Family drama

  • Thread starter Thread starter Keran
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Keran

Guest
IWe are having a large family gathering tomorrow night which will include my parents, siblings, their spouses and numerous neices and nephews. We are a big mix of personalities with a number of us being rather outspoken. It seems that lately when we have these gatherings, my sisters, who are not conservative people will bring up controversial issues and broadcast their very liberal opinions. When I speak my opposing opinion, however calmly, things always tend to get a little heated. They always behave as if I am attacking them which I don’t mean to, I just seem to have very different opinions than they do. Any advice on how to avoid this, other than keeping my mouth shut?
 
Your scenario sounds familiar. The problem is that the ultra liberal crowd for some reason can’t handle an opposing view and tends to react in a really emotional way. It has happened to me so many times. Don’t keep your mouth shut, state your opinion but perhaps keep it at that. Don’t let them pull you into an argument. If possible point out to them that they are behaving in an immature and irrational way by not being willing to listen to your opinion without making a scene out of it.
 
They become defensive because they feel criticized and judged by your opinions, that’s why they would become heated. You see more things as sinful and disordered than they do, and to them it would sound like you think you are better than they.
Nobody like to be told that the attitudes that they think are normal for what they feel are perfectly good reasons, are in fact wrong/against gospel /against Catechism teaching/against Canon Law.

Obviously it rankles with them or they wouldn’t keep bringing things up. They’re not going to convince you, and you aren’t likely to convince them, so all that is left on both sides is hurt feelings.

Regarding those matters upon which the family challenges you, you could look up and copy gospel passages, appropriate excerpts from Catechism and Canon Law and Papal Encyclicals so that you have the information with you or have the information clear in your mind, although that may or may not have a good reception.

Or if you don’t want to do any of those things, and wish to avoid argument, you could say firmly that this is a family occasion and it’s not the time or place to disturb family peace so nobody talk about controversial issues. You need to decide what is the priority on this occasion.

Prayer for them and for family peace.
 
IWe are having a large family gathering tomorrow night which will include my parents, siblings, their spouses and numerous neices and nephews. We are a big mix of personalities with a number of us being rather outspoken. It seems that lately when we have these gatherings, my sisters, who are not conservative people will bring up controversial issues and broadcast their very liberal opinions. When I speak my opposing opinion, however calmly, things always tend to get a little heated. They always behave as if I am attacking them which I don’t mean to, I just seem to have very different opinions than they do. Any advice on how to avoid this, other than keeping my mouth shut?
You are a lucky person on having such large family gatherings. So, DO NOT spoil them.
What do you want: to win an argument or having a fine family time?
It is up to you to decide.
It is so important to nod a few times when your sisters share their views? Will you lose your faith? Will the world end? Are you going to change your sister’s views?
Just tell a few jokes, do not say anything that brings fights and bad will and have a nice time… Have your sisters…that the most pretious thing you have…
But if you want to win the arguments, it is up to you but you may lose your sisters…
Now, look: in the year 3000, what happened to your arguments? Would the world be different, having you behaved one way or the other?
Maybe, your sisters are talking that way as they are searching for someone to unerstand them, for maybe, they are not feeling well on the way they are.
God knows…
…for it is impossible for a man to understant what a woman wants…
…such said my father-in-law who was married for 62 years…
So, be gentle, maybe you are fighting your sisters in one point and they are saying another thing completely different !!!

Finally, do not hear me…hear the ladies around…
 
. Any advice on how to avoid this, other than keeping my mouth shut?
advice DD got from her MIL who has a similar problem:
smile and wave (like the queen)
in other words you just ignore their inflammatory remarks–which is what they are, they are baiting as they did in childhood–and assume all attention directed at you, the queen, is beneficent, just smile and wave
 
Some good advice above.

