Ex Catholic in need of guidence

  • Thread starter Thread starter mtjoycol
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sometimes I wonder how many of the posters on here would act this way if they were face to face and not on the other side of the internet.
There’s a great comic about what happens when people debate anonymously over the internet, but it’s probably not appropriate here 😛

I most definitely appreciate the respectful tone you maintain even when you greatly disagree with someone.
 
You may marvel at my life story. I was a cradle Catholic and became a very devout Catholic, learning what I could whenever I could.

As I grew older I did everything I could to be a good Catholic. I went to mass every Sunday and observed all the holy days of obligation. I went to Eucharistic adoration when I could and I went to confession at least once per month. I married a woman who wanted to become Catholic with me. At the time we were married in the church, she was going through RCIA as was I. My faith in the church had been waning for quite some time prior to all of this so I thought that the classes would help me to revive as well as my new wife to learn the faith. The deeper we got, the more questions I had and the more doubt set in. My wife was equally baffled. We had hours of discussions with our priest and even our bishop. Ultimately my wife became very ill and we left the church together. In the weeks to come, we met our local Anglican parish priest and got ot know him and the parish. He bcame the priest who baptized my wife and eventually was confirmed by our Diocesan bishop. I truly found our Lord there and it was like he was saying, “what took you so long?”. My wife and I and our son haven been devout members of the Anglican faith ever since. I know God and his saving grace like I have never known before. To see my son born and to see him now carrying the cross into Sunday Holy Eucharist brings tears to my eyes as it is doing right now. God is there. He is with our clergy and with our parish. Most importantly to me, he is with my family and I know him through his graces.

Luckily, I don’t wonder, what if. I don’t long for anything from my past. The Anglican liturgy is beautiful and fulfilling. I feel like I have been Anglican my whole life. My parents are both Catholics and very devoted to their parish and thats good. They also know that my family is very devoted to our church and they respect that. I hope and pray that you will find peace in your heart and soul. God’s grace makes all things new. I will pray with the Saints in Heaven today for you and your family.
 
Warning this is going to be long, but my heart is heavy…
I was raised in a Roman Catholic Family. I attended a Catholic school from grades 1-12. I loved my educational experience and have non of the “Catholic School” horror stories you hear of. I continued to go to mass as a young adult.

I married in a Catholic Church and went to mass and loved my experience. When others would look down on my faith I was proud to say I was a Catholic. My husband did not practice the faith even though he too was raised Catholic and went to Catholic School. His experience with the Church were very different from mine. Once we began to have children my husband did begin to worship with us.

Around 1994, I began to see a change in the church ( the same Catholic Church I was raised in and went to school through). It was becoming very apparent that every sermon followed with another sermon about donating more money. There never was enough money. We had a huge church in our city and I knew for a fact we were not hurting for money. However, as the months past I could see the sermons and tone had change in my church. I began to see myself doubting everything the church stood for.

I guess the final straw for my husband came when at my sons first grade All Saints Mass. The sermon to the children was not about the saints or even the gospel. The sermon was about how Mommy and Daddy are giving money so they can attend a Catholic School, and how Mommy and Daddy need to give to the church just as much as they give to the school. It was followed by “when you see mommy and daddy put their envelope in the collection, as them is my future catholic faith worth the amount you have set aside?”

My husband fumed and walked out, along with many of the other fathers. My husband never returned to that Catholic Church again. We tried other churchs, but at the time the theme was all the same. It was the in the height of the Priest Molestation cases that were everywhere. And to be honest I was disgusted with the whole faith… We no longer felt we were being feed the word. At the end of my sons first grade year we put him in public school.

While I still attended a Catholic Church my husband attended a Lutheran Church. I began to attend his studies to convert to Lutheran with him. I figured if the children were going to be raised in a two faith household, I may as well know a little bit about his faith. I guess you can see where this story is going…In the end I converted as well.

While I enjoy being Lutheran and am very active in my church I feel something is missing inside of me. When my children made their Holy Communions they just walked up in their church clothes took communion and carried on. They didn’t have the excitement I did as a child. They do not hold it as dear as I did as a child. My heart cried when my daughter made her communion one sunday in a basic fall dress, not the white communion dress, with the rosary beads and bible as I did.

While I try to tell my children about my love of Mary and the Rosery I had at one time. I am reminded that we are only to pray to Jesus alone. No middle man is needed. I understand that, but as a Mother who else would one pray to over her children, but to another mother?

My children have no idea what the stations of the cross are. In Bible study there is always some form of Catholic Bashing ( since most of my class are ex Catholics). My older children in Sr. High Sunday School are taught about the Catholic Church and its corruption through out history. Unfortunatly, what is being taught to them is true. I tried to take my Children about 5 years ago to a Catholic Church. It was Mothers Day ( in the Lutheran faith, on mothers day no mention of Mary the Mother of God is ever mentioned)…anyway, I wanted my children to see the faith I was raised in. When we left Church they thought it was just horrible. I felt like I was back home.

