Faith Alone & James 4:18

  • Thread starter Thread starter heisenburg
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Since this is my thread, im going to step in here…

I’ve allowed this diversion into OSAS even though I said early on dont go there…

But if your going to claim we are in bondage if we are catholic… then i respectfully request that you split this into a different thread…

PC and I (as well as others) have had a very cordial conversation even though it is sorta a touchy subject for many and I want to keep it that way.

By inference, saying catholics are in Bondage is a little off beat for this thread that has so far remained calm and gentle…

If you want, I can get a Moderator to split it out for you

Just please… I hate threads that digress to insults… Especially one I started

In Christ
**How about a topic **on Catholic Charismatics. I have had 7 or 8 years of experience with them. I have a personal testimony of my relation ship with them but may not be proper to put on this forum? How do you get a topic started?

Bill
 
**How about a topic **on Catholic Charismatics. I have had 7 or 8 years of experience with them. I have a personal testimony of my relation ship with them but may not be proper to put on this forum? How do you get a topic started?

Bill
Is it a positive or negative experience?

God Bless,
Michael
 
If you want to start a new thread (and all topics are welcome) at the top of the main thread list page, you will see a New Thread button. Click that and it will ask for title and intro statement…

Then…

Have fun

Hope that helps

In Christ
 
Is it a positive or negative experience?

God Bless,
Michael
Is it a positive or negative experience?__ Well, you might say it is negative but it is true. My comments about my experience you will not agree with.

that is my fair warning. So, shall I proceed?
 
Even the most “negative” comments can be posted in charity and love…

If you can maintain those two…

Any topic is welcome
 
Since this is my thread, im going to step in here…

I’ve allowed this diversion into OSAS even though I said early on dont go there…

But if your going to claim we are in bondage if we are catholic… then i respectfully request that you split this into a different thread…

PC and I (as well as others) have had a very cordial conversation even though it is sorta a touchy subject for many and I want to keep it that way.

By inference, saying catholics are in Bondage is a little off beat for this thread that has so far remained calm and gentle…

If you want, I can get a Moderator to split it out for you

Just please… I hate threads that digress to insults… Especially one I started

In Christ
I agree – OSAS really isn’t on topic of this thread. This thread was and is about works and faith and more specifically, how they each relate to salvation. Can we get a moderator in here to split this off?

I’m not sure that there’s a lot more to be said in regards to the original topic – I think we’ve both made our positions pretty clear (and done so without any hostility, which I think is a big plus) – I just really don’t want to see the thread degrade into a “Luther was a moronic heretic who split with God’s true church” versus “Luther saved people from the captivity in the harlot church of Rome” argument. There’s no useful outcome of such a topic.
 
I agree – OSAS really isn’t on topic of this thread. This thread was and is about works and faith and more specifically, how they each relate to salvation. Can we get a moderator in here to split this off?

I’m not sure that there’s a lot more to be said in regards to the original topic – I think we’ve both made our positions pretty clear (and done so without any hostility, which I think is a big plus) – I just really don’t want to see the thread degrade into a “Luther was a moronic heretic who split with God’s true church” versus “Luther saved people from the captivity in the harlot church of Rome” argument. There’s no useful outcome of such a topic.
I don’t want this thread to degrade into that either. Although OSAS is not specifically the topic of this thread, it’s inevitably included because those who believe in OSAS see it as the logical extension of faith alone. Therefore, if a Christian can lose his salvation due to a “work” (i.e. sin) or lack of good works (sins of omission), then salvation is truly not by faith alone.

God Bless,
Michael
 
If Anyone wants to read my testimony of my time with Catholic charismatis, please e-mail me with a request.

Bill (Edited to remove personal e-mail)
 
I don’t want this thread to degrade into that either. Although OSAS is not specifically the topic of this thread, it’s inevitably included because those who believe in OSAS see it as the logical extension of faith alone. Therefore, if a Christian can lose his salvation due to a “work” (i.e. sin) or lack of good works (sins of omission), then salvation is truly not by faith alone.
While I agree that the discussion is logically connected, it’s not implicitly required for discussion to discuss the original topic, and thus it’s still off-topic, and can easily be channeled into another thread.
When it is in writing one might think it is not in love when it is>>>
True. It’s easy to misinterpret the mood of words on a page. However, I think there’s another important point to consider – whether well-intentioned or not, I read comments regularly that include “Protestants are misguided” and references to Protestants as heretics, schismatics, etc – none of these terms are going to be of benefit to the discourse between Roman Catholics and non-Roman Catholics. Any person should be able to understand this concept, and yet the snide remarks continue, making me wonder if these things truly are said in love or not. 😦

(In fact, it’s due to such comments that a couple of Roman Catholic friends have told me I should leave CAF. They feel it’s not a good representation of Roman Catholicism and its teachings.)
 
Thanks to all who have participated in this discussion.
This thread is now closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top