Family Planning

  • Thread starter Thread starter TBenedicta
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a wonderful saying!

I was reading Rome Sweet Home. In that book Kimberly Hahn (she was not a Catholic at this point when considering these things) was considering this same question of family planning and avoiding in marriage. She said, “When I examined what the Scripture had to say about children the witness of the Word was overwhelming. Every verse that spoke about children spoke of them only and always a blessing. There was no proverb that cautioned about the expenses of a child outweighing their worth. There was no blessing pronounced over the man or woman who in their own wisdom had what they considered perfect spacing of children, or the couple who had the right number of childless years before the burden of children, or the husband and wife who had planned contraception. These were thoughts I had learned from the media, public school, and my neighborhood, but they had no foundation in the Word of God”.
“Fertility, in Scripture, was presented as something to be prized and celebrated rather than a disease to be avoided at all cost…God was the one who opened and closed the womb, and, when He gave life, it was only seen as a blessing…Perhaps it was more of an American attitude than a godly one to think of our fertility as something for us to control as we deemed best.” She said that her husband and her were committed to each other and the Lord, but it was a significant leap of faith in their relationship thinking could they really trust God on the blessing of children in their marriage, would God really even have any idea what was best for them, what they could handle financially, spiritually, and emotionally?
👍👍
Aloe, this really hits the nail on the head… Absolutely, our fertility is not something for us to control as we wish. We need to be open to His will and welcome the children He decides to send us, when He decides to send them. We can use NFP when it is necessary to avoid, but it’s not based on what we want. He does know what is best for us, He loves us more than we could ever imagine.

Aloe’s story earlier reminded me a little of my family. My parents had a “honeymoon” baby and welcomed each one of us (4 of us, about 2 yrs apart each) by leaving it all in God’s hands. When they first got married my mom was working on her Master’s and my dad had just graduated and was starting to work (army). Money was so tight mom told us she used to count the eggs and worry about having enough. My dad was hard working and very healthy, very athletic, he ran several miles every morning. Despite all this, he got a fast acting cancer and died when my youngest brother was 1. Had my parents waited to have kids until things were “perfect” (whatever that is), and had they spaced us out more to make it easier on them, there is a very good chance my brother, and possibly I, would not be here. I am thankful for their generosity! 🙂
 
The Church does not call us to NFP. The Church permits NFP when there is a serious reason and abstaining will lead one or both spouses to sin.
Very true, I should have clarified that. We should always be open to life and use NFP as a last resort for VERY grave reasons. Wanting a new car, a bigger home, or vacations not being one of them. 😃
 
Very true, I should have clarified that. We should always be open to life and use NFP as a last resort for VERY grave reasons. Wanting a new car, a bigger home, or vacations not being one of them. 😃
Saying “VERY grave reasons,” sounds and is a bit misleading. The Church doesn’t say we need VERY grave reasons (life/death situation). “Serious reasons” is a more accurate way of explaining to someone what the Church actually teaches in that regard.
 
I didn’t read all the replies so sorry if this has been said. If you did have a baby, you could take in a couple of little ones and be paid like a daycare. If I was dropping off my toddler to go to work, I would rather it was a home environment with a couple of kiddies than a daycare, any day.
 
Saying “VERY grave reasons,” sounds and is a bit misleading. The Church doesn’t say we need VERY grave reasons (life/death situation). “Serious reasons” is a more accurate way of explaining to someone what the Church actually teaches in that regard.
Grave- meriting serious consideration or likely to produce great harm or danger.

If you read Humanae Vitae, the following are cited as reasons to delay pregnancy; “physical, economic, psychological and social conditions.”

Wanting to live in a $100,000+ home, drive two cars, wear name brand clothing, vacation every year and have an IPhone are not serious reasons to avoid pregnancy.
I would wager that the vast majority of those who claim they cannot afford a child could most certainly have several children if they changed their lifestyle. Alas, we are a selfish society who are very materialistic.

I support myself, my wife, and three children so far on my salary. We don’t vacation, we don’t wear name brand clothing, we don’t even have cable TV. We survive.
 
Grave- meriting serious consideration or likely to produce great harm or danger.

If you read Humanae Vitae, the following are cited as reasons to delay pregnancy; “physical, economic, psychological and social conditions.”

Wanting to live in a $100,000+ home, drive two cars, wear name brand clothing, vacation every year and have an IPhone are not serious reasons to avoid pregnancy.
I would wager that the vast majority of those who claim they cannot afford a child could most certainly have several children if they changed their lifestyle. Alas, we are a selfish society who are very materialistic.

