Family Planning

  • Thread starter Thread starter TBenedicta
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TBenedicta

Guest
Hello All,

I’m seeking prayer and advice regarding how a young couple should plan their family according to God’s will. My DH and I have been married for 10 months. We are both 22 years old (we met in first grade!) and have always had the desire for a large family. So why don’t we have children yet? The crux of the issue is this: DH just started medical school (an expensive venture) and I scarcely make enough money as a nanny to cover our living expenses. Financially speaking, if we were to conceive, it would make much more sense for me to stay home with our child… and yet, obviously, DH is still a student and will be for three more years, so we would be living off of student loans. Our souls battle between the desire to be good stewards of our financial blessings (i.e. live frugally, tithe regularly, and adhere to responsibility over excess) and the desire to start a family.

We know we were called to be married young. We *know *DH was called to become a doctor. We know we are called to be parents… but we don’t know when to start a family.

We have prayed over it extensively and not a day goes by where one or both of us don’t sigh and remark how we wish we knew whether the time is right or not.

We still don’t have an answer! Do we take a leap of faith and start trying for a family, offering our finances and trust to God? Or do we continue with our current plan: practice NFP faithfully for the next two years so that I can work to provide for our living expenses instead of tacking them onto student loans. (We have seen other students live completely off of student loans… but DH and I are cautious individuals and are truly frightened at the thought of throwing a child into the living-off-of-loans mix.) Help! And thank you.

Blessings,
Sarah
 
Hello All,

I’m seeking prayer and advice regarding how a young couple should plan their family according to God’s will. My DH and I have been married for 10 months. We are both 22 years old (we met in first grade!) and have always had the desire for a large family. So why don’t we have children yet? The crux of the issue is this: DH just started medical school (an expensive venture) and I scarcely make enough money as a nanny to cover our living expenses. Financially speaking, if we were to conceive, it would make much more sense for me to stay home with our child… and yet, obviously, DH is still a student and will be for three more years, so we would be living off of student loans. Our souls battle between the desire to be good stewards of our financial blessings (i.e. live frugally, tithe regularly, and adhere to responsibility over excess) and the desire to start a family.

We know we were called to be married young. We *know *DH was called to become a doctor. We know we are called to be parents… but we don’t know when to start a family.

We have prayed over it extensively and not a day goes by where one or both of us don’t sigh and remark how we wish we knew whether the time is right or not.

We still don’t have an answer! Do we take a leap of faith and start trying for a family, offering our finances and trust to God? Or do we continue with our current plan: practice NFP faithfully for the next two years so that I can work to provide for our living expenses instead of tacking them onto student loans. (We have seen other students live completely off of student loans… but DH and I are cautious individuals and are truly frightened at the thought of throwing a child into the living-off-of-loans mix.) Help! And thank you.

Blessings,
Sarah
You’re in pretty much the same financial position as me. I got married a year ago, but I still have to work because my husband doesn’t make enough money to support the both of us by himself.

If you plan on having a baby right now, you wouldn’t be able to be a stay at home mom because you’d have to work to earn money while your husband finishes med school. If you do decide you want a baby right now, I guess you’d have to be ok with leaving her/him at day care while you worked.

If you’re cool with that, go for it! If not, wait until your husband is doing residency. He should start making some money by then so you could stay at home with the baby.

I’m personally waiting for my husband to make enough so that I can quit working and be a stay at home mom for my child.

Good luck and congrats on the wedding!!
 
I am in a different but similar situation. My fiance and I are getting married in June. We are both open to having children but do not feel like we will be ready for a while after we get married. More importantly, our financial situation will not be ideal. I will be graduating in the spring so I may or may not have a job, and even if I do get a job, it will be a teaching job so I won’t be making a lot of money. He is currently employed but is only paid hourly. We have lots of student loans, and even living frugually, I think we will struggle a bit financially. I know that this is not the ideal situation to be getting married into either, but we are positive that this is our calling. We have been dating for over 5 years. We are currently taking NFP Creighton classes, and I’m starting to wonder if we’re being a little selfish about not wanting to have children right away. Although I am starting to open up to the idea of having children as soon as we get married, I’m extremely worried that our financial situation will not be good for the child(ren).

I really don’t have any advice for you, but I thought it might help to know that there are other people in similar situations as yours. Keep me updated on what you decide to do!
 
