Extreme Hatred/Anger Towards God

  • Thread starter Thread starter nsper7
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

nsper7

Guest
I find that I sometimes have an extreme anger and hatred towards God. Ever since I came to faith (first as an Evangelical Protestant about six or so years ago), my faith has been based on fear of Hell and it has been one nervous breakdown of one sort or another since then. There has never been any love there and a part of me thinks that the Christians (Catholic or otherwise) who are lovey-dovey are either foolish as to the truth of Christianity or are just deluding themselves with happy thoughts.

As a Catholic, I am plagued by Scrupulosity (I admit I dealt with OCD when I was a young child, but I seemed to outgrow it…until I really came to faith) that can be quite debilitating. Reading sermons like St. Leonard of Port Maurice’s The Little of Those Who Are Saved does not help things. I did the math on that sermon and it seems a Jewish person in Nazi Germany statistically has better odds than a Catholic at the Throne of God and Hitler never cast people into Hell. Why should my hatred for God not far surpass a Holocaust survivor’s hatred of a Hitler, an Eichmann or a Mengele…other than fear of Hell of course? And that only gets me angrier!

People talk about loving God and even loving others, but I find that hard to do. Much of it I admit maybe goes back to the loss of a mother (she died when I was 12) and several embarrassing failures with women when I was an adolescent. It was like I realized if you open yourself up to love, you get stabbed right in the back–I admit I have developed a fairly strong misogynistic streak over the years and it seems the more I see the emotional manipulation and psychological games women seem to excel at, the more I can certainly sympathize with homosexuality (I am definitely not a homosexual though).

My spiritual director is unsure how to advise me because these are all interlocking issues (i.e. loss of a mother and a sense of rejection by women in general has led to anger/hatred becoming a primary motivator and emotion in my life and then add in that my faith has been based on fear of Hell, not love of/for anything, and the OCD/Scrupulosity issue). I listen to people here and other places talk about how much they love God, and I truly sometimes think they are ignorant (ignorance is bliss) or just deluding themselves. If they said they were motivated by just fear, it would anger me because it would cause me to continue to ruminate on how God seems to delight in holding Hell as a threat over us much in the same way I am sure certain Nazis enjoyed holding the gas chambers over the heads of the victims of the concentration camps. I know some may be offended by my Holocaust comparison, but it is an apt one…except for the fact that even at his worst, Hitler never sent people to Hell.

At times, I hate God and I don’t understand how others cannot feel similarly. I truly feel like a lot of people just delude themselves in their faith, but it all comes down to fear of Hell it seems.
 
It certainly sounds like you’re not “lukewarm.” Keep working with your spiritual director (maybe he can refer you to a new one if he’s overwhelmed). After all, God only asks us to persevere to the end. He doesn’t require we win. 😉
 
Is it possible that you are suffering from scrupulosity? I used to suffer from scrupulosity to a quite severe degree. I no longer suffer from it to such a degree but I still suffer from it to a limited extent. I think that scrupulosity tends to occur in new converts and sometimes doesn’t disappear for years or at all. However, it can be managed and in most cases, eliminated. Scrupulosity often comes with an excessive fear of Hell. Now, don’t get me wrong, a healthy fear of Hell is a good thing and can help to deter you from committing mortal sin but fear of Hell can sometimes become excessive and even crippling. Anyway, here is a link to a website where you can submit a request via e-mail to subscribe to a newsletter (snail mail) called Scrupulous Anonymous:

mission.liguori.org/newsletters/scrupanon.htm

You can even view the current issue and archives of past issues online at this same site. I prefer to receive it via snail mail.

So yeah, if you think that scrupulosity is a problem that you are suffering from, this newsletter may prove to be quite helpful to you. 🙂
 
I just want to assert the teaching of the Church that God never sends anyone to hell.

.
 
nsper7, what do you think of the Passion of Jesus Christ, and the fact that He died so horrible a death in order to keep you from having to go to Hell?
 
