Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My answer: Yes!

As an Earth Science teacher, I tell my students that what I teach is the `best theories’, that they will find precious few facts in my entire year long course.

I teach evolution for what it is… a theory' with strong points and weknesses. I also teach creationism, its strong points and weaknesses. I teach BOTH theories from a purely scientific standpoint! Invariably, I am asked What do you believe?’ I tell them that as a Catholic AND a scientist, I find confidence that a Creator was more than able to accomplish the creation of the Universe. As interested sceintists, we can only try to peak behind the curtain, so to speak.

I teach at a public school, and have never been `called to the matt’ on this mode of instruction, though I’m sure I will be someday by some depressed atheist. ;].
If you would give me your name and where you teach I’ll be happy to accomodate you. 🙂

But seriously, we don’t need people pretending there is any validity in creationism. There is absolutely no observation or evidense that contradicts evolution, whereas creationism hasn’t a scintila of evidense to support it. We need to teach our students real methods of knowing, not dogma.

But I’m curious… what do you think are the “strong” points of creationism and the “weak” points of evolution?
 
As for Creationism, there are missing portions of the rock record that shouldn’t be missing, indicating that some time' is missing. There is also evidence that the formerly known theory of catastrophism’ (implying sudden, `creative’ forces) can result in rapid formation of certain geologic formations (mountains, scarpments, etc).

Evolution is weak on alot of fronts, namely the need for missing links. We are finding species of commor form (bidpedal, cannine teeth, dental patterns in herbivores), but there are HUGE gaps missing int he timeline itself. Some of these missing links would require a leap of DNA change verging on a radical mutation', rather than the process of nature naturally selecting. (Some of these changes can be traced’ by evolutionists in the line of horses/hippo’s).

Overall, theories are still just that: theories. God did it… science is trying to peak behind the curtain.
 
As for Creationism, there are missing portions of the rock record that shouldn’t be missing, indicating that some `time’ is missing.
If you’re an earth science teacher, you should be aware of erosion; it’s absolutely impossible for deposition to be going on over the entire Earth at the same time. The sediment has to come from somewhere, and there, the rock that was laid down, is being removed. However, as you should know, there are a few sites in the world where all the layers of the geologic column exist. If the creationists were right, there wouldn’t be any at all.
There is also evidence that the formerly known theory of catastrophism' (implying sudden, creative’ forces) can result in rapid formation of certain geologic formations (mountains, scarpments, etc).
I you had read Lyell, you would know that he and all subsequent geologists were quite aware of catastrophic changes. But he and others debunked the idea that it was all catastrophic.
Evolution is weak on alot of fronts, namely the need for missing links.
Which two major groups, which are said to be linked evolutionarily, lack transitionals? That’s not a rhetorical question. Tell us about these “missing links.”
Overall, theories are still just that: theories.
A science teacher should know that “theory” is as strong as it can get in science. Evolutionary theory, for example, is stronger than the theory of gravitation. We can describe and observe each of them, but we also know why evolution works, while we still aren’t sure why gravity works.
God did it…
True. But you don’t seem very happy about the way He did it.
 
True. But you don’t seem very happy about the way He did it.
Ummm… Im absolutely happy about it. My point is that theories are not fact, they are `best guesses’. My point is that science is an attempt to find out HOW God did it. I don’t care if he did it with bottle caps, gum wrappers and Elmer’s Glue… it’s just interesting to watch as science peels the layers back is all.

I’m not sure what your driving at, or why you think I’m unhappy with anything.
 
As for Creationism, there are missing portions of the rock record that shouldn’t be missing, indicating that some time' is missing. There is also evidence that the formerly known theory of catastrophism’ (implying sudden, creative' forces) can result in rapid formation of certain geologic formations (mountains, escarpments, etc). (edited for spelling) Evolution is weak on a lot of fronts, namely the need for missing links. We are finding species of common form (bidpedal, cannine teeth, dental patterns in herbivores), but there are HUGE gaps missing int he timeline itself. Some of these missing links would require a leap of DNA change verging on a radical mutation’, rather than the process of nature naturally selecting. (Some of these changes can be `traced’ by evolutionists in the line of horses/hippo’s).

