Fatima report of God's anger, saddness, happiness, etc

  • Thread starter Thread starter clarkgamble1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I recommend the Catechism of the Catholic Church and the Roman Catechism. And most importantly, I recommend he ask forgiveness for his rash words against God. The best advice I could give would be to learn the Most Holy Rosary and pray it daily.
 
The Scriptures portray God as angry over man’s sins, many, many, many times.

Have you ever read them? God’s anger at men comes up in Scripture so very often that it’s a bit hard to miss.

Oh, by the way, that really was the Virgin Mary at Fatima, not “a being the seers believed was the Virgin Mary” or whatever rot you’re describing it as.
 
Last edited:
I’m a Catholic , probably in name only, 12 years in a Catholic grade and high school, 4 years in a Catholic university. All that education brought up more questions than it provided answers. I’m also a retired Electronic Engineer who has been taught to accept nothing that cannot be proven logically. I find the beliefs of most of my Catholic relatives and acquaintances are all based on memorized catechism statements and a lot of non-logical emotional feelings.
 
I totally understand, i come from a very catholic country where catholicism is absorbed with culture, yet i had to work by myself to make sense of all i was reading with standard education. It’s a good thing you want to go deeper, the beauty of how everything make logic sense once you understand it, it is what can make your faith “mature” if you have a rational mind like mine. By the way, I am an aerospace engineer… My suggestion is to apply an analytic approach about the questions you are trying to address, set a priority list of questions and research a couple of good books to study the problem. Make sure to research the right sources, just like you would do for an academic work. this forum can help you with that in my opinion, as a starting point but obviously you need to go further on your own. I agree with Saxum on one thing (only): you may want to start with the Catechism http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/_INDEX.HTM. if you are not familiar with it. There are answers, not only statements, and you can go from there to study more about those answers
 
Last edited:
I’m also a retired Electronic Engineer who has been taught to accept nothing that cannot be proven logically. I find the beliefs of most of my Catholic relatives and acquaintances are all based on memorized catechism statements and a lot of non-logical emotional feelings.
If you want logic, read Thomas Aquinas and the other scholastic theologians. They will answer your questions.
 
With all the horrible things people do to each other on earth, I’d be a lot more worried if Mary had told them God did not feel anger about it.
 
The being whom the seers at Fatima believed was the Virgin Mary, reported that she told them God was, among other things angry, sad, disappointed, etc. that mankind was so full of sin and did not pray enough. She has said on other occasions that it is very difficult to hold back his anger. Now those statements to me really point to the lack of veracity that the being was actually Mary. If it was Mary, she must be completely unaware of the Church approved list of God’s attributes. Read them. God cannot be angry, He is not affected by anything. He cannot be sad or disappointed either if His attributes are real. So why would “Mary” suggest such things. I think either the children made everything up or the being made it all up to motivate the people to change their ways.
If that’s your line of reasoning, how do you make sense of Bible verses like the following?

Deuteronomy 9:8

“Even at Horeb you provoked the LORD to wrath, and the LORD was so angry with you that He would have destroyed you.”

Exodus 15:7

“And in the greatness of Your excellence You overthrow those who rise up against You; You send forth Your burning anger, and it consumes them as chaff.”

Exodus 32:10-11

“Now then let Me alone, that My anger may burn against them and that I may destroy them; and I will make of you a great nation.”

Numbers 11:1-2

“Now the people became like those who complain of adversity in the hearing of the LORD; and when the LORD heard it, His anger was kindled, and the fire of the LORD burned among them and consumed some of the outskirts of the camp.”

Job 4:9
"By the breath of God they perish, And by the blast of His anger they come to an end.

The Wrath of God, Divine Justice, and Divine Retribution are perennial, infallible, dogmatic teachings of the Church and immutable aspects of God, firmly rooted in both Sacred Scripture and Tradition.
 
Last edited:
And the Church insists they are. Most modern believers reject the old testament God as a vindictive, bloodthirsty, ethnic cleanser…a racist, infanticidal, genocidal, capriciously malevolent bully. He was made up by the early barbaric bronze agers to justify their own vicious actions.
You should consider removing “Catholic” from your “religion” in your profile until you repent of this errant, heretical, blasphemous belief. It is very misleading to see someone who claims to be Catholic saying anti-Christian statements like this.

I pray that you are not sacrilegiously receiving the Body and Blood of the Lord if you genuinely believe this.

You’re not saying anything even remotely Catholic - you just verbatim quoted a rabid misotheist (Richard Dawkins).
 
Last edited:
Anger and Wrath are not attributes of God - attributes of God are equivalent to his Essence, his Very Being.

So God is Love, Truth, Beauty, Power, Knowledge, Wisdom, Goodness, Justice, Mercy, etc.

However, God’s Perfect Justice is what gives rise to the Catholic doctrines regarding God’s Righteous Anger and Retribution. God punishes sin, and he does so because he hates sin and it angers him. Hatred and anger are not attributes of God’s Essence, but God is capable of expressing anger and hatred in reaction to sin and evil committed against him, since God is not some abstract concept but a Godhead of Persons - God is a Person, even a Man, the Man-God Christ Jesus, to whom all Judgment has been entrusted. And as we see in the Gospels, Jesus is certainly capable of becoming angry.
 
Last edited:
I’m also a retired Electronic Engineer who has been taught to accept nothing that cannot be proven logically.
I have two degrees in EE and my husband had one. Husband had a 34-year career as an EE in the defense industry, I worked for about a dozen years before I changed careers. Neither of us had any problem with accepting both the principles of science and the saving grace of Our Lord Jesus Christ. My husband’s Baptist relatives could not understand how he managed to accept both things so easily, but he himself had no problem with it. It is the grace of God that gave us faith as well as the good minds to be engineers and the help in reaching our career goals.

I realize that not everybody has the gift of faith, but the fact that you’re a logical engineer or scientist doesn’t exclude a belief in God or Jesus or Catholicism.
 
Last edited:
I realize that not everybody has the gift of faith, but the fact that you’re a logical engineer or scientist doesn’t exclude a belief in God or Jesus or Catholicism.
you are right, it actually helps. 2000+ year of solid theology, that passed through illuminism and criticism, it is at least hard to debate for anyone who wants to go deeper in that. But again, Theology is not geometry, always keep the balance with prayer and love (just like when studying science we had to study piano to stay sane lol)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top