Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Evolution has always been promoted by the Nazis and the Communist governments.
And shall we quote that well known Nazi, Adolf Hitler:“My feelings as a Christian points me to my Lord and Savior as a fighter. It points me to the man who once in loneliness, surrounded by a few followers, recognized these Jews for what they were and summoned men to fight against them and who, God’s truth! was greatest not as a sufferer but as a fighter. In boundless love as a Christian and as a man I read through the passage which tells us how the Lord at last rose in His might and seized the scourge to drive out of the Temple the brood of vipers and adders. How terrific was His fight for the world against the Jewish poison. To-day, after two thousand years, with deepest emotion I recognize more profoundly than ever before the fact that it was for this that He had to shed His blood upon the Cross. As a Christian I have no duty to allow myself to be cheated, but I have the duty to be a fighter for truth and justice… And if there is anything which could demonstrate that we are acting rightly it is the distress that daily grows. For as a Christian I have also a duty to my own people.”

-Adolf Hitler, in a speech on 12 April 1922 (Norman H. Baynes, ed. The Speeches of Adolf Hitler, April 1922-August 1939, Vol. 1 of 2, pp. 19-20, Oxford University Press, 1942)
The Nazis used, and misused, many things. They misused Darwinian evolution and the misused Christianity. You argument has just as much an impact against Christianity as it does against evolution - no impact at all.

As for the communists, you need to learn about Lysenko.
Belief and worship of God is an impediment to the total state.
Except in a theocratic totalitarian state, where belief in God is rigidly enforced.

rossum
 
The Nazis scientifically proved that certain types of people were inferior. The United States Supreme Court allowed for the forced sterilization of those deemed unfit and who would contaminate the gene pool. Darwin wrote about not allowing less fit animals to breed.

The [Soviet] State will produce propaganda against religion and all superstitious beliefs among the people. See marxist.com

Peace,
Ed
 
I won’t put words in the mouth of SeekingCatholic but we have been on a different thread before and you being a theologian may be of enormous help here.
The reason it would be better for the Church is polygenism which supports a larger founding population group than two.
For the evolutionist (put crudely but for space I abbreviate the central argument) If Eden falls then what is the nature of original sin? This takes into account the surety that man is and always has been desperately in need of God’s help.
Chuck H
Chuck, briefly, a good place to start is John Haught’s Deeper than Darwin. But many others are working on these questions as well (Zycinski, Hewlett, Peters, etc.).

(1) I don’t believe you have to posit polygenism to argue that the human species evolved as a single group with multiple individuals. Hecd has argued on this forum that in order to avoid a genetic bottleneck the evolving species must have numbered around 10,000. I’m a theologian, not a geneticist, so whether it was really that large I don’t know, but clearly a single pair, an “Adam and Eve,” if you will, would not be sufficient. So “Adam and Eve” must refer to the hominid group evolving into full human consciousness. This is not polygenism in the sense of separately evolved hominid lines merging to form modern humans.

(2) You ask, “If Eden falls then what is the nature of original sin?” I would answer that the very nature of creation is that it is unfinished, in process, “fallen.” Predation and competition for resources are built into the evolving order, as there has been death and destruction since life first appeared on earth 3.5 billion years ago. It could be argued that all of this death and suffering were not sinful in a preconscious, pre-rational environment – after all, there is nothing morally wrong with a lion tearing apart a gazelle.

However, when rationality evolved as a trait carrying survival value, moral consciousness came concomitantly with it. When early humans first realized that there was not always enough food for everyone in the tribe to have a full belly, the moral obligation of sharing – and the deadly consequences of selfishness – become apparent. Sin entered the picture when humans came to realize that when it was possible to do otherwise, individuals sometimes chose to commit actions that led to suffering or death.

So it can be argued that “original sin” is the dawning human awareness that the world is not perfect, and that humans have the potential both to make and to avoid making evil choices. Early Hebrew oral tradition (later written down by scribes) developed a beautiful story of an Edenic garden, a garden of Paradise in which all was perfect, a situation spoiled by a willful decision by an "Adam and an “Eve” to disobey God’s commandment not to eat the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. What a wonderful mytho-poetic framing of the evolution of moral consciousness!

