Face to Face Confessions vs. Traditional

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jacob18
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jacob18

Guest
Which do you prefer and why?

My aunt says when she does a face-to-face confession it feels like more complete forgiveness. Some people seem to really dislike it.

I did my first confession yesterday and it was a room with a curtain with the priest on the other side. It just amazes me that so simple an act by the priest and such simple words being said to you and your guilt is forgiven.

God is great, indeed.
 
I love face to face. I’ve only been a few times but I’m hooked.

The body language and facial expressions exchanged with the priest, to me, make it seem much more like I confessed to a real person and not a hole in the wall.

Moreover, it gives the priest more to go on as far as your state of mind and heart, than just your voice.

And I was confessing a sin that was very embarrassing to me, but face to face I felt more comfortable because I could see he was hearing me. If I say something embarrassing behind the curtain, how do I know he didn’t just snooze for a second or was thinking about something else? Of course none of it has to do with the sacrament, but just with how I felt about it.

Alan
 
While I vastly prefer the traditional anonymous confessions,
two years ago, I experienced quite a memorable face-to-face confession …
You see, I was so nervous that I ended up
walking through the wrong door by mistake …
yup, I ended up walking through the priest’s door
instead of the penitent’s door !!! :eek:
Found myself face-to-face, all right. :bigyikes:
No anonymity that time!
It ended up being quite humorous, actually. :o

~~ the phoenix
 
I’ve never done the talking-a-curtain type of confession but I much prefer face-to-face. That said, I would only feel comfortable doing that with certain priests who are well known to me, so… 🤷
 
I haven’t had the opportunity to do a “confessional”. I would think it might be easier because of the annonymity. (I don’t think I spelled that right.)
 
Face To Face! Since I’ve come back to the church a year ago it’s been face to face. I feel I need to look into the eyes of my confessor, as if I’m facing Jesus eye to eye, face to face. I have nothing to hide. Jesus knows that I have sinned. I then get on my knees to give my contrition with a very contrite soul. It’s been a very moving experience. I wouldn’t have it any other way.
 
I’ve done it both ways. I’ve also done it in the traditional Anglican way: kneeling at the altar rail with the priest sitting in a chair with his back to me. The problem with this method is the possibility of being overheard.

I prefer the confessional, because I think I’m too aware of the the confessor’s reactions to what I say during a face-to-face confession, and I thus have the temptation of saying what I think he wants me to say, rather than what is in my heart.

The Baltimore Catechism states that it is most desirable to use the same confessor every time. If one does this, it really doesn’t make much difference.
 
I like the confessional box. It has a grate opening not a curtain and the Priest sits side on. I can see him but the lighting is low and I feel more able to bare my soul that way.
 
Well my church only has anonymous confessions.
Even when I’ve gone up to father after Mass and asked for confession, we went to the dark room with the screen lol.
I’ve had the opportunity for a face to face confession twice, visiting other parishes, but I went with anonymous because it’s more comfortable to me, and I love Catholic traditions, and the screen feels more “Catholic” and “traditional” to me:)
 
I prefer kneeling and anonymous when I go to regular confession;

And sitting and face to face when I go to confession during a retreat or as part of spiritual direction.
 
Our parish does not offer face-to-face confession unless you make an appointment. Our confessional is set up in the approved way with a fixed screen. I am fine with that. When I was in parishes that offered both, I always felt pressure to go face-to-face as if that was the normal expectation. 😦
 
I’ve only gone face to face a few times and I have to say I prefer the screen. However, if I go to my parish priest, I’m sure he can recognize my voice since I’m involved in parish activities. Anyway, he sometimes sits waiting with his confessional door open (probably for air since the confessional is very small). So, if it’s something like a first Friday when he’s in the confessional much of the day, he would see you entering the confessional before he closes his door. It’s like a hybrid confession - behind the screen but not anonymous.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top