Overall, theories are still just that: theories. God did it… science is trying to peak behind the curtain.
I hear the old missing link argument so often but it is a claim that is not substantiated in fact. Just this last year the missing link between walking fish and terrestrial animals was found in the arctic. I would suggest you spend some serious time on Kenneth Millers web site millerandlevine.com/km/ or at least go the Panda’s thumb website below.
pandasthumb.org/archives/2006/01/ken_miller_webc.html Dr. Miller is a Catholic educator and someone who has spent his life studying biology and evolution.
Actually catastrophism is one of Gould and Eldridge’s arguments for punctuated equilibrium for it opens environments for rapid speciation. The splitting off of the Australian continent with its small founder population of about 15 species of marsupials and no placental mammals led to the incredible marsupial radiation with over a thousand marsupial species occupying every possible niche in a geological blink of time.
As for peeking behind the curtain, it is simply a bad analogy. God has a whole library with neon signs and open doors. The “OPEN” card is always hanging in the doorway and all are free to enter and learn.
A Christian scientist (again, no pun intended) should never be afraid to run in and study to his/her heart’s delight. And should never let the hijacking of science by some scientists who’s god was so small he could killed off with a side swat be an excuse not to learn. To say that genetics and evolution are bad because Richard Dawkins uses it to preach atheism is like saying nuclear physics is bad because some scientists used it to create the nuclear weapons. Kenneth Miller looks at evolution and sees the creative process of a mighty and powerful God.

Lastly; The quotes around theory in your previous post are simply objectionable. As a science teacher you should know that a Theory is a hypothesis that has been well tested and continues to withstand the null hypothesis. Whereas Darwin’s evolution hypothesis has continued to withstand the null hypothesis for over a hundred years no matter how sophisticated technical science has become; and whereas the application of Darwin’s hypothesis has led to both intellectual and practical break throughs in science and medicine it is a Theory of the highest order approaching moral certainty. Creationism is still at the starting gate and in fact has fallen to the null hypothesis several times as applied by Behe and others. It is correct and just that ID be ignored since it presents a false picture of reality and does fit the criteria of good science. Its status as a pseudoscience should remain until it has met the criteria experimentally and proven anything.
 
I’m not sure what your driving at, or why you think I’m unhappy with anything.
You seem very uncomfortable with the way He produced the diversity of living things, for example. And the geologic column seems to annoy you.

BTW, I really would like to hear about the missing transitionals between major groups. There still are a few, but so few that I’m guessing you can’t name any.
 
Conspiracy Magazine, is it, Chuck H? Even my accent gives me away, but I tell you, I do not know the man! I have never climbed the Grassy Knoll, and I was not even in Dealey Plaza that dismal day. They told me they found my body in Area 51, with Dawkins’ contracepting fingerprints on my glasses and documents from the Magisterium spilling from my broken briefcase. Unreal city, the liberal parish under the brown fog of a winter dawn, I had not thought evolution had undone so many!
Silly but appropriate

:rotfl:
 
To all who are open to the idea:

I very highly recommend the web site below.

Dr Miller presents a compelling treatise on physical science that is given in the best Aquinan manner. I think that anyone who reads it will have a deeper understanding of how and why evolution is not a “best guess” but an incredible link between science and God that fits His nature and love.

findingdarwinsgod.com/excerpt/index.html
 
Ummm… Im absolutely happy about it. My point is that theories are not fact, they are `best guesses’. My point is that science is an attempt to find out HOW God did it. I don’t care if he did it with bottle caps, gum wrappers and Elmer’s Glue… it’s just interesting to watch as science peels the layers back is all.