These are my reflections about “sin” and “polygenism” on this Saint Partick’s day.

Prayerfully yours,
Petrus
 
The Nazis scientifically proved that certain types of people were inferior. The United States Supreme Court allowed for the forced sterilization of those deemed unfit and who would contaminate the gene pool. Darwin wrote about not allowing less fit animals to breed.Peace,Ed
Ed,

Let me get this straight: You’re implying that
(1) Darwin the evolutionist wouldn’t allow less fit animals to breed
(2) Some Nazis espoused evolution
(3) Therefore evolution leads to eugenics

How about this:

(1) Catholics are pro-family.
(2) Charles Manson and his family were murderers
(3) Therefore being Catholic can lead to murder

Do I understand you correctly?
 
The Nazis scientifically proved that certain types of people were inferior. The United States Supreme Court allowed for the forced sterilization of those deemed unfit and who would contaminate the gene pool. Darwin wrote about not allowing less fit animals to breed.

The [Soviet] State will produce propaganda against religion and all superstitious beliefs among the people. See marxist.com

Peace,
Ed
Sorry Ed but the Nazis proved nothing. Their eugenics program was based on the unfounded belief of the eugenics movement and Vichow’s application of that flawed movement. The famous family ‘the Jukes’ turned out to be a hoax and was one of several prime reasons for the dumping of the eugenics movement. Further proof came with the advance of DNA and gene alleles that proved the genetic ‘load’ that we all carry and enhanced the exact opposite view that the more outbreeding there was enhanced the “mutt” effect (hybrid vigor) One of the exercises of population genetics in graduate school was doing the calculations of how many generations it would take to completely rid the world of such deleterious genes like sickle cell anemia. (over one thousand generations and there would still be a remnant). Further, research proved that such genetic defects like sickle cell had become widespread in some populations simply because, in their heterozygous form (one sickle cell, one normal Hb gene) they conferred a protection on the carrier. Other than increased frequency of something like Tay Sach’s in Azkenazi jews of Russia where heterozygous people are more likely to marry due to a small closed population and hemophilia in the royal families of Europe there is no proof that any specific group constitutes a genetic liability to the human race

If you are interested check out this web site

eugenicsarchive.org/eugenics/list3.pl
 
Whatever the Nazis did or did not prove, it was used as justification for their murderous policies.

Currently, in the United States, an atheist-secular movement is again attempting to enshrine science as a dictatorship for the origin and implementation of social policy. It will not be interesting to see what soon-to-be-discredited-by-another-expert ideas will be put into motion.

If you don’t believe me, pick an issue that is considered by the experts to be a fact, and then after a few months, another group of experts comes around to say it is not true. Happens all the time.

God bless,
Ed
 
Whatever the Nazis did or did not prove, it was used as justification for their murderous policies.

Currently, in the United States, an atheist-secular movement is again attempting to enshrine science as a dictatorship for the origin and implementation of social policy. It will not be interesting to see what soon-to-be-discredited-by-another-expert ideas will be put into motion.

If you don’t believe me, pick an issue that is considered by the experts to be a fact, and then after a few months, another group of experts comes around to say it is not true. Happens all the time.

God bless,
Ed
Oh Ed if you only knew!

Check out the web sites I direct a possible teacher to in the last post on the bottom of this thread. Beyond Belief is now a yearly meeting of those “intellectuals” and their proposals. I believe you and the actual evidence of those plans and proposals from the very mouths of the “enlightened”. (Do we ever get rid of gnostics?)

I just didn’t want anyone to think the Nazis proved anything other than man can be very stupid and very cruel.

👍
 
I just didn’t want anyone to think the Nazis proved anything other than man can be very stupid and very cruel. 👍
Chuck, you asked questions in #171; I attempted to answer them in #178.