It certainly sounds like you’re not “lukewarm.” Keep working with your spiritual director (maybe he can refer you to a new one if he’s overwhelmed). After all, God only asks us to persevere to the end. He doesn’t require we win. 😉
It is not so much that he is overwhelmed and wants another spiritual director to take his slack, it is more that he feels the issues I am dealing with are somewhat out of his purview and he is not sure what he can do to help.
Is it possible that you are suffering from scrupulosity? I used to suffer from scrupulosity to a quite severe degree. I no longer suffer from it to such a degree but I still suffer from it to a limited extent. I think that scrupulosity tends to occur in new converts and sometimes doesn’t disappear for years or at all. However, it can be managed and in most cases, eliminated. Scrupulosity often comes with an excessive fear of Hell. Now, don’t get me wrong, a healthy fear of Hell is a good thing and can help to deter you from committing mortal sin but fear of Hell can sometimes become excessive and even crippling. Anyway, here is a link to a website where you can submit a request via e-mail to subscribe to a newsletter (snail mail) called Scrupulous Anonymous:

mission.liguori.org/newsletters/scrupanon.htm

You can even view the current issue and archives of past issues online at this same site. I prefer to receive it via snail mail.

So yeah, if you think that scrupulosity is a problem that you are suffering from, this newsletter may prove to be quite helpful to you. 🙂
Yes, I deal with major Scrupulosity issues (esp. according to my spiritual director and I think every Priest I have ever Confessed to, including a Priest from the FSSP, seemed to agree that I got too Scrupulous in the Confessional) and I have found the SA site very informative.

One thing I will say is that with this anger/hatred towards God (please note, I do not walk around all the time with anger/hatred towards God, it is more that reading that sermon or something else triggers it), I find I have a strong devotion to Mother Mary. Perhaps part of it is because of the issues I had with my mother (as I said, she died of alcoholism when I was 12), but I guess it is also because it seems like Mother Mary constantly does everything she can to protect us and save us from Hellfire (i.e. giving us the Brown and Green Scapulars, the Rosary, various Devotions and promises and always being willing to listen to us and intercede on our behalf).
 
I find that I sometimes have an extreme anger and hatred towards God. Ever since I came to faith (first as an Evangelical Protestant about six or so years ago), my faith has been based on fear of Hell and it has been one nervous breakdown of one sort or another since then. There has never been any love there and a part of me thinks that the Christians (Catholic or otherwise) who are lovey-dovey are either foolish as to the truth of Christianity or are just deluding themselves with happy thoughts.

As a Catholic, I am plagued by Scrupulosity (I admit I dealt with OCD when I was a young child, but I seemed to outgrow it…until I really came to faith) that can be quite debilitating. s.
this sounds a lot more like a burden of mental health or psychological issues, rather than spiritual, although of course those have an impact on spiritual health. You may need help from professionals in those areas, as well as competent experienced orthodox spiritual direction, as these are beyond the competence of anyone here to help you with. We will be praying for you.
 
I think it might be beneficial for you to contemplate the fact that God sends no one to Hell. They choose to leave Him and send themselves to Hell. God is a loving Father and does not want His children to go to Hell. That’s where you go if you deliberatly reject all of His mercy and love and decide that you are better on your own than with Him.

Also, Mary does do a lot of things to help us get to heaven, but think about what Jesus did! I mean, the death He suffered on the cross was purely and only to keep you from going to Hell. He loved you so much that He went as far as anyone can possibly go to rescue you! If anything should inspire love of God, this should.

Have you heard the song By Your Side by Tenth Avenue North? If you haven’t, it might behoove you to look it up. It’s a very powerful song!
 
this sounds a lot more like a burden of mental health or psychological issues, rather than spiritual, although of course those have an impact on spiritual health. You may need help from professionals in those areas, as well as competent experienced orthodox spiritual direction, as these are beyond the competence of anyone here to help you with. We will be praying for you.
My spiritual director has suggested that I consider seeking psychological assistance and possibly taking medication (i.e. for OCD/Scrupulosity symptoms). He also indicates that these issues also might reduce culpability (he was specifically talking about a certain besetting sexual sin I deal with) since his opinion is that I am almost stuck in a track/loop as it were.
 
I’ve read your opening post, nsper7.

Yup. Scrupulosity, great anger toward God, fear of hell…
Many clinicians, in professional psychology, would quickly recognize
what is occuring, most likely. http://bestsmileys.com/nono/9.gif

Did a 12 day tour on a psyche ward, 15 years ago, with another
go-round a few years back. [Part of the pilgrimage, as it were.]
Let me put things this way. I was half out of my head with anguish,
along with agonizing, near-paralyzing fear. After 15 years of psychotherapy,
and medication that actually addresses whatever it is that my brain needs,
I sleep like a log, anxiety is somewhat reduced, and the tendency
toward rumination is blessedly curtailed quite a bit.

