T
Timothy_Crown
Guest
To all:
I really wasn’t sure which forum to post this in. Hope hit the closest place. Would like some advice on an moral/ethical decision must make. Will provide a broad
overview of the situation without going into detail.
My 76 year neighbor is dying from lung cancer. She is still living in an apartment in the
same complex as me. But she needs a lot of help. And shortly she will have to get a
lot more assistance-and will be eventually probably go to group home. This lady worked
at relatively low paying jobs her entire life and just retired last year. She has $20,000 in savings.
What happened is she found a couple of months had lung cancer (it is terminal)-so she
transferred her savings out of the bank into the daughters name. This was to be able
to apply for more government aid-without the goverment able to tape her assets.
Her is where I come in.
The forms to fill out for this aid can be complicated-so the daughter has asked me to
help to fill out. The big note-is that the government knows that many people try to
hide their assets in order not to go through their worth-and be able to pass money onto
their relatives-rather than the nursing home.
Is is permissable to help my neighbor/with her daughter to fill out the necessary forms
to apply for this government aid-knowing my neighbor does actually have some money?
Keep in mind-we are talking $20,000-which she wants to leave some of this between
her 2 daughters. It is not like she is trying to hide a $1,000,000 dollars
a. Would it be OK to help my neighbor fill out these forms under any condtion?
b. Would be it Ok to fill out these forms if no where on forms-anyone had to tell a lie?
It would be up to the government to find the truth.
Help? I can go into a little more detail-but that pretty well covers it. Will have to make
a decision in next couple days-as the social worker came out Monday and gave my
neighbor the necessary forms to fill out.
Personally-I never believe in lying in life-even a white lie. Is this lying in this case?
By just helping fill the forms-is it in anyway a sin?
Thanks for anyones expertise
Timothy
I really wasn’t sure which forum to post this in. Hope hit the closest place. Would like some advice on an moral/ethical decision must make. Will provide a broad
overview of the situation without going into detail.
My 76 year neighbor is dying from lung cancer. She is still living in an apartment in the
same complex as me. But she needs a lot of help. And shortly she will have to get a
lot more assistance-and will be eventually probably go to group home. This lady worked
at relatively low paying jobs her entire life and just retired last year. She has $20,000 in savings.
What happened is she found a couple of months had lung cancer (it is terminal)-so she
transferred her savings out of the bank into the daughters name. This was to be able
to apply for more government aid-without the goverment able to tape her assets.
Her is where I come in.
The forms to fill out for this aid can be complicated-so the daughter has asked me to
help to fill out. The big note-is that the government knows that many people try to
hide their assets in order not to go through their worth-and be able to pass money onto
their relatives-rather than the nursing home.
Is is permissable to help my neighbor/with her daughter to fill out the necessary forms
to apply for this government aid-knowing my neighbor does actually have some money?
Keep in mind-we are talking $20,000-which she wants to leave some of this between
her 2 daughters. It is not like she is trying to hide a $1,000,000 dollars
a. Would it be OK to help my neighbor fill out these forms under any condtion?
b. Would be it Ok to fill out these forms if no where on forms-anyone had to tell a lie?
It would be up to the government to find the truth.
Help? I can go into a little more detail-but that pretty well covers it. Will have to make
a decision in next couple days-as the social worker came out Monday and gave my
neighbor the necessary forms to fill out.
Personally-I never believe in lying in life-even a white lie. Is this lying in this case?
By just helping fill the forms-is it in anyway a sin?
Thanks for anyones expertise
Timothy