Father Serpa! Adoration

  • Thread starter Thread starter cathyken
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

cathyken

Guest
I elected to have direct communication with my priest on the adoration/communion issue as well as the interfaith communion issue. I was polite and yet straight forward. I didn’t get a return email and feel that he is angry. Being that he is a Jesuit; I was thinking maybe he is seeing things from such an “educated” perspective that I am unfounded. My husband said I should ask you the reason the church would say you can’t have communion at adoration so that when I go this Saturday- I can respond without appearing self-righteous. I acted on this because I felt my silence was a sin. I see a moderinsm coming into the church in its layed back format. I fear the eventual " Catholic in name" but “but Protestant in truth” church. I am so sad that we can’t even rely on our priests to follow the faith. Out of obedience to the faith- I want to follow our Priests final decision faithfully. I want him to be responsiable as the shepherd of his flock. I think sometimes he is first a college professor and then a priest. I have only been going to this parish for two years and I don’t want to cause waves or disent . Maybe father will respond but I think he will not change his mind. sign , sad and concerned
 
I elected to have direct communication with my priest on the adoration/communion issue as well as the interfaith communion issue. I was polite and yet straight forward. I didn’t get a return email and feel that he is angry. Being that he is a Jesuit; I was thinking maybe he is seeing things from such an “educated” perspective that I am unfounded. My husband said I should ask you the reason the church would say you can’t have communion at adoration so that when I go this Saturday- I can respond without appearing self-righteous. I acted on this because I felt my silence was a sin. I see a moderinsm coming into the church in its layed back format. I fear the eventual " Catholic in name" but “but Protestant in truth” church. I am so sad that we can’t even rely on our priests to follow the faith. Out of obedience to the faith- I want to follow our Priests final decision faithfully. I want him to be responsiable as the shepherd of his flock. I think sometimes he is first a college professor and then a priest. I have only been going to this parish for two years and I don’t want to cause waves or disent . Maybe father will respond but I think he will not change his mind. sign , sad and concerned
I cannot tell from the information you stated here, what the problem is that you think needs to be corrected. Can you be more specific?
 
She had asked the question in the “Ask an Apologist” section, I think.
Cathy, I think you posted this in the wrong spot.
 
I cannot tell from the information you stated here, what the problem is that you think needs to be corrected. Can you be more specific?
I think from an earlier post she is experiencing some irregularities at her parish’s eucharistic adoration. I believe it is twelve-hour adoration, and as I understand it the “incoming” adorer is to receive communion from the “outgoing” adorer.

Not a mass, not a communion service - sounds like something “new”. I believe Fr. Serpa has given his opinion that the proposed is not allowed, and I would tend to agree.

Peace all.
 
why are Jesuits (the backbone of missionary work and education) so liberal in their views?
 
Hi,
I am the one that posted the Adoration problem to Father Serpa and I am sorry about posting it in the wrong place. But, what happen is… a member of our parish announced that we would have an all day adoration next weekend. At this adoration they had arranged for father to consecrate the hosts and then people relieving the next person could give that person communion. Father Serpa said communion does not belong outside the mass (except for the sick) and this was not allowed. I had also told him that we were having interfaith communion. He said that was not allowed either and that I should notify my bishop. I elected to email my priest and speak directly to him but received no response. When I go to adoration on Saturday I was just going to say I will wait for communion until mass but what do I say to the incoming person who wants communion? Am I being to by the regulations? My priest is a Jesuit and I know they are very educated but appears to have a very liberal perspective. If our Priest ignores me altogether- I guess I will just have all this rest on his shoulders. Now many of the members think it is really great that father extends communions to non-Catholics and it seems to be the general will. They say you can evangelize by sharing communion.
 
I elected to have direct communication with my priest on the adoration/communion issue as well as the interfaith communion issue. I was polite and yet straight forward. I didn’t get a return email and feel that he is angry. Being that he is a Jesuit; I was thinking maybe he is seeing things from such an “educated” perspective that I am unfounded. My husband said I should ask you the reason the church would say you can’t have communion at adoration so that when I go this Saturday- I can respond without appearing self-righteous. I acted on this because I felt my silence was a sin. I see a moderinsm coming into the church in its layed back format. I fear the eventual " Catholic in name" but “but Protestant in truth” church. I am so sad that we can’t even rely on our priests to follow the faith. Out of obedience to the faith- I want to follow our Priests final decision faithfully. I want him to be responsiable as the shepherd of his flock. I think sometimes he is first a college professor and then a priest. I have only been going to this parish for two years and I don’t want to cause waves or disent . Maybe father will respond but I think he will not change his mind. sign , sad and concerned
Ummm … Fr Serpa ain’t no Jesuit. At the bottom of his posts he always signs himself ‘OP’ - standing for Ordo Predicatorum or Order of Preachers - in other words the Dominican order. If he was Jesuit it’d be ‘SJ’ - for ‘Society of Jesus’.
 