Pleased to see that you recognize that wretched earthly despots
only hold sway here on terra firma, while God is attributed with
creating a hell of eternal fire. *
Human beings are more merciful than such a god. They rush in to
help a burn victim, hour after hour, while the Lord of the Universe is said to arrange for
‘flames that never quench.’

For those untroubled by double-messaging ‘God is Love’…‘flames that
never quench’] this presents no difficulty whatsoever, apparently.

In any case, each religious entity is somewhat limited. It’s as if human beings,
through time, have received hints of Godhead. And I am grateful for these hints.
[For what it’s worth, Judaism is the sanest religion, I have found.]
Judaic thought sees a purgatory of no longer than a year, and those humans
who have done colossal, abysmal evil, in their lifetimes - such souls are extinguished.
No eternal hell fire. That is a merciful God. And all is left to His Wisdom.

I ask God to walk with you, nsper7, with regard to such matters as you delineate in your opening post.

It eases the heart, sometimes, when another says “I know about that, too.”

God bless you, nsper7.

reen12*
 
I’ve read your opening post, nsper7.

Yup. Scrupulosity, great anger toward God, fear of hell…
Many clinicians, in professional psychology, would quickly recognize
what is occuring, most likely. http://bestsmileys.com/nono/9.gif

Did a 12 day tour on a psyche ward, 15 years ago, with another
go-round a few years back. [Part of the pilgrimage, as it were.]
Let me put things this way. I was half out of my head with anguish,
along with agonizing, near-paralyzing fear. After 15 years of psychotherapy,
and medication that actually addresses whatever it is that my brain needs,
I sleep like a log, anxiety is somewhat reduced, and the tendency
toward rumination is blessedly curtailed quite a bit.

Pleased to see that you recognize that wretched earthly despots
only hold sway here on terra firma, while God is attributed with
creating a hell of eternal fire. *
Human beings are more merciful than such a god. They rush in to
help a burn victim, hour after hour, while the Lord of the Universe is said to arrange for
‘flames that never quench.’

For those untroubled by double-messaging ‘God is Love’…‘flames that
never quench’] this presents no difficulty whatsoever, apparently.

In any case, each religious entity is somewhat limited. It’s as if human beings,
through time, have received hints of Godhead. And I am grateful for these hints.
[For what it’s worth, Judaism is the sanest religion, I have found.]
Judaic thought sees a purgatory of no longer than a year, and those humans
who have done colossal, abysmal evil, in their lifetimes - such souls are extinguished.
No eternal hell fire. That is a merciful God. And all is left to His Wisdom.

I ask God to walk with you, nsper7, with regard to such matters as you delineate in your opening post.

It eases the heart, sometimes, when another says “I know about that, too.”

God bless you, nsper7.

reen12*

Thank you for understanding where I come from. My problem is that I truly and fully believe that Catholicism is the Truth, although elements of that Truth seem to cause me mental torment.

It does seem that Christianity is unique among the Abrahamic faiths on the issue of Hell. Judaism, as you said, does not believe in a eternal Hell and I believe that Islam sees that most people who are condemned to Hell are eventually released by the mercy of Allah. Certainly, it does not seem like either of the other faiths fixates on it and uses it as a weapon to terrorize its followers. As an example, at the university I attended, there was a public square where people could set up tables and spread their messages. There were almost always Christians (albeit Evangelical/Fundamentalist Protestants) out there, many of them using Hell to get people’s attention and get them to listen. Often, there was also a Muslim group tabling and I never once saw them accost people and when I once went up to talk to them (just being friendly) and I never got the obnoxious/preachy vibe one gets when dealing with the Christian groups out there. They just showed me some information about Islam, but never tried a high-pressure sale.
 
I think it might be beneficial for you to contemplate the fact that God sends no one to Hell. They choose to leave Him and send themselves to Hell. God is a loving Father and does not want His children to go to Hell. That’s where you go if you deliberatly reject all of His mercy and love and decide that you are better on your own than with Him.

Also, Mary does do a lot of things to help us get to heaven, but think about what Jesus did! I mean, the death He suffered on the cross was purely and only to keep you from going to Hell. He loved you so much that He went as far as anyone can possibly go to rescue you! If anything should inspire love of God, this should.

Have you heard the song By Your Side by Tenth Avenue North? If you haven’t, it might behoove you to look it up. It’s a very powerful song!
Great post, Joyful!

Mary does everything she can to save us from Hell, and so does Jesus, Who suffered the Passion and opened the way to redemption for all the world. He did all that, suffering supernatural agonies beyond those any human can endure, in order to save each and every one of us from Hell and bring us eternal Paradise with Him.
 
