Evolution and Creation: What to Teach Students?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lucille5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A warning…

There are some self professing Catholics that in the questioning of the Churches Current position on evolution are bordering on schism…

We are free to believe with respect to this matter as long as that belief does not contradict any other official teaching…

However, we are not free to question the Teaching Authorities motives…

If the teaching authority is subject to it’s individuals motives, then this would also mean that it is guided less by the HS and more on popularity and flawed men…

A heretical view for a Catholic…

Saying that the Teaching authority is making no statements for Politically Correct reasons does just that…

And since when is Pope B16 politically correct over truth

Just a warning…

If god said do it and it it was created… well, thats obviously is creationism
If God used Evolution as a tool to create… it is still creationism because God is still the one that Created it…

In Christ
 
Thank you, Camron. I agree with you in principle, and up to a point. But my work involves me (inter alia) in both (1) helping children toward careers in science, if they are so gifted and inclined, and (2) helping preserve the religious faith of Catholic sand non-Catholics alike When YECs shove a scientifically ignorant doctrine down kids throats and represent it as consistent with Christianity – or more specifically with Catholicism (as the Kolbe Center does) – and then when kids mature in scientific understanding and draw the false conclusion that Christianity is nonsense fit only for simpletons, that I regard as a serious problem.

Young Earth Creationism not only deprives children of potential careers in science, and deprives the scientific world of authentic Christian voices to speak out against abuses of science and technology, but it can lead to utterly unnecessary crises of faith and falling away from religious belief. For these reasons I regard YEC as a serious evil in society, and the anti-scientific work of the Kolbe Center and other YEC organizations as heinous, if not deliberately diabolical.

Petrus
Ok, that seems to be going a tad bit overboard Petrus.

The Church would not allow people the option to believe in these things (if they choose to) if indeed they were downright evil teachings. In fact, the Church would actively engage them to recant what they are claiming.

I too think that YEC is seriously flawed. I also accept theistic evolution as the method in which God created humanity. I would also say the YEC movement is terribly naïve to the point that they are hindering the progress of science within the biological field for example. But I wouldn’t resort to demonizing them like you just did. 😦

I guess we’ll have to agree on God allowing evolution to create for Him but disagree on the “true nature” of the people who are actively engaged in using extremely poor science when trying in vain to dispute theistic evolution. :tiphat:
 
Ok, that seems to be going a tad bit overboard Petrus. t:
Not if you care about truth, the well-being of children, and the credible voice of Catholics continuing to be involved in science. Just as pornography distorts the truth about human sexuality, YEC distorts the truth about science. I would be very dismayed if Catholics left participation in geology, biology, and physics in droves because their commitment to an inane Young Earth position forced a false choice between science and religious belief.

Thankfully, there are great spokespersons for a middle way, such as Ken Miller, Francisco Ayala, Martinez Hewlett, Ted Peters, Robert Russell, George Coyne, and many others. Visit the website of the International Society for Science and Religion – http://www.issr.org.uk/.
 

Quote:
Evolution is contrary to what the Bible says.
The Barbarian said:
You are adding doctrines to the Bible, if you believe that. Pope Benedict has said that evolution is virtually certain. Do you think the Pope doesn’t understand Scripture?​

Question: Who is adding doctrines? Evolution is not what is being mentioned in the bible. The bible clearly states that God created the world and everything in it in a certain period of time, then rested. If we were to take the bible literally, then it would be contrary to the big bang & evolution.

How in the world can we use the bible creation story to back up the current scientific understanding that the universe is 13.7 billion years old, and the earth is 4.5 billion years old? It’s not in there.

While i have attempted in the past to make a case for the literal belief in the creation story, in all honestly i can’t do that. So, yes i believe there is a contradiction with the bible and current scientific understanding.

Either the story is somehow strangely true, or it isn’t, and science is now gradually revealing to us the real truth… whatever that turns out to be.

Do you feel confident taking a story that has so many literal problems, and seemingly ridiculous far-fetched beliefs, then using some specific literal lines from it to back up our religious beliefs, and claiming truth? (Just curious)

I guess my problem with it is simply that it’s either literally true, (which i don’t believe) or it’s not, so how can we pick and choose lines from such a problematic story and find truth?
 
