Feeling conflicted about faith. Please Help

  • Thread starter Thread starter helpme90
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

helpme90

Guest
Hi,

here lately I find most days that I want to believe in my faith as a catholic, but deep down I am very unsure. It wasn’t always this way. I just completed my freshman year in college and I had to take a philosophy course. We read books that dealt with forming conclusions based mainly on logic and reason. The bible was even interpreted, but not as a means of a religious authority, but just as a means of being a good person. Meaning that they did not believe the bible, but listened to the stories to decide how to live. one day in discussion section my professor was asking why we believers believe instead of just using reason to live our lives. I was baffled since nobody had ever questioned my faith but also because I didn’t have an answer. I wanted to say I believe on faith alone but that isn’t good enough for these professors. This sent me into a tailspin. how would you have answered this question? I want to believe but I don’t want to be a blind follower. There must be something more to prove we are on the right path. So why do you believe and what can I do to strengthen my faith?

Sorry for the book but in light of recent events I have something else troubling me. I am an American and believe deeply in the values that this country stands for, well maybe stood for. I feel conflicted about the supreme court gay rights ruling. I really want to oppose the ruling, but on the other hand it seems to be something that should be allowed at a secular level. Do any of you feel this way? Please share your advice on how to approach this. Also how can I answer people who ask why I am against gay marriage when they reject any moral argument?

Thanks again and I pray that my mind be open to all the responses.
 
Hi,

here lately I find most days that I want to believe in my faith as a catholic, but deep down I am very unsure. It wasn’t always this way. I just completed my freshman year in college and I had to take a philosophy course. We read books that dealt with forming conclusions based mainly on logic and reason. The bible was even interpreted, but not as a means of a religious authority, but just as a means of being a good person. Meaning that they did not believe the bible, but listened to the stories to decide how to live. one day in discussion section my professor was asking why we believers believe instead of just using reason to live our lives. I was baffled since nobody had ever questioned my faith but also because I didn’t have an answer. I wanted to say I believe on faith alone but that isn’t good enough for these professors. This sent me into a tailspin. how would you have answered this question? I want to believe but I don’t want to be a blind follower. There must be something more to prove we are on the right path. So why do you believe and what can I do to strengthen my faith?

Sorry for the book but in light of recent events I have something else troubling me. I am an American and believe deeply in the values that this country stands for, well maybe stood for. I feel conflicted about the supreme court gay rights ruling. I really want to oppose the ruling, but on the other hand it seems to be something that should be allowed at a secular level. Do any of you feel this way? Please share your advice on how to approach this. Also how can I answer people who ask why I am against gay marriage when they reject any moral argument?

Thanks again and I pray that my mind be open to all the responses.
Faith and reason are not mutually exclusive. We use both faith and reason.

I believe because my reason tells me that God exists, and in my faith, I believe that God has revealed Himself through His people Israel and continuing to do so in the New Covenant which is maintained by the Catholic Church.

Ever since I came back to the Church, my faith has not stirred!

My advice is to look into what the Church has to say about faith and reason. Catholic.com has some resources as well.

May God bless you on your journey and may He help you through your struggles, and may the Saints help guide you to the Lord.
 
