Eucharist.... cannibalism arguments

  • Thread starter Thread starter bigfootbob
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

bigfootbob

Guest
I’ve been doing a little thinking about how atheists and other religions call our communion cannibalism.

Here is my question: What makes it not cannibalism?

It seems like a silly question, but…
 
We are not eating his ‘Physical’ body (like a chunk of his leg), we are consuming his entirety, body blood soul and divinity
 
Cannibalism is eating the flesh of a dead human being.

We are not eating the dead physical flesh of Jesus, but the body, blood, soul, and divinity of the risen, glorified Christ.
 
When God asks you to do something, you don’t ask questions about it. What I see here is that you are supposed to follow the directive even in situations where one would say, “WHAT??” you just do it and don’t ask, and don’t try to look back (Lot’s wife) when you are told what to do. Take your orders and just do it. If you believe.
The bible makes a very compelling story for heeding the instructions you are given. If you don’t., well good luck with that. I am assuming you are up against a fundamentalist theology. If that is the case, then they can respect you for taking the narrative seriously.
 
That may be the usual practice, but cannibalism does not exclude eating live human flesh.
God even mentions it in the bible. How he will make people cannibals. It is not a pretty topic really.
 
How he will make people cannibals…
Citation please?

In John 6 Jesus gives this discourse about the necessity to eat His flesh and drink His blood in order to have life. He doesn’t explain the physics of it, just that if we don’t, we don’t have life in us. There is no property of human flesh that effects a change like that, but we don’t know anything about what supernatural flesh may or may not do. He, however, does. This is why it is called faith.

To those who followed when it was easy, these words made them falter and turn away, likely because they viewed it only as a form of cannibalism that was absolutely prohibited by Mosaic law. Jesus did not stop them, nor plead with them that He was only speaking symbolically, He let them put their own ideas at the forefront and walk away.

But, as Peter said, “To whom would we go? You have the words of eternal life.” So, you either take those words of eternal life as coming from the source of all Truth and accept that what He says is good for us IS good for us, or you walk away. It’s worth considering all the other times He said something that fell on human ears as one thing but really meant another. Tearing down the Temple and building it back up in 3 days, for example. Not a soul who heard that, Apostles included, didn’t think Jesus was talking about anything except physical stones comprising a large building.

I think there is a lesson in that; the lesson being that what we hear isn’t necessarily the ultimate truth of His words. It’s ridiculous on its face to think the Son of God became man, set aside all his glory and put up with every indignity and rejection up to and including death, only to give us one tidbit of misinformation that is completely useless to us. He said what He said, and He meant it.
 
Cannibalism is eating the flesh of a dead human being.
That may be the usual practice, but cannibalism does not exclude eating live human flesh.
That’s right, Digitonomy. So, perhaps we have to look elsewhere for what distinguishes the Eucharist from cannibalism.

Likewise, if we say:
"GrahamAPhone:
We are not eating his ‘Physical’ body (like a chunk of his leg), we are consuming his entirety, body blood soul and divinity
Someone could counter that while it is nearly always the case that a cannibal eats only part of a body, that a cannibal could eat the entire body of someone. However. . . perhaps this notion of consuming the soul should be pursued?
We are not eating the dead physical flesh of Jesus, but the body, blood, soul, and divinity of the risen, glorified Christ.
I’m not sure this is on the right track either. I think we should also take into account the Apostles at the Last Supper. They didn’t receive the risen and glorified Christ, but they weren’t cannibals either.

VC
 
I think we should also take into account the Apostles at the Last Supper. They didn’t receive the risen and glorified Christ
Well, we don’t really know this. In Matt 17 Peter, James, and John see the transfigured Christ well before His death and resurrection. Who’s to say that isn’t what was received at the last supper?
 
Maybe If we said we consumed his entire being? Body, Blood Soul, and Divinity.
 
Well, we don’t really know this. In Matt 17 Peter, James, and John see the transfigured Christ well before His death and resurrection. Who’s to say that isn’t what was received at the last supper?
Hi DOShea,

Good thoughts. But I believe there is good reason to think the Apostles received Christ’s un-glorified body at the Last Supper, and in this I follow Aquinas. Certainly this is speculative, but it is tremendously consistent. Besides Aquinas there are other instances where this idea can be found - for instance in Pope Paul VI’s Credo of the People of God. If you are interested I can share some of this information with you.

As to the Transfiguration, I don’t think this necessarily implies an identical state with His resurrected, glorified body. Again, one can find this in Aquinas among others. For instance Aquinas quotes St. Bede the Venerable: “In His mortal body He shows forth, not the state of immortality, but clarity like to that of future immortality.”

VC
 
I rejoice, yea, glory, to be called a cannibal by infidels over this issue.

So were the early Christians stigmatized by the pagan Roman population.
 
Maybe If we said we consumed his entire being? Body, Blood Soul, and Divinity.
I don’t think that argument works very well either.

Sorry for the crude analogy.:D…

Say I walk into McDonalds and order a burger. I am a now a “burger eater.” Does ordering fries and a drink make me not a “burger eater”? No, I am a “burger eater” that is eating fries and a drink with my burger. :hmmm:
 
I don’t think that argument works very well either.

Sorry for the crude analogy.:D…

Say I walk into McDonalds and order a burger. I am a now a “burger eater.” Does ordering fries and a drink make me not a “burger eater”? No, I am a “burger eater” that is eating fries and a drink with my burger. :hmmm:
You are a steer eater but you are not eating the whole steer. It just looks like a hamburger :confused:

In the Eucharist, we do as Christ commanded us to eat His flesh and drink His blood. And he showed us how this was to be accomplished at the Last Supper. Unlike cannibalism , we do not eat Jesus’ physical body parts. We chew and drink the “accidents” of bread and wine that remain after the consecration has taken place. But we still literally consume the Body and Blood of Christ even though the appearance of bread and wine remain. I can’t expain it or completely understand how it happens, but I believe because this is what Jesus told us to do.
 
We do not metabolize human tissue, living or dead. The accidents, physical properties of bread and wine remain. We consume Christ ontologically.
 
We do not metabolize human tissue, living or dead. The accidents, physical properties of bread and wine remain. We consume Christ ontologically.
It’s frustrating to read a definition and having to define the words in the defining.😊
 
It is important to remember the physical species (the accidents) of the bread and wine remain. These are part of the sign of the sacrament.

*[l]n the august sacrament of the holy Eucharist, after the consecration of the bread and wine, our Lord Jesus Christ, true God and man, is truly, really, and substantially contained under the species of those sensible things. (Council of Trent, 13.1)The very nature of the bread is a sacramental signFor as bread is completely one, though made of up many grains of wheat, and these, albeit unseen, remain nonetheless present, in such a way that their difference is not apparent since they have been made a perfect whole, so too are we mutually joined to one another and together united with Christ. (St. John Chrysostom, In Epistolam I ad Corinthios Homiliae, 24, 2, quoted by Pope John Paul II, Ecclesia de Eucharistia, #23)*There are many other writings that demonstrate the reasons for the species of bread and wine to remain sense perceptible in the physical realm. For a longer treatment, see the January 2009 and February 2009 issues of This Rock called “Why Wheat” and “Why Grape Wine.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top