Error of Person

  • Thread starter Thread starter wonderofwonders
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

wonderofwonders

Guest
Can someone help me understand what “Error of person” and “Error of quality” mean as they refer to a petition to declare a marriage invalid.
 
Can someone help me understand what “Error of person” and “Error of quality” mean as they refer to a petition to declare a marriage invalid.
Error of person means you are mistaken about who you are marrying. For example, Jacob’s marriage where Leah is substituted for Rachel by Laban. Or a twin switching places.

Error of quality means a particular quality of the person is withheld that would have caused the person not to marry the other had it been known. For example, a man with SSA marries a woman but doesn’t tell her of his SSA.
 
Error of person means you are mistaken about who you are marrying. For example, Jacob’s marriage where Leah is substituted for Rachel by Laban. Or a twin switching places.

Error of quality means a particular quality of the person is withheld that would have caused the person not to marry the other had it been known. For example, a man with SSA marries a woman but doesn’t tell her of his SSA.
What is SSA?
 
SSA means same sex attraction, which is the impulse behind the act of homosexuality.

People who are same sex attracted do not have to engage in the act although our current society does not separate the two terms or impulses. We as Catholics believe that those with SSA are called to remain chaste and not indulge in the sin of homosexuality.
 
For error of quality to invalidate a marriage, it must be directly and principally intended. For example, a golddigger marrying a man she thought was rich but who was really poor.
 
SSA as a reason for nullity doesn’t fly in Rome unless perhaps under c. 1098, which is fraud, that is if a quality that by it’s nature could gravely disturb the community of married life is hidden from the other by malice perpetrated in order to obtain consent.

In plain English: if someone lies about his SSA, then yeah, it could cause nullity (fraud, not error).

Error in regard to the quality of person is where a quality is directly and principally intended, as the poster before me wrote, which, in the words of a former Rota judge basically means that the quality is intended more than the actual person is. I’m not sure I agree with that definition but the man obviously knew his cannon law better than I do mine, and even if he exaggerated, then not by far anyway.

Also, it can’t be something like a good or kind person or whatever. It needs to be a precise quality. And it needs to be precisely formulated. A presumption that e.g. all of us specifically desire our prospective spouse not to have SSA will not work and will not rise up to the standard required by this ground of nullity.

Error as regards the person is basically an error as to identity. The wrong twin brother or some other kind of impostor etc.
 
SSA as a reason for nullity doesn’t fly in Rome unless perhaps under c. 1098, which is fraud, that is if a quality that by it’s nature could gravely disturb the community of married life is hidden from the other by malice perpetrated in order to obtain consent.

In plain English: if someone lies about his SSA, then yeah, it could cause nullity (fraud, not error).

Error in regard to the quality of person is where a quality is directly and principally intended, as the poster before me wrote, which, in the words of a former Rota judge basically means that the quality is intended more than the actual person is. I’m not sure I agree with that definition but the man obviously knew his cannon law better than I do mine, and even if he exaggerated, then not by far anyway.

Also, it can’t be something like a good or kind person or whatever. It needs to be a precise quality. And it needs to be precisely formulated. A presumption that e.g. all of us specifically desire our prospective spouse not to have SSA will not work and will not rise up to the standard required by this ground of nullity.

Error as regards the person is basically an error as to identity. The wrong twin brother or some other kind of impostor etc.
A person who a directly and principally intended to marry a heterosexual “man’s man” – tall, dark, handsome and masculine-- would have had a case for error of quality had they married Rock Hudson without knowing he was homosexual. I was thinking of many machismo cultures where men stay on the down low and marry a woman to facilitate a manly facade or the US 50 years ago where Hollywood icons pretended to be heterosexual.

I think either fraud or error of quality could qualify here.
 
A person who a directly and principally intended to marry a heterosexual “man’s man” – tall, dark, handsome and masculine-- would have had a case for error of quality had they married Rock Hudson without knowing he was homosexual. I was thinking of many machismo cultures where men stay on the down low and marry a woman to facilitate a manly facade or the US 50 years ago where Hollywood icons pretended to be heterosexual.

I think either fraud or error of quality could qualify here.
I’m not sure even that would fall under “directly”. I think it would be almost impossible to form the kind of frame of mind to have this particular ground of nullity, if there is such a frame of mind at all. Perhaps a person who had once been involved with a bisexual or a hidden homosexual and then went paranoid about the subject could succeed at it.

The problem with fraud is how widely one can define that deceit perpetrated by malice, e.g. will non-disclosure out of fear of getting dumped qualify or not. Interpreting this part of canon law sounds like a massive headache coming.
 
Why do you ask? Just curious as your answer will tell me where I can direct you for more precise help. If you do not want to answer openly feel free to message me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top