I am in a different but similar situation. My fiance and I are getting married in June. We are both open to having children but do not feel like we will be ready for a while after we get married. More importantly, our financial situation will not be ideal. I will be graduating in the spring so I may or may not have a job, and even if I do get a job, it will be a teaching job so I won’t be making a lot of money. He is currently employed but is only paid hourly. We have lots of student loans, and even living frugually, I think we will struggle a bit financially. I know that this is not the ideal situation to be getting married into either, but we are positive that this is our calling. We have been dating for over 5 years. We are currently taking NFP Creighton classes, and I’m starting to wonder if we’re being a little selfish about not wanting to have children right away. Although I am starting to open up to the idea of having children as soon as we get married, I’m extremely worried that our financial situation will not be good for the child(ren).

I really don’t have any advice for you, but I thought it might help to know that there are other people in similar situations as yours. Keep me updated on what you decide to do!
I wouldn’t say you’re being selfish (though in the end it is between you and God whether you are or not).

Sounds like you’re just being responsible and want to establish a good environment to bring children into so that they can be well taken care of. 👍

Things aren’t like they used to be 30 years ago.
 
You are making sure someone else’s children are well cared for, so why not expand that to your own child? Can’t you bring your child to that job as well since the job is very geared toward being all about the children?
You sound like a responsible married couple. Consider being open to the blessing of children in your marriage at this time. You have 9 months to prepare if you are blessed right away as well. If you both think if you want to have a large family starting now is not a bad idea, it can also lessen your breast cancer risk. There are no guarantees you will get pregnant right away anyway. Starting now could be quite a blessing in the future since fertility is not always guaranteed. It is a gift for a short time in a woman’s life, some people’s shorter than others. Many people are surprised when things don’t happen right away. My husband and I were happily married but waited for years for the right time due only to finances. There is not a right time, people told us this, and it is true. I have always been healthy but a medical problem came out of nowhere in my 20’s. I was told I should have a hysterectomy despite not having any children. We thought we were being smart those years but by being so focused on money and everything being “perfect” before even trying to conceive we could have lost our opportunity to have biological children. My story isn’t unique but I really wish we had left it totally up to God more. God bless.
 
No, things are not like they were 30 years ago, families were stronger then.
 
Hello All,

I’m seeking prayer and advice regarding how a young couple should plan their family according to God’s will. My DH and I have been married for 10 months. We are both 22 years old (we met in first grade!) and have always had the desire for a large family. So why don’t we have children yet? The crux of the issue is this: DH just started medical school (an expensive venture) and I scarcely make enough money as a nanny to cover our living expenses. Financially speaking, if we were to conceive, it would make much more sense for me to stay home with our child… and yet, obviously, DH is still a student and will be for three more years, so we would be living off of student loans. Our souls battle between the desire to be good stewards of our financial blessings (i.e. live frugally, tithe regularly, and adhere to responsibility over excess) and the desire to start a family.

We know we were called to be married young. We *know *DH was called to become a doctor. We know we are called to be parents… but we don’t know when to start a family.

We have prayed over it extensively and not a day goes by where one or both of us don’t sigh and remark how we wish we knew whether the time is right or not.

We still don’t have an answer! Do we take a leap of faith and start trying for a family, offering our finances and trust to God? Or do we continue with our current plan: practice NFP faithfully for the next two years so that I can work to provide for our living expenses instead of tacking them onto student loans. (We have seen other students live completely off of student loans… but DH and I are cautious individuals and are truly frightened at the thought of throwing a child into the living-off-of-loans mix.) Help! And thank you.

Blessings,
Sarah
Do not feel it is YOUR problem alone. Do not feel alone.
In Christ’s time, it was common for people to get married at 15/19 years of age.
Nowadays with studies, there are women at 30 still progressing in their work and feeling that time is running out in their lives.
Yours is a similar situation.
I simply do not know how to solve your problem.
But i could give you simple principles, common sense principles. Nevertheless, if you feel they are wrong, just throw them away:
  • you cannot have it all: long studies, big families, short salaries, christian life, enjoy life, be frugile…
  • so, you must choose. do not feel bad in missing something: it is life. you cannot have it all, that is a rule of life.
  • you are a responsible person, person who looks for answers, a person who reflects, who knows what life is about, who thinks and plans.
  • so, I will pray for you. dialogue with your partner and choose, after praying to God.
God will love you.
 
I know that this is not the ideal situation to be getting married into either, but we are positive that this is our calling. We have been dating for over 5 years. We are currently taking NFP Creighton classes, and I’m starting to wonder if we’re being a little selfish about not wanting to have children right away. Although I am starting to open up to the idea of having children as soon as we get married, I’m extremely worried that our financial situation will not be good for the child(ren).