I’m not too crazy about the idea of keeping your mouth shut…silence conveys consent…
However, it might depend on the specific issue, timing, location, who’s around etc…

The big thing is to not get drawn into arguments. Reasoned debates are fine, but arguments - no…

Much can depend on how the issue(s) come up, in what context and whether it seems that other opinions are welcome.
I would avoid using phrases like “I disagree with that” (their opinion) and substitute, “well I think that…”. This way, when they jump on your view, you can simply say that they have their opinion and you have yours…
If they wish to push it, you might offer to have a discussion with them on the matter at another time when there is not so much going on and you can both present your arguments more fully without interruption…

If the subject is such that you feel that a discussion is truly needed then and there, ask them to present their views clearly, listen carefully without interruption, and then ask them to remain quiet while you present your view. If they try to interrupt you stop - say, “I listened to you without interruption, please do me the same courtesy”. If that does not work then simply stop, get up and walk away - and be sure to do it while they are still talking.
In this way, everyone around will know who is the more reasoned and thoughtful person (you) and who is the aggressor bully.

Peace
James
 
IWe are having a large family gathering tomorrow night which will include my parents, siblings, their spouses and numerous neices and nephews. We are a big mix of personalities with a number of us being rather outspoken. It seems that lately when we have these gatherings, my sisters, who are not conservative people will bring up controversial issues and broadcast their very liberal opinions.
My first question is who are they talking to? If they are loud and you overhear them… They may see it as you butting into their conversation. If you are talking to someone else, ignore them and continue talking to whoever you were talking to about something else
When I speak my opposing opinion, however calmly, things always tend to get a little heated.
If they are talking to you, then I would say exactly what you said above with a different twist eg 'I just feel that whenever I try to express my opinion things get heated. Why not just respect each other’s opinion and talk about something else. Wasn’t that the best salad you ever had?
They always behave as if I am attacking them which I don’t mean to, I just seem to have very different opinions than they do. Any advice on how to avoid this, other than keeping my mouth shut?
Well… if a number of you are rather outspoken as you mentioned above… they will feel attacked. Ot they could simply be the type that feels attacked no matter how nice you are. So why not turn the tables? ‘Whenver you bring these matters up, I feel you are attacking me. I need to know ‘do you respect that I have different views?’’ Then if they attack you say ‘Ok, I am not going to fight. I will never change my mind and you will never change yours and I have better things to do than run in circles on this arguement’

CM
 
Ignore them and don’t say anything. They are wanting a fight. I’ve had experiences with these situations. They are probably WANTING some strife. Don’t let their low self esteem ruin the get-together.

Let us know how it goes!!!

:hug1:
 
advice DD got from her MIL who has a similar problem:
smile and wave (like the queen)
in other words you just ignore their inflammatory remarks–which is what they are, they are baiting as they did in childhood–and assume all attention directed at you, the queen, is beneficent, just smile and wave
I LOVE this advice! I think listening to the conversation without becoming entangled does NOT signal agreement, it signals that you can control yourself!

Debating with people who are running on mostly emotion is fruitless, because you can’t debate emotions, only ideas. You will know when someone is emotion-driven if their reactions to ideas are extreme, and become irrational as more time elapses and especially if someone disagrees with those ideas.

I have a lot of family members who are on opposite sides of the political spectrum from me. And only 1 or 2 of them are Catholic. So when we get together, I am careful to avoid these subjects. I still love them, they are my kin, and we can differ in our beliefs and yet still love one another. If the subjects arose through others, I would simply keep my mouth shut or drift away, “Oh, that potato salad was so yummy, I MUST have more…excuse me for a minute…”

Discretion is the better part of valor.
 
Well, I would take a different tact.

I would provide the counter argument to whatever they feel obligated to espouse. If the react in a hostile, immature and defensive manner. I would hold up my hand and say, OK. Stop. If you can not carry on an adult conversation and discussion on an issue then you really should remain quiet. Your constant espousal of views without intending to enter into a rational discussion is deeply offensive to me and hurtful when you show such little respect for my opinions. Let’s just not discuss this, ok? How about them Raiders!!!
 
Thank you, everyone. for your lovely family peace advice. I will always love my sisters. Somtimes we argue and get angry but we get over it very quickly. Last night was lovely with no controversy or arguing. I just ate and drank a little too much and enjoyed seeing my parents, all the kids and 2 family members new puppies:)

The last two family gatherings that I am thinking of that ended with some heated discussions were: They were discussing something to do with homosexuality and when I offered my opinion, it was apparently the wrong opinion. I will probably just avoid that subject from now on. The other heated discussion had to do with criticism of my parenting. My 14 year old son was asking to spend the night with my sister on a Saturday night and I was having a quiet discussion with him about how I wanted him to make sure he went to Mass the next morning. My other sister who is no longer a practicing Catholic kept repeatedly making comments form across the room during the conversation that went something like this: “You don’t need to go to church. God is everywhere. I wouldn’t make my son go to church…” I took offense and after several minutes asked her to refrain from telling me how to raise my children. We didn’t stay mad at each other.
 
