What evidence do you have that would lend doubt to the idea that random mutation plus natural selection is the driver for all genetic diversity?
A number of things. Now obviously, “mutation” means “change” so tautologically mutation must be responsible for all genetic diversity by definition. But it’s the “random” aspect that I want to discuss. While parsimony and Occam’s razor would lead me to dismiss the hypothesis of a directed or front-loaded evolution should the data be consistent with a “random” or completely contingent evolutionary process, there are still some questions about exactly what a completely “random” process could produce. What I mean by “directed” evolution is that God intervenes in the process, keeping it on track, while “front-loaded” evolution means that the initial conditions were set to bring about the intended result, with however no more interventions needed after that. With this in mind, however, almost all criticisms against “random” evolution simply aren’t applicable to directed or front-loaded evolution.
By analogy, we would reject the idea that if all the air in the room present while I am typing this moves to the other half, asphyxiating me, that this would be the result of a “natural” process - it’s too wildly improbable, even though technically speaking no laws at the micro level would be violated. We would also reject the idea from parsimony that God caused all the air in the room to disappear and then miraculously reappear on the other side. He must have either moved it directly to the other side, or arranged the initial conditions of the molecules so they would go there by a seemingly natural process.
First of all, I need to be specific on what is meant by “random”. The term “random” here technically means “random with respect to fitness”, not “random” in the ontological sense, like one might mean it with regard to quantum events. Yet this element of “randomness” is often implied, and an empirical randomness (based only on our lack of knowledge) is conflated with an ontological one. Thus, a “random” process in the technical sense is consistent with directed or front-loaded evolution, since all that would mean is that we can’t predict when the next beneficial mutation will occur. So I’m not arguing against the technical definition but against the implied one.
Now, the evidence. I’m not “dogmatic” on this either way, and could be convinced either way by more evidence.
There appear to be jumps in the fossil record followed by periods of stasis. Now it is possible that this is merely a result of not finding the appropriate fossils since the species didn’t fossilize. However it is also possible that they aren’t there and never were there. To be fair relatively small jumps in DNA space can result in large jumps in phenotype space; however, the “relatively small jumps” might still be larger than what a “random” process could produce.
There also appear to be “jumps” in the DNA evidence. If you look at the ape and monkey and human DNA, the chromosomal pattern between the various groups show big mutations at the chromosomal level (for instance the well-known fusion of chromosome 2 in humans). So there is evidence that “jumps” in the DNA space also occur. Are these random? Well, perhaps, but these appear to be one-off, and irreversible events.
And there is the question of the fitness landspace. With so many mutations being deleterious, even fatal, can you really get from point A to point B by a stochastic process? Perhaps Michael Behe was dead wrong about chloroquine resistance in his “Edge of Evolution” book but the question still remains. There may be an “Edge of Evolution” - a limit as to what a stochastic process can produce. True, the fitness landscape is not static, but changing (which is the response given to this critique) but there may still be too many valleys in the fitness landscape. And saying well it must be possible because here we are is begging the question.
Last, but certainly not least, is information theory. Information theory is IMHO one of the most sound and well-supported disciplines. Where does the information arise to build a given phenotype? Obviously you don’t get information from random noise anymore than you hear Beethoven’s Ninth by tuning the radio to static. Trial and error? Natural selection could form Beethoven’s Ninth if you waited for the right series of intensities from the noise. But is there enough time for this? You aren’t going to get a Shakespeare play by setting monkeys to randomly type on typewriters, to use a shop-worn example. The typical response is that how can you quantify the information in the genome. A good question, and one I don’t have an immediate answer ready for, but how can you quantify the information in this post. Doesn’t mean there isn’t information in it (well I hope so, anyway).
(Note BTW I didn’t include “irreducible complexity”. That one I haven’t found convincing at all.)