I really don’t have any advice for you, but I thought it might help to know that there are other people in similar situations as yours. Keep me updated on what you decide to do!
I feel exactly the same way as you. I know from experience as a nanny that children truly don’t need much to be happy and well-adjusted. They need love, guidance, and strong faith. (Which we have plenty of!) So, sometimes I too wonder if I’m being a bit selfish and seeing things the way the rest of our career, money-oriented society does. 😦
 
Health insurance is a big one as well. Do you have that?
Thanks for your responses! Very helpful to hear others’ points of view 🙂

We do have health insurance and made sure to opt into a plan that has maternity coverage. Without getting into the details of our finances, our budget has us looking into starting a family at the end of M2 (so, just under two years.) By then I will have put in 2 years of salary/savings to mitigate his student loan debt. For the remaining 2 years of his schooling, we would have to live off of student loans exclusively, which is no different than what non-married students do their entire 4 years. DH’s loans will be low enough that he can pay them off in 10 years if we live frugally, which we prefer anyway 🙂

It’s just frustrating because God has given me such an intense desire for children that I sometimes wonder if we shouldn’t start trying now. (Logically I know we shouldn’t… but this isn’t a question of mere finances or logic. It’s a question of faith and living life as God has called us to do. Having children during medical school will certainly require immense sacrifice and more loans than we would have if I continued working all four years. But contrary to what many people think, sacrifice, frugality, and family are something to celebrate. It might make us seem crazy to others, but we care much more about how we appear to God than anyone else!)
 
Do not feel it is YOUR problem alone. Do not feel alone.
In Christ’s time, it was common for people to get married at 15/19 years of age.
Nowadays with studies, there are women at 30 still progressing in their work and feeling that time is running out in their lives.
Yours is a similar situation.
I simply do not know how to solve your problem.
But i could give you simple principles, common sense principles. Nevertheless, if you feel they are wrong, just throw them away:
  • you cannot have it all: long studies, big families, short salaries, christian life, enjoy life, be frugile…
  • so, you must choose. do not feel bad in missing something: it is life. you cannot have it all, that is a rule of life.
  • you are a responsible person, person who looks for answers, a person who reflects, who knows what life is about, who thinks and plans.
  • so, I will pray for you. dialogue with your partner and choose, after praying to God.
God will love you.
Thank you. Blessings to you! 🙂
 
You are making sure someone else’s children are well cared for, so why not expand that to your own child? Can’t you bring your child to that job as well since the job is very geared toward being all about the children?
You sound like a responsible married couple. Consider being open to the blessing of children in your marriage at this time. You have 9 months to prepare if you are blessed right away as well. If you both think if you want to have a large family starting now is not a bad idea, it can also lessen your breast cancer risk. There are no guarantees you will get pregnant right away anyway. Starting now could be quite a blessing in the future since fertility is not always guaranteed. It is a gift for a short time in a woman’s life, some people’s shorter than others. Many people are surprised when things don’t happen right away. My husband and I were happily married but waited for years for the right time due only to finances. There is not a right time, people told us this, and it is true. I have always been healthy but a medical problem came out of nowhere in my 20’s. I was told I should have a hysterectomy despite not having any children. We thought we were being smart those years but by being so focused on money and everything being “perfect” before even trying to conceive we could have lost our opportunity to have biological children. My story isn’t unique but I really wish we had left it totally up to God more. God bless.
Thank you. I’m truly sorry for your suffering, but your story and wisdom has blessed me.
 
Another thing probably worth mentioning is you should decide what is truly necessary to survive. You probably won’t be able to afford a nice vacation, or nice clothes etc, but maybe having a child outweighs that.

It might mean going through some lean times, but if you are all being fed, cared for, clothed and sheltered, the rest is negotiable. A lot of people – particularly those who are affluent and have children late – want to wait until they’ve essentially saved up for the kid’s college before he’s even born! I think it’s good to be prepared, but not hyper-prepared
 
It’s just frustrating because God has given me such an intense desire for children that I sometimes wonder if we shouldn’t start trying now. (Logically I know we shouldn’t… but this isn’t a question of mere finances or logic. It’s a question of faith and living life as God has called us to do. Having children during medical school will certainly require immense sacrifice and more loans than we would have if I continued working all four years. But contrary to what many people think, sacrifice, frugality, and family are something to celebrate. It might make us seem crazy to others, but we care much more about how we appear to God than anyone else!)
Good for you! 👍

Do what you think is best for yourself, your husband, and your future children… whatever that may be. Good luck and God bless!
 
Sarah,

Here is the brillance of God’s design. The decision to have sex is yours. The decision when to have sex is yours. Whether or not a child is conceived is up to God. Certainly there is a bit of chance involved. You increase your chances when you’re fertile. You decrease your chances when you are infertile. But I’m going to tell you this. If you practice NFP perfectly and end up pregnant its not like you’re the Blessed Virgin who had zero chance of getting pregnant.

