J
Juris
Guest
What are your thoughts on fasting?
Wednesday, Friday fasting/abstinence tradition is from an anciet Jewish tradition, that was adopted by the first Christians. During Lent we do fasting on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday and abstinence every Friday. Although Friday is nolonger an abstinence day outside of Lent, it is still a day of penence. If you don’t observe abstinence/fasting on Fridays you must do something else as a penitent act ( a small service to the poor, some volunteer work etc. if you can ).Cadian: Is there a reason why you do it on Wednesday?
Fr. John Corapi says “Just do It!” when he speaks about the Rosary.I think fasting is a bit like Nike: you gotta “Just do It!”
(I hate Nike, by the way, but they have a good catch-phrase).
Ok to be more correct then fasting is a form of Mortification in the catagory of self denial. And your example is an example of this type of Morification that is offered in prayer.Fasting need not always be from food. Sometimes it can be “fasting” from some words I might utter in impatience or something else the Lord would have me fast from.
This is a little too general as a statement. Fasting is not “highly impractical” it CAN be in certain circumstances but, not as a general rule.Sometimes fasting from food is highly impractical and damaging as it causes uncharitableness or even spiritual pride.
Right, hence the adverb “sometimes.”Fasting is not “highly impractical” it CAN be in certain circumstances but, not as a general rule.
Not “if done to,” which implies a conscious end result, but can lead to even involuntarily. If any mortification leads to spiritual pride, whether voluntarily or involuntarily, intentionally and unintentionally, it is best to give it up.Any Mortification can become a source of spiritual pride if done to “boast” of ones “piety” etc.![]()
Oops sorry.Right, hence the adverb “sometimes.”
Confused. Are you implying that one should not practice any form of mortification? The voluntarily or involuntarily, intentionally or unintentionally language is kinda wide open. It could make one who is scrupulous ( one of my crosses ) think that one should never practice any mortifications like voluntarily obstaining etc. And one must only do so upon direction of a Spritual Advisor and/or the Church.Not “if done to,” which implies a conscious end result, but can lead to even involuntarily. If any mortification leads to spiritual pride, whether voluntarily or involuntarily, intentionally and unintentionally, it is best to give it up.
No.Are you implying that one should not practice any form of mortification?
That’s because it is wide open, but this doesn’t mean we should try to mortify our passions. We merely have to recognize our limits.The voluntarily or involuntarily, intentionally or unintentionally language is kinda wide open. It could make one who is scrupulous ( one of my crosses ) think that one should never practice any mortifications like voluntarily obstaining etc. And one must only do so upon direction of a Spritual Advisor and/or the Church.