Ummm … Fr Serpa ain’t no Jesuit. At the bottom of his posts he always signs himself ‘OP’ - standing for Ordo Predicatorum or Order of Preachers - in other words the Dominican order. If he was Jesuit it’d be ‘SJ’ - for ‘Society of Jesus’.
She is referring to her priest as being a SJ and not to father Serpa.
 
Hi,
I am the one that posted the Adoration problem to Father Serpa and I am sorry about posting it in the wrong place. But, what happen is… a member of our parish announced that we would have an all day adoration next weekend. At this adoration they had arranged for father to consecrate the hosts and then people relieving the next person could give that person communion. Father Serpa said communion does not belong outside the mass (except for the sick) and this was not allowed. I had also told him that we were having interfaith communion. He said that was not allowed either and that I should notify my bishop. I elected to email my priest and speak directly to him but received no response. When I go to adoration on Saturday I was just going to say I will wait for communion until mass but what do I say to the incoming person who wants communion? Am I being to by the regulations? My priest is a Jesuit and I know they are very educated but appears to have a very liberal perspective. If our Priest ignores me altogether- I guess I will just have all this rest on his shoulders. Now many of the members think it is really great that father extends communions to non-Catholics and it seems to be the general will. They say you can evangelize by sharing communion.
Nope - it’s your responsibility to see it through by going to the Bishop if your priest doesn’t listen to you. The reception of communion by known non-Catholics constitutes desecration of the Eucharist, and you could be complicit in it if you don’t pursue the matter at least to the Bishop.

Remember what St Paul says about not allowing those who are unworthy - meaning those who don’t discern (understand) the Eucharist (in other words non-Catholics) - to receive Communion? And the consequences of doing so are grave - physical and spiritual illness for them and even death.
 
why my bad humble apologies? on going to the Bishop…I think I should give my Priest a little time more to respond to this, It obviously is okay with the whole parish! BUT can’t I go to the Bishop anonomysly or have him address a general letter to the University of Jesuits at which he teaches at so that he is not singled out and also so that he doesn’t hate me! He has been a Priest for years and years…maybe he thinks we are losing people because we turn them away. I was also thinking he may feel extra pressure in light of the Priest scandals in that he might be seen as self- righteous in not sharing the banquet.
 
Fr Serpa did answer your question, and he did tell you how to register a complaint.

for complete guidance on how to report a serious issue like this see the lay witness protocol on the Catholics United for the Faith website. cuf.org

I can guarantee that an anonymous letter to the bishop unless it is something like child abuse will just be filed
 
This is a very serious issue as it desecrates the eucharist through open communion and because it is conveying the eucharist in a manner that is not authorized by the Holy See. You are not required to participate in what is clearly a sacrilegious act - even if this liberal priest means well. As a matter of protocol you owe it to the priest to talk to him first to give him an opportunity to correct himself or explain if he got some kind of special dispensation from the Bishop. But this is so irregular that it is highly doubtful. If you do not get an immediate explanation that is favorable then you MUST elevate this and go talk to the Bishop ASAP.

James
 
why my bad humble apologies? on going to the Bishop…I think I should give my Priest a little time more to respond to this, It obviously is okay with the whole parish! BUT can’t I go to the Bishop anonomysly or have him address a general letter to the University of Jesuits at which he teaches at so that he is not singled out and also so that he doesn’t hate me! He has been a Priest for years and years…maybe he thinks we are losing people because we turn them away. I was also thinking he may feel extra pressure in light of the Priest scandals in that he might be seen as self- righteous in not sharing the banquet.
Well, it’s only right to apologise if you make a mistake, no?

In regard to complaining to the Bishop - well, of course you can do it anonymously, it has more oomph if you forward the correspondence to him though. Perhaps you can forward the request and at the same time ask the bishop to keep it anonymous.

You’re right - the priest may be thinking all those things. None of them are any reasons for him to commit the sin of desecrating the Eucharist, though.
 
I think you have acted in good faith by sending an e-mail to the priest. If he doesn’t answer, however (as it seems he won’t) I think you probably have the duty to take the matter to the Bishop.
As to anonymous complaints, a priest in my Diocese told me it is our Diosecean policy to ignore all anonymous complaints, so that may be the case there too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top