I support myself, my wife, and three children so far on my salary. We don’t vacation, we don’t wear name brand clothing, we don’t even have cable TV. We survive.
Using the term “very grave” is incorrect, misleading, and can put undue pressure on a couple. The reasons must be just/serious, but they need not be grave. If you want to take the life/death approach to discern pregnancy you are free to do so - but to say the Church holds us responsible to that is false.

Please see below:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=39854
 
Using the term “very grave” is incorrect, misleading, and can put undue pressure on a couple. The reasons must be just/serious, but they need not be grave. If you want to take the life/death approach to discern pregnancy you are free to do so - but to say the Church holds us responsible to that is false.

Please see below:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=39854
I didn’t say it was life or death.

The couple must also have a properly formed conscious in order to determine whether it is a just reason. As I stated previous, many could have children.
 
From natural-family-planning.info/

NFP for a Just Reason

In most cases, a couple will use NFP only to limit the total number of children and to provide a space of time between births. They must have a just reason to do so, such as the limited resources of the family and the need to provide for existing children. Most couples today meet this standard and can use NFP to limit family size and space births. It is not moral in such cases to attempt to use NFP so strictly as to eliminate the possibility of conception. Using NFP with a contraceptive intention is immoral. The couples’ intentions must be open to life and to the will of God concerning the procreation of children.

NFP for a Grave Reason

If a couple has a serious reason, they may use NFP very strictly, with the aim of avoiding conception entirely. Few couples have such a grave reason, which may include a significant risk to the health or life of the mother if she becomes pregnant, or a similar risk to the health or life of the child. All pregnancies involve some risk, so a grave reason must be well above the ordinary risk of pregnancy.
 
If you absolutely cant afford children, don’t have sex. Abstain until you can afford them.
 
I didn’t say it was life or death.

The couple must also have a properly formed conscious in order to determine whether it is a just reason. As I stated previous, many could have children.
I don’t disagree with this (though as Michelle Arnold said, it is impossible to judge another couple’s family from the outside), I disagree with your use of “very grave reason.”

Such is incorrect.
 
I don’t disagree with this (though as Michelle Arnold said, it is impossible to judge another couple’s family from the outside), I disagree with your use of “very grave reason.”

Such is incorrect.
I am sure you do. Do you not think your doing a disservice to people reading this by insinuating that they can use NFP for trivial reasons?
 
I am sure you do. Do you not think your doing a disservice to people reading this by insinuating that they can use NFP for trivial reasons?
Ummmm please don’t make up lies. :mad:

And please specify where I insinuated that people should use NFP for trivial reasons.

…Wait a minute, you CAN’T. Because I DIDN’T.

I posted a link to a CAF apologist who pointed out that “grave reasons” were not necessary - only JUST reasons.
 
Ummmm please don’t make up lies. :mad:

And please specify where I insinuated that people should use NFP for trivial reasons.

…Wait a minute, you CAN’T. Because I DIDN’T.

I posted a link to a CAF apologist who pointed out that “grave reasons” were not necessary - only JUST reasons.
Re read the thread, you did. I am not arguing with you anymore.
 
Re read the thread, you did. I am not arguing with you anymore.
I DID reread the thread, and I saw NOTHING on there where I insinuated that pregnancy can be postponed for “trivial reasons.” Which is why I asked YOU to copy and paste where I have done so. You did not - because I did no such thing, and you KNOW it.

These are ALL the things I said before you threw this false accusation at me:
Saying “VERY grave reasons,” sounds and is a bit misleading. The Church doesn’t say we need VERY grave reasons (life/death situation). “Serious reasons” is a more accurate way of explaining to someone what the Church actually teaches in that regard.
Using the term “very grave” is incorrect, misleading, and can put undue pressure on a couple. The reasons must be just/serious, but they need not be grave. If you want to take the life/death approach to discern pregnancy you are free to do so - but to say the Church holds us responsible to that is false.

Please see below:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=39854
Originally Posted by Jordan719
Again, please don’t make up blatant lies and publicly accuse me of something I did NOT do. Thank you.
 
I am sure you do. Do you not think your doing a disservice to people reading this by insinuating that they can use NFP for trivial reasons?
Hi, I don’t see where Debora123 suggested that a couple may use NFP for a trivial reason. Since you publicly claimed she did, the Church would say that you owe her the benefit of providing proof, or an apology (per CCC 2477 and 2479 and 2487).