I’m not sure what your driving at, or why you think I’m unhappy with anything.
IAmEdmund, as a science teacher, you need to learn about the relationship between facts and theories. Theories do not ever become facts, because facts lie at a lower epistemological level than theories.

Fact: things fall down. The most cogent theory that has been developed to explain this is that the force of gravity attracts objects.
Fact: everything is genetically related. The best theory that has been developed to explain it is descent from common ancestors with modification and differential survival.

Thus, people who refer to evolution as “theory, not fact” have no idea what “theory” means in science. See talkorigins.org/indexcc/CA/CA201.html.

I hope this might help you and your students.

Petrus
 
Silly but appropriate:rotfl:
Chuck H, I posted that because the Integrists on CAF often talk darkly about conspiracies and slippery slopes. Let evolutionary thinking in Catholic schools and pretty soon there will be euthanasia clinics on every street corner. On one thread about inclusive language I mentioned that about two thirds of our parish quietly omit a word, saying “for us and for our salvation” instead of “for us men and for our salvation.” Some woman got apoplectic about this, implying that it’s not a long step from leaving a word out of the Nicene Creed to mainlining heroin and fire-bombing the Vatican. Give me a break!

Petrus
 
Chuck H, I posted that because the Integrists on CAF often talk darkly about conspiracies and slippery slopes. Let evolutionary thinking in Catholic schools and pretty soon there will be euthanasia clinics on every street corner. On one thread about inclusive language I mentioned that about two thirds of our parish quietly omit a word, saying “for us and for our salvation” instead of “for us men and for our salvation.” Some woman got apoplectic about this, implying that it’s not a long step from leaving a word out of the Nicene Creed to mainlining heroin and fire-bombing the Vatican. Give me a break!

Petrus
Oh, I never doubted your intent. I was enjoying the style and humor of the response. If you ever present in Texas let me know where. Your lectures must be far from dry and academic.
 
Oh, I never doubted your intent. I was enjoying the style and humor of the response. If you ever present in Texas let me know where. Your lectures must be far from dry and academic.
Chuck H, I’d love to come talk in Texas. I believe your governor has just appointed a Young Earth Creationist to head up the department of education in the year that biology textbooks are being reviewed.

I love Texas – I have friends and family there (Waxahachie). There is a vibrant Texan community of people who both accept modern science and live deep Catholic Christian lives.

By the way, what do you make of the Chris Comer affair? She was fired from her job as Texas Director of Science for forwarding an email to her staff about an upcoming talk on evolution. The stated reason for her termination was that she was expected to remain neutral on the question of Creationism.

Petrus
 
Oh, I never doubted your intent. I was enjoying the style and humor of the response. If you ever present in Texas let me know where. Your lectures must be far from dry and academic.
Chuck, do you knwo about the Texas Frredom Network (TFN)? They are a useful group: http://www.tfn.org/

Of course, I do run into many atheists in my work; part of my personal apostolate is witnessing my authentic Catholicism to them in our common work of defending sound science. I don’t know that I’ve led any of them to RCIA, but I have pleasantly surprised some of the more arrogant of them by showing them that not all Christians are uneducated knuckle-draggers (as I’ve heard one of them opine).

Petrus
 
He spoke tonight on “The Dance of The Fertile Universe: Did God Do It?” He seriously believes Intelligent Design Creationism is the great heresy of our time.
George Coyne gave a great lecture in 2006. 🙂

**AAAS Dialogue on Science, Ethics, and Religion **
(DoSER) Public Lecture March 27, 2006
The Dance of the Fertile Universe: Chance and Destiny Embrace
George V. Coyne, S.J. Director, The Vatican Observatory

SUMMARY
**When talking about evolution in a very broad sense there is a classical debate about chance and necessity. “According to Modern Science,” declared George V. Coyne, Jesuit and director of the Vatican Observatory, “the debate is mistaken.” What is missing in the debate, he argued in his lecture on March 27, 2006 presented in the series sponsored by the AAAS Dialogue on Science, Ethics, and Religion, is “the fertility of the universe.” The evolution of the universe is propelled by fertility as well as chance and necessity, he proposed.

