Enough with the cell phones

  • Thread starter Thread starter briang72
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In our parish, the priest asks us to put our cell phones in “prayer mode” before he begins the Mass.
Love it! One Sunday the man in front of me started and then reached into his pocket for his cell phone, looked at the screen and then left. He’s a doctor, the phone was on vibrate and he had to make a trip to the hospital. The phone was quiet, he got his message and no one was bombarded by a raucous ringtone.
 
"Good morning, and welcome to St. Hardhead’s Parish. Today we celebrate the Feast of Our Lady of Silence.

Please be aware that your are in God’s house, in the very Presence of the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ; therefore, we ask that everyone please display the proper reverence and respect for Our Lord.

Those chewing gum are instructed to take it out now. Men will remove their hats at this time. All unnecessary chatter and talking will now halt. If you have a cell phone, turn it off now. Please be advised that ringing cell phones and electronic devices such as GameBoys will be confiscated by the ushers, taken outside the church, and destroyed.

For those of you who still believe that their cell phone is more important than showing the proper reverence for Our Divine Savior, Jesus Christ, there are three main exits from the church: the doors in the right front of the nave next to the baptistry, the doors to the left center of the nave just in front of the statue of St. Hardhead, and the six main doors to the very rear of the nave.

Thank you, and have a nice day."
Brilliant!! 👍
 
I just don’t bring it in with me to Mass! If you can’t have it on in the building, then what’s the point of even bringing it in there? I’ve never understood all this commotion over “forgetting to turn it off”.
 
I just don’t bring it in with me to Mass! If you can’t have it on in the building, then what’s the point of even bringing it in there? I’ve never understood all this commotion over “forgetting to turn it off”.
I have it vibrate.
 
I think that cell phones should be jammed (either passively or actively – legal or not) at those parishes that have congregations that do not heed repeated warnings. Ideally people wouldn’t need to be reminded and if reminded they would always comply, but that’s clearly not the case in some parishes.

There is a hierarchy of importance in our lives and the Mass trumps anything else and that includes doctors, care givers, public safety, fire fighters, or paramedics on call. In my parish, such individuals “sign-out” for the one hour they need to attend Mass or they attend another Mass when they are not on-call or where they can sign-out.

One thing that infuriates me are those parishes where cell phone calls during Mass have become normative. Even though people are continually instructed to silence their cell phones, it’s almost expected that they WILL ring during Mass no matter what effort is made. The results are predictable – more and more phones ring during the Mass.

In problem places like that I say jam them once and for all – much like they already do at performing arts venues, movie theatres and even some sporting places.
 
I think that cell phones should be jammed (either passively or actively – legal or not)
I give you this rare scenario - your church has phone signal gets jammed.

You come to the church one evening and pray - you were all alone. All of a sudden, you are fainted and fell on the floor. An old lady came in and saw that. She took out her cell phone and called. She tried to call 911. Her call couldn’t go through. She tried to call for help, no one was around to help her and you.

Later someone came in and found you dead. That person asked the lady, why didn’t you run out for help? She said she was on a handicap and she was too nervous and also fell down on the floor next to you.

Weird example but can you know for sure it never happens?

😃
 
I just don’t bring it in with me to Mass! If you can’t have it on in the building, then what’s the point of even bringing it in there? ** I’ve never understood all this commotion over “forgetting to turn it off”.**
Because it interrupts the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass. Your phone takes people’s focus away from the altar or ambo and places it on your cell phone.

Your own confusion (which many seem to share) blows me and a great many others away. To some degree I can understand how someone would forget to turn off their cell phones. I cannot however understand how someone would not view a ringing cell phone during the Mass as a VERY big negative.
 
I give you this rare scenario - your church has phone signal gets jammed.

You come to the church one evening and pray - you were all alone. All of a sudden, you are fainted and fell on the floor. An old lady came in and saw that. She took out her cell phone and called. She tried to call 911. Her call couldn’t go through. She tried to call for help, no one was around to help her and you.

Later someone came in and found you dead. That person asked the lady, why didn’t you run out for help? She said she was on a handicap and she was too nervous and also fell down on the floor next to you.

Weird example but can you know for sure it never happens?