Not if you care about truth, the well-being of children, and the credible voice of Catholics continuing to be involved in science. Just as pornography distorts the truth about human sexuality, YEC distorts the truth about science. I would be very dismayed if Catholics left participation in geology, biology, and physics in droves because their commitment to an inane Young Earth position forced a false choice between science and religious belief.
Now you’re comparing YEC to pornography? 🤷

Excuse me, but yes I most certainly do care about truth, the well-being of children, and the credible voice of Catholics continuing to be involved in science.

I just find your claim to be unwarranted.

Think about it.

So the Catholic Church freely allows people (without any strong warning within the Catechism) to believe in an idea that essentially appeals to their base or sensual desires of the Bible, a view which is apparently contrary to the established moral code of the Catholic Church?

Be reasonable and think about what you’re claiming here.

If you don’t like YEC, fine. Just to be clear, I too think they’re doing some serious damage to various scientific establishments, notably the biological sciences. But I don’t think they’re evil.

Naïve? Yes.

Evil. No.
 
So the Catholic Church freely allows people (without any strong warning within the Catechism) to believe in an idea that essentially appeals to their base or sensual desires of the Bible, a view which is apparently contrary to the established moral code of the Catholic Church?
Can you please explain the above? Sensual desires? Moral code?
 
How in the world can we use the bible creation story to back up the current scientific understanding that the universe is 13.7 billion years old, and the earth is 4.5 billion years old? It’s not in there.

Either the story is somehow strangely true, or it isn’t, and science is now gradually revealing to us the real truth… whatever that turns out to be./QUOTE]

(1) We can’t use the creation story to back up the modern view of the cosmos, because Genesis was not intended to do this.

(2) A black-and-white approach to Genesis 1-11 is not helpful. Truth lies on many levels. There are key moral and theological truths in Genesis, and it serves important liturgical purposes. Genesis can be true as story without being true as science.
 
It has been my experience that many debates are more easily resolved if there is an agreed upon definition of terms. Indeed, some philosophers believed that almost all debates were over semantics.

That said, as a first-time-reader as well as –poster, it seems to me that much of this discussion revolves around a definition of terms.

It seems each of us has a different definition of ‘‘proof’’, ‘‘Catholic’’, and ‘‘science’’, not to mention ‘‘evolution’’.

To some, it seems, a literal reading of the bible is most comforting. To others, as long as they can rationalize one interpretation of each biblical passage, then the literal meaning is almost inconsequential.

To some the only Catholics are the ones who believe as the good nuns taught them. To others, catholic (lower case) has a broader, less exclusive connotation. To some Catholic merely requires agreement with official dogma; to others it requires at least one and maybe more levels of authority being accepted.

To some ‘‘evolution’’ is any adaptive change in genetics. To others evolution connotes major leaps, such as from germ to insect, from insect to mammal, from Australopithecus to Homo sapiens.

But IMO the most confusing and, therefore, the most controversial term to be defined is ‘‘proof’’.

I am no expert — trust me — but to some, a proof can be only classic Aristotelian syllogisms. To others, deduction is a proof. To many — including many empirical scientists — the reproducibility of induction is a proof. Wasn’t this why Des Cartes took such comfort in his cogito ergo sum?

To most empiricists a scientific theory is just a theory until it has been replicated enough to induce a rule that ‘‘seems’’ to have been universally applied; i.e. there have been no exceptions observed. To most traditional Christians, ‘‘proof’’ requires not merely the failure to find ‘‘exceptions’’ but that there be no possible ‘‘exceptions’’. Both speak of ‘‘proofs’’ but the connotation is very different.

Hence we have discussions in which many clamor there has been ‘’proof’’ while an equal number clamor that there has been no ‘‘proof’’ at all.

We are like the blind men and the elephant. Each interprets using his or her unique experience or ‘’definitions’’.

I fear that for many Faith in their God requires absolutes. If so, then loss of one absolute belief might endanger all their absolute beliefs. There is nothing wrong with that, but it is the classic slippery-slope that leads to crises of Faith and, sadly for many, loss of Faith.

The Christian bible explains that God does not reason as man reasons. But we still try to apply our own way of thinking. God has different priorities, different criteria. (See C S Lewis’ The Screwtape Letters).