Just get them to talk about themselves. Then tune out when the tone settles down to a pleasant babble. They really just want to be heard, anyways. Since they want to be heard and validated, when you think about it, that’s really the Christian thing to do, anyways. You can have spirited discussions with friends who are capable of discussing without taking things personally and letting it degenerate into a fight.

“I see,” “um, hmm,” “and then what happened?” work really well to keep the monologue flowing.

If they press you for your opinion, you can sidestep the bait by saying, “oh, I don’t know, what you are saying is really far more interesting. Please do go on!”

People love to talk about themselves. If you let them do exactly that, you will be considered a scintillating conversationalist. Manipulative? Maybe. But isn’t it worth it to avoid what you are calling “family drama?” I think so, and I have one of the most dramatic and operatic families you could think of! I just prefer to live my life in peace, and try to enjoy their company. If not trying to fight, they can be pretty entertaining. If an actual opportunity to effectively evangelize or catechize presents itself, I believe the Holy Spirit will bring it to my attention and I will be able to do so gracefully, without giving offense or causing a fight. That wouldn’t be effective–hearts and minds are more responsive when a message is delivered via velvet glove than nuclear warhead!

And an occasional “pass the bean dip, please,” doesn’t hurt, either.
 
Glad things went well! :hug1:

About the conversation with your son, what nerve that lady has! She reminds me of a couple of folks in my family…
 
point well taken. get them talking about themselves.

they criticize your childrearing, turn the conversation:
so tell me, has your son gotten out of juvie yet?
tell me about your 4 year old’s beauty pageant how did that go?

they criticize your religion:
so, how about them Lions/Browns/Broncs whatever team is playing the big game?
in fact a good way to bust up a family argument is pass around the betting sheets for the game

when they ask for an opinion on a moral issue from you, the Designated Catholic, just say:
if you really want to know what the Church teaches I will give you a good book and we can talk about it at a more appropriate time. If you are trying to start an argument, I have to go stir the gravy.

I think we need to start this thread each year well before thanksgiving, or however long it takes for our prescribed anti-anxiety drugs to kick in before the holidays.

for years I took the kids to my folks, or DH took them to his, alternating holidays and years, while the other one “had to work or study” simply to avoid the drama. I was not above diagnosing a child with a contagious illness to get out of a nightmare either. (that is how I avoided my brother’s mountaintop wedding on new year’s eve to a practicing Wicca lady).

In all my 42 years of marriage I have only hosted TG once, when I served cornish game hens, wild rice with mushrooms, veggies from our garden and apparently so upset my in-laws that he had a minor heart attack because I deviated from tradition. In future years I learned I do not know the proper way to chop celery, mash potatoes, make gravy, or any other skill, so I have never been allowed in the kitchen. we all have our minor victories in the battle of family life.
 
point well taken. get them talking about themselves.

they criticize your childrearing, turn the conversation:
so tell me, has your son gotten out of juvie yet?
tell me about your 4 year old’s beauty pageant how did that go?

they criticize your religion:
so, how about them Lions/Browns/Broncs whatever team is playing the big game?
in fact a good way to bust up a family argument is pass around the betting sheets for the game

when they ask for an opinion on a moral issue from you, the Designated Catholic, just say:
if you really want to know what the Church teaches I will give you a good book and we can talk about it at a more appropriate time. If you are trying to start an argument, I have to go stir the gravy.

I think we need to start this thread each year well before thanksgiving, or however long it takes for our prescribed anti-anxiety drugs to kick in before the holidays.

for years I took the kids to my folks, or DH took them to his, alternating holidays and years, while the other one “had to work or study” simply to avoid the drama. I was not above diagnosing a child with a contagious illness to get out of a nightmare either. (that is how I avoided my brother’s mountaintop wedding on new year’s eve to a practicing Wicca lady).