Great post, Joyful!

Mary does everything she can to save us from Hell, and so does Jesus, Who suffered the Passion and opened the way to redemption for all the world. He did all that, suffering supernatural agonies beyond those any human can endure, in order to save each and every one of us from Hell and bring us eternal Paradise with Him.
Yet if St. Leonard is to be believed, the extreme vast majority of us (the 29,995 out of 30k) will be damned. How can that not lead a person to despair and anger?
 
Thank you for understanding where I come from. My problem is that I truly and fully believe that Catholicism is the Truth, although elements of that Truth seem to cause me mental torment.
nsper7, this appears to be quite a conundrum.
In essence: X is the truth, and the truth torments?

May I please ask a question?
What would have to change in Christianity - more specifically Catholicism,
that would eliminate such torment? Do you have a thought on that?

Since you’ve attended university, I pose a rhetorical question:
What attributes - of logical necessity - would be found in the One, true God?
And if such attributes were not to be found, in the order of Being, what then?

quote: nsper7
…Certainly, it does not seem like either of the other faiths fixates on it and uses it as a weapon to terrorize its followers. As an example, at the university I attended, there was a public square where people could set up tables and spread their messages. There were almost always Christians (albeit Evangelical/Fundamentalist Protestants) out there, many of them using Hell to get people’s attention and get them to listen. Often, there was also a Muslim group tabling and I never once saw them accost people and when I once went up to talk to them (just being friendly) and I never got the obnoxious/preachy vibe one gets when dealing with the Christian groups out there. They just showed me some information about Islam, but never tried a high-pressure sale.
Thank you for extending my knowledge base, nsper7. I’d never heard the word
‘tabling’ employed in that context. 🙂 Most descriptive. *

From what I’m reading in your post, quoted above, you seem to be
most observant - which is a real plus in life, I think. Yet through hard experience,
I have found that being highly observant requires a lot of energy, as well as
‘processing’ time. Not an unalloyed blessing, by any means, in my experience.
But better to be the case than not.

And speaking of blessings, there are many fine members, on CAF,
who share with you the Catholic faith. I ask God to enlighten their
minds and hearts that they may address your questions with both charity and grace,
as well as knowledge.

Kindest regards, nsper7,

reen12*
 
Yet if St. Leonard is to be believed, the extreme vast majority of us (the 29,995 out of 30k) will be damned. How can that not lead a person to despair and anger?
I have three thoughts on this.

First of all, St. Leonard was a great saint, but his opinion on what proportion of the population is damned is non-infallible. St. Catherine of Siena prayed for the soul of Judas Iscariot. Blessed Pope John Paul II hoped that all the world might be saved. The Fatima prayer goes, “Oh my Jesus, forgive us our sins, save us from the fires of Hell and lead all souls into Heaven, especially those who have most need of thy mercy.” This approved apparition hopes and prays for all souls.

I personally believe that the majority of souls are going to be damned, for that seems the most consistent Catholic teaching, but that doesn’t mean 29,995 out of 30k, and I don’t claim that my personal view on the matter is infallible.

My second thought on this is that you should be directing your anger where it is deserved. Jesus Christ laid down His life for us, that we might be with Him in Heaven forever and not go to Hell. He wants the very best for us, and He wants it so badly that He allowed Himself to be brutally tortured to death for all the world, if they would only come to Him and take advantage of what salvation He offers them.

I read one of the comments of the saints about the Passion was that the reason Jesus suffered most at Gethsemane was because He knew so many souls would not come to Him and be saved in spite of how much anguish He was going to endure for them.

God the Father loved us so much He gave up His Son for us. Jesus loved us so much He abandoned Heavenly glory for us, choosing instead the worst agony anyone has endured, and He lived and died purely out of love for us.

It seems to me that God abandoned everything and gave up His very life and Son, all that is most dear to Him, that we might live forever in everlasting joy. However, Satan and the demons are doing all that they can to destroy the souls of everyone on the planet.

If anyone deserves wrath, the devils do. If anyone deserves love, God does.

Continued in the next post . . .
 
The third point I would raise is that you can’t calculate your chances of salvation on a table of probabilities. This is because God has provided abundant means of supernatural grace that we might be saved. He has provided us Confession, through which He instantly wipes our souls clean of any sins we repent for. He also provides us with the Eucharist, which provides us with supernatural grace to help us not to commit sin. He provides us with Guardian Angels, who we can converse with and whose single mission is to bring us to Heaven. We can communicate with them and pray to them and through their intercession receive graces, help, advice and all kinds of protection from sin.