If the universe evolved only by chance, then there would be no place for a God of purpose. If the universe evolved only by necessity, this might tend to lead to an affirmation of God. But if it
evolves due to both, then, he said, “we are caught in between.” Coyne used this point to emphasize that in the debate between materialism and non-materialism or atheism and theism,
“science is completely neutral.” This neutrality is a consequence of both the inherent limitations of the scientific method and the profound depth of human ignorance about the universe, even in
the face of all the knowledge that has been gained.

To begin defining what he meant by “the fertility of the universe” Coyne offered the following numerical illustrations:

• There are about 30,000 human genes, but only about 2010 vary among human beings.
• Thus the genetic variance between human beings is 22010 or 10605 .
• Each individual human can produce 10605 different eggs or sperm.
• In the visible universe there are 1076 atoms. What sense does it make to compare 10605 and 1076 ?

It is not clear, but it is a marvel, he suggested, that a universe with this number of atoms has produced such a degree of human fertility. Of course, one of the difficulties with trying to come to terms with large numbers e.g., 10605, a 1with six hundred and five 0s following it, is that they are so far from ordinary human experience. It is helpful to use a metaphor from a more common experience of time to relate astronomical time. So, for example, if the whole 13.7 billion year history of the universe were stretched over only one Earth year, significant events in evolution would be dated as follows:

Date Event*
January 1 - -Big Bang
February 7 - -Birth of the Milky Way
August 14 - -Birth of the Earth
September 4 - -First appearance of life on Earth
December 15 - -The “Cambrian explosion”
December 25 - -Dinosaurs appear
December 30 - -Dinosaurs become extinct

The last day of the year is a very rich one.
*
December 31 Event*
7:00:00 pm - - First hominids
11:58:00 pm - - First humans
11:59:30 pm - - Age of Agriculture
11:59:47 pm - - Building of the Pyramids
11:59:58 pm - - Jesus is born
11:59:59 pm - - Galileo is born
12:00:00 Midnight Today

If you look at cosmic history this way, all of modern science happened “in the last second.” Coyne concluded, “So, if there are a few gaps in our knowledge [of how the universe works] – if there is some ignorance – give us more time; we’ve only had one second.” [please read and view the graphics presented in his lecture.] For him religious faith “is a free gratuitous gift and it is a personal relationship not just a rational relationship. “God,” he declared, “is not a God of explanation but a God of love.” It is only after the “moment of personal relationship” that the question of the meaning of “God” arises, and how our understanding of the universe bears on this question. . . .Coyne closed his talk by turning to the question: “If I believe in God, what does this sort of fertile universe say about God?” First, he stated, it does not prove that God exists. This, in his view, is the false premise that underlies the intelligent design movement (ID). The universe seems to exhibit an intrinsic destiny in the process of volutionary complexification through natural processes. But recognizing this does not require that a person believe in God nor does it lead to belief in God. . . .*
aaas.org/spp/dser/02_Events/Lectures/2006/02_Lecture_2006_0327.pdf
http://www.aaas.org/spp/dser/02_Events/Lectures/2006/02_Lecture_2006_0327.pdf

Father Coyne, I love you! 😃 May you have a very Happy Easter:thumbsup:
 
AAAS Presidential Address, St. Louis, 16 February, 2006
GRAND CHALLENGES and GREAT OPPORTUNITIES in SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY, and PUBLIC POLICY
Gilbert S. Omenn
An excerpt from the document:

"Ever since Darwin’s original writings, the intersection of various religious beliefs about the origins of the world and origins of humans with observations of natural selection for reproductive advantage has stimulated speculation, debate, and periods of intense conflict. The literature on this subject is rich and fascinating, beginning with Darwin’s own observations. For examples, **Richard Dawkins has described the “illusion of design”****. Ursula Goodenough, our Saturday evening plenary speaker, has written of the “Sacred Depths of Nature” and “the epic of evolution”. **. And Randolph Nesse and George Williams have addressed “Why Do We Get Sick?” from the viewpoint of evolutionary biology.

