ESPN fires and suspends 2 analysts

  • Thread starter Thread starter SMA_12
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Chink in the armor is widely used in sports as has already been said. Sports announcing is so pollyannish and filled with euphemisms enough as it is. Let people say what they think.
If they had used the expression as part of the color commentary that would have been one thing. But it was in a headline. Those are filled with puns. It is extremely unlikely that they didn’t intend the double meaning.
 
If they had used the expression as part of the color commentary that would have been one thing. But it was in a headline. Those are filled with puns. It is extremely unlikely that they didn’t intend the double meaning.
Exactly. I have no issue with the analyst that said it during the game, but sports headlines are, as you say, typically filled with puns or clever phrases. That is what makes it seem deliberate to me.
 
I am as un-PC as you can get, and these guys deserve punishment of some sort. Come on. No one believes they weren’t using Chink to refer to the first Taiwanese NBA player, aka Jeremy Lin.

Honkey, the N word, and others too have no place in a news article on a sports page. This wasn’t some random blogger’s piece. ESPN has a reputation that want to uphold (one that stinks, IMO, but nonetheless, it was a stupid thing to do).

Even if you don’t suspend them for trying to intentionally be offensive, suspend them for being too stupid to realize it was a dumb idea. Billion dollar companies have no rooms for dullards hurting their bottom line with stupidity.
If this was an obscure phrase, or one with overt racial meaning, I would agree with you. In this case, though, the phrase is used very often when dealing with sports figures that seem invincible as Lin has. If this phrase had been used for Tebow we wouldn’t even think for a moment that a Chinese racial slur was being used because it’s such a common sports expression, and has no relation to race in its meaning.

I think it was an oversight that needed correction, like removing the article, but not punishment unless malice was truly demonstrated. As it is I think people are projecting their own thoughts.

Peace and God bless!
 
If this was an obscure phrase, or one with overt racial meaning, I would agree with you. In this case, though, the phrase is used very often when dealing with sports figures that seem invincible as Lin has. If this phrase had been used for Tebow we wouldn’t even think for a moment that a Chinese racial slur was being used because it’s such a common sports expression, and has no relation to race in its meaning.

I think it was an oversight that needed correction, like removing the article, but not punishment unless malice was truly demonstrated. As it is I think people are projecting their own thoughts.

Peace and God bless!
I believe it was the editor’s piece. They need a better editor. This wasn’t some low level staffer. They haven’t used chink in the armor in years, if even longer. I read them a lot.
 
Last week 2 ESPN analysts used the term “Chink in the Armor” in their analysis of Jeremy Lin, referring to a game in which he had 9 turnovers. They used the term to describe a weakness in his otherwise outstanding play as of late. One of the analysts was fired and the other was suspended because “Chink” can be used as a racist term towards Asians, and Jeremy Lin happens to be Asian American. It was apparent the analysts had no intention of being racist, yet were punished for using the common phrase referring to a dent or broken piece of armor, used to today to describe a weakness in an otherwise strong item or ideal.

Is it just me or was this a huge over reaction? Being politically correct has gone completely overboard.

nydailynews.com/sports/basketball/knicks/jeremy-lin-slur-honest-mistake-fired-espn-editor-anthony-federico-claims-article-1.1025566
Political correctness is the “tyranny of good manners”. This whole incident is stupid and ESPN should be ashamed of themselves. The phrase “chink in the armor” is a very commonly known expression and it is obvious that the commentator meant it in its colloquial form, not as an insult to asian people. This whole thing reminds me of when we had to call “Flip Charts” some other stupid name, because “Flip Charts” could be seen as offensive by Philipinos. Give me a freaken break. People need to get over themselves.
 
I remember when Madden was announcing Monday NIght Football and was discussing the different areas the runner could approach. He stated that the offensive line for that team was creating holes in the defense and it was the running back’s job to figure out whether to choose the A hole, the B hole, or C hole.

During the week, radio guys laughed at it and replayed the comments. From that point on, Madden referred to the holes as gaps instead. So it was A gap, B gap, etc…

Chink in the armor is widely used in sports as has already been said. Sports announcing is so pollyannish and filled with euphemisms enough as it is. Let people say what they think.
A Gap, B Gap, etc… are defensive line references. The A Gap is the space between the center and the guard. “Holes” are numbered 1 - 10 and refer to running back lanes. They have been referred to in these terms for nearly 60 years. If Madden referred to them as something different…its because he is John Madden and he has a certain amount of poetic license.
 
How was this “very clear”? Please explain to me how you know the intention of the author without knowing their writing style or previous clever “turns of phrase”. Tell me how you can know this as “fact”.

I’m curious how people evaluate these kinds of things, because I’m not gifted with the kind of mind-reading that so many others seem to have.

Peace and God bless!
If it wasn’t their intention then their ignorance is cause for their firing.
 
If it wasn’t their intention then their ignorance is cause for their firing.
I’m not convinced ignorance on a subject like this is a firable offense. Definitely worthy of some training, though. My wife, who is Asian, had never even heard the term. I was surprised at that, but it shows it’s not an obvious connection to all.

Peace and God bless!
 