Hey there,
Don’t feel discouraged when I went to college I had a lot of the same questions and doubts about the existence of God you talk about (and I went to a Baptist College). I am not going to bother you with the details of my life and my journey back to the truth of the Catholic Church, rather I am going to suggest some books and resources to you. However, the best advice I can give you is PRAY FOR TRUTH and mean it! Catholic Answers has some really good books you can look at such as “The Truth is Out There” (it’s a graphic novel so it’s a fast read), don’t have time to read check out “How to Talk to Atheists” its an mp3 I think. A book that really cinched it for me when I was coming back was “Rome Sweet Home” by Dr. Scott Hahn it really helped me realize that the Catholic Church was the one and only church founded by Christ in fact I highly recommend watching and reading stories about converts to the Catholic faith “Journey Home” on EWTN is a great show for this. Also “Absolute Relativism: The New Dictatorship and What to do About it” by Chris Stefanick can help you with questions your philosophy class might have brought up. Dr. Peter Kreeft is also a professor of philosophy and I think he has some DVD’s out called “College Survival Kit for Catholics.” Recently I came across this in which Dr. Kreeft talks about which is more rational God or Atheism watch it it’s great! catholiceducation.org/articles/apologetics/ap0473.htm
Catholic Lighthouse Media also has a cd on “Answering Atheism” which I found very helpful. Don’t get discouraged and find a local group for Catholic college students that are on fire for their faith this support group can help you strengthen your faith and pray with you. Many parishes have groups for college students, but if your town is like mine and you can’t find one use the internet and sources like this one.
The gay rights thing was also something I wondered about I knew the Church was right, but I needed clarity on the issue so I began to investigate what the Church had to say on this topic. Catholic Answers has a Radio Show which was very enlightening for me. catholic.com/radio/shows/atheist-lesbian-turned-catholic-mom-6579
Lighthouse Catholic Media also has a Cd which treats the matter with respect and compassion called “From Love, By Love, For Love.”
I haven’t looked it up yet but someone also suggested “Theology of the Body” and lastly get yourself a “YouCat” it’s very easy to read written in a question and answer format and it’s helped me figure out a lot of questions I had. Don’t get discouraged and look at this time as one of growth with your relationship with Christ and His Holy Church. Turn to Him constantly.
I’ll be praying for you.
🙂
 
Hi, helpme90,

First, the title “Catholic Church” is a bit misleading. These words literally mean “Universal Congregation.” What this forum teaches and discusses generally is Roman Catholicism. Obviously, universal encompasses all Christians. RC and Protestantism both incorporate denominational teachings.

There is a very small group that holds to the non denominational literal truth of Scripture. Biblical Christianity says that the Bible is the perfect Word of God, and that no man made dogma can circumvent this truth. Though there is much more similar teachings in RC vs Biblical Christianity, the differences are crucial. 2Tim 3:16 says that …“All Scripture is God breathed…” This is a declaration of perfection of the Scriptures, as God is perfect.

The 2 most debated topics are “Sola Fida” & “Sola Scriptura” {Faith alone and Scripture alone.} The RCC denies the literal meaning of these doctrines, and Biblical Christians hold to their truth. If you read the 2Tim verse closely, it says that Scripture is directly from God, and throughout the New Testament the theme of only living by faith ( Romans 1:17… the just shall live by faith…) is repeated again and again. Eph 2:8,9 is even more specific… “8 For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God— 9 not by works, so that no one can boast.”

The RC dogma incorporates works, but this is not Biblically based. The rule book for the RCC is the magisterium. (Sacraments are 2nd and the Bible is 3rd.) Biblical Christianity is simply the Bible (Scripture, and faith alone.) with no added help. I would also advise to look up the "Counsel of Trent’s #15, and #22. This is accepted by the RCC as official and perfect dogma. Maranatha (…even so, come Lord Jesus.) and may God Bless.

M33
 
Hi, helpme90,

First, the title “Catholic Church” is a bit misleading. These words literally mean “Universal Congregation.” What this forum teaches and discusses generally is Roman Catholicism. Obviously, universal encompasses all Christians. RC and Protestantism both incorporate denominational teachings.

There is a very small group that holds to the non denominational literal truth of Scripture. Biblical Christianity says that the Bible is the perfect Word of God, and that no man made dogma can circumvent this truth. Though there is much more similar teachings in RC vs Biblical Christianity, the differences are crucial. 2Tim 3:16 says that …“All Scripture is God breathed…” This is a declaration of perfection of the Scriptures, as God is perfect.

The 2 most debated topics are “Sola Fida” & “Sola Scriptura” {Faith alone and Scripture alone.} The RCC denies the literal meaning of these doctrines, and Biblical Christians hold to their truth. If you read the 2Tim verse closely, it says that Scripture is directly from God, and throughout the New Testament the theme of only living by faith ( Romans 1:17… the just shall live by faith…) is repeated again and again. Eph 2:8,9 is even more specific… “8 For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God— 9 not by works, so that no one can boast.”

The RC dogma incorporates works, but this is not Biblically based. The rule book for the RCC is the magisterium. (Sacraments are 2nd and the Bible is 3rd.) Biblical Christianity is simply the Bible (Scripture, and faith alone.) with no added help. I would also advise to look up the "Counsel of Trent’s #15, and #22. This is accepted by the RCC as official and perfect dogma. Maranatha (…even so, come Lord Jesus.) and may God Bless.