God has also provided us with wise teachings through the Church for us to apply in our lives to the best of our ability, which will help us to live love and escape from all that is evil. He provides us with teachings that can lead us to Heaven. If we listen to Jesus’ teachings and seek Him in His Sacraments, and try to live in obedience to the Church’s teachings, we are not on the path to Hell but the path to Heaven. The reason so many people will be damned is because so many people do not try to walk along the pathway to salvation Christ provided in the Catholic Church. All you have to do is look at the vast numbers of lapsed Catholics and people not even trying to hold to the Church’s teachings to see this. So many are just doing their own thing without regard for the Sacraments or teachings God provided that they might be saved. Many live without regard to the poor or the needy, thinking only about themselves and not trying to live according to the teachings of the Gospels.

On the other hand, if someone, though very weak and sinful, is trying to do God’s will out of a sincere heart, God will help that soul and not turn him or her away.

One cannot calculate one’s chances of salvation on a table of probabilities because the probabilities are all thrown off when one is really seeking God. Jesus said in the Bible, “He who asks receives, he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks, the door will be opened.” He offers salvation to anyone who will come to Him to take it. Even people who fall repeatedly into grave sins like sexual immorality or theft but are striving to change have a good chance of salvation, because they are trying to do God’s will and He understands our weakness and does not judge it. He simply cannot take to live with Him forever people who willfully refuse to do so in this life. People who will not seek Him will not find Him, but everyone who will seek Him truly will receive Him.

The message of the Gospels is really extremely hopeful. We will be saved if we sincerely seek God. Go once to the Confessional with sincere repentance and your sins will all be wiped out and you will be immediately back on the path to salvation.

Try to love your neighbor, and that is the path to salvation. You don’t have to perfectly love your neighbor, but work at it, and that is working at doing God’s will and we don’t have to be at the end of the journey to be saved, but on the path. Jesus said, “I am the Way, the Truth and the Life.” He is the Way, not just the destination, and if we are seeking to do His will, we will be saved. If we give to others, try to forgive those who sin against us, go to Mass on Sundays and obey all the Church’s teachings as best we can, and repent when we fail, we are on the path to salvation. Just try, and then you are on the Way.

The fact that God provides so much grace and so much mercy to anyone who will ask for His mercy and rely on it, and gives Sacraments and teachings to help hold us steady in righteousness, makes salvation certainly within our grasp. Jesus said in the Scripture, “Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am lowly and gentle of heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For my yoke is easy and my burden light.”

Jesus doesn’t demand that much, just that we try, and then His infinite Mercy, which was most perfectly manifested on the Cross, will carry us the rest of the way.
 
My spiritual director has suggested that I consider seeking psychological assistance and possibly taking medication (i.e. for OCD/Scrupulosity symptoms). He also indicates that these issues also might reduce culpability (he was specifically talking about a certain besetting sexual sin I deal with) since his opinion is that I am almost stuck in a track/loop as it were.
As someone who’s suffered from anxiety/OCD disorders since childhood, and also had serious issues with scrupulosity during my time as a Catholic I have to very strongly urge you to listen to your spiritual director and seek professional help.

It is very pointless for you to suffer from a mental illness (and that’s what it is) when there is help available. Medications work very well to kill symptoms of OCD.

You should know by now that no amount of people telling you that your view about hell/sin is wrong will change this for you. It really is not a spiritual issue. Yes, Catholicism is a trigger for your OCD, however your concerns are the result of your OCD, and with the right medication it may well be possible for you to be Catholic without suffering from the OCD symptoms.

There really is no reason for you to suffer this much. You need to take action and seek help so you can get back to enjoying your life.

sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/07/080717140456.htm
The scientists have discovered that people with OCD and their close family members show under-activation of brain areas responsible for stopping habitual behaviour. This is the first time that scientists have associated functional changes in the brain with familial risk for the disorder.
You really need to realize (on an emotional, not just intellectual level) that your brain is abnormal, and that is why you have the thoughts you do. Your thoughts are not reasonable, even though they seem reasonable to you, and even though you think that everyone else doesn’t really understand the teaching, or is ignorant of it, or is too easy going. It’s not them, it’s you.

I know this because I used to have those kinds of thoughts, and now they’re 98% gone.

ocduk.org/2/foursteps.htm That can be helpful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top