Political correctness is the “tyranny of good manners”. This whole incident is stupid and ESPN should be ashamed of themselves. The phrase “chink in the armor” is a very commonly known expression and it is obvious that the commentator meant it in its colloquial form, not as an insult to asian people. This whole thing reminds me of when we had to call “Flip Charts” some other stupid name, because “Flip Charts” could be seen as offensive by Philipinos. Give me a freaken break. People need to get over themselves.
👍
 
If it wasn’t their intention then their ignorance is cause for their firing.
Seriously. No one knows whether they were trying to be funny, but regardless, if they are too stupid to realize this (which I don’t believe), they deserve some sort of punishment. I don’t advocate firing anyone as a general rule, especially sitting miles away behind a keyboard with no access to the men and their resumes or history.

But if we are truly going to not be PC about this sort of thing, just allow them to write whatever they, even if they are intending to offend.

Then, they can use the word as a perjorative if they want. it will be a free for all, but at least we can express how we truly feel about some people.
 
I’m not convinced ignorance on a subject like this is a firable offense. Definitely worthy of some training, though. My wife, who is Asian, had never even heard the term. I was surprised at that, but it shows it’s not an obvious connection to all.

Peace and God bless!
If you are selling bait and tackle at Wal-Mart it wouldn’t be, if you are writing about events that you hope millions will read it is.
 
If you are selling bait and tackle at Wal-Mart it wouldn’t be, if you are writing about events that you hope millions will read it is.
Then I expect that this person was trained never to use that term. As I said it’s quite plausible that they didn’t know it was an offensive term, or hadn’t been exposed to it being used in such a way. It’s not nearly as recognized as the n-word. When was the last time it has come up as a public issue? I honestly can’t remember ever hearing it raised as such, though I’m sure it has in some quarters.

Obviously some awareness training is needed, but I’m not convinced that in these cases that awareness could reasonably be expected beforehand. The man who said it on t.v. and was suspended is married to an Asian woman and it didn’t raise red flags in his mind (and by his cadence it’s clear he wasn’t trying to make a pun). Even Jeremy Lin said he didn’t think anything was meant by the expression.

Peace and God bless!
 
Here is a reaction:
blog.angryasianman.com/2012/02/espn-fires-employee-for-chink-in-armor.html
Well, that was quick. I’d like to think that it was the collective fury of the internet and beyond that forced ESPN to take swift action and fire the employee responsible for writing that incredibly stupid “Chink In The Armor” headline on Friday night: ESPN fires writer of offensive headline about Jeremy Lin.
Some editor probably thought they were being clever when they it occurred to them to use a freaking racial slur in the headline. And if you’re one of those people arguing that “chink in the armor” is a legitimate expression, you can suck it. The writer was invoking race and knew exactly what they were doing.
The headline was only up for 35 minutes, but it was enough to get screen-grabbed, shared and social media-ed like crazy. ESPN issued a short statement of apology the morning after, promising a review of editorial procedures and “appropriate disciplinary action.” Not very reassuring, but it was a start.
By this morning, ESPN announed that they had taken action to address both the headline and a previous instance in which anchor Max Bretos used the expression during a broadcast, as well as a similar recent reference uttered on ESPN Radio in New York:
Statement on offensive comments
At ESPN we are aware of three offensive and inappropriate comments made on ESPN outlets during our coverage of Jeremy Lin.
Saturday we apologized for two references. We have since learned of a similar reference Friday on ESPN Radio New York. The incidents were separate and different. We have engaged in a thorough review of all three and have taken the following action:
The ESPN employee responsible for our Mobile headline has been dismissed.
The ESPNEWS anchor has been suspended for 30 days.
The radio commentator is not an ESPN employee.
We again apologize, especially to Mr. Lin. His accomplishments are a source of great pride to the Asian-American community, including the Asian-American employees at ESPN. Through self-examination, improved editorial practices and controls, and response to constructive criticism, we will be better in the future.
I’ve seen a lot of **** like this over the years, but I’ve never seen a media entity like ESPN act this fast to address a complaint. That’s the Jeremy Lin Effect. More here: Apparently intentional, ESPN’s since-deleted headline about Jeremy Lin was distressing.
Of course, this doesn’t mean it all goes away. In addition to firing this fool, I hope ESPN and other newsrooms take a good, hard look at the way they address race in instances like this – not just as a pun or a punchline.
I guess that’s an important component of how Jeremy Lin has inadvertently opened up the dialogue on what it means to be Asian in America. With all the hero worship and scrutiny of number 17, the lone Asian face on the court, will people think twice about making a dumbass Asian comment? I wouldn’t hold my breath, but like I said, it’s a start.
It appears that not only one, but three people made similar types of comments at ESPN.
espn.go.com/espn/story/_/id/7591778/espn-statement-offensive-jeremy-lin-comments
 
Then I expect that this person was trained never to use that term. As I said it’s quite plausible that they didn’t know it was an offensive term, or hadn’t been exposed to it being used in such a way. It’s not nearly as recognized as the n-word. When was the last time it has come up as a public issue? I honestly can’t remember ever hearing it raised as such, though I’m sure it has in some quarters.
Again, if they are that ignorant they need a job that doesn’t expose their ignorance to millions of people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top