M33
Your misunderstanding of the Catholic faith isn’t surprising, most Protestants don’t fully understand the Catholic teachings.
 
one day in discussion section my professor was asking why we believers believe instead of just using reason to live our lives. I was baffled since nobody had ever questioned my faith but also because I didn’t have an answer. I wanted to say I believe on faith alone but that isn’t good enough for these professors. This sent me into a tailspin. how would you have answered this question?
Well, they’re philosophy professors, so you could point out to them that every modern philosopher after Francis Bacon (Descarte, Hume, Kant, Spinoza, Rousseau, Nietzsche - every one of them) decided to strip away all vestiges of tradition, go into seclusion, and develop his own philosophy from scratch, based only on reason. That has been the ideal of modern philosophy. And that’s what each of them did - except none of them agreed.

So the lesson is that you can’t use reason alone - because it does not produce consistent results. If you set out on your own to create your own philosophy based on reason, what are the odds that you would be anymore successful?

Another reason - atheists do not lead lives governed by “just reason” either. Part of the modern liberal worldview is the notion of “the right to the pursuit of happiness.” Happiness, in this case, is undefined and arbitrary - it’s not “reasonable.” You choose what you want according to your desire.

The other reason not to rely on reason alone is because we believe Catholicism is true. It’s not just a matter of building a consistent philosophy that applies to life; it is about believing what is true. You may want to acquaint yourself with some of the arguments for God’s existence, the historicity of Jesus, etc.

A good place to start might be reasonablefaith.org. There are certainly atheist objections to William Lane Craig’s arguments, but that would be a good place to become familiar with some of the dialogue between believers and nonbelievers.
 
Skilled philosophers can always outwit me, but I don’t let them get me down for long. I examine my own life, the world around me, and I study science, and I see signs of God’s existence and his loving presence. However, the things that convince me, the things I see as “proof,” don’t necessarily prove it to someone else.

Your friends and people that you meet have diverse backgrounds and upbringings, and different ideas about what’s important in life. I find it hard, maybe impossible, to have a meaningful discussion about Catholic beliefs and moral teachings with people who value personal liberty and happiness above all. But when words fail, even then you can show others, by your behavior, what it means to be a good Christian. As Jesus said, “By this all men will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another.” (John 13:35)

Here are a few suggestions for strengthening your faith:
  • Stay in close contact with the campus Catholic community when you are at school.
  • Join their Bible study group if they have one (but I cannot recommend Protestant bible study groups, because they can be radically different in their approach to Scripture.)
  • If your church or campus Catholic center offers any faith-building or Catechism workshops or discussion/study groups, definitely participate in that.
  • There is a wealth of wisdom in the Catechism of the Catholic Church that is often overlooked. This online Catechism has a fairly good search tool for looking up topics that interest you, and there is also a very detailed subject index.
  • Pray regularly. Pray that the Holy Spirit may assist and guide you in your faith journey.
God bless you.
 
Hi, helpme90,

First, the title “Catholic Church” is a bit misleading. These words literally mean “Universal Congregation.” What this forum teaches and discusses generally is Roman Catholicism. Obviously, universal encompasses all Christians. RC and Protestantism both incorporate denominational teachings.

There is a very small group that holds to the non denominational literal truth of Scripture. Biblical Christianity says that the Bible is the perfect Word of God, and that no man made dogma can circumvent this truth. Though there is much more similar teachings in RC vs Biblical Christianity, the differences are crucial. 2Tim 3:16 says that …“All Scripture is God breathed…” This is a declaration of perfection of the Scriptures, as God is perfect.

The 2 most debated topics are “Sola Fida” & “Sola Scriptura” {Faith alone and Scripture alone.} The RCC denies the literal meaning of these doctrines, and Biblical Christians hold to their truth. If you read the 2Tim verse closely, it says that Scripture is directly from God, and throughout the New Testament the theme of only living by faith ( Romans 1:17… the just shall live by faith…) is repeated again and again. Eph 2:8,9 is even more specific… “8 For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God— 9 not by works, so that no one can boast.”

