Explaining the "Real" vs "Symbolic" Presence

  • Thread starter Thread starter JRKH
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JRKH

Guest
I had this idea the other day and wanted to run it by the folks here to get your (name removed by moderator)ut.

Statement:
"It is not Christ that is symbolic, and the bread that is real in the Eucharist.
Rather it is the Bread that is symbolic and Christ that is real.

Explanation:
We wish to give our Love to others. Especially to those who we love in a special way. For this reason we give gifts or favors or whatever. For instance a parent might give a child graduating college car. They do so because they are proud of the child and because they love the child.
The Car is a symbol of the Love that is real. The car will eventually pass away, but the love remains. The car will pass away, but the parent will remain to Love and guide the child. The car, while it lasts, can help to bring the child home to his/her parents, but the parents are the goal and not the car.

When people refer to the presence of Christ as being “symbolic” they are looking at the thing backwards. They are accepting what is real only from the viewpoint of nature and what they can see. What think that what they see is real and what they don’t see is “symbolic”. In fact the exact opposite is true.

Comments? Refinements? Better examples?

Peace
James
 
I understand the way you are thinking and agree to a point. But, I think the it can be fine-tuned a bit by changing “symbol” to “material manifestation that is effectual.” A wedding ring is symbolic, but a car is a gift that greatly enhances an individual’s quality of life. The Eucharist is effectual in this way.
 
I understand the way you are thinking and agree to a point. But, I think the it can be fine-tuned a bit by changing “symbol” to “material manifestation that is effectual.” A wedding ring is symbolic, but a car is a gift that greatly enhances an individual’s quality of life. The Eucharist is effectual in this way.
Interesting - but it is not the symbol that has this effect, it is the Reality behind that symbol. In the case of the car, it is the Real Love (the Reality) of the parent, demonstrated through the symbol of the car.

Peace
james
 
Comments? Refinements? Better examples?
Hi James,

I think it is interesting!

But, it might have limited explanatory power. One difficulty I see is that it doesn’t claim to be an analogy but an example. The problem here is that it makes the car/love just like the Eucharist, and so the Eucharist isn’t anything special – a car can be changed into love just as easily as Bread becomes the Body of Christ.

Another difficulty might be that the “real” thing in the car/love example (or, I think in other examples you might give) is something that is non-sensible. But the Body and Blood of Christ in the Eucharist is un-sensible not non-sensible (His Soul and Divinity are non-sensible, however). What I mean to say is, if you can give an example where the “real” thing is not only real (like Love is) but real and usually sensible (like a Body) then you would be closer. But, you’ll be hard pressed to give an example of that because the Eucharist is unique in that way.

One more difficulty that I see is that in your explanation you seem to indicate that two options of “real” and “symbol” are exclusive. In other words, something can’t both be real and a symbol. But that is how most symbols work, right? They are real things that are also symbols of something else that is real. So, a car is real, and it is a symbol of the love that is real. It’s not like the car isn’t real itself.

Just a few thoughts, **not **criticisms. I think it is valuable to think about these things like you seem to be doing here.

VC
 
Hi James,

I think it is interesting!

But, it might have limited explanatory power. One difficulty I see is that it doesn’t claim to be an analogy but an example. The problem here is that it makes the car/love just like the Eucharist, and so the Eucharist isn’t anything special – a car can be changed into love just as easily as Bread becomes the Body of Christ.

Another difficulty might be that the “real” thing in the car/love example (or, I think in other examples you might give) is something that is non-sensible. But the Body and Blood of Christ in the Eucharist is un-sensible not non-sensible (His Soul and Divinity are non-sensible, however). What I mean to say is, if you can give an example where the “real” thing is not only real (like Love is) but real and usually sensible (like a Body) then you would be closer. But, you’ll be hard pressed to give an example of that because the Eucharist is unique in that way.

One more difficulty that I see is that in your explanation you seem to indicate that two options of “real” and “symbol” are exclusive. In other words, something can’t both be real and a symbol. But that is how most symbols work, right? They are real things that are also symbols of something else that is real. So, a car is real, and it is a symbol of the love that is real. It’s not like the car isn’t real itself.

Just a few thoughts, **not **criticisms. I think it is valuable to think about these things like you seem to be doing here.