Petrus
 
Don,

You can repeat this all you want but it is still nonsense. Just because someone labels one view as “science” and the other as “religion” doesn’t mean a thing.
Are you actually saying that there’s no essential difference between religion and science? That the two disciplines are not methodologically distinct? That the terms “religion” and “science” are interchangeable?

Blessings,

Don
+T+
 
Chuck, briefly, a good place to start is John Haught’s Deeper than Darwin. But many others are working on these questions as well (Zycinski, Hewlett, Peters, etc.).

(removed for brevity)

These are my reflections about “sin” and “polygenism” on this Saint Partick’s day.

Prayerfully yours,
Petrus
(answers get lost in the threading, just found your post)
Your answer tells several things.
First Your reflections (to me) are good. They deal with a reality that is suggested by the scientific data both on numbers and emerging sense of right and wrong with the gift of our soul.
Second, I take it that the theologians you name above are within the Church and that suggests that the Church is looking at this closely and seeking truth. That is hopeful.

I posed a thread on “was Augustine wrong” based on the idea that St Augustine was a man of his age and therefore only had the science of his age to work with. For my goals that was a great success since I wasn’t out to “get” St Augustine but to get a better handle on him and subsequent Church doctrine. The only questions that remained was in the application of the doctrine such as limbo etc. However I was directed to the RC catechism and see that even the Church allows God to be in charge of the unbaptized infants and backs off of Augustine’s initial premise that they went to hell directly. My God sense is that, God being God, He has a loophole big enough to drive a semi through for unbaptized infants.
 
The Nazis scientifically proved that certain types of people were inferior.
No. Practically all of Nazi “racial science” turned out to be so poorly done that it was effectively worthless. Can’t think of anything that actually was an increase in knowledge.

And evolutionary theory shows that there are no biological human races.

However, at least one creationist leader was still (in the 1990s) writing about the spriritual and intellectual inferiority of blacks. A shameful thing, and astonishingly, no other creationist leader called him on it.

However, the lack of racism on the part of science, and the problem of racism in creationism, is not the issue. What matters is the truth. Let’s get back to the evidence.
 
No. Practically all of Nazi “racial science” turned out to be so poorly done that it was effectively worthless. Can’t think of anything that actually was an increase in knowledge.

And evolutionary theory shows that there are no biological human races.

However, at least one creationist leader was still (in the 1990s) writing about the spriritual and intellectual inferiority of blacks. A shameful thing, and astonishingly, no other creationist leader called him on it.

However, the lack of racism on the part of science, and the problem of racism in creationism, is not the issue. What matters is the truth. Let’s get back to the evidence.
Balance: At least one science leader (James Watson) fell to the same crud this last year but James Watson was a nut anyway. A couple of nucleotides short of a full chromosome

Just an aside, back to the evidence 👍
 
I would not put “random” mutation plus natural selection as the mechanism responsible for all genetic diversity in this category [beyond a resonable doubt], at least not yet, nor would I put gradualism in this category
What evidence do you have that would lend doubt to the idea that random mutation plus natural selection is the driver for all genetic diversity?
 
“Darwinists are zealots!” is an ad hominem argument which also doesn’t address what is at issue.
This attempt to exaggerate what I said is the mark of a certain kind of zealotry. Why try to characterize my argument in the worst way possible, using a phrase that I never said?

Again, I think you have some kind of emotional committment to Darwinism, and that’s not uncommon. I was just commenting on what I’ve seen in the discussion. It’s simple enough to point out that discussions on plumbing techniques do not draw this kinds of heated responses.

But I don’t feel the need to argue that with you because you’ve already said that evolution provides a problem for Catholicism. As such, it’s obvious why there would be strong opposition and strong support for it, at least from those who are opposed to Catholicism.
 