To many of us humans, perceived attacks on (or insults to) ourselves justify reciprocating in kind, which then might spiral out of control. The sad history of man.

So, if I might suggest, perhaps more light and less heat might be generated if each of us defined the terms that we take for granted.
 
It has been my experience that many debates are more easily resolved if there is an agreed upon definition of terms. Indeed, some philosophers believed that almost all debates were over semantics.

That said, as a first-time-reader as well as –poster, it seems to me that much of this discussion revolves around a definition of terms. .
Nice first post, bnapgh! You are right – definition is so important, as is knowing what words carry fearsome connotations. One woman with whom I’ve worked used to run into problems in public school with the “E” word, so she stopped using it, and instead spoke of “descent from common ancestry, with modification amplified by natural selection.” Some of the same kids (and their parents) – who had been freaked out by the very word “evolution” – said that they could easily live with her definition, which carefully avoided using the dread “:E” word. She has never had problems teaching evolutionary biology since making this semantic shift.

Petrus
 
Can you please explain the above? Sensual desires? Moral code?
I found a definition of pornography and modified it to fit your claim against YEC. In short, you appear to be saying that the Catholic Church tolerates the “pornographic side” of creationism, which is apparently YEC according to your definition.
40.png
drpmjhess:
Just as pornography distorts the truth about human sexuality, YEC distorts the truth about science.
You can draw your own analogies according to your own definitions you provided.

I’m just saying that the Catholic Church would simply not tolerate YEC if it were as evil as you claim, especially in the analogy that you gave.

The usage of pornography is a mortal sin.

Believing the entire universe was created 6,000 years ago is not.

I think that many who are in a higher authority in the Vatican simply understand that theistic evolution is not an easy subject for most believers to accept, so they allow the YEC belief as people gradually adjust to the alternative (which, based on the internet readings I do, could still take some time for many in the Church).

Anyway, what do I care, since I’m not a YEC.

But I thought I would at least attempt to set the matter straight. Just because someone is naive to science does not mean they are evil. I think that’s really unfair what you said before and ultimately distances those who need to hear about theistic evolution away from us.

I know that many YEC do think that we “theistic evolutionists” are evil because we believe that God allowed evolution to create via the contingency of nature itself for Him. But they’re misguided in their convictions because they are too busy listening to the atheists saying that God and evolution are not compatible.

If we are indeed claiming to know better than them, then we should also know better than to fall into the error of making the same sort of claims against them. It doesn’t help anything.
 
One woman with whom I’ve worked used to run into problems in public school with the “E” word, so she stopped using it, and instead spoke of “descent from common ancestry, with modification amplified by natural selection.”
Darwin preferred “descent with modification” which pretty well sums up his theory. Your friend’s version nicely sums up modern evolutionary theory.

I do that myself. I teach in a theologically conservative area, and yes, that is more sensitive than using the “E” word. I’ve had a few people say that it was dishonest; by bypassing the term, people learn about it and accept what it says, before they realize it’s something “they aren’t supposed to” accept.

That seems wrong to me.
 
What should a Catholic biology teach in a Catholic high school about creation and evolution?
The truth. 🙂

Seriously, they should teach what we know about evolution.

Creation is a topic for their religion class.
 
(Barbarian observes that it is adding one’s own doctrines, if one asserts that Scripture or the magesterium is not compatible with evolution)

(Question: Who is adding doctrines?)

Anyone who does that.
Evolution is not what is being mentioned in the bible.
Neither are protons. That’s not what the Bible is for. God gave us intelligence and curiosity to find out the rest. Use your talents; they are God-given.
The bible clearly states that God created the world and everything in it in a certain period of time, then rested.
All of us agree on that. The only difference between creationists and me is that I also accept the way He did it.
If we were to take the bible literally, then it would be contrary to the big bang & evolution.
If we were to take the Bible literally or not, it refutes the “life ex nihilo” claims of YE creationism, since it says that the earth brought forth living things.
How in the world can we use the bible creation story to back up the current scientific understanding that the universe is 13.7 billion years old, and the earth is 4.5 billion years old?
No more than we can use the Bible idea of beating swords into plowshares to explain the welding of iron crystals with carbon under heat and pressure. It’s still true, but that’s not what the Bible is about.
While i have attempted in the past to make a case for the literal belief in the creation story, in all honestly i can’t do that. So, yes i believe there is a contradiction with the bible and current scientific understanding.
I"m sorry that you do. If we think Scripture and science are incompatible, it is because we have misunderstood one or both of them.
Either the story is somehow strangely true, or it isn’t, and science is now gradually revealing to us the real truth… whatever that turns out to be.
It’s true. And science isn’t a problem.
Do you feel confident taking a story that has so many literal problems, and seemingly ridiculous far-fetched beliefs, then using some specific literal lines from it to back up our religious beliefs, and claiming truth? (Just curious)
I really don’t see any inconsistencies.
I guess my problem with it is simply that it’s either literally true, (which i don’t believe) or it’s not, so how can we pick and choose lines from such a problematic story and find truth?
The usual idea is that we accept it as literal, unless there is a reason not to. For example, nothing in science denies that there was a real pair of humans from which all the rest of us descended.