VC
Even if they were criticisms that would be fine. 😉 So don’t worry about that.
You’ve given me several things to consider.
Thanks a lot.

Peace
James
 
I understand the way you are thinking and agree to a point. But, I think the it can be fine-tuned a bit by changing “symbol” to “material manifestation that is effectual.” A wedding ring is symbolic, but a car is a gift that greatly enhances an individual’s quality of life. The Eucharist is effectual in this way.
The Eucharist is a bit like a wedding ring as it symbolises the marriage between Jesus and his Church. The Eucharist is related to the wedding feast at Cana where there is a transubstantiation of water into wine. The Eucharist is also in the same shape as a fertilised egg and traditionally a wedding ring is a symbol of consummation.
 
Christ took the bread and when had blessed it he broke it saying this IS my body.

Here we have exactly the belief of the Church from day one. It persists in churches that have not been in communion with Rome since the 400’s if not earlier. It exists in the eastern churches as well. It was the belief universal.

And this is what is done each week in mass. Bread is taken, blessed and broken as the true body of Christ. In accordance with his words and universal understanding, until a bunch of lawyers arose in the 1500’s and tried to argue it all away.
 
The Eucharist is a bit like a wedding ring as it symbolises the marriage between Jesus and his Church. The Eucharist is related to the wedding feast at Cana where there is a transubstantiation of water into wine. The Eucharist is also in the same shape as a fertilised egg and traditionally a wedding ring is a symbol of consummation.
Not quite. The water at Cana was transformed into wine - it looked and tasted like wine. Presumably its substance was also changed from water to wine, but we don’t really know that.

The problem is that we don’t ordinarily use the word “substance” the way it was used in the philosophical discourse that was the background to the transubstantiation definition. In that usage, “Substance” means “what something is” - in the mind of God, if you will. In Eucharist the substance is changed, the form remains the same.
 
I’m still an Episcopalian. I believe that it is the Holy Spirit, by the mysterious Blessing by the Priest through whom the Spirit flows, who turns the Bread and Wine to Jesus’s Body and Blood. This, as I understand and believe, is the mystery of the Sacrement of the Eucharist. An outward sign of inward grace. This is what my Lord tells me. Any thoughts? I may have been clumsy in my wording but I think my intention is understood.
 
I heard an example that really hit home for me (sorry tothe person who I am stealing this from)-

A child in CCD comes to priest and says “My parents are both scientists and if my senses can’t notice a change, the change hasn’t happened.”

The priest was concerned because the child would be recieving first communion soon from the bishop and he would have to profess to believe in the REAL presence of Christ in the Eucharist to receive his first communion.

The priest tried everything he knew to no avail, and the day of the first communion came.

As the boy was queastioned before church by the bishop, the bishop asked if he believed the Eucharist became the body and blood of Christ.

The boy replied "Look, feel, taste, smell the host, what does it look, feel, taste or smell like? The bishop replied “bread”. The boy said “Then its bread dummy1”

Since the bishop had been pre-warned by the good priest and knowing his parents were scientists, he was ready with the answer. He asked the boy if he would eat a “normal” piece of bread. Of course the boy said yes. Then the bishop asked if he took that same bread and radiated it with nuclear material (plutonium) for a day, would he still eat it?

The boy very proudly answered “No, it would kill me” The bishop smiled and said "how does it look, feel, taste, smell - the same as normal bread right? It’s not the same though anymore is it? It has been infused with POWER that doesn’t change the appearance but definately changes the reality. The child submitted and received communion that day.

Not a perfect example but the closest I have ever heard - Christ comes down and infuses HIMSELF into the bread and MAKES it more than it appears. He actually makes it HIMSELF as a feast for us for the journey. Hope it helps.
 
Not quite. The water at Cana was transformed into wine - it looked and tasted like wine. Presumably its substance was also changed from water to wine, but we don’t really know that.

