Family Advice, Please!

  • Thread starter Thread starter pamnbam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

pamnbam

Guest
Hi all, wondering if you could provide a bit of advice (sorry it’s a bit long):

My mom has always been overprotective of me. Oftentimes, I wouldn’t know what I wanted because I would do what she wanted me (or didn’t want me) to do. I feel that it’s all getting old at 30 years old now, and I’ve really started standing on my own two feet and making my own decisions over the past months.

To make a long story short, DH, DS and I are moving 600 miles away in March (we currently live within 10 minutes of my parents and 1 hour of his mother). My mom has come up with so many reasons for me “leaving her,” but I’m not having any of it. It all came to a head when DH and my mom got into a heated argument and unwise words were exchanged.

I’ve chosen (more definitively now) DH over my mother. She thinks I’m being controlled, but it’s her who’s trying to be controlling. However, DH doesn’t want to see or speak to my mother until “he’s ready.” My mom says she has no hard feelings over the blowout.

So DH feels he needs “space.” My parents mentioned they’d like to come with us for a few days when we move to help us set things up. DH is okay with it, but doesn’t want my parents to sleep over at our house just yet.

Recently, his mother stated she’d like to help us move in, too. DH asked me how I would feel if my MIL slept over at our house. I told him that it would be unfair to have only one set of parents to be “allowed” to stay over at our house, and that they should be treated equally. If my parents need to get a hotel, his mother should need to get one, as well. If one set can stay at the house, the other should be able to, as well. I don’t think it’s asking too much to allow my mother to stay at our house (if his is, too) for one or two nights. If the situation were reversed, and I had a blowout with his mother, I’d suck up my feelings (if I still had them as long) for a couple of nights.

He says my MIL is on a fixed income, which is true, but I stood by my word and even offered the idea of paying for a hotel for MIL for a few nights. That idea didn’t sit well, so now MIL just won’t come on the trip.

I offered two options (both sets of parents staying at the house or paying a hotel for his mother) that were rejected. Would you have done anything differently? I felt I was fair, but would like objective opinions. Are there any other options for this situation that you might have done?

Now, DS’s birthday is the month after we move, and I’m sure the same situation will come up again when the parents come to visit. If DH still “doesn’t feel like” seeing my mother/letting her stay over, fine, and my mother doesn’t need to know who stays where if it’s just her and my dad in town. If both sets of parents are coming to town, though, to be obviously exclusive is a bit rude to me.

Ideas or suggestions? Comments?
 
I think you handled it very well.

I cannot think of anything would have done differently.

Peace
James
 
You seem to have a very good grasp on being objective. I pray that I can be as-level minded as you are when I’m dealing with my future spouse’s in-laws one day.

I think your DH might be acting a bit unreasonable here. It doesn’t make sense that he would be OK having your mom stay over during the day but not during the night. Does your new home have separate bedrooms? Personally, I would think sleep-overs would be easier then day-visits since there is less interaction at night and there’s always the option to “shut the door”.
 
Hi all, wondering if you could provide a bit of advice (sorry it’s a bit long):

My mom has always been overprotective of me. Oftentimes, I wouldn’t know what I wanted because I would do what she wanted me (or didn’t want me) to do. I feel that it’s all getting old at 30 years old now, and I’ve really started standing on my own two feet and making my own decisions over the past months.

To make a long story short, DH, DS and I are moving 600 miles away in March (we currently live within 10 minutes of my parents and 1 hour of his mother). My mom has come up with so many reasons for me “leaving her,” but I’m not having any of it. It all came to a head when DH and my mom got into a heated argument and unwise words were exchanged.

I’ve chosen (more definitively now) DH over my mother. She thinks I’m being controlled, but it’s her who’s trying to be controlling. However, DH doesn’t want to see or speak to my mother until “he’s ready.” My mom says she has no hard feelings over the blowout.

So DH feels he needs “space.” My parents mentioned they’d like to come with us for a few days when we move to help us set things up. DH is okay with it, but doesn’t want my parents to sleep over at our house just yet.

Recently, his mother stated she’d like to help us move in, too. DH asked me how I would feel if my MIL slept over at our house. I told him that it would be unfair to have only one set of parents to be “allowed” to stay over at our house, and that they should be treated equally. If my parents need to get a hotel, his mother should need to get one, as well. If one set can stay at the house, the other should be able to, as well. I don’t think it’s asking too much to allow my mother to stay at our house (if his is, too) for one or two nights. If the situation were reversed, and I had a blowout with his mother, I’d suck up my feelings (if I still had them as long) for a couple of nights.

He says my MIL is on a fixed income, which is true, but I stood by my word and even offered the idea of paying for a hotel for MIL for a few nights. That idea didn’t sit well, so now MIL just won’t come on the trip.

I offered two options (both sets of parents staying at the house or paying a hotel for his mother) that were rejected. Would you have done anything differently? I felt I was fair, but would like objective opinions. Are there any other options for this situation that you might have done?

Now, DS’s birthday is the month after we move, and I’m sure the same situation will come up again when the parents come to visit. If DH still “doesn’t feel like” seeing my mother/letting her stay over, fine, and my mother doesn’t need to know who stays where if it’s just her and my dad in town. If both sets of parents are coming to town, though, to be obviously exclusive is a bit rude to me.

Ideas or suggestions? Comments?
I don’t think it wise to equate treatment of the parents like you have. Your mother, whom you describe as controlling, has had a blow out with your husband, has accused your husband falsely (as you’ve stated) and as a consequence your husband is not comfortable having her over night. So far so good. Seems your mother is sewing what she has reaped.

However, now out of a sense of “fairness”, you’ve also insisted that your husband’s mother be treated similarly. But why? What has she done? What is your justification for this “equality”? To spare your mother her feelings? To punish your husband? Big mistake.

In essence you’ve now punished your husband’s mother for your mother’s actions. I think this is foolish. Also, you’ve just given your mother another way of controlling your family.

Obviously, your mother needs firm boundaries. But why insist that everyone be treated that way. It will go a long way to clearly show your mother the consequence of her actions. If she stands in the way of you and your husband, she needs to be corrected.

I strongly suggest you reevaluate why you believe “it would be unfair to have only one set of parents to be “allowed” to stay over at our house, and that they should be treated equally.” What is unfair about this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top