You are right that a desire for a lavish life-style is not a good reason for using NFP. But I have not seen anyone in this thread suggest that this is the case in any of their current situations.

Again, the Church has left the responsibility to each couple to properly discern, with a well-formed conscience, whether they have a just reason to use periodic continence.
 
I have so enjoyed reading and discussing everyone’s answers with my husband. We feel so strongly called to children that using NFP to delay starting our family has felt like a burden- a burden we have offered up to God numerous times in the hopes of a clear answer.

As it is, our “answer” is that we continue using NFP to delay starting a family until next September, when we will not necessarily start “trying” to conceive but will offer full trust to God for our fertility. At that point, I will willingly continue on with my nanny position should the family not object. 🙂 This is the only way that makes financial sense for us, and because we are not by any means a “$100k+, 2 car, vacations” kind of family I feel that we have just cause. (We live on my nanny salary right now- $20k/year- and take out a significant chunk of loans each year for my husband’s education. We have no credit card debt and live frugally. For us, this means: one [very old] car, renting a one-bedroom apartment a bit further from school, baking our own bread, and forgoing cable tv and expensive entertainment.) We certainly don’t feel like we need much to provide for a child, we’re just thinking ahead to when my poor husband will have to pay off all of our student loan debt by himself, on one salary, and of course thinking of any future children we might have! Our current health insurance does not cover maternity care and our new insurance won’t kick in for several months, so at the very least we are hoping to be diligent in NFP until then so that, God-willing, my future pregnancy will be covered. I view these considerations as practical, responsible, and just.

I do not think that they are “grave” but I do think they are “just”. With that said, after our experience using NFP as newlyweds, I am certainly looking forward to the day when we can put NFP permanently behind us and trust in God to “plan” our family. I do not anticipate ever using NFP to the degree we’ve used it thus far, unless it’s to actually conceive a child, not avoid one! 🙂

Thanks everyone for the (name removed by moderator)ut, and God bless. Your prayers for myself, my husband, and our future little ones are much appreciated!

Sarah Teresia Benedicta
 
Hi Sarah, Since you mentioned maternity coverage, and I am not sure what type of insurance you have right now, I thought I would throw it out there that for us, having individual insurance (eg, not through a group from work) it was cheaper to forgo the maternity coverage rider and go with the self-pay discount (pre-paid) at the hospital and OB. I thought I would mention just in case so you can look into it if you wish! 🙂
 
I have so enjoyed reading and discussing everyone’s answers with my husband. We feel so strongly called to children that using NFP to delay starting our family has felt like a burden- a burden we have offered up to God numerous times in the hopes of a clear answer.

As it is, our “answer” is that we continue using NFP to delay starting a family until next September, when we will not necessarily start “trying” to conceive but will offer full trust to God for our fertility. At that point, I will willingly continue on with my nanny position should the family not object. 🙂 This is the only way that makes financial sense for us, and because we are not by any means a “$100k+, 2 car, vacations” kind of family I feel that we have just cause. (We live on my nanny salary right now- $20k/year- and take out a significant chunk of loans each year for my husband’s education. We have no credit card debt and live frugally. For us, this means: one [very old] car, renting a one-bedroom apartment a bit further from school, baking our own bread, and forgoing cable tv and expensive entertainment.) We certainly don’t feel like we need much to provide for a child, we’re just thinking ahead to when my poor husband will have to pay off all of our student loan debt by himself, on one salary, and of course thinking of any future children we might have! Our current health insurance does not cover maternity care and our new insurance won’t kick in for several months, so at the very least we are hoping to be diligent in NFP until then so that, God-willing, my future pregnancy will be covered. I view these considerations as practical, responsible, and just.

I do not think that they are “grave” but I do think they are “just”. With that said, after our experience using NFP as newlyweds, I am certainly looking forward to the day when we can put NFP permanently behind us and trust in God to “plan” our family. I do not anticipate ever using NFP to the degree we’ve used it thus far, unless it’s to actually conceive a child, not avoid one! 🙂

Thanks everyone for the (name removed by moderator)ut, and God bless. Your prayers for myself, my husband, and our future little ones are much appreciated!

Sarah Teresia Benedicta
I’m glad we were able to help, and I am glad you have put a responsible amount of thought into your decision. 🙂

I will pray that God give you patience while you wait till September.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top