"Some of our problems arise from misunderstandings about specific words. In science the term “theory” carries connotations of elegance and a strong evidentiary basis. The “theory” of evolution is ranked together with the theory of gravitation. To most laymen, “theory” is more or less equivalent to “speculation”. Thus, we should recognize by now that it is a diversionary battle to explain the meaning of “theory” when we should be explaining the meaning of “evolution” and of natural selection. Darwin used the phrase “descent with modification”, but the sound-bite of “survival of the fittest” has long conjured up images unrelated to reproductive fitness. Finally, the terms “random” and “chance” irritate ordinary people and religiously observant scientists who celebrate the remarkable designs in nature, however they arose. The results of natural selection are not random; it is the substrate of mutations which may have arisen in random fashion, though even here we would argue that not all mutations are equally likely at the molecular level. The good news is that we are successfully turning the attacks on the teaching of evolution to our advantage, helping many more people, including scientists, to learn more about evolution and, more broadly, learning more about scientific ways of thinking. . .

"Evolution is, simply put, the most important single concept in learning about biology. And evolution is essential to understanding geology and astronomy.

"Evolution is an ongoing process, highlighted this year as the 2005 Breakthrough of the Year by SCIENCE magazine [SLIDE 45], in recognition of several scientific publications that show natural selection in action. In our own academic community of Ann Arbor and the adjacent blue-collar city of Ypsilanti, Michigan, this year’s combined “Community Reads” book selection is “The Beak of the Finch” by Jonathan Weiner [SLIDE 46]. The book has engaged thousands of local people in seminars and courses on the theme of “Revolutions in Science: the people, theories, explanations and discoveries that challenged our thinking and changed the world”. Weiner describes the work of Rosemary and Peter Grant, modern evolutionists painstakingly studying 13 species of Darwin’s finches for 33 years now on the island of Daphne Major in the Galapagos. They are standing on the shoulders of the giant who was Darwin. They are doing what Darwin could not do—going back to the Galapagos year after year, seeing there what Darwin did not imagine could be seen at all in relatively brief periods of time. As emphasized by Weiner, On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life does not document the origin of a single species, or a single case of natural selection. Darwin marshaled an enormous amount of evidence that evolution has occurred, but he never saw it happen. He was in the Galapagos (for just 5 weeks) only once during his 5-year Voyage of the Beagle. He described natural selection as “silently and insensibly working, whenever and wherever opportunity offers…We see nothing of these slow changes in progress…we see only that the forms for life are now different from what they formerly were.” Evolutionists are now observing evolution of species real time on isolated island laboratories around the globe. Yet the Galapagos archipelago remains paradise for evolutionists, where life is evolving as fast as the volcanoes responsible for these two dozen islands.

"The power of direct observation and the testing of hypotheses drive us to challenge unexpected findings until they cannot be explained away. Such logical thinking is the opposite of learning a catechism. The pressure on teachers to ignore evolution or lump it together together with some particular religious view of “creation science” or its reincarcation as “intelligent design” first neglects the beliefs and views of many other religions and cultures and then usurps the already-limited time to interest children and the families in the math and science essential to their being prepared for good jobs and effective citizenry in the knowledge-based, technological economy of this new century. The AAAS Board, I am proud to say, has taken a strong stand denouncing anti-science legislation and mixing of religion and science in the science classroom.