😃
In reality the “old lady” dosen’t own a cell phone. Her son gave her one but she trashed it after continually hearing them ring during Mass.

She was quick enough however to take my cell phone. Even though she was handicapped and had taken a bit of a fall, her formation as a Catholic Christian made her instictively step outside of the church before placing the call.

As she was dialing “911” a fire engine pulled-up replete with 2 paramedics to do the structure’s annual inspection. I was given excellent care, released and told not to eat any more two foot burritos for lunch…
 
There is a hierarchy of importance in our lives and the Mass trumps anything else and that includes doctors, care givers, public safety, fire fighters, or paramedics on call. In my parish, such individuals “sign-out” for the one hour they need to attend Mass or they attend another Mass when they are not on-call or where they can sign-out.
Most cell phones have a silent/vibrate mode. If you don’t know how to use it, find a 14 year old to help you. If the phone goes off and it’s something you can’t put off, you quitely get up and leave, and no one is disturbed

While it’s obvious our culture has become ill mannerd with cell phones…

If you or a love one were on a waiting list for an organ transplant, would you not answer a beeper and get up and go out to return the call???

If someone in mass had a stroke symptons or cardiac arrested and passed out? Would you not want the ability to communicate(Remember cardiac arrest=brain death in 4-6 minutes without intervention.)

Even Jesus allowed ‘work’ on the Sabbath to take care of necessities…There are times it’s appropriate to disturb mass
 
Seriously, you are right - there is absolutely no good reason to have a cell phone at Mass unless you are a doctor, fire fighter, or paramedic on call - anything else can wait until you get out of Mass.
Yes, I agree. My father is a doctor, but he always has his cell phone and pager on vibrate, especially when he’s on call. And yes, he has had to leave mass because of an emergency at a hospital, but I only remember his pager going off once in all the years we’ve been to mass together.

A few months ago I was cantoring. Before the distribution of the communion, an older man’s cell phone goes off. Instead of just turning it off, he answered it and says out loud, “Hello? I’m in church!” then proceeded to have a conversation in the pew. We started the hymn and people started to receive communion. Some were looking at him in disgust, others (younger people) were laughing at him and I couldn’t help but think what a disruption it was.

I do have to admit that I’m guilty of my cell phone going off once during mass though. I’m usually very good about turning it off. My old phone didn’t have a cover and would sometimes turn back on if it was pressed up against something. Apparently it was up in the choir loft. I was all the way down in the sanctuary. Not once, but twice does my cell phone goes off. They first time, it went off during the music, so you could barely hear it. I couldn’t get up to the loft to turn it off and the organist was old and didn’t know what to do. The second time it was during the homily. Luckily my husband (fiance at the time) had come with me that evening for mass, ran up to the loft when he realized it was my Mozart ring tone and turned it off. The little old organist said to him, “I don’t know what it is or where it’s coming from”. I was so embarrassed and of course it was my mother calling. She knew I cantored the 5:00 mass every Saturday night, but totally forgot and is one of those kinds who won’t stop calling until someone answers. She actually left about 5 messages during that hour!!! Gotta love my Mom! 🙂
 
There is one other matter. More than a few actually like the attention a beeping cell phone provides for them…
 
There is a hierarchy of importance in our lives and the Mass trumps anything else and that includes doctors, care givers, public safety, fire fighters, or paramedics on call. In my parish, such individuals “sign-out” for the one hour they need to attend Mass or they attend another Mass when they are not on-call or where they can sign-out.
I cant’ speak for others, but growing up with a father who is a physician and a mother who is a nurse, when you’re on call, you’re on call all 48 hours of the weekend. You can’t sign out for an hour since you are the one covering for the other doctors who have the weekend off, which is why my father has his pager and cell on vibrate mode so that he can at least attend mass on Sunday.
One thing that infuriates me are those parishes where cell phone calls during Mass have become normative. Even though people are continually instructed to silence their cell phones, it’s almost expected that they WILL ring during Mass no matter what effort is made. The results are predictable – more and more phones ring during the Mass.
It is very sad and is unfortunately very common in almost everywhere else, not just in churches. It’s amazing how many classical concerts I attend where they ask the audience to silence their cell phones and, inevitably, someone will still leave theirs on. I do understand people just forgetting, but when you have the reminder before a concert or before mass, you’d think they’d double check their cells. We do that all the time prior to a concert even though we know the phones are either off or silent.
 
