S
Sailor_Kenshin
Guest
Ooo, linkies for your fic, please? Dappled Things is a journal I would like to see.This is very interesting indeed. Thanks to Michelle B.
There’s been much discussion of what constitutes “Catholic fiction”. Michelle’s answer is different from my own. I don’t suppose it matters much except to critics who must use certain analytical nomenclature. For publishers and for writers themselves, the question is one of genre, so the discussion tends to get bogged down in apples and oranges issues. E.g., are we talking popular fiction or “literary” fiction? Popular fiction can be subdivided into mystery, children’s lit, romance, sci-fi, etc., fiction that aims for a “popular” market. Literary fiction would be Waugh, Greene, O’Conner, etc., or fiction that aims for university syllabi., classics canons, and all that. Popular fiction is craft; literary fiction is art. The latter’s most prominent contemporary example is probably Ron Hansen, one who writes in “poetic prose”. Though his work is not to my taste–I have my reasons–he’s much praised.
I had a story in the Easter issue of Dappled Things, a Catholic literary quarterly of considerable quality, and a very welcome oasis in the literary desert of boringly predictable existential angst. I hope they will continue with high quality poetry and fiction and not lapse into reviews and essays, becoming yet another Catholic cultural journal–we have enough of those, I think. I have another story appearing there in the fall. But I am working on a novel now which would be called “popular” fiction, though I know it will never be published, set in Elizabeth England. (Yes, there is irony here. The “literary” fiction is published; the “popular” fiction is not and never will be.) I’m writing it anyway because I’m interested in the countless silent white martyrs of that period, invisible in both Protestant revisionist history and in Catholic emphasis on the red martyrs of the time.
What constitutes Catholic fiction is fiction that is produced by a Catholic mind, regardless of themes or intended market. If a writer is thoroughly Catholic, his work will also be Catholic. Yes, Mary Higgins Clark fits that definition; so does J.R.R. Tolkien. “By their fruits ye shall know them” or “It must follow as the night, the day.” Take your pick.