The problem is that we don’t ordinarily use the word “substance” the way it was used in the philosophical discourse that was the background to the transubstantiation definition. In that usage, “Substance” means “what something is” - in the mind of God, if you will. In Eucharist the substance is changed, the form remains the same.
My understanding and belief (based on Church teaching):

There is nothing symbolic in any way of the reality of Jesus’ Body, Blood,Soul,and Divinity in the Eucharist. The substances of the bread and wine are changed but the “accidents” of taste, texture, etc. remain. Remember. Jesus’ used “IS” at the Last Supper and “MY” in John 6. How much clearer and more to the point can those be? As for “do this in memory of me,” He was instituting the Sacrament of the Eucharist he was telling them this is what you, as my priest/bishops are to do will do and are doing to this day. In these actions His words were very specific and deliberate. The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is not just ritual, Christ Himself acts through the priest in “confecting” the Eucharist, using the priests hands as the priest is acting “In Persona Christae,” “In the Person of Christ.” Thus, Jesus’ one and only Sacrifice on the cross is presented to us at every Mass that is celebrated.

This Sacrifice is ***re-***presented not just memorialized/ritualized

When we receive the “host” (as it is commonly referred to), we are receiving Jesus into our bodies where He “communes with our soul” for the 10-20 minutes time our body takes to break down the “accidental natures” of the consecrated bread and wine.

These are supernatural realities that are made present to us and they must of necessity require a leap/act of faith to accept/discern.

God Bless…🙂
 
How great to see such things discussed and grappled with! From a Protestant background, i’ve heard these same questions, most often asked in complete doubt. One will say, “it is still just bread and wine, even under a microscope.” I smile and ask that Evangelical Protestant if they believe Jesus lives in their heart. They say, “of course i do!” I say, but do you REALLY believe He REALLY lives in your heart?"

“Of course!”

“So, if you underwent open heart surgery, would the doctor’s find a little tiny Jesus sitting in your aorta?”

Then the blushing begins…and some things start to click. Maybe not a great analogy, but i heard this from someone on Catholic Answers Live, i think, and i’ve used it many times. I also liked the plutonium example above.

But hey, just try explaining how a 200 ton 747 can fly. Hard to explain and really understand, but we can see that they DO fly.
 
This is all Faith and the spiritual working of The Holy Spirit. Someone mentioned supernatural, God certainly works that way today as well as in the Bible.
Peace
A Blessed Easter to everyone.
 
As a former Protestant preparing to celebrate my conversion into the Catholic faith in five days, I recall that whenever communion was celebrated in my former church, it was pretty much understood to be nothing more that a symbol. For sixty years I believed that to be true. And then came RCIA to the rescue. It was at a retreat about one month prior to Easter Vigil 2005 that one of the deacons carefully explained what takes place when the priest consecrates the Host. The process actually has a name, Epiclesis (sp.?). The priest calls down the Holy Spirit to transform (transsubstantiate) the bread and wine into the Real Presence of Christ. The elements of communion are not changed in form, rather in substance. After the Deacon explained this, I thought for a nanosecond that it was all a bunch of Catholic hocus-pocus. But, thankfully, in the very next nanosecond I said to myself that if I did not believe this to be true, then I would be denying the power of the Holy Spirit which is something that I absolutely could not and would not do under any circumstances. Since that time my life has changed a full 180 degrees in that I now realize the reality that, indeed, Christ lives in me and I in Him. Praised by Jesus.
 
As a former Protestant preparing to celebrate my conversion into the Catholic faith in five days, I recall that whenever communion was celebrated in my former church, it was pretty much understood to be nothing more that a symbol. For sixty years I believed that to be true. And then came RCIA to the rescue. It was at a retreat about one month prior to Easter Vigil 2005 that one of the deacons carefully explained what takes place when the priest consecrates the Host. The process actually has a name, Epiclesis (sp.?). The priest calls down the Holy Spirit to transform (transsubstantiate) the bread and wine into the Real Presence of Christ. The elements of communion are not changed in form, rather in substance. After the Deacon explained this, I thought for a nanosecond that it was all a bunch of Catholic hocus-pocus. But, thankfully, in the very next nanosecond I said to myself that if I did not believe this to be true, then I would be denying the power of the Holy Spirit which is something that I absolutely could not and would not do under any circumstances. Since that time my life has changed a full 180 degrees in that I now realize the reality that, indeed, Christ lives in me and I in Him. Praised by Jesus.
One small addition I would always include when explaining this to non-Catholics is that consecration can only be achieved by someone with the authority given by Jesus (i.e. a priest via Apostolic succession). In that sense, when communion was celebrated in your Protestant church it was indeed symbolic.
 
Christ took the bread and when had blessed it he broke it saying this IS my body.