I cant’ speak for others, but growing up with a father who is a physician and a mother who is a nurse, when you’re on call, you’re on call all 48 hours of the weekend. You can’t sign out for an hour since you are the one covering for the other doctors who have the weekend off, which is why my father has his pager and cell on vibrate mode so that he can at least attend mass on Sunday.
So what did people in your parents’ positions do before cell phones? Just hang around the house all weekend in arm’s reach of a phone? Could they even go grocery shopping?
 
At my parish, before each mass starts, they announce what Sunday, for example, the second sunday in ordinary time; who the celebrant is that day; and they also ask everyone to turn off their cell phones or pagers or to silence the ring tone. This works out great because many times, people forget that they have their cell phone on, or they just don’t think about it.

Even though you still end up hearing the music that plays when a cell phone is turned off, this method of asking people to turn them off before mass really reduces the chance of a person’s cell phone going off during the mass.
Exactly what happens at my parish. And suprizingly for a big parish in a pretty fast-paced community, I have heard relatively few rings during Mass.
 
I think we should all chill out.

Mass isn’t a theatrical production. The only person who paid admission to get in is Jesus Christ.

Most humans are flawed and very stupid. Those of you who were born perfect, we apologize for being lower on the evolutionary chain than you, but honest, we’re muddling along as best as we can!

Can’t we stop dissecting each other because we are human and make dumb mistakes like zoning out while the lector asks us to please turn off our cell phones?

Can’t we learn to live with distractions and the very human mistakes of others?

Why are we so irritated with all of our fellow human beings, especially in church, for making such small mistakes?

A cell phone isn’t a gun. Now if someone zoned out and brought their pistol into the church, that might be worth getting upset about . (This happened at our company party last year–someone accidentally brought his gun to the party–the crowd sure thinned out in a hurry!)

Do you honestly think you’re defending the Lord? If the Lord is truly that angry with cell phones that go off because their owners made the very human error of forgetting to turn it to “vibrate”, He is perfectly capable of jamming them Himself. Or of healing the stupid brains of the people who forget.

From what I have seen, a lot of cell phones that go off belong to the elderly. For gosh sakes, everyone, we will all grow old and absentminded someday. Cut the poor old souls some slack, OK? It’s not like they deliberately left their cell phone on just to insult Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament, the priest, and you. They FORGOT! It happens. Big deal.

If my father ever brought his cell phone (which he just got) into a church and it went off, and ANY of you glared at him when he got too confused and couldn’t figure out how to turn it off, I would meet you outside the church after Mass. It’s not his fault that he got old.

Let the one who has never forgotten to turn off their cell phone during a public event cast the first stone.

As for all the people who say, “Dag nabbit, we didn’t have cell phones when we were younger and we got along,” well, bully for you. Cell phones are a wonder and I appreciate them greatly. So we don’t always use them “correctly.” No one dies if a cell phone goes off, do they? Maybe we should get rid of cars.
 
So what did people in your parents’ positions do before cell phones? Just hang around the house all weekend in arm’s reach of a phone? Could they even go grocery shopping?
Yes, I understand. My family was always one of the last families to get the latest technology in almost everything - microwave, computers, cable (I was one of the few of the "MTV generation who actually didn’t grow up with MTV thank goodness). Although I was finally forced to get a cell phone when I moved to Maine for a year and was always driving far distances where there was hardly any civilization. My parents were afraid of my car breaking down, especially after my car broke down outside of Philly on a major highway in the dead of winter around 11:30 at night and I had to trek for an hour to find a place where someone would trust me enough to call the police for me. Not fun, especially as a young woman. We always laugh and ask ourselves how we survived without these modern appliances or gadgets. Yes, we can survive without some of them, but it’s not to say that some of these gadgets do make life a little easier.