In all my 42 years of marriage I have only hosted TG once, when I served cornish game hens, wild rice with mushrooms, veggies from our garden and apparently so upset my in-laws that he had a minor heart attack because I deviated from tradition.** In future years I learned I do not know the proper way to chop celery, mash potatoes, make gravy, or any other skill, so I have never been allowed in the kitchen. we all have our minor victories in the battle of family life.**
Your post made me LOL several times. The last paragraph was so funny! The absurdities of family…we all do what we have to in order to survive…LOL

🤷
 
point well taken. get them talking about themselves.

they criticize your childrearing, turn the conversation:
so tell me, has your son gotten out of juvie yet?
tell me about your 4 year old’s beauty pageant how did that go?

they criticize your religion:
so, how about them Lions/Browns/Broncs whatever team is playing the big game?
in fact a good way to bust up a family argument is pass around the betting sheets for the game

when they ask for an opinion on a moral issue from you, the Designated Catholic, just say:
if you really want to know what the Church teaches I will give you a good book and we can talk about it at a more appropriate time. If you are trying to start an argument, I have to go stir the gravy.

I think we need to start this thread each year well before thanksgiving, or however long it takes for our prescribed anti-anxiety drugs to kick in before the holidays.

for years I took the kids to my folks, or DH took them to his, alternating holidays and years, while the other one “had to work or study” simply to avoid the drama. I was not above diagnosing a child with a contagious illness to get out of a nightmare either. (that is how I avoided my brother’s mountaintop wedding on new year’s eve to a practicing Wicca lady).

In all my 42 years of marriage I have only hosted TG once, when I served cornish game hens, wild rice with mushrooms, veggies from our garden and apparently so upset my in-laws that he had a minor heart attack because I deviated from tradition. In future years I learned I do not know the proper way to chop celery, mash potatoes, make gravy, or any other skill, so I have never been allowed in the kitchen. we all have our minor victories in the battle of family life.
Love it!

Sad thing is her son (and I love him dearly) is 18, a former honor student and star athlete, has been arrested several times and smokes pot. Last year when she and my BIL left him home for a week, one of his friends came to my sister when she got home and told her he was concerned that her son was snorting pain pills. He also was sporting a lovely homemade swastika tattoo on his ankle. He is not a Nazi. He passed out and his “friends” carved that on his ankle as a joke. She never made him go to Mass, thank goodness!
 
Our family drama has officially started this year! My in laws are Catholic yet they see nothing wrong with homosexual “marraiges” and expect my husband and I to agree with those “marraiges” and embrace them wholeheartedly. Because my husband and I can’t validate those, we are called all sorts of names. The sad thing is our children are the ones that miss out on getting to know grandma and grandpa or rather they are missing out on our children. Out of all my husbands siblings, we are the only family with children that are strong in their faith (never been in jail, gangs, mental hospitals, suicidal…the list goes on). Yet we are criticized for the way we raise them. We were just informed by my mother in law that the "ONLY"reason our oldest daughter and her fiance aren’t living together yet is because she is afraid of us. Our daughter and her fiance each have their own apartments, she has a roommate, and I know that they’re getting married because They want to. We have tried to instil morals in our children, and I can’t say they’ve not tested what we’ve tried to teach. Luckily the lessons they’ve learned thru rebellion have been learned alot quicker than it took us sometimes. I just dread the holidays, especially around that side of the family, and now with one of the nephews being openly gay and bringing different partners around I really don’t want to go over there. But in not going I know it’s going to make the division between us and the in laws even bigger…I’m at a loss.
 
Looks like there might just be a whole lot of lunches out taking place this year!!!

😉

Seriously. I just love the idea of taking these people out in a public place to help contain the circus acts to one ring instead of 3.

Maybe we should start a “Take Your Difficult Relative(s) to Lunch” Day…needs to hit before or just after Thanksgiving.
 
Looks like there might just be a whole lot of lunches out taking place this year!!!

Seriously. I just love the idea of taking these people out in a public place to help contain the circus acts to one ring instead of 3.

.
don’t suppose you want to hear the story about the year we went to the Ritz Carlton for afternoon “tea” with “dah girls”. Nah, why inject more tension in the discussion. There just happened to be one of the “girls” who invited herself who is a self-designated non-DNA verified “girl”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top