Fatima and Staring at the Sun

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jcnava15
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jcnava15

Guest
I have been very interested in Fatima. I have watched a documentary on it, and read a few of the usual background info on it. I don’t know a great deal about it yet, but will continue to study it. I don’t know if a Miracle happened, all I know is something happened.

Below I detail my testing of the “Staring at the Sun” explanation pushed forward by skeptics.

One of the most common points that skeptics make is that this miracle was a result of “staring at the sun”. This seemed to me the only reasonable objection to it, as I know that I am not the only one that experiences color distortions from sun light, such as spending a good amount of time outside in the bright sun and walking in doors. The in doors usually looks either sepia-ish or blue-ish until my eyes adjust.

So against all medical advice I decided to test this for myself (do not test it for yourself, it hurts very bad). Knowing full well that I may encounter some damage to my eyes, and knowing how bad of an idea it was, I did it because I wanted to know.

The witnesses are said to have witnessed this event upwards of 10 minutes. I could only stare at the sun for roughly 5 seconds no matter how hard I tried.

Here is what happened.
-It hurt to stare at the sun, but for atleast 5 seconds I willed myself to do it.

-I could see the Sun with my naked eye. I saw the ball of the sun, it was vibrant white.

-The sun did “appear” to spin rapidly towards the right, and then to the left, but I could tell it was because my eyes where rapidly shifting away from looking at the sun, against me fighting them to stare at it. The effect was caused by the physical shaking of my eyes, not because of a sun induced hallucination,other mental phenomenon, or the sun actually spinning. If I even shifted my eyes slightly away, it completely went back to normal. Not impressive. In fact you can briefly replicate what I saw safely by straining your eyes and looking towards a light bulb.
  • At no point did I feel that something miraculous was occurring. I was completely aware that I was looking at a normal sun.
-As it “spun” it created ripples in the sky immediately surrounding. (The sun appeared roughly the size of a small marble, and the ripples radius was only barely bigger).

-When I looked away, the land around me, including my dog were tinted blue and purple. You could have guessed that.

-For about 10 minutes my eyes hurt bad, I had a burnt in after image of the sun in the center of my vision everywhere I looked. I began to worry it was permanent eye damage, so I prayed that it would go away, luckily it did.

This was easily one of the STUPIDEST decisions I have ever made, but in the search for truth, I had to test the hypothesis.

My conclusion;
Although I saw 2 of the often cited effects of the Fatima miracle of the Sun (the spinning, and color distortions), there is NO WAY I would ever stare at it for more than a split second if someone told me, or because everyone was doing it. It hurt so freaking bad.

If I were a hardcore skeptic on that Fatima field on Oct 13 1917, there is no way I would have been impressed if all that miracle was, was what I saw. Nothing about it took me back. I knew it was the sun and what was happening was my eyes twitching.

If someone had pointed toward the sun after we had been staring at the tree where the 3 peasants were, and told me “Miracle!”, I would have been very confused and asked “Where?”. My instinct would not be to stare at the sun and embrace the pain, in fact my body (eyeballs) fought against me violently.

I did not see the sun “dancing”, spewing out a spectrum of colors and painting the whole land, or see it “zig zag” toward earth as if it were about to crush me, and destroy the earth.

I am not convinced that “The miracle of the sun” was caused by staring at the sun. Of course I didn’t stare at it for 10 minutes so I don’t know what would be seen if stared at for that long, but I am convinced that anymore than a few dozen seconds, and I would probably be in the ER and blind.

The “Staring at the Sun” hypothesis for explaining what happened at Fatima seems to me to be bogus. If any skeptics want to keep pushing that explanation, I challenge them to follow the scientific method, and test their hypothesis.
 
For Heaven’s sake don’t stare at the sun any more!

Personal investigations, even of Fatima, aren’t worth walking through your life in the dark.

As I understand it, either they weren’t looking directly at it or they were somehow (miraculously?) protected from harm to their sight.

Take care. Protect those eyes so you’ll have them to see our LORD with!

ICXC NIKA
 
, but I am convinced that anymore than a few dozen seconds, and I would probably be in the ER and blind.
You have put yourself at extreme risk of macular degeneration and early blindness as you age. You have damaged a great deal of the DNA in the cells of your eyes. Get a very good complete B-vitamin supplement and wear sunglasses and a visored hat at all times outside, even in cloudy weather. Also get plenty of Vitamin A.

The “scientific” method depends on science, which has already done the testing and gotten and published the results. Objections by skeptics on the internet does not qualify as anything. Try reading more extensively next time. While you still can.
 
You have put yourself at extreme risk of macular degeneration and early blindness as you age. You have damaged a great deal of the DNA in the cells of your eyes. Get a very good complete B-vitamin supplement and wear sunglasses and a visored hat at all times outside, even in cloudy weather. Also get plenty of Vitamin A.

The “scientific” method depends on science, which has already done the testing and gotten and published the results. Objections by skeptics on the internet does not qualify as anything. Try reading more extensively next time. While you still can.
Yea, I knew that I was risking my vision doing this. My vision has already been successively getting worse since I was a kid, so I anticipate early blindness anyways.
 
That’s all find and dandy, but I would recommend NOT to star at the suns anymore.

God Bless you
and Heal your Eyes
 
Hey, I don’t reccomend it either.

Now imagine trying to persuade 40-70,000 people to stare at the sun and convince themselves they saw a Miracle.
 
Hey, I don’t reccomend it either.

Now imagine trying to persuade 40-70,000 people to stare at the sun and convince themselves they saw a Miracle.
You make a good point, but you must realize that is why they call it Faith. I know by heart that Our Lady of Fatima was a true miracle because it has no yet been proven by Science as possible. That is why it is called a miracle
 
and how come no one has ever seen the sun moving before. What about Galileo who lost his sight looking at the sun? He never reported a dancing sun.

How come the witnesses of Fatima aren’t all blinded?

10 minutes will burn through the cornea
 
My instinct would not be to stare at the sun and embrace the pain, in fact my body (eyeballs) fought against me violently.
That must be how Satan feels when he is before God.

Don’t look at the sun.

What would happen if you stared at the moon?
 
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top