Ethics of Fur

  • Thread starter Thread starter Marfran
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dude, have you been reading this thread??? We have a factory farm mink rancher here trying to convince us to wear mink!!!
I have never referred to YOU as a “Factory Fur Farmer.” I have never referred to YOU as anything. Your commentaries are unnecessarily personal, you assume personal things about people and post such. This is against CAF rules. Please stick to the topic and debate the topic.
Actually, as you can see from your own quote above, you referred to me as a “factory farm mink rancher” although I told you I grew up on a fur farm and I haven’t worked on one in many years. So, once again, Marfran, follow your own advice and do not refer personally to me and I will refrain from doing the same to you.
 
I don’t think I have any Vaseline in the house.
Anyway, I mentioned the use of petroleum because if we are having a fuel crisis, should we use petroleum to make fake furs, instead of using it for fuel? My house is oil heat…we would have liked to switch to Natural Gas, but it isn’t an option where I live. I need to stay warm, if petroleum is in such short supply, why use it to make fake fur?
Petroleum as a resource is limited. We are already looking at and usig alternatives. I believe it is the byproducts that are used. Plastic also uses that.
 
Petroleum as a resource is limited. We are already looking at and usig alternatives. I believe it is the byproducts that are used. Plastic also uses that.
Of course there are alternatives; the stuff things were made of before plastic. Metal, wood, cellulose, glass. But it’s precisely because petroleum is plentiful and cheap that so many things are made of plastic. I have a friend who is a very successful “recycler” who makes biodiesel and all kinds of things. The way he puts it is “I don’t care what you do. You can’t make anything as cheaply as something you can pump right out of the ground.”
 
I would be happy to go further, once I read of reasons why people need fur that are not to do with vanity or personal preference.
Reading through this thread you will find many that cite fur as the best material for keeping warm in extreme climates.
I have already explained how I and others I know living in extreme temperate conditions have managed to get by without the use of fur.
‘Managed to get by’ implies a struggle.
Perhaps there would not be such a struggle using real fur to keep warm.
Iam not judging anyone, but these expereinces of mine make it extremely difficult to understand why a human being needs to wear fur.
Perhaps you should read through this thread again. It has been explained many times that fur is better at keeping people warm in extreme climates.
And there are numerous other advantages outlined within this thread of fur over anything else.
What are these many needs the fur industry serves?
Economics.
 
Actually, as you can see from your own quote above, you referred to me as a “factory farm mink rancher” although I told you I grew up on a fur farm and I haven’t worked on one in many years. So, once again, Marfran, follow your own advice and do not refer personally to me and I will refrain from doing the same to you.
I did not!!! Is your name attached??? I have not used YOUR name, and pointed to you in a personal way. You make personal references in all of your posts and ask posters personal questions. Again, stick to the topic. Please show us some evidence that the industry is*** not ***cruel.

What constitutes a “factory farm?” I believe it is the number of animals, and the methods of husbandry used. all-creatures.org/adow/cam-fur-inside.html

I suspect that you do not like the word “factory.”
 
I did not!!! Is your name attached??? You make personal references in all of your posts and ask posters personal questions.
Well we can clear this up real quick…

Who exactly were you refering to, and which post is it in which “have a factory farm mink rancher here trying to convince us to wear mink!!!”
 
Reading through this thread you will find many that cite fur as the best material for keeping warm in extreme climates.

‘Managed to get by’ implies a struggle.
Perhaps there would not be such a struggle using real fur to keep warm.

Perhaps you should read through this thread again. It has been explained many times that fur is better at keeping people warm in extreme climates.
And there are numerous other advantages outlined within this thread of fur over anything else.

Economics.
A few have said real fur is warmer, others have said that it is not necessarily so, including JaneGrey who lives in a cold climate.

What numerous advantages please?

If money is the be all and end all, then we can do many, many unethical things.
 
Reading through this thread you will find many that cite fur as the best material for keeping warm in extreme climates.
And who wears a mink coat specifically for keeping warm in extreme climates? Makers of these coats design them for FASHION.

This model isn’t even wearing a hat!!! She’s going to freeze off her earlobes!!! madisonavemall.com/products/product.asp?SKU=2404RA&cid=3&gclid=CMnF6OLI9p0CFdA65QodwkZ8qA

And this model isn’t wearing gloves!!! I can’t believe they are selling mink coats on amazon.com. amazon.com/gp/product/B001IA13MK/ref=pd_lpo_k2_dp_sr_2?pf_rd_p=486539851&pf_rd_s=lpo-top-stripe-1&pf_rd_t=201&pf_rd_i=B001IA1CVC&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=020JF7AT4RA74B9EQ278

For the woman of distinction (note, no gloves, no hat…) www1.bloomingdales.com/catalog/product/index.ognc?ID=453347&CategoryID=2910&PartnerID=SHP&cm_mmc=Froogle--Womens--COAT-_-Maximilian_Dyed_Black_Sheared_Horizontal_Mink_Coat_with_Uptone_Russian_Sable_Collar/Cuffs_41L&utm_source=GoogleProduct&utm_medium=organic (And if the fur is so beautiful why are we dying it?)

I’m having trouble finding anyone who is marketing mink coats for climate conditions. Seems the target audience is looking for luxury, sophistication, and elegance.
 