“On the matter of the teaching of evolution in the schools, we now have a comprehensive verdict from Judge John E. Jones III of the U.S. District Court in Pennsylvania in the case of Kitzmiller et al v Dover School District [SLIDE 47]. He made clear that “intelligent design” is a direct descendant of “creation science” and should have no standing in a science classroom. I strongly share that view. I would add that many scientists are themselves religious and seem to compartmentalize their professional activities and their religious beliefs.”
aaas.org/news/releases/2006/pdf/0217omenn.pdf
http://www.aaas.org/news/releases/2006/pdf/0217omenn.pdf
 
George Coyne gave a great lecture in 2006. 🙂AAAS Dialogue on Science, Ethics, and Religion **
(DoSER) Public Lecture March 27, 2006
The Dance of the Fertile Universe: Chance and Destiny Embrace**George V. Coyne, S.J. Director, The Vatican Observatory…
Father Coyne, I love you! 😃 May you have a very Happy Easter:thumbsup:
Wildleafblower, if you ever get a chance to hear George Coyne, you will find him a delightful speaker – brilliant, witty, earnest, and humble. Retired from the Vatican, he now works in Arizona at Kitt Peak Observatory.

Petrus
 
I hear the old missing link argument so often but it is a claim that is not substantiated in fact. Just this last year the missing link between walking fish and terrestrial animals was found in the arctic. I would suggest you spend some serious time on Kenneth Millers web site millerandlevine.com/km/ or at least go the Panda’s thumb website below.
pandasthumb.org/archives/2006/01/ken_miller_webc.html Dr. Miller is a Catholic educator and someone who has spent his life studying biology and evolution.
Actually catastrophism is one of Gould and Eldridge’s arguments for punctuated equilibrium for it opens environments for rapid speciation. The splitting off of the Australian continent with its small founder population of about 15 species of marsupials and no placental mammals led to the incredible marsupial radiation with over a thousand marsupial species occupying every possible niche in a geological blink of time.
As for peeking behind the curtain, it is simply a bad analogy. God has a whole library with neon signs and open doors. The “OPEN” card is always hanging in the doorway and all are free to enter and learn.
A Christian scientist (again, no pun intended) should never be afraid to run in and study to his/her heart’s delight. And should never let the hijacking of science by some scientists who’s god was so small he could killed off with a side swat be an excuse not to learn. To say that genetics and evolution are bad because Richard Dawkins uses it to preach atheism is like saying nuclear physics is bad because some scientists used it to create the nuclear weapons. Kenneth Miller looks at evolution and sees the creative process of a mighty and powerful God.

Lastly; The quotes around theory in your previous post are simply objectionable. As a science teacher you should know that a Theory is a hypothesis that has been well tested and continues to withstand the null hypothesis. Whereas Darwin’s evolution hypothesis has continued to withstand the null hypothesis for over a hundred years no matter how sophisticated technical science has become; and whereas the application of Darwin’s hypothesis has led to both intellectual and practical break throughs in science and medicine it is a Theory of the highest order approaching moral certainty. Creationism is still at the starting gate and in fact has fallen to the null hypothesis several times as applied by Behe and others. It is correct and just that ID be ignored since it presents a false picture of reality and does fit the criteria of good science. Its status as a pseudoscience should remain until it has met the criteria experimentally and proven anything.
Dude… chill.😊

I feel like I’m under fire for stating how I see this whole argument. Yay science!.. yay faith! Yay us!

God created… Science tries to find out how. Im not sure how this offends you so much that it prompts the above response. LOL
 
You seem very uncomfortable with the way He produced the diversity of living things, for example. And the geologic column seems to annoy you.

BTW, I really would like to hear about the missing transitionals between major groups. There still are a few, but so few that I’m guessing you can’t name any.
You seem to be under the delusion I am against evolution!? … maybe? I’m not sure. However, my point was and still is: It is a theory with weaknesses and strengths like ANY other theory.

The geologic column doesnt annoy me. (However, schist does get my nerves from time to time. ((thats a joke!))

I can name alot of these missing transitionals'. I do take umbrage at your trolling’ to get me to do so, as though I am bereft of any evidences.

Smile… God made it all, and still loves you. ;]

👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top