I have been away from the Catholic Faith for over 14 years now, and I can honestly say there is something missing and has been missing inside of me faith wise for many years. Is it only the traditions that I miss? Or, is this the Lord calling me back to the faith I held so precious for so many years?

Has the Catholic Church changed at all in the past 14 years? Has it become the Church that I no longer wanted to attend all those years ago? I have many questions and would love to speak to someone about them.
Check out these stories to get a more complete picture:

chnetwork.org/converts.html
 
When we left Church they thought it was just horrible. I felt like I was back home.
I have been away from the Catholic Faith for over 14 years now, and I can honestly say there is something missing and has been missing inside of me faith wise for many years.
I was born & raised Catholic, converted to Mormonism when I was 18 and now 18 years later I am considering a return to Catholocism.

For the first time in 18 years, I attended Mass last Saturday evening with my parents, wife, and kids and for whatever it’s worth… I felt like I was back home.
 
I was born & raised Catholic, converted to Mormonism when I was 18 and now 18 years later I am considering a return to Catholocism.

For the first time in 18 years, I attended Mass last Saturday evening with my parents, wife, and kids and for whatever it’s worth… I felt like I was back home.
This is awesome, C2M2C! 👍

God bless you and your family!!
 
Born and raised Catholic, grade school, high school, college. But I was caught up in the aura of the 60s and 70s, and the things I wanted to do didn’t fit with being Catholic. I looked at a variety of other churches, but could never be anything else. When my son wanted to go to the school of religion (mainly because the other kids in his class went…in NYC at that time, school of relgion was on Tuesday afternoon and the kids going got out at 2pm…not just Catholic but Jewish kids and some Protestants too) I said if we’re doing it, we’re doing it all the way. So I somehow ended up a Catechist and editor of the Sunday bulletin. My ex-huband had said he was agnostic, and I didn’t care at that time, but like some other critical information, this wasn’t really accurate. The first time my son didn’t want to go to Mass, his father’s attitude was “leave the boy alone”. If I was annoyed after a classroom of rowdy 9 year olds wore on my patience, he wanted me to quit. He travelled and when he was home, he expected me to drop any other committments I had for either the church or the school, and entertain him. Then he wanted a divorce. I mentioned this to the nun who ran the school of religion and the pastor and both said we needed to “re-think” my position in the parish. No we didn’t. I was out of there – for the 2nd time. About 7 years ago, my sister asked me to sing with her choir for Christmas because they were short of sopranos. I haven’t left again. She’s left the church now and I’m the only Catholic left in the family. My Italian grandparents are spinning in their crypt. My other sister joined her husband’s UCC church and now likes to harp on man-made laws. I almost clocked her at her son’s confirmation. I choose to abstain from meat on Fridays because nothing else seemed to be right for me, and you wouldn’t believe how many people give me grief about that. Most Catholics I know don’t realize you’re supposed to do something if you don’t abstain from meat. I didn’t know it until I learned it here…thanks you guys.

What was my point? Oh yeah…even when I wasn’t going to Mass and committing all the mortal sins our secular society thinks are dandy, I couldn’t be anything else. Being Catholic is as much a part of me as being Italian-American and female. Even when I don’t like something or wish it would be different or get mad at some human’s stupidity, I know that the Catholic Church is the church Jesus created, and the only one for me. At the same time, the most truly Christian person I know is Lutheran, so they must have something going for them. But all the other churches are missing something vital…the real body and blood of Christ.
 
all the stories related are valid and the inspirational ones contain something more, in that each of the posters tells how he has looked inside himself to find the source of his unease or dissatisfaction and resolved those issues so that he could find his way home. this honesty is the core to a real conversion story
 
I can symphathize with you. I’ve been disgusted when I’ve visited a certain upscale parish where the priest uses the homily to guilt people into giving more money. I’ve also been confused by the behavior and attitude of many priests and the vast differences in style and theology of other parishes.

It makes me sad that 10% of the U.S. population is made up of ex-Catholics.

The Catholic Church is still the true apostolic Church founded by Christ with St. Peter as the first pope, so maybe you should look at other Catholic parishes.

Personally, I’ve found the faith to be a little more stronger in the more modest parishes or the more traditional parishes.

My parents have always said that God is the only one that matters, so you shouldn’t let scandals and imperfections cause you to leave His Church, especially since the Catholic Church has the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist.

I have always practiced my Catholic faith privately and with my family and don’t heavily depend on a parish community to live my faith. I do miss the priests of my childhood parish, they were very holy priests I could depend on.

Remember, the Church has gone through dark times before and has always risen above. The Church will get better.

And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, an the gates of hell shall not prevail against the Church. (Matthew 16:18)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top