Here we have exactly the belief of the Church from day one. It persists in churches that have not been in communion with Rome since the 400’s if not earlier. It exists in the eastern churches as well. It was the belief universal.

And this is what is done each week in mass. Bread is taken, blessed and broken as the true body of Christ. In accordance with his words and universal understanding, until a bunch of lawyers arose in the 1500’s and tried to argue it all away.
Vincent-
Thx for you generous plug for the Truth,

That a part of Christiandom no longer believes this is a sad consequence of the history you relate to us.
It was an unforseen consequence as well I believe, caused by the eventual breaking of the chain of Apostolic Succession.
Certainly Luther and other early ‘reformers’ did not doubt the True Presence.

BTW, not only is it done each week in mass, it is done every day in mass, somewhere on Earth, every hour of every day. 🙂

God bless you.
 
You all must be crazy. The God who is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent, who created the whole universe, raises people from the dead, created every soul, knows every hair on our head, and parted the Red Sea, could NOT possibly change bread and wine into His body and blood (even though He also changed water into wine).

/end of sarcasm
 
My understanding and belief (based on Church teaching):

There is nothing symbolic in any way of the reality of Jesus’ Body, Blood,Soul,and Divinity in the Eucharist. The substances of the bread and wine are changed but the “accidents” of taste, texture, etc. remain. Remember. Jesus’ used “IS” at the Last Supper and “MY” in John 6. How much clearer and more to the point can those be? As for “do this in memory of me,” He was instituting the Sacrament of the Eucharist he was telling them this is what you, as my priest/bishops are to do will do and are doing to this day. In these actions His words were very specific and deliberate. The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass is not just ritual, Christ Himself acts through the priest in “confecting” the Eucharist, using the priests hands as the priest is acting “In Persona Christae,” “In the Person of Christ.” Thus, Jesus’ one and only Sacrifice on the cross is presented to us at every Mass that is celebrated.

This Sacrifice is ***re-***presented not just memorialized/ritualized

When we receive the “host” (as it is commonly referred to), we are receiving Jesus into our bodies where He “communes with our soul” for the 10-20 minutes time our body takes to break down the “accidental natures” of the consecrated bread and wine.

These are supernatural realities that are made present to us and they must of necessity require a leap/act of faith to accept/discern.

God Bless…🙂
I agree completely, btw. My “not quite” was to point out that what Jesus did at the Wedding at Cana was not transubstantiation, and to try to highlight the difference between transformation and transubstantiation.
 
we have a body that you can see and soul that you can not see. We need food for the body to live and we need food for the soul you can not see. Just because we can not see our souls does not mean that it we do not have them. Just because we can not see any changes to the host that does not mean it is not there.
Also remember Passover ,the blood of the lamb was painted on the door post once but you need to eat the lamb each and every Passover.
 
One small addition I would always include when explaining this to non-Catholics is that consecration can only be achieved by someone with the authority given by Jesus (i.e. a priest via Apostolic succession). In that sense, when communion was celebrated in your Protestant church it was indeed symbolic.
I would like to offer a point of clarification if I may.

There is a difference in the authority of the bishop of a diocese and his priests. The bishop does indeed have apostolic authority and his priests have been delegated the authority to confect the Eucharist by the bishop. As I understand it, the priests “share” in the priesthood of the bishop by his delegating those powers to them. In a sense, the bishop is “the priest of a diocese.” The diocesan priest is not an “apostolic successor” as is the bishop and cannot be unless and until raised to the rank of bishop by the pope. If this is not correct in this I would appreciate some sort of correction.

W. r. t. transubstantiation, the miraculous change in substance that occurs, while ian the action of the Holy Spirit that accomplishes the change in substance, the priest is acting in Persona Christae (In the Person of Christ) when he says; “This IS my Body” and This IS my Blood." In a sense, which is still a mystery to me, Jesus in a wayis using(?) the priest’s hands and voice as the unbloody sacrifice unfolds and the one and only sacrifice
of Calvary is **RE-**presented at each and every Mass that is said. What a glorious experience to be present at the One, True Sacrifice irrespective of time. And as I understand St. Thomas Aquinas’ description of the Holy Trinity (see “Summa”) there is but one Divine Will between the Father, Son and Spirit, then I think we must conclude that where one person of the Trinity is present/acting then all three are present and acting

God Bless…🙂

Bussi

God Bless…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top