What’s wrong with it?Look at this. What do you think about this?
I don’t know if I understand it? Is it just saying that St. Mary was eternally predestined to be the Mother of God?What’s wrong with it?
Yes. God is outside of time - He knows it all already - and He knew Mary before Mary existed and exactly what Her unique existance would be and would mean.I don’t know if I understand it? Is it just saying that St. Mary was eternally predestined to be the Mother of God?
I agree with that - the term can mislead. I had never actualy heard it before.The only issue I would take is that the term “eternal” would have to be qualified as pertains to Mary. While God (who alone is truly eternal in that he has always existed) foreknew and predestined Mary’s role in salvation, her existance is a punctuation in time from an ontological standpoint. To make her otherwise is to set her on equal footing with the Creator, and I don’t think anyone (least of all, our Lady) would desire that misunderstanding.
True, I think by eternal, it just meant that God knew He would create her since the beginning.The only issue I would take is that the term “eternal” would have to be qualified as pertains to Mary. While God (who alone is truly eternal in that he has always existed) foreknew and predestined Mary’s role in salvation, her existance is a punctuation in time from an ontological standpoint. To make her otherwise is to set her on equal footing with the Creator, and I don’t think anyone (least of all, our Lady) would desire that misunderstanding.
Yea that was my only problem with it, I thought it somehow meant predestination. I guess it doesn’t.I agree with that - the term can mislead. I had never actualy heard it before.
DD