow maybe? Regard, O.N.
 
Hi, first post here. I was wondering about a film called ‘Da vinci code’ with Tom Hanks. This is one of my favourite movies, I find it very interesting and fun to watch; until recently I looked up the movie on google and it came up with ‘Criticisms’. I opened it up and apparently it recieved heavy barrages of Criticism from the Catholic Church! I hope I havn’t commited a sin from liking this movie or anything, what are your opinions?:confused:
I**t is impossible to be Catholic & have this trash as one of your “favourite movies!”

Have we all been so dumbed down that we believe the ignorant garbage spewed out by Hollywood elites like Tom Hanks & Opie, without even trying to learn the Truth of Jesus Christ, our Lord & Savior???

GOD HELP US!!!**

Sancta Maria, Mater Dei, Ora Pro Nobis Peccatoribus!

mark
 
Thanks very much all for all your responses; and no I didn’t think it was true because it was againsed everything I learned in Catholicism when I was a kid. Thanks again.
 
I just wanted to say that I read the book. it was very good.I watched the movie thought it was good. I also watched the angels and demons movie. which I am sure some would not approve of. But I just wanted to say that those books and movies made me want to be catholic… seriously It made go online and reasearch the catholic faith . so I think they are just books and just movies and have different effects on different people so don’t judge others for what they do. decided for yourself whether or not you will watch it.
 
I just wanted to say that I read the book. it was very good.I watched the movie thought it was good. I also watched the angels and demons movie. which I am sure some would not approve of. But I just wanted to say that those books and movies made me want to be catholic… seriously It made go online and reasearch the catholic faith . so I think they are just books and just movies and have different effects on different people so don’t judge others for what they do. decided for yourself whether or not you will watch it.
Wow! That’s interesting. I guess it’s an example of how God can bring great good even out of something horrible ;).
 
Could it be meaning of 2 Thess. 2:11, " And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie." Regard, O.N.
You may already know about this website, but just in case, www.thecode.com.au
It is audio/visual presentation from Seventh Day Adventist Church. Regard, O.N.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top