Does any of this help?
 
If we were to take the Bible literally or not, it refutes the “life ex nihilo” claims of YE creationism, since it says that the earth brought forth living things.
I understand and basically agree with your approach but God can create “life ex nihilo” and still have it then evolve. So the Bible does not, to use your word, ‘‘refute’’ “life ex nihilo” per se.

Again, I, for one, would find it helpful for understanding each other if we each used the terms ‘‘literally’’ or ‘‘figuratively’’ when discussing what the Bible ‘‘says’’.

I am not a literalist, but I am comfortable being a literalist apologist.

IMO the Bible does not ‘‘literally’’ say that the six days of creation are sequential. I pay a handyman who works only on Saturdays for six days of work that take a couple months to complete.

God’s ‘‘rest’’ on His seventh day was probably a ‘‘cessation’’ not a ‘‘respite’’ as IMO the all-power God should not need R&R.
 
“It is a strange aspect of science in the twentieth century that while physics has had to submit to the indignity of a principle of uncertainty and physicists have become accustomed to such strange entities as matter-waves and virtual particles, many of their colleagues down the corridor in biology seem not to have noticed the revolution of quantum electrodynamics. As far as many biologists are concerned, matter is made of billiard balls which collide with Newtonian certainty, and they carry on building molecular models out of coloured ping-pong balls.”
Richard Milton

It seems Edmund is right. The Uncertainty principle shows that while Descent through change is statistically trustworthy (good science) It can never know everything about organic life since the very molecule it studies is fully subject to the principle. The above statement by Milton aptly sums up the problem with materialistic evolutionists and properly puts us in our place. That does not mean that evolution is not a good science. The trustworthiness through statistical accuracy allows it to be a generally predictive science since it is one that learns from studying history (past change) and behavior of the genetic complex now. Surprisingly, the Uncertainty principle also allows us to see the “free will” bestowed by God, not only on the cosmos, but also on us.
It is not only science but has some positive theological implications as well although those are not new implications but reinforcements of theology known for a long long time. The ancient “gods” of nature were restrictive while God is shown to be freeing us from pagan enslavement.

Funny how, if you look, creation works with the Creator to reveal truth.

Generally I would rank Kenneth Miller’s Finding Darwin’s God up there with CS Lewis, G K Chesterton and a slew of other excellent Christian apologists and thinkers.
 
The truth. 🙂

Seriously, they should teach what we know about evolution.

Creation is a topic for their religion class.
While I don’t see any real problem with your answer; I would suggest that the biology teacher and the catechist be in the same ball park. Imagine a situation where one is teaching evolution and the other is teaching literal creationism using line by line Genesis. (I doubt if this situation would arise in the typical catholic school and give it only as an absurd situation)
Both classes will get questions roughly the same so it would pay for both teachers to have an understanding of where the other is coming from
 
Chuck, the existence of God can of course never be proven, and the classic proofs have undergone remarkable mutations. My doctoral dissertation was on the transformation during the Scientific Revolution of the ten most popular arguments for God’s existence.

That being said, I do find the Cosmological or First Cause argument to be the least uncompelling one. The ontological argument is, I believe, ultimately vacuous; the “prime mover” is dead in the post-Newtonian water; and the teleological proof was forever changed after the nineteenth century, even with the incorporation of so-called anthropic fine-tuning of constants.