I would advise you to focus on that. Every sexual act is an Yes to God, a lifting up of trust. A handing over of the fate of your life to God. That’s why you’re keeping each act oriented toward procreation even during your infertile cycle. You’re still saying yes even if you don’t desire to become a parent and hope to wait a little while.

I would say that you have sufficient reason to be cautious, and to continue abstaining during your fertile time. But I’d say also keep a steady focus on the unitive purpose of sex and your need for unity. Perhaps there will be a day where the need to unite is stronger than the need to prevent. So one day during a fertile period in one month out of 5, you have sex. You increase your chances of getting pregnant, but it doesn’t mean you will get pregnant. Its not a surprise if it happens, but its not a surprise if it doesn’t. Then you can go back to being cautious again.

I think too often we get caught up in this either/or mentality. You’re either trying for a baby or trying to prevent a baby. But to me actively avoiding a baby could get as obsessive as avoiding every fertile day. Meanwhile actively trying for a baby can mean taking every available fertile day. I think its important not to get obsessed with the baby aspect but to keep your hands open. Use the knowledge from NFP but don’t obsess about it. Also take comfort that if you ever have an intensely grave reason to avoid pregnancy, you can indeed practice NFP more strictly.
 
Sarah,

Here is the brillance of God’s design. The decision to have sex is yours. The decision when to have sex is yours. Whether or not a child is conceived is up to God. Certainly there is a bit of chance involved. You increase your chances when you’re fertile. You decrease your chances when you are infertile. But I’m going to tell you this. If you practice NFP perfectly and end up pregnant its not like you’re the Blessed Virgin who had zero chance of getting pregnant.

I would advise you to focus on that. Every sexual act is an Yes to God, a lifting up of trust. A handing over of the fate of your life to God. That’s why you’re keeping each act oriented toward procreation even during your infertile cycle. You’re still saying yes even if you don’t desire to become a parent and hope to wait a little while.

I would say that you have sufficient reason to be cautious, and to continue abstaining during your fertile time. But I’d say also keep a steady focus on the unitive purpose of sex and your need for unity. Perhaps there will be a day where the need to unite is stronger than the need to prevent. So one day during a fertile period in one month out of 5, you have sex. You increase your chances of getting pregnant, but it doesn’t mean you will get pregnant. Its not a surprise if it happens, but its not a surprise if it doesn’t. Then you can go back to being cautious again.

I think too often we get caught up in this either/or mentality. You’re either trying for a baby or trying to prevent a baby. But to me actively avoiding a baby could get as obsessive as avoiding every fertile day. Meanwhile actively trying for a baby can mean taking every available fertile day. I think its important not to get obsessed with the baby aspect but to keep your hands open. Use the knowledge from NFP but don’t obsess about it. Also take comfort that if you ever have an intensely grave reason to avoid pregnancy, you can indeed practice NFP more strictly.
👍 Excellent post. This is why the Church calls us to NFP. The act of abstaining, which can be difficult at times.
 
👍 Excellent post. This is why the Church calls us to NFP. The act of abstaining, which can be difficult at times.
The Church does not call us to NFP. The Church permits NFP when there is a serious reason and abstaining will lead one or both spouses to sin.
 
But contrary to what many people think, sacrifice, frugality, and family are something to celebrate.
This is a wonderful saying!

I was reading Rome Sweet Home. In that book Kimberly Hahn (she was not a Catholic at this point when considering these things) was considering this same question of family planning and avoiding in marriage. She said, “When I examined what the Scripture had to say about children the witness of the Word was overwhelming. Every verse that spoke about children spoke of them only and always a blessing. There was no proverb that cautioned about the expenses of a child outweighing their worth. There was no blessing pronounced over the man or woman who in their own wisdom had what they considered perfect spacing of children, or the couple who had the right number of childless years before the burden of children, or the husband and wife who had planned contraception. These were thoughts I had learned from the media, public school, and my neighborhood, but they had no foundation in the Word of God”.
“Fertility, in Scripture, was presented as something to be prized and celebrated rather than a disease to be avoided at all cost…God was the one who opened and closed the womb, and, when He gave life, it was only seen as a blessing…Perhaps it was more of an American attitude than a godly one to think of our fertility as something for us to control as we deemed best.” She said that her husband and her were committed to each other and the Lord, but it was a significant leap of faith in their relationship thinking could they really trust God on the blessing of children in their marriage, would God really even have any idea what was best for them, what they could handle financially, spiritually, and emotionally?
 
You probably won’t be able to afford a nice vacation, or nice clothes etc, but maybe having a child outweighs that.
But then again maybe they will later by the time the child(ren) grow up enough to really remember such things. A few years really makes a difference financially for the better for many married couples who are students working towards completing their degrees, internships, etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top