To answer you questions in my normally verbose nature, (sorry can’t help it - I’ve always been too verbose when writing. Must be all the 18th and 19th century novels I read and studied. Ha!) my father graduated from medical school in the late 70s and started residency right after. When he was on call as a resident, he was basically at the hospital all day and all night with maybe a few hours of sleep, if that. There are many stories from him and his colleagues where they might have gotten about a half hour’s worth of sleep while being a resident. They stayed awake and alert on adrenalin and the drive to make save people’s lives in the emergency rooms. He was actually on-call the weekend I was born and luckily it was at the same hospital where he was doing his residency and could come for my birth since they had another resident there. This was prior to cell phones. Residents still have to do that. But even after he started his practice he basically had an answering service who would call him if there was an emergency. And, yes, even when he’d come home from the hospital on the weekends he was on call, he’d stayed home. When he was at the hospital on Sunday mornings, they had mass there since it was a Catholic hospital, so they could page doctors over the intercom or at least send someone to get the doctor. And back then, when he was on call, he was at the hospital in the morning and afternoons and be home by around 6:00, so we’d go to mass at our parish without him while he’d attend mass at the hospital. During the week he was at the hospital and his office from 7:30 a.m. to 10:30 or 11:30 p.m. He’d come home almost every night around midnight. BTW - My mother did the grocery shopping. 🙂 Nurses aren’t on call like doctors are. My father no longer has to go to the hospital on the weekends, and has cut his 16 hour days to 12 hours days. He’s “old”. Ha! Ha! Although he is still on call, but can now use the pager and cell phone.

I can’t say what doctors did prior to phones or answering services since I wasn’t around back then, but I suppose if a person couldn’t find the doctor to come to the house or to the hospital, I guess the sick individual was out of luck or would just pray that that he or she would get better. It’s not a sin for a doctor to have a pager or a cell phone especially if they care enough about their patients to want to be available at a moment’s notice so that a patient won’t die. Although people do misuse their cell phones, it doesn’t mean it hasn’t helped make things a little easier, especially in terms of contacting people quickly for emergencies. With the exclusion of the minor or major annoyances of cell phones going off when not wanted, they can be help in certain circumstances.
 
I just don’t bring it in with me to Mass! If you can’t have it on in the building, then what’s the point of even bringing it in there? I’ve never understood all this commotion over “forgetting to turn it off”.
Because it interrupts the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass. Your phone takes people’s focus away from the altar or ambo and places it on your cell phone.

Your own confusion (which many seem to share) blows me and a great many others away. To some degree I can understand how someone would forget to turn off their cell phones. I cannot however understand how someone would not view a ringing cell phone during the Mass as a VERY big negative.
I think you missed Exoflare’s point. Let me help. If people would just leave their cell phones in the car or at home, they wouldn’t need to remember to turn them off. Hence Exoflare’s comment of not understanding “all this commotion over ‘forgetting to turn it off’.” You can’t forget to turn off the cell phone you left at home. You’ll notice that Exoflare’s very first comment is that he/she doesn’t bring it in to Mass.

Let’s check to make sure our cell phones are off, and our charity is on, ladies and gentleman.

Gertie
 
In reality the “old lady” dosen’t own a cell phone. Her son gave her one but she trashed it after continually hearing them ring during Mass.
.
Have you visited a Nursing Home yet?
Come and see how many of those folks having cellularphone. 😃
 
Recently got a new cell phone and low and behold, it does not
ring when one is setting it to “vibrate” mode. I usually remember
to put it on vibrate before entering church, but the other times when the annoucement reminds me, it’s nice to go to the vibrate
mode silently. Otherwise, on the old phone, I had to go to
turning it to off. I have a 92yo mother and I do need it in case
of emergency.
 
Cellphones go off frequently during mass at my parish.
Announcement after announcement has failed to stop it.
It’s really rude and annoying. They should be set on Vibrate before the person even walks thru the Church door.

Another problem, and let me first say that I absolutely adore and cherish little babies, so don’t jump on me for being heartless okay? Sometimes, for whatever reason, a little baby will start to whimper during mass. But at other times, the child begins
screaming bloody murder at the top of his lungs to the point where NO ONE can hear the priest, and mom will sometimes just bounce the shrieking baby on her lap instead of going with him to the washroom or outside for a few minutes till the little
fellow or fellowette calms down. I love babies dearly, but please, when they start to **scream and shriek **uncontrollably, please take the little guy or gal out of the sanctuary to calm him or her down. 🙂

Love,
Jaypeeto4
+JMJ+
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top