But the First Cause argument will perdure no matter what Dawkins of Hitchens or Harris Sagan say about the universe being all that ever was or is or will be. Why is there something rather than nothing? Why is there a universe at all? Why a universe where complexity arises out of quarks, where self-consciousness and soulishness evolve, where religion and spirituality and pure altruism emerge from mere energy?

Of course, this argument does not lead us ineluctably to an anthropocentric universe – the History Channel’s recent and sobering “Life After People” puts smug anthropocentrism in stark biological perspective – but it certainly leads to questions that will be forever open to minds open to considering them.

Prayerfully yours,
Petrus
The Cosmological or First Cause argument is a “best fit” model due to its ability to work within the “free will” theological doctrine. Once having created a universe from nothing, God sets it free to be what it can and at the same time sets forth the same contract for any creature He deems ready for sharing His eternal life with. Once set free, it should be reassuring to us to know that the cosmos returns the favor bestowed on it by God by giving rise to a creature that is capable of that intimate relationship. It is not compelled to, but in its freewill returns to God with its offering which God accepts. That physical creation becomes a perfect allegory for how each individual is set free and accepts God without reservation as the source of life or rejects God and creates his/her own hell. Nature then becomes the first of creation to recognize the Creator and His goals and serves as a real physical model for us all.
What is both humbling and a relief at the same time is to realize that natural shape has little to do with the gift of the soul. That we have hair (or lack thereof), walk upright and have an opposable thumb cannot be absolutely assumed for a certainty. All biological references aside, humans could have been from any branch of the tree of life and still have received the gift of the soul. ( Oh am I going to be lambasted for this statement). Recognizing this is humbling because it puts the gift of the soul purely in the hands of God and takes away any natural hubris of homo sapiens that we just had to get the soul since we are the best species.

Thanks, looked up perdure and ineluctably.A veritable cornucopia of obscure English words (at least in Texas)
 
I understand and basically agree with your approach but God can create “life ex nihilo” and still have it then evolve.
Could, but that’s not how Scripture describes it. He says that the earth brought forth living things. Not everything created was created ex nihilo. Life is one of those things.
So the Bible does not, to use your word, ‘‘refute’’ “life ex nihilo” per se.
If “ex nihilo” means “from nothing,” it does. Live was not created from nothing, according to Genesis.
Again, I, for one, would find it helpful for understanding each other if we each used the terms ‘‘literally’’ or ‘‘figuratively’’ when discussing what the Bible ‘‘says’’.
I don’t see any way even a figurative reading of “let the earth bring forth” can mean an ex nihilo creation. How would you see it so?
IMO the Bible does not ‘‘literally’’ say that the six days of creation are sequential. I pay a handyman who works only on Saturdays for six days of work that take a couple months to complete.
St. Augustine thought they were merely descriptions of categories of creation, after a long period of trying to justify them as literal days.
God’s ‘‘rest’’ on His seventh day was probably a ‘‘cessation’’ not a ‘‘respite’’ as IMO the all-power God should not need R&R.
In the strict sense, “rest” means “not active.” So that makes sense. It’s rather difficult to see how an almighty spirit would need to rest.
 
While I don’t see any real problem with your answer; I would suggest that the biology teacher and the catechist be in the same ball park. Imagine a situation where one is teaching evolution and the other is teaching literal creationism using line by line Genesis. (I doubt if this situation would arise in the typical catholic school and give it only as an absurd situation)
Both classes will get questions roughly the same so it would pay for both teachers to have an understanding of where the other is coming from
The religion teacher should teach what the Catholic Church teaches about creation. Since that doesn’t contradict the science of evolution, there shouldn’t be a problem.

If a religion teacher is teaching a literal translation of Gensis, the department head needs to get involved.
 
Both classes will get questions roughly the same so it would pay for both teachers to have an understanding of where the other is coming from
Some years ago, I was teaching where the history teacher was telling students that people warned Columbus that he would fall off the edge of the Earth if he sailed too far west.

At the same time, I was teaching that Eratosthenes had accurately measured the circumference of the Earth around 500 BC, and that the Romans and medieval Europeans were well aware that the world was round.

The history teacher was not pleased, until we had a talk, and he learned that what he had learned about Columbus was not correct.

Incidentally, the source of this error seems to be a book by Washington Irving, The Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top