The RC dogma incorporates works, but this is not Biblically based. The rule book for the RCC is the magisterium. (Sacraments are 2nd and the Bible is 3rd.) Biblical Christianity is simply the Bible (Scripture, and faith alone.) with no added help. I would also advise to look up the "Counsel of Trent’s #15, and #22. This is accepted by the RCC as official and perfect dogma. Maranatha (…even so, come Lord Jesus.) and may God Bless.

M33
Hi Maranatha33,
Just wanted to make a quick book recommendation to you b/c I think you might have a few misunderstandings about the Catholic Church. "The Fathers Know Best " by Jimmy Akin and the three volume “Faith of the Early Fathers” by William A. Jurgens. I strongly recommend a study of the Patristic Fathers their wisdom is very enlightening.
Speaking of the Patristic Fathers I leave you with this quote “Let no man do anything connected with the Church without the bishop. Let that be deemed a proper Eucharist, which is [administered] either by the bishop, or by one to whom he has entrusted it. Whenever the bishop, shall appear, there let the multitude [of the people] also be; even as, wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.” St. Ignatius of Antioch (c. A.D. 110).
St Augustine of Hippo “Indeed, I would not believe the gospel myself if the authority of the Catholic Church did not move me to do so.” I challenge you to search for the Truth of what the Catholic Church has consistently taught and welcome to Catholic Answers. May the Holy Spirit guide you on your quest for truth. :byzsoc:
 
keep in mind that while we can’t “prove” god exists, neither can an athiest “prove” he doesn’t exist. religion has become the set of values and beliefs a person holds, which means as long as someone exists and can identify what things they believe, they have a religion. this is basic logic, yet people who subscribe to moral relativism or straight up philosophy, or those “I’m spiritual, not religious” types - basically, all those enlightened people who are too good for an organized group - somehow seem to completely miss this.

some people will adhere to a stricter definition of religion that excludes any belief system without a “standardized” book of rules - you can counter by pointing out that if they subscribe to a particular political party but not an organized religion, that their ideology has become their religion, not to mention the fact that not all members of a given traditional religion necessarily believe every single thing their religion teaches. just look at the percentage of people who identify as catholic but who support gay marriage or abortion (it varies depending on which study you read, but all the ones I’ve seen are over 50% :eek:). some world religions are atheistic, though maybe those people would consider buddhism a “philosophy” and not a “religion”… :rolleyes:

polytropos has an excellent reply!! individuals interpreting things for themselves yet always coming up with different answers seems to be a big red flag as far as truth is concerned. I am catholic because I trust that 2000 years of people collaborating and discussing is worth infinitely more than what I can think up in my own head…
 
Hi Helpme,
I believe in Christianity, specifically Catholicism, because I don’t think it possible that it’s an invention, since so many early Christians were willing to die horrific deaths rather than renounce their faith. This includes the 12 apostles, all of whom except John were martyred. I think it’s impossible that all of them would have died for something they made up. Not to mention the thousands of early Christian martyrs. Not to mention the miracles which we can still see today, for example the mantle of the Virgin of Guadelupe, and the miracle of Lanciano. There is just too much evidence for the truth of Christianity.

As far as your question about same sex marriage: I have a 3 year old grandson. When he’s in grade school, I don’t want him taught that it’s okay to fall in love with and marry another boy, as if this were normal. Same sex attraction is a sad affliction, and I feel for people who suffer it, but that doesn’t mean it’s not an affliction.
One reason the law is wrong is that many young people go through a period of confusion about their sexuality. If they have some kind of same sex event, such as seduction by an older person, around that time, they might be persuaded that they are homosexual when in truth they’re not. Society treating it as normal is a really bad idea.
Also, there is the question of definition of bigotry. Priests have been jailed in Canada for preaching what the Bible says about homosexuality. If I say anything against same sex marriage at my workplace, I might lose my job. People are being sued for not providing same sex marriage services, such as florists and bakers. Is this the kind of society we want, where people are not allowed to hold the beliefs of their religion?
Some (not all) homosexual activists are pushing their agenda aggressively, trying to change society. I do not think we should fall for it. But at this point, standing against it may have serious economic or legal consequences. Are we still the land of the free?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top