What evidence do you have that would lend doubt to the idea that random mutation plus natural selection is the driver for all genetic diversity?
A number of things. Now obviously, “mutation” means “change” so tautologically mutation must be responsible for all genetic diversity by definition. But it’s the “random” aspect that I want to discuss. While parsimony and Occam’s razor would lead me to dismiss the hypothesis of a directed or front-loaded evolution should the data be consistent with a “random” or completely contingent evolutionary process, there are still some questions about exactly what a completely “random” process could produce. What I mean by “directed” evolution is that God intervenes in the process, keeping it on track, while “front-loaded” evolution means that the initial conditions were set to bring about the intended result, with however no more interventions needed after that. With this in mind, however, almost all criticisms against “random” evolution simply aren’t applicable to directed or front-loaded evolution.

By analogy, we would reject the idea that if all the air in the room present while I am typing this moves to the other half, asphyxiating me, that this would be the result of a “natural” process - it’s too wildly improbable, even though technically speaking no laws at the micro level would be violated. We would also reject the idea from parsimony that God caused all the air in the room to disappear and then miraculously reappear on the other side. He must have either moved it directly to the other side, or arranged the initial conditions of the molecules so they would go there by a seemingly natural process.

First of all, I need to be specific on what is meant by “random”. The term “random” here technically means “random with respect to fitness”, not “random” in the ontological sense, like one might mean it with regard to quantum events. Yet this element of “randomness” is often implied, and an empirical randomness (based only on our lack of knowledge) is conflated with an ontological one. Thus, a “random” process in the technical sense is consistent with directed or front-loaded evolution, since all that would mean is that we can’t predict when the next beneficial mutation will occur. So I’m not arguing against the technical definition but against the implied one.

Now, the evidence. I’m not “dogmatic” on this either way, and could be convinced either way by more evidence.

There appear to be jumps in the fossil record followed by periods of stasis. Now it is possible that this is merely a result of not finding the appropriate fossils since the species didn’t fossilize. However it is also possible that they aren’t there and never were there. To be fair relatively small jumps in DNA space can result in large jumps in phenotype space; however, the “relatively small jumps” might still be larger than what a “random” process could produce.

There also appear to be “jumps” in the DNA evidence. If you look at the ape and monkey and human DNA, the chromosomal pattern between the various groups show big mutations at the chromosomal level (for instance the well-known fusion of chromosome 2 in humans). So there is evidence that “jumps” in the DNA space also occur. Are these random? Well, perhaps, but these appear to be one-off, and irreversible events.

And there is the question of the fitness landspace. With so many mutations being deleterious, even fatal, can you really get from point A to point B by a stochastic process? Perhaps Michael Behe was dead wrong about chloroquine resistance in his “Edge of Evolution” book but the question still remains. There may be an “Edge of Evolution” - a limit as to what a stochastic process can produce. True, the fitness landscape is not static, but changing (which is the response given to this critique) but there may still be too many valleys in the fitness landscape. And saying well it must be possible because here we are is begging the question.

Last, but certainly not least, is information theory. Information theory is IMHO one of the most sound and well-supported disciplines. Where does the information arise to build a given phenotype? Obviously you don’t get information from random noise anymore than you hear Beethoven’s Ninth by tuning the radio to static. Trial and error? Natural selection could form Beethoven’s Ninth if you waited for the right series of intensities from the noise. But is there enough time for this? You aren’t going to get a Shakespeare play by setting monkeys to randomly type on typewriters, to use a shop-worn example. The typical response is that how can you quantify the information in the genome. A good question, and one I don’t have an immediate answer ready for, but how can you quantify the information in this post. Doesn’t mean there isn’t information in it (well I hope so, anyway).

(Note BTW I didn’t include “irreducible complexity”. That one I haven’t found convincing at all.)
 