I did not!!!
Sure looks like you did to me.
Is your name attached??? I have not used YOUR name, and pointed to you in a personal way.
You implied that. Who else could you have been referring to? You said something like, “Dude, we have a factory mink farmer HERE trying to convince…” Who else could it be?
You make personal references in all of your posts and ask posters personal questions. Again, stick to the topic. Please show us some evidence that the industry is not cruel.
You have been shown plenty of (first hand) evidence -if you don’t believe me just look back… You just dismiss it as being not true.
What constitutes a “factory farm?” I believe it is the number of animals, and the methods of husbandry used. all-creatures.org/adow/cam-fur-inside.html
I suspect that you do not like the word “factory.”
 
And who wears a mink coat specifically for keeping warm in extreme climates? Makers of these coats design them for FASHION.

This model isn’t even wearing a hat!!! She’s going to freeze off her earlobes!!! madisonavemall.com/products/product.asp?SKU=2404RA&cid=3&gclid=CMnF6OLI9p0CFdA65QodwkZ8qA

And this model isn’t wearing gloves!!! I can’t believe they are selling mink coats on amazon.com. amazon.com/gp/product/B001IA13MK/ref=pd_lpo_k2_dp_sr_2?pf_rd_p=486539851&pf_rd_s=lpo-top-stripe-1&pf_rd_t=201&pf_rd_i=B001IA1CVC&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=020JF7AT4RA74B9EQ278

I’m having trouble finding anyone who is marketing mink coats for climate conditions. Seems the target audience is looking for luxury, sophistication, and elegance.
I must agree for the most part BUT I think that fur is excellent for keeping warm too. (not just coats)
 
I must agree for the most part BUT I think that fur is excellent for keeping warm too. (not just coats)
They are not marketed for warmth, they are marketed for fashion, and they are designed for fashion, not warmth–or they would be designed differently (like zipping all the way up the neck, re-inforced cuffs that cling to the body, etc.)

And dyeing them to get even coloration, how does that enhance warmth???
 
Is it ethical for modern, civilized man to raise and kill animals for their fur?

Something like 85% of the fur industry’s skins come from animals living captive in fur factory farms–is this ethical???

Any compelling reasons/moral imperatives to cease procuring animal fur, specifically by these methods?

Any additional thoughts on hunting animals for the sole purpose of trophies, e.g., canned hunts that are designed specifically for the hunter to bring home an exotic trophy skin?? (This may be a related corollary to the fur farming topic–as it is about killing animals for their skins/fur and not for “food.”)
Just spotted this thread and would like to respond. given so much has transpired I am sorry if things get repeated. OK.

I am an ex-mink farmer. For 35 years I farmed mink. I shall restrict my defence to mink farming. As regards the ethics of it, I refer to the Triune God as a guide, not to some looney ‘animal-rights’ ideology. In the Scriptures God tells us He provided all for man’s use and benefit Adam and Eve were given animal skins to cover themselves after the fall. St John the Baptist wore a camel skin without complaint from Jesus…

End of debate. Anything else you wish me to answer to?
 
Quality
Longevity
Insulating qualities
resistence to water
biodegradable

These are just a few that have been outlined on this thread.
Perhaps you missed them?

Who said anything about money?
Those qualities were suggested. The first three could just as much apply to faux fur. Faux fur may take longer to biodegrade. Anyway there are other options (not real fur).

My apologies if you reference to economics was to anything other than money and related matters lile jobs and of course profits.
 
They are not marketed for warmth, they are marketed for fashion, and they are designed for fashion, not warmth–or they would be designed differently (like zipping all the way up the neck, re-inforced cuffs that cling to the body, etc.)

And dyeing them to get even coloration, how does that enhance warmth???
I am agreeing with you that *most *coats are for fashion, but there are some fur products that are very good for keeping warm. (like the rabbit hat I used to have -nothing was warmer than that one!)
 
This is from the Fur Council of Canada. Mink is the most popular fur. Mink and fox are almost exclusively raised on “fur farms” as opposed to being hunted. furcouncil.com/FurTypes.aspx

“Virtually since the beginning of mankind, ***fur has been valued for its comfort and beauty ***by people all over the world.”
 
Just spotted this thread and would like to respond. given so much has transpired I am sorry if things get repeated. OK.

I am an ex-mink farmer. For 35 years I farmed mink. I shall restrict my defence to mink farming. As regards the ethics of it, I refer to the Triune God as a guide, not to some looney ‘animal-rights’ ideology. In the Scriptures God tells us He provided all for man’s use and benefit Adam and Eve were given animal skins to cover themselves after the fall. St John the Baptist wore a camel skin without complaint from Jesus…

End of debate. Anything else you wish me to answer to?
Good, now we have another catholic person who has first hand experience with fur farms.👍
 
Just spotted this thread and would like to respond. given so much has transpired I am sorry if things get repeated. OK.

I am an ex-mink farmer. For 35 years I farmed mink. I shall restrict my defence to mink farming. As regards the ethics of it, I refer to the Triune God as a guide, not to some looney ‘animal-rights’ ideology. In the Scriptures God tells us He provided all for man’s use and benefit Adam and Eve were given animal skins to cover themselves after the fall. St John the Baptist wore a camel skin without complaint from Jesus…

End of debate. Anything else you wish me to answer to?

Looney? Good way to come into a discussion, by calling names. I thought God had all the answers, certainly not you.

After the fall, exactly! Now we need mink, sables as a necessity?

End of debate? Now what debate did you enter into exactly?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top