This attempt to exaggerate what I said is the mark of a certain kind of zealotry. Why try to characterize my argument in the worst way possible, using a phrase that I never said?
Ah, but you did say that (Darwinists are zealots), even if you never used the exact phrase. In fact in the very quote above you are again accusing me of “zealotry”.
Again, I think you have some kind of emotional committment to Darwinism, and that’s not uncommon. I was just commenting on what I’ve seen in the discussion. It’s simple enough to point out that discussions on plumbing techniques do not draw this kinds of heated responses.
But I don’t feel the need to argue that with you because you’ve already said that evolution provides a problem for Catholicism. As such, it’s obvious why there would be strong opposition and strong support for it, at least from those who are opposed to Catholicism.
Of course, but I could just as well argue that you have an emotional antagonism towards Darwinism, because it provides a problem for Catholicism, thus providing a motive for strong opposition to it. This leads nowhere. If Darwinism (or at least common descent) can be shown to be true, at least to a moral certainty using the scientific method, then Catholicism will simply have to deal with it, just like it dealt with heliocentrism.
 
What evidence do you have that would lend doubt to the idea that random mutation plus natural selection is the driver for all genetic diversity?
Too many accidents need to happen. Plus, according to Human Persons Created in the Image of God, without God, those two things alone producing what we see is impossible.

God bless,
Ed
 
Trial and error? Natural selection could form Beethoven’s Ninth if you waited for the right series of intensities from the noise. But is there enough time for this? You aren’t going to get a Shakespeare play by setting monkeys to randomly type on typewriters, to use a shop-worn example. The typical response is that how can you quantify the information in the genome. A good question, and one I don’t have an immediate answer ready for, but how can you quantify the information in this post. Doesn’t mean there isn’t information in it (well I hope so, anyway).
Yes, I find a lot of information in your post. Beyond that, I would characterize your evidence as serious flaws (gaps) in the theory, while you would not. That’s a matter of subjective judgement, but that’s the way I see it. In any case, what you’ve just posted is far more critical of the theory (and far more objective in my view) than anything we’ve seen from the Darwinist-wing on CAF over the past few months.

The monkey typing Shakespeare may be a shop-worn example but I think it resonates with people in a convincing way. Perhaps it is totally wrong, but I think evolutionists make a big mistake in just dismissing that example, or by arguing that monkeys could, indeed, type the full text of Hamlet if given enough time. Because the follow up question is as you posted – would there ever be enough time?

I also do not think that Behe’s search for an edge to evolution is an unreasonable quest. Probability has an edge, beyond which we call “impossible”. I have found the evolutionist defense of certain extremely improbable developments to be unconvincing and more than that, a defense posture that will not even admit that there is a limit to probability.

Your openness to the evidence critical of evolution is refreshing and totally unique among any of the most vocal proponents of evolution here on CAF. It may be that the others simply have been arguing so long that they do not want to admit even the slightest compromise, whereas otherwise they would agree with your concerns.

If that’s true, I think that’s an unfortunate result of too many hours spent in embattled arguments on the internet. Walls are build and positions become entrenched.

But you gave quite a lot of critical ideas for anyone who is curious to pursue. And again, I find that a far more realistic view of this topic.
 
Ah, but you did say that (Darwinists are zealots), even if you never used the exact phrase. In fact in the very quote above you are again accusing me of “zealotry”.
Ok, I hate this kind of argument but I will reply because I’m quite sure you can understand (unlike others here).

My concern was with regards to the arguments given on this particular forum. The evidence is available for you to research. Do I see evidence of zealotry (religious zeal) as applied to the defense of Darwin and his theory? Yes, I do. That’s the point. Again, I don’t see that kind of zealotry in discussions about plumbing.

I wasn’t arguing with you when I raised that point.

I don’t think you would deny that some Darwinists pursue their defense of Darwinism with a kind of religious zeal.

I just happened to notice that all of the promient Darwinists here on CAF argue with that kind of zeal. That’s a comment on the nature of the arguments, not on the persons themselves.

Calling someone a “zealot” is different than saying they argue with religious zeal or fervor. In the one case, it’s name-calling. In the other, it’s a comment about the nature of the argumentation.

I have not called anyone a derogatory name as you made it appear that I did. Additionally, I did not make any generalized statement about “Darwinists”.

Please feel free to have whatever last word you would like but I’m not going to argue any more about this. I